Needs Help: Weird Moon

Re-clocked. Does anyone like the moon◊ from Homestar Runner enough to include it in a collage, or should we just crowner the options we've got now?

Looks kinda cheesy.

Crowner's hooked.

All thee collages have examples of subtropes. Can we get more image ideas in to replace questionable content?

Votes bump; all are in the green.

Here's a suggestion that doesn't overlap with any of the subtropes The Man in the Moon, Deface of the Moon or Detonation Moon.

Votes bump for new entry 31.1

Honestly, I prefer the non-reddened version of the moon from Assassination Classroom, plus, I think it's toeing the line of Detonation Moon a little too closely.

What about Van Gogh's "Starry Night"?

edited 1st May '17 6:05:33 PM by eroock

Eh, not really crazy about that.

Calling the crowner. Now, does anyone think we should run a new one with the options that have come up since then or just go with the winner?

Just go with it. The lead won by a margin large enough to comfortably call.

Caption suggestion:

With the standard note to list the sources.

If a tree falls in the forest and nobody remembers it, who else will you have ice cream with?

What are the sources? The only one I recognize is the bottom right...is the heart one from Kingdom Hearts?

EDIT: The new pic's up and the tag's adjusted.

Old pic:

edited 6th May '17 2:11:11 PM by Willbyr

The heart is from the secret ending of Kingdom Hearts II Final Mix and the bottom left is from the World 5 Boss Battle in Super Mario World 2: Yoshi's Island. No idea about the other two.

edited 6th May '17 2:17:29 PM by Karxrida

If a tree falls in the forest and nobody remembers it, who else will you have ice cream with?

Top left is from Fairy Tail ([1])

Wait, the top left's actually a layer in the atmosphere cracking?◊ Should it be replaced in the collage? I thought 26 was a decent image for the collage.

My vote was based on the assumption it was an example of the moon cracking and being purple. There's the argument that it could confuse people who know that particular image isn't an example.

edited 6th May '17 6:39:48 PM by WaterBlap

Look at all that shiny stuff ain't they pretty

I don't think users knowing it to be a subversion will be confused as to what the trope is about in general. 26 seems like a Cheesy Moon example and I wanted to avoid showing subtrope examples on the supertrope page.

For what it's worth, there a reasonable argument that the Gunnerkrigg Court moon was not from a subtrope. It looks like Deface of the Moon, but that trope also is at least partially about intent; the point of the trope is a villain trying to intimidate the world by demonstrating an ability to shape the moon to their image.

In the Gunnerkrigg Court example, the person who made the fingerprint mark (Antimony) did it by accident. (To be fair, it reflects a show of power by Coyote, so it sort of falls under the trope, but it's not a clear example.)

No further caption discussion; locking up.