Follow TV Tropes

Following

History AnachronismStew / PiratesOfTheCaribbeanOnStrangerTides

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* This movie has Jack Sparrow interacting with two historical characters: King George II and Blackbeard. Edward Teach, the historical Blackbeard, died in 1718 at age 38, played by the 68 year old Ian [=McShane=]. George II became King in 1727 and the movie has him appearing to be much older than the 44 years he was in 1727 (he's portrayed by Richard Griffiths who was 63). '''However''', Jack referred to Blackbeard's real life death, or more specifically his beheading after the Battle of Ocracoke Island. Backstory explains Blackbeard surviving by bribing Robert Maynard (the man who killed him in real life) into claiming that he slew Blackbeard and took his head. The 1740s-date also explains how both George II and Blackbeard are in their 60s (if Blackbeard faked his death). UsefulNotes/FerdinandVI of Spain has a brief scene in the movie and he became king in 1746.

to:

* This movie has Jack Sparrow interacting with two historical characters: King George II and Blackbeard.UsefulNotes/{{Blackbeard}}. Edward Teach, the historical Blackbeard, died in 1718 at age 38, played by the 68 year old Ian [=McShane=]. George II became King in 1727 and the movie has him appearing to be much older than the 44 years he was in 1727 (he's portrayed by Richard Griffiths who was 63). '''However''', Jack referred to Blackbeard's real life death, or more specifically his beheading after the Battle of Ocracoke Island. Backstory explains Blackbeard surviving by bribing Robert Maynard (the man who killed him in real life) into claiming that he slew Blackbeard and took his head. The 1740s-date also explains how both George II and Blackbeard are in their 60s (if Blackbeard faked his death). UsefulNotes/FerdinandVI of Spain has a brief scene in the movie and he became king in 1746.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* This movie has Jack Sparrow interacting with two historical characters: King George II and Blackbeard. Edward Teach, the historical Blackbeard, died in 1718 at age 38, played by the 68 year old Ian [=McShane=]. George II became King in 1727 and the movie has him appearing to be much older than the 44 years he was in 1727 (he's portrayed by Richard Griffiths who was 63). '''However''', Jack referred to Blackbeard's real life death, or more specifically his beheading after the Battle of Ocracoke Island. Backstory explains Blackbeard surviving by bribing Robert Maynard (the man who killed him in real life) into claiming that he slew Blackbeard and took his head. The 1740s-date also explains how both George II and Blackbeard are in their 60s (if Blackbeard faked his death). Ferdinand VI of Spain has a brief scene in the movie and he became king in 1746.

to:

* This movie has Jack Sparrow interacting with two historical characters: King George II and Blackbeard. Edward Teach, the historical Blackbeard, died in 1718 at age 38, played by the 68 year old Ian [=McShane=]. George II became King in 1727 and the movie has him appearing to be much older than the 44 years he was in 1727 (he's portrayed by Richard Griffiths who was 63). '''However''', Jack referred to Blackbeard's real life death, or more specifically his beheading after the Battle of Ocracoke Island. Backstory explains Blackbeard surviving by bribing Robert Maynard (the man who killed him in real life) into claiming that he slew Blackbeard and took his head. The 1740s-date also explains how both George II and Blackbeard are in their 60s (if Blackbeard faked his death). Ferdinand VI UsefulNotes/FerdinandVI of Spain has a brief scene in the movie and he became king in 1746.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Jack mentions that he supports "the missionary's position" when Philip is arguing with Blackbeard over Syrena. Intended to be an obvious DoubleEntendre, but the term "missionary position" was first coined by professor Alfred Kinsey in 1948 during his famous study on human sexual behavior.
* When discussing Philip with Scrum, Jack offhandedly refers to the missionary as a "bible-thumper", a mostly American/Canadian term that would not be invented until 1923.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Jack mentions that he supports "the missionary's position" when Philip is arguing with Blackbeard over Syrena. Intended to be an obvious DoubleEntendre, but the term "missionary position" was first coined by professor Alfred Kinsey in 1948 during his famous study on human sexual behavior.
* When discussing Philip with Scrum, Jack offhandedly refers to the missionary as a "bible-thumper", a mostly American/Canadian term that would not be invented until 1923.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Jack mentions that he supports "the missionary's position" when Philip is arguing with Blackbeard over Syrena. Intended to be an obvious DoubleEntendre, but the term "missionary position" was first coined by professor Alfred Kinsey in 1948 during his famous study into human sexual behavior.

to:

* Jack mentions that he supports "the missionary's position" when Philip is arguing with Blackbeard over Syrena. Intended to be an obvious DoubleEntendre, but the term "missionary position" was first coined by professor Alfred Kinsey in 1948 during his famous study into on human sexual behavior.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* When discussing Philip with Scrum, Jack offhandedly refers to the missionary as a "bible-thumper", a mostly American/Canadian term that would not be invented until 1923.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Jack mentions that he supports "the missionary's position" when Philip is arguing with Blackbeard over Syrena. Intended to be an obvious DoubleEntendre, but the term "missionary position" was first coined by professor Alfred Kinsey in 1948 during his famous study into human sexual behavior.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
More historical inaccuracies

Added DiffLines:

* The film shows that the corpse of Juan Ponce de León is in his ship "Santiago", which is stuck in-between rocks. In history, "Santiago" came back to Florida and de León was buried in Puerto Rico.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Buckingham Palace in the 1700s apparently had electrical outlets and modern day A/C ventilation.

to:

* Buckingham St James's Palace in the 1700s apparently had electrical outlets and modern day A/C ventilation.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
from the main page

Added DiffLines:

* Buckingham Palace in the 1700s apparently had electrical outlets and modern day A/C ventilation.

Changed: 103

Removed: 145

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* This movie has Jack Sparrow interacting with two historical characters: King George II and Blackbeard. Edward Teach, the historical Blackbeard, died in 1718 at age 38, played by the 68 year old Ian [=McShane=]. George II became King in 1727 and the movie has him appearing to be much older than the 44 years he was in 1727 (he's portrayed by Richard Griffiths who was 63). However, Jack referred to Blackbeard's real life death, or more specifically his beheading after the Battle of Ocracoke Island. Backstory explains Blackbeard surviving by bribing Robert Maynard (the man who killed him in real life) into claiming that he slew Blackbeard and took his head. The 1740s-date also explains how both George II and Blackbeard are in their 60s (if Blackbeard faked his death). Ferdinand VI of Spain has a brief scene in the movie and he became king in 1746.
* The Union Flag is the current version incorporating the red saltire of Saint Patrick's flag representing Ireland. This first flew in 1801 following the Act of Union 1800.
** Made a bigger slip up considering the previous films used the correct rendition of the Union Flag (the one lacking the Saint Patrick's cross).

to:

* This movie has Jack Sparrow interacting with two historical characters: King George II and Blackbeard. Edward Teach, the historical Blackbeard, died in 1718 at age 38, played by the 68 year old Ian [=McShane=]. George II became King in 1727 and the movie has him appearing to be much older than the 44 years he was in 1727 (he's portrayed by Richard Griffiths who was 63). However, '''However''', Jack referred to Blackbeard's real life death, or more specifically his beheading after the Battle of Ocracoke Island. Backstory explains Blackbeard surviving by bribing Robert Maynard (the man who killed him in real life) into claiming that he slew Blackbeard and took his head. The 1740s-date also explains how both George II and Blackbeard are in their 60s (if Blackbeard faked his death). Ferdinand VI of Spain has a brief scene in the movie and he became king in 1746.
* The Union Flag is the current version incorporating the red saltire of Saint Patrick's flag representing Ireland. This first flew in 1801 following the Act of Union 1800.
** Made a bigger slip up considering the previous
1800 (previous films used the correct rendition of the Union Flag (the one Flag, lacking the Saint Patrick's cross).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Theodore Groves is referred to in both dialogue and the credits as "Lieutenant Commander". However, this rank wasn't created in the British Navy until 1877. Groves can only be a Lieutenant or a Commander, with the latter being more likely in serving as second-in-command to an Privateer Admiral (Barbossa).

to:

* Theodore Groves is referred to in both dialogue and the credits as "Lieutenant Commander". However, this rank wasn't created in the British Navy until 1877. Groves can only be a Lieutenant or a Commander, with the latter being more likely in serving as second-in-command to an a Privateer Admiral (Barbossa).

Changed: 553

Removed: 788

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* This movie has Jack Sparrow interacting with two historical characters: King George II and Blackbeard. Edward Teach, the historical Blackbeard, died in 1718. George II didn't become King until 1727 and the movie has him appearing to be much older than the 44 years he was in 1727 (he's portrayed by Richard Griffiths who was 63).
** The movie also has Blackbeard, who died at around the age of 38, being played by the 68 year old Ian [=McShane=].
*** It should be noted that Jack referred to Blackbeard's real life death, or more specifically his beheading after the Battle of Ocracoke Island. Backstory explains Blackbeard surviving by bribing Robert Maynard (the man who killed him in real life) into claiming that he slew Blackbeard and took his head. The 1740s-date also explains how both George II and Blackbeard are in their 60s (if Blackbeard faked his death). Ferdinand VI of Spain has a brief scene in the movie and he became king in 1746.

to:

* This movie has Jack Sparrow interacting with two historical characters: King George II and Blackbeard. Edward Teach, the historical Blackbeard, died in 1718. 1718 at age 38, played by the 68 year old Ian [=McShane=]. George II didn't become became King until in 1727 and the movie has him appearing to be much older than the 44 years he was in 1727 (he's portrayed by Richard Griffiths who was 63).
** The movie also has Blackbeard, who died at around the age of 38, being played by the 68 year old Ian [=McShane=].
*** It should be noted that
63). However, Jack referred to Blackbeard's real life death, or more specifically his beheading after the Battle of Ocracoke Island. Backstory explains Blackbeard surviving by bribing Robert Maynard (the man who killed him in real life) into claiming that he slew Blackbeard and took his head. The 1740s-date also explains how both George II and Blackbeard are in their 60s (if Blackbeard faked his death). Ferdinand VI of Spain has a brief scene in the movie and he became king in 1746.



* Also it features Blackbeard as a pirate and Barbossa as a British privateer. Blackbeard didn't become a pirate until after Britain outlawed the practice of privateering.



* Jack and Angelica jump into the Thames to escape King George's soldiers, and are shown swimming in clear water. The River Thames of the 1740s was a slurry of waste and a fall into the water could--and often did--kill.

to:

* Jack and Angelica jump into the Thames to escape King George's soldiers, and are shown swimming in clear water. The River Thames of the 1740s was a slurry of waste and a fall into the water could--and could -- and often did--kill.did -- kill.

Added: 4

Changed: 194

Removed: 191

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** It should be noted that Jack referred to Blackbeard's real life death, or more specifically his beheading after the Battle of Ocracoke Island. Backstory explains Blackbeard surviving by bribing Robert Maynard (the man who killed him in real life) into claiming that he slew Blackbeard and took his head.
** The 1740s-date explains how both George II and Blackbeard are in their 60s (if Blackbeard faked his death). Ferdinand VI of Spain has a brief scene in the movie and he became king in 1746.

to:

*** It should be noted that Jack referred to Blackbeard's real life death, or more specifically his beheading after the Battle of Ocracoke Island. Backstory explains Blackbeard surviving by bribing Robert Maynard (the man who killed him in real life) into claiming that he slew Blackbeard and took his head.
**
head. The 1740s-date also explains how both George II and Blackbeard are in their 60s (if Blackbeard faked his death). Ferdinand VI of Spain has a brief scene in the movie and he became king in 1746.



* Several of Angelica's outfits include underbust corsets. Eighteenth-century stays were underwear, and provided support for the bust; underbust corsets weren't invented until the Victorian era, when they were still underwear. An underbust corset worn as decorative outerwear, with an hourglass silhouette, shaped to a point between the breasts, is a modern costume element.

to:

* Several of Angelica's outfits include underbust corsets. Eighteenth-century stays were underwear, and provided support for the bust; underbust corsets weren't invented until the Victorian era, when they were still underwear. An underbust corset worn as decorative outerwear, with an hourglass silhouette, shaped to a point between the breasts, is a modern costume element.element.
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The 1740s-date explains how both George II and Blackbeard are in their 60s (if Blackbeard faked his death). Ferdinand VI of Spain has a brief scene in the movie and he became king in 1746.

Changed: 6

Removed: 4

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Jack and Angelica jump into the Thames to escape King George's soldiers, and are shown swimming in clear water. The River Thames of the 1740s was a slurry of waste and a fall into the water could - and often did - kill.

to:

* Jack and Angelica jump into the Thames to escape King George's soldiers, and are shown swimming in clear water. The River Thames of the 1740s was a slurry of waste and a fall into the water could - and could--and often did - kill.did--kill.



* Several of Angelica's outfits include underbust corsets. Eighteenth-century stays were underwear, and provided support for the bust; underbust corsets weren't invented until the Victorian era, when they were still underwear. An underbust corset worn as decorative outerwear, with an hourglass silhouette, shaped to a point between the breasts, is a modern costume element.
----

to:

* Several of Angelica's outfits include underbust corsets. Eighteenth-century stays were underwear, and provided support for the bust; underbust corsets weren't invented until the Victorian era, when they were still underwear. An underbust corset worn as decorative outerwear, with an hourglass silhouette, shaped to a point between the breasts, is a modern costume element.
----
element.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Several of Angelica's outfits include underbust corsets. Eighteenth-century stays were underwear, and provided support for the bust; underbust corsets weren't invented until the Victorian era, when they were still underwear. An underbust corset worn as decorative outerwear, with an hourglass silhouette, shaped to a point between the breasts, is a modern costume element.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* This movie has Jack Sparrow interacting with two historical characters: King George II and Blackbeard. Edward Teach, the historical Blackbeard, died in 1718. George II didn't become King until 1727 and the movie has him appearing to be much older than the 44 years he was in 1727 (he's portrayed by Richard Griffiths who was 63).
** The movie also has Blackbeard, who died at around the age of 38, being played by the 68 year old Ian [=McShane=].
*** It should be noted that Jack referred to Blackbeard's real life death, or more specifically his beheading after the Battle of Ocracoke Island. Backstory explains Blackbeard surviving by bribing Robert Maynard (the man who killed him in real life) into claiming that he slew Blackbeard and took his head.
* The Union Flag is the current version incorporating the red saltire of Saint Patrick's flag representing Ireland. This first flew in 1801 following the Act of Union 1800.
** Made a bigger slip up considering the previous films used the correct rendition of the Union Flag (the one lacking the Saint Patrick's cross).
** They use the Blue Ensign, which denotes Atlantic, Pacific and East Indies stations. The correct flag would be the Red Ensign, which denotes West Indies.
* Also it features Blackbeard as a pirate and Barbossa as a British privateer. Blackbeard didn't become a pirate until after Britain outlawed the practice of privateering.
* Mechanical tuners were not used for mandolins until early in the 19th century. Peg tuners were the standard.
* During the chase scene, when Jack Sparrow is fleeing from the Palace of King George, one of the pursuing troops uses a pea whistle to raise the alarm. The pea whistle was not invented until 1883, by Joseph Hudson.
* Jack and Angelica jump into the Thames to escape King George's soldiers, and are shown swimming in clear water. The River Thames of the 1740s was a slurry of waste and a fall into the water could - and often did - kill.
* Theodore Groves is referred to in both dialogue and the credits as "Lieutenant Commander". However, this rank wasn't created in the British Navy until 1877. Groves can only be a Lieutenant or a Commander, with the latter being more likely in serving as second-in-command to an Privateer Admiral (Barbossa).
----

Top