Follow TV Tropes

Following

Archived Discussion Main / HonorAmongThieves

Go To

This is discussion archived from a time before the current discussion method was installed.


Madrugada: How is this "overly specific?" It's well-written, it is a trope, and as far as I can see, we don't have it under a different name. Let it live.

Cidolfas: There are no examples and it didn't go through YKTTW. Generally a trope without examples isn't very useful.

Muninn: Well, how about we add some examples, then? Who's that guy in the picture?

Madrugada Throwing out a well-written trope that we don't already have simply because it didn't go through YKTTW is silly. Examples can be added.

Cidolfas: But unless Wiki Magic magically trips itself, these pages tend to just wallow in obscurity. YKTTW is the best place to add examples, so cutting it and putting it properly on YKTTW is the best process to turning it into a usable page.

Muninn: How about making a YKTTW with the trope description, requesting examples, and just move all of the examples suggested onto this page rather than cutting this page so that you can just launch it a second time. That way, if somebody does find this page through Wiki Magic (or, say, seeing it on cutlist), they can still add examples.

Top