Discussion link appears to be dead.
Also, this isn't strictly true. There are tropes and trivia which can (and presently do) refer to real-life events and people. However, there are several tropes that fall under No Real Life Examples Please, which obviously should NOT cover real life and people. Some such tropes do not have this explicitly written out on their main pages. Check the page for No Real Life Examples Please if you are uncertain. The main focus of the MLP Analysis page should be the creators' works and not the creators themselves.
And of course, Rule of Cautious Editing Judgment always applies.
Edit: Link appears to be working again.
Edited by Ninja857142
Who is your favorite MLP Analyst? Least favorite? And why?
Hide / Show Replies
Most Favorite: Silver Quill and TBBBAP. It was a tough call. Silver Quill is funny, goes the extra mile in his reviews, and never acts demeaning or rude. TBBBAP are so enthusiastic in the material, and have great intros. Both have perfect voices, diction, opinions, and professional quality in their videos.
Least Favorite: Mr. Enter. Just watch a few of his videos. You'll see why.
Why? I kind of like him.
Anyway, my favourites are a tossup between Silver Quill, Antony C, Tommy Oliver and Joshscorcher.
Favorite MLP Analysis: Somewhat between Enter/Mis Anthro. Mis Anthro, despite the controversy surrounding him is a pretty laid back and not so picky reviewer when it comes to his reviews.
Least are between ILKPA or Josh. Josh these days ever since his friendship with Jerry Peet and of course, his critiques over Luna.
Edited by BronyoftheOctaves FURIOUS MASTURBATION!!!
Josh Scorcher: Good thoughts, presentation, and humor all around.
The Mysterious Mr. Enter: Does a mostly good job of explaining his thoughts and opinions, and I actually think he can be pretty funny at times. Also, Fluttershy's his favorite.
Brawny Buck
: For his discussions on morals and glorious puns.
Silver Quill: Funny, clever, and great animation presentations. Also, Fluttershy's his favorite.
Antony C: A showy and hilarious take on the Caustic Critic.
HungrySohma: Because the cuteness is over 9,000.
Officer Happy: Clever, underrated analyst with some well-thought-out vids, arguments and zingers.
Troping real people and their inter-community drama is not permitted on TV Tropes. Keep entries restricted to their works alone. This group of youtubers has a habit of making videos about their inter-community drama, but it is not applicable here. https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/query.php?parent_id=57440&type=att
Edited by lianawolfe Hide / Show Replies