Suggestion: Nightmare Fuel.The Little Mermaid

Which picture looks scarier, this one, or the one I already put on the page?

If anyone else thinks they can do a better job cropping it, here's the uncropped version: [1]◊

edited 28th Apr '13 1:10:07 PM by dsneybuf

I always thought this◊ was the scariest moment when I was a kid.

I prefer this one.

I like #2. It's creepy in a far less obvious way, and nightmares lies in things unknown.

All are good, but 2>1>current. 2 has, as Ducky said, the creepy feel — the others are more generic "evil song" scenes.

edited 28th Apr '13 1:45:08 PM by Telcontar

2 for me.

I'd go with number one.

I prefer the cropped version of number one.

Number 2.

2 because Nothing Is Scarier

I'd be fine with any image other than the current one.

The image @2 has pretty strong support. I think it could be uploaded.

Should it be brightened or is the darkness added creepy, since you see her big, creepy eyes best?

edited 10th May '13 6:24:48 AM by helterskelter

I like it as it is.

This is one of the few pages where having a dark image isn't necessarily bad. I think it works.

Looks good enough.

Bump; I also vote for using Helter Skelter's Ariel image.

We've got enough consensus to run with the Ariel pic. It's up and potholed; add a caption if you want one. Locking up.