Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Characters / DrDeath

Go To

OR

Added: 409

Changed: 140

Removed: 189

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AgeLift: In real life, Shughart was young, but not as youthful as she's portrayed here.

to:

* AgeLift: In real life, Shughart was young, but not as youthful as she's portrayed here. For reference, Shughart was in her thirties when she prosecuted the case while [=AnnaSophia=] Robb was in her late twenties during filming.



* NewMeat: A lot of emphasis is put on Shughart being young and early in her career, which compounds the difficulty in trying to prosecute Duntsch in an unprecedented case.



* BenevolentBoss: Despite his MeanBoss tendencies, partof his reluctance to prosecute Duntsch comes from the fact that he cares about Shughart, as he warns her that if the case goes poorly, she'll be in danger of ruining her own career.



** Part of his reluctance to prosecute Duntsch comes from the fact that he cares about Shughart, as he warns her that if the case goes poorly, she'll be in danger of ruining her own career.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ScrewTheRulesImDoingWhatsRight: Kirby lives by this. SurprisinglyRealisticOutcome though, as his disdain for rules sometimes alienates his allies and makes it hard for him to work with the medical bureaucracy.

to:

* ScrewTheRulesImDoingWhatsRight: Kirby lives by this. SurprisinglyRealisticOutcome though, as Though, his disdain for rules sometimes alienates his allies and makes it hard for him to work with the medical bureaucracy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* EvilMakesYouUgly: As his horrible maiming of patients continues to the point he starts switching hospitals, he starts putting on weight, already have a visible gut by the time he's left Baylor Plano. By the time of his arrest he got at his heaviest.


Added DiffLines:

* FormerlyFit: In college he was a fit football player (Though not very good at it), as his medical career and drug use goes overboard, he starts putting on weight until he's hardly recognizable when he's arrested.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* JerkWithAHeartOfGold: He comes across as a cynical and self-interested grouch who's focused mostly on getting reelected, but he does care about Michelle, and respects and values her as a colleague. His reluctance to let her prosecute Duntsch is partly because he doesn't want her career to suffer if the case goes badly, as he believes it probably will.

to:

* JerkWithAHeartOfGold: He comes across as a cynical and self-interested grouch who's focused mostly on getting reelected, but he does care about Michelle, and respects and values her as a colleague. His reluctance to let her prosecute Duntsch is partly because he doesn't want her career to suffer if the case goes badly, as he believes it probably will.will, but respects her decision to go ahead and wishes her well in doing so.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HiddenDepths: He's a pretty stereotypical Texan who also loves fancy cocktails, classical music, and is an avid outdoorsman who is planning to climb Mount Everest and is coming back from a hike when he gets word of Duntsch's arrest.

to:

* HiddenDepths: He's a pretty stereotypical Texan who also loves fancy cocktails, classical music, and is an avid outdoorsman who is planning to climb Mount Everest and is coming back from a hike when he gets word of Duntsch's arrest. It's also shown that despite his cocky demeanor and eccentricities, he takes his work completely seriously and cares very much about helping people.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SenseLossSadness: [[spoiler:After his surgery leaves him a quadriplegic, he spirals into a depression that the show ends with him never smiling again like he always was before the surgery.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HighHopesZeroTalent: He'll brag that he could've gone pro as a football star and that it's a question of when, not if, he'll have his neurosurgery empire, there's a constant reminder that he has absolutely no talent for either craft he has taken up with a string of failures defining him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* PscyhopathicManchild: He demonstrates extreme arrogance and is unwilling to admit when he's wrong, shows a very juvenile sense of entitlement in his career and his relationships, and reacts to setbacks by whining and sulking like a child.

to:

* PscyhopathicManchild: PsychopathicManchild: He demonstrates extreme arrogance and is unwilling to admit when he's wrong, shows a very juvenile sense of entitlement in his career and his relationships, and reacts to setbacks by whining and sulking like a child.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* PscyhopathicManchild: He demonstrates extreme arrogance and is unwilling to admit when he's wrong, shows a very juvenile sense of entitlement in his career and his relationships, and reacts to setbacks by whining and sulking like a child.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
dewicking Badass Baritone


* BadassBaritone: He has Alec Baldwin's commanding voice.

Added: 952

Changed: 187

Removed: 1293

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptationalAttractiveness: The real Duntsch wasn't quite as handsome as Joshua Jackson, and started getting fat ''before'' his career came unstuck.
* AdaptationalHeroism: Minor, but the show gives him the small redeeming trait of being truly passionate about biological research. The real-life Randall Kirby, however, has said that when he reviewed Duntsch's research, he found that it was mostly either plagiarized or outright falsified, and his old colleagues in that field have called Duntsch lazy and barely functional due to his drinking, stating his only value was winning over investors.






* HistoricalBeautyUpgrade: The real Duntsch wasn't quite as handsome as Joshua Jackson, and started getting fat ''before'' his career came unstuck.



* AdaptationalAttractiveness: The real Henderson wasn't as good-looking as Alec Baldwin. He's short and bald, while Baldwin is tall and has a full head of hair.



* HistoricalBeautyUpgrade: The real Henderson wasn't as good-looking as Alec Baldwin. He's short and bald, while Baldwin is tall and has a full head of hair.



* AdaptationalAttractiveness: Kirby in real life isn't bad looking, but he isn't as handsome as Christian Slater.



* HistoricalBeautyUpgrade: Kirby in real life isn't bad looking, but he isn't as handsome as Christian Slater.



* AdaptationalAttractiveness: The real Michelle Shughart isn't an unattractive woman by any means, but she bears very little resemblance to Creator/AnnaSophiaRobb, and was about a decade older in real life than she's portrayed here.
* AdaptationalDyeJob: The real Shughart has jet-black hair, but Creator/AnnaSophiaRobb keeps her own natural blonde color.

to:

* AdaptationalAttractiveness: The real Michelle Shughart isn't an unattractive woman by any means, but she bears very little resemblance to Creator/AnnaSophiaRobb, and was about a decade older in real life than she's portrayed here.
* AdaptationalDyeJob: The real Shughart has jet-black hair, is a brunette, but Creator/AnnaSophiaRobb keeps her own natural blonde color.



* HistoricalBeautyUpgrade: The real Michelle Shughart isn't an unattractive woman by any means, but she bears very little resemblance to Creator/AnnaSophiaRobb, and was about a decade older in real life than she's portrayed here.



* AdaptationalHeroism: The show heavily downplays the anger issues that Jerry develops as a result of being [[spoiler:made quadriplegic]], with the original podcast detailing an account that he would even [[spoiler: use his wheelchair as a battering ram to break furniture and assault his girlfriend]].


Added DiffLines:

* HistoricalVillainDowngrade: The show heavily downplays the anger issues that Jerry develops as a result of being [[spoiler:made quadriplegic]], with the original podcast detailing an account that he would even [[spoiler: use his wheelchair as a battering ram to break furniture and assault his girlfriend]].

Changed: 351

Removed: 257

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Moving to Diagnosed By The Audience in YMMV page


* AmbiguousDisorder: ''Something'' is very wrong in Duntsch's psyche, be it malignant narcissism, psychopathy, substance abuse, psychosis, delusional disorder, mania, vascular dementia from his rampant cocaine use, or some combination of these. The writers don't choose one answer, instead letting the viewers judge Duntsch's pathology for themselves.
** He also seems to have poor spatial reasoning. On the football field and a couple of times in the OR, he confuses left and right.
** After he's arrested, he expresses irritation at the constant noise in the prison, hinting at some sort of sensory overload.

to:

* AmbiguousDisorder: ''Something'' is very wrong in Duntsch's psyche, be it malignant narcissism, psychopathy, substance abuse, psychosis, delusional disorder, mania, vascular dementia from his rampant cocaine use, or some combination of these. The writers don't choose one answer, instead letting the viewers judge Duntsch's pathology for themselves.
** He also seems to have poor spatial reasoning. On the football field and a couple of times in the OR, he confuses left and right.
** After he's arrested, he expresses irritation at the constant noise in the prison, hinting at some sort of sensory overload.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AdaptationalHeroism: The show heavily downplays the anger issues that Jerry develops as a result of being [[spoiler:made quadriplegic]], with the original podcast detailing an account that he would even [[spoiler: use his wheelchair as a battering ram to break furniture and assault his girlfriend]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* JerkWithAHeartOfGold: He's aggressive, blustery, cocky and insulting, even to his allies, and he has a crude sense of humor, even cracking jokes in the OR. But he deeply cares about his patients' wellbeing, is devastated when he sees the damage Duntsch has done, has a warm and gentle bedside manner, and is determined to stop Duntsch from hurting more people. He also does his best to be respectful towards Dr. Henderson, despite their major personal differences. And even though his first meeting with Michelle goes poorly--he's disappointed that a rookie prosecutor got assigned to the case, and doesn't hide it--he warms up, and likes and respects her by the end.

to:

* JerkWithAHeartOfGold: He's aggressive, blustery, cocky and insulting, even to his allies, and he has a crude sense of humor, even cracking jokes in the OR. But he deeply cares about his patients' wellbeing, is devastated when he sees the damage Duntsch has done, has a warm and gentle bedside manner, and is determined to stop Duntsch from hurting more people. He also does his best to be respectful towards Dr. Henderson, despite their major personal differences.differences, making it clear that he does respect him as a doctor and sees him as a friend. And even though his first meeting with Michelle goes poorly--he's disappointed that a rookie prosecutor got assigned to the case, and doesn't hide it--he warms up, and likes and respects her by the end.



* PetTheDog: He gets a number of these moments to show his softer side, most notably when speaking with one of Duntsch's victims where he is noticeably far more soft spoken and genuinely devastated at not being able to do more to help her. He also warms up to Michelle after his initial hostility and shares a vulnerable moment with her in the same episode. He also makes it clear that, despite their differing personalities, he does respect Henderson as a coleleague and sees him as a friend.

to:

* PetTheDog: He gets a number of these moments to show his softer side, most notably when speaking with one of Duntsch's victims where he is noticeably far more soft spoken and genuinely devastated at not being able to do more to help her. He also warms up to Michelle after his initial hostility and shares a vulnerable moment with her in the same episode. He also makes it clear that, despite their differing personalities, he does respect Henderson as a coleleague colleague and sees him as a friend.

Added: 257

Changed: 23

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BrutalHonesty: Kirby is never afraid to tell anyone exactly what he really thinks about them.

to:

* BrutalHonesty: Kirby is never afraid to speak his mind or tell anyone exactly what he really thinks about of them.


Added DiffLines:

* HonorBeforeReason: He wants to stop Duntsch and doesn't care how he does it or about taking the slower, more methodical route if it means even the possibility of Duntsch hurting anyone else, leading Henderson and Shughart to reign him in much of the time.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CoolOldGuy: He's in his later years with grandchildren, and is a compassionate, pleasant, and caring man who is highly respected in his field, and is determined to stop Duntsch from hurting anyone else. He's also played by Alec Baldwin, making him cool by default.

to:

* CoolOldGuy: He's in his later years with grandchildren, and is a compassionate, pleasant, charming and caring man who is highly respected in his field, and is determined to stop Duntsch from hurting anyone else. He's also played by Alec Baldwin, making him cool by default.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Foil}}: He's Duntsch's polar opposite. While Duntsch is fairly young, Henderson is old enough to have grandchildren. Dunstch can't go five minutes without bragging about his supposed brilliance that masks his real lack of skill while Henderson is quite humble despite being a genuinely very skilled and respected surgeon. Duntsch has bad relationships with women that are undermined by his abusive behavior while Henderson has been happily married for decades and his scenes with his wife show his sweet side. Duntsch is disliked by colleagues, even before his real ineptitude becomes apparent, due to his arrogance while Henderson is well-liked and respected by those he works with, being seen as a mentor by younger doctors. The biggest difference is that while Duntsch's ego massively outweighs his actual skill and he couldn't care less about his patients, Henderson is a truly skilled surgeon who sincerely cares about those under his care and takes their suffering very hard. Henderson is both a good doctor and a good person while Duntsch is neither.

to:

* {{Foil}}: He's Duntsch's polar opposite. While Duntsch is fairly young, Henderson is old enough to have grandchildren. Dunstch can't go five minutes without bragging about his supposed brilliance that masks his real lack of skill while Henderson is quite humble despite being a genuinely very skilled and respected surgeon. Duntsch has bad relationships with women that are undermined by his abusive behavior while Henderson has been happily married for decades and his scenes with his wife show his sweet side. Duntsch is disliked by colleagues, even before his real ineptitude becomes apparent, due to his arrogance while Henderson is well-liked and respected by those he works with, being seen as a mentor by younger doctors. The biggest difference is that while Duntsch's ego massively outweighs his actual skill and he couldn't care less about his patients, Henderson is a truly skilled surgeon who sincerely cares about those under his care and takes their suffering very hard. Henderson is both a good doctor and a good person man while Duntsch is neither.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArchEnemy: He arguably qualifies as one to Duntsch. Kirby was the first to notice how botched Duntsch's surgeries were and try to do something about it and is the most adamant and vocal in stopping him by any means necessary. He even goes out of his way to make sure Duntsch knows it was him who was behind ruining his career and he will make it his mission to ensure Dunstch never practices medicine again.

to:

* ArchEnemy: He arguably qualifies as one to Duntsch. Kirby was the first to notice how botched Duntsch's surgeries were and try to do something about it and is the most adamant and vocal in stopping him by any means necessary.necessary and has easily the most intense and personal hatred for him. He even goes out of his way to make sure Duntsch knows it was him who was behind ruining his career and he will make it his mission to ensure Dunstch never practices medicine again.



* PetTheDog: He gets a number of these moments to show his softer side, most notably when speaking with one of Duntsch's victims where he is noticeably far more soft spoken and genuinely devastated at not being able to do more to help her. He also warms up to Michelle after his initial hostility and shares a vulnerable moment with her in the same episode.

to:

* PetTheDog: He gets a number of these moments to show his softer side, most notably when speaking with one of Duntsch's victims where he is noticeably far more soft spoken and genuinely devastated at not being able to do more to help her. He also warms up to Michelle after his initial hostility and shares a vulnerable moment with her in the same episode. He also makes it clear that, despite their differing personalities, he does respect Henderson as a coleleague and sees him as a friend.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptationalDyeJob: The real Kirby has dark blonde hair and striking blue eyes while here he has Christian Slater's natural black/greying color and brown eyes.

to:

* AdaptationalDyeJob: The real Kirby has dark blonde hair and striking blue eyes while here he has Christian Slater's natural black/greying color and brown eyes.

Added: 1001

Changed: 381

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HistoricalVillainDowngrade: As nasty as his [[DomesticAbuse treatment of Wendy is]] in the show, it was even ''worse'' in real life. The show omits the worst of it, such as a time when he beat her so badly while she was pregnant that she needed to go to the emergency room, or an incident after they'd separated when he drunkenly broke into her apartment with a gun.

to:

* HistoricalVillainDowngrade: Duntsch's behavior, both personal and professional, is actually toned down for the series,
**
As nasty as his [[DomesticAbuse treatment of Wendy is]] in the show, it was even ''worse'' in real life. The show omits the worst of it, such as a time when he beat her so badly while she was pregnant that she needed to go to the emergency room, or an incident after they'd separated when he drunkenly broke into her apartment and was found covered in blood and bruises while holding a knife and gun with a gun.ransom note written in blood nearby.
** The screenwriters treat Duntsch's research pursuits as legitimate, and portray his interest in biology as his sole redeeming trait. In reality, Duntsch's colleagues at Discgenics[[note]]a biotech startup that Duntsch was involved in, that went belly-up during the financial crisis of 2008[[/note]] have recalled him as a lazy drunkard whose only job was wining and dining prospective investors, and in an interview with Christian Slater, the real Randall Kirby said that he reviewed Duntsch's research and found to be either plagiarized or nonsensical.

Added: 334

Changed: 367

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* RedOniBlueOni: Blue to Kirby's red. He is soft-spoken, straight-laced, and polite.

to:

* RedOniBlueOni: Blue to Kirby's red. He is soft-spoken, straight-laced, logical, diplomatic and polite.



* BunnyEarsLawyer: And he'd be the first to admit it: he's blustering, foul-mouthed, hyperactive, and rarely bites his tongue. Luckily, Henderson is there to put the brakes on Kirby's wilder ideas. Much of his eccentricity is accepted both due to being fairly harmless and the fact that he is a legitimately very skilled surgeon.

to:

* BunnyEarsLawyer: And he'd be the first to admit it: he's blustering, foul-mouthed, hyperactive, and rarely bites his tongue. Luckily, Henderson is there to put the brakes on Kirby's wilder ideas. Much of his eccentricity is accepted both due to being fairly harmless and the fact that he is a legitimately very skilled surgeon.surgeon, having privileges at just about every major hospital in Dallas.



* NoSocialSkills: It's less that he doesn't have them so much as he just doesn't care enough to use them, bluntly insulting anyone he dislikes and not giving a rat's ass about diplomacy. He even thinks nothing of taking his shoes off and putting his feet on Henderson's desk to show his new socks despite Henderson's clear discomfort.



* PetTheDog: He gets a number of these moments to show his softer side, most notably when speaking with one of Duntsch's victims where he is noticeably far more soft spoken and genuinely devastated at not being able to do more to help her.

to:

* PetTheDog: He gets a number of these moments to show his softer side, most notably when speaking with one of Duntsch's victims where he is noticeably far more soft spoken and genuinely devastated at not being able to do more to help her. He also warms up to Michelle after his initial hostility and shares a vulnerable moment with her in the same episode.



* RedOniBlueOni: Red to Henderson's blue.

to:

* RedOniBlueOni: Red to Henderson's blue. He is emotional, heated, confrontational, blunt, has little regard for proptocal or social niceties and doesn't really care how Duntsch is stopped, only that he is.

Added: 375

Changed: 42

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BeneathTheMask: To the world and his patients, Duntsch is a brilliant surgeon, handsome, charming, confident and successful with hospitals and clinics lining up to make use of his skills. Underneath though lies a truly monstrous figure who is capable of unspeakable cruelty, has an ego the size of Jupiter with nothing to back it up and has seemingly no empathy whatsoever.



* TheCharmer: Chris can be very charismatic and good at gaining people's trust when he needs to be.

to:

* TheCharmer: Chris can be very charismatic and good at gaining people's trust when he needs to be. It's part of what sucks in many patients.

Added: 409

Changed: 6

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArchEnemy: He arguably qualifies as one to Duntsch. Kirby was the first to notice how botched Duntsch's surgeries were and try to do something about it and is the most adamant and vocal in stopping him by any means necessary. He even goes out of his way to make sure Duntsch knows it was him who was behind ruining his career and he will make it his mission to ensure Dunstch never practices medicine again.



* JerkWithAHeartOfGold: He's aggressive, blustery, and insulting, even to his allies, and he has a crude sense of humor, even cracking jokes in the OR. But he deeply cares about his patients' wellbeing, is devastated when he sees the damage Duntsch has done, has a warm and gentle bedside manner, and is determined to stop Duntsch from hurting more people. He also does his best to be respectful towards Dr. Henderson, despite their major personal differences. And even though his first meeting with Michelle goes poorly--he's disappointed that a rookie prosecutor got assigned to the case, and doesn't hide it--he warms up, and likes and respects her by the end.

to:

* JerkWithAHeartOfGold: He's aggressive, blustery, cocky and insulting, even to his allies, and he has a crude sense of humor, even cracking jokes in the OR. But he deeply cares about his patients' wellbeing, is devastated when he sees the damage Duntsch has done, has a warm and gentle bedside manner, and is determined to stop Duntsch from hurting more people. He also does his best to be respectful towards Dr. Henderson, despite their major personal differences. And even though his first meeting with Michelle goes poorly--he's disappointed that a rookie prosecutor got assigned to the case, and doesn't hide it--he warms up, and likes and respects her by the end.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


->'''Portrayed By:''' Hubert Point-du-Jour

to:

->'''Portrayed By:''' Hubert Point-du-Jour
Creator/HubertPointDuJour



->'''Portrayed By:''' Medina Singhore

to:

->'''Portrayed By:''' Medina Singhore
Creator/MedinaSinghore



->'''Portrayed By:''' Danny Burstein

to:

->'''Portrayed By:''' Danny Burstein
Creator/DannyBurstein



->'''Portrayed By:''' Dominic Burgess

to:

->'''Portrayed By:''' Dominic Burgess
Creator/DominicBurgess



->'''Portrayed By:''' Molly Griggs

to:

->'''Portrayed By:''' Molly Griggs
Creator/MollyGriggs



->'''Portrayed By:''' Laila Robins

to:

->'''Portrayed By:''' Laila Robins
Creator/LailaRobins



->'''Portrayed By:''' Spencer House

to:

->'''Portrayed By:''' Spencer House
Creator/SpencerHouse

Added: 265

Changed: 4

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In a stunning moment that showcases how utterly lacking in empathy he is, he goes up to Jerry (who he has just [[spoiler: rendered fully quadriplegic]]) and coldly denounces him for telling everyone [[spoiler: they were doing coke the night before the surgery]].



* PetTheDog: The only time he is ever shown in a positive light is with his son, to whom he is friendly, playful, and kind, never lashing out or talking down to him. At one point he jokingly guesses wrong about the toy that his son got for him in a McDonald's happy meal, which his son teases him about--note that this is the ''only'' time he readily and easily admits to being wrong about something.

to:

* PetTheDog: The only time he is ever shown in a positive light is with his son, to whom he is friendly, playful, and kind, never lashing out or talking down to him. At one point he jokingly guesses wrong about the toy that his son got for him in a McDonald's [=McDonald=]'s happy meal, which his son teases him about--note that this is the ''only'' time he readily and easily admits to being wrong about something.

Added: 400

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* PetTheDog: The only time he is ever shown in a positive light is with his son, to whom he is friendly, playful, and kind, never lashing out or talking down to him. At one point he jokingly guesses wrong about the toy that his son got for him in a McDonald's happy meal, which his son teases him about--note that this is the ''only'' time he readily and easily admits to being wrong about something.



* RedemptionRejection: When his father learns of Chris's crimes and that he is jeopardizing his family, he tells his son to clean up his act before it's too late. Chris actually seems to consider it, but eventually goes back and and keeps spiraling until he is arrested. Finally, in prison, he starts suggesting that he might surrender his medical license in exchange for freedom and the ability to go back to research, but his father realizes it's too latet, and that jail is the only choice.

to:

* RedemptionRejection: When his father learns of Chris's crimes and that he is jeopardizing his family, he tells his son to clean up his act before it's too late. Chris actually seems to consider it, but eventually goes back and and keeps spiraling until he is arrested. Finally, in prison, he starts suggesting that he might surrender his medical license in exchange for freedom and the ability to go back to research, but his father realizes it's too latet, late, and that jail is the only choice.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AmbiguousDisorder: ''Something'' is very wrong in Duntsch's psyche, be it malignant narcissism, psychopathy, substance abuse, a delusional disorder, mania, or some combination of these. The writers don't choose one answer, instead letting the viewers judge Duntsch's pathology for themselves.

to:

* AmbiguousDisorder: ''Something'' is very wrong in Duntsch's psyche, be it malignant narcissism, psychopathy, substance abuse, a psychosis, delusional disorder, mania, vascular dementia from his rampant cocaine use, or some combination of these. The writers don't choose one answer, instead letting the viewers judge Duntsch's pathology for themselves.

Top