Suggestion: Dastardly Whiplash

The image for Dastardly Whiplash was evidently changed without discussion, so here are the two versions, both showing Snidely Whiplash, with the old one on top. I think it's cleaner-looking than the replacement, but either would probably work. Or maybe someone has something better.

edited 9th Jan '13 11:59:47 AM by Geoduck

Pick 1. 2 has way too much black space and looks like a demotivator.

Cleaner = better. There's nothing else significant that differs.

Looks more like a title starring card to me.

You should feel awesome.

edited 9th Jan '13 6:06:27 PM by AnotherDuck

I am endorsing the post of a duck. I'm unsure how to feel about this.

I like the old one better. The second one puts too much emphasis on the name, and de-emphasizes the appearance.

^ What's to be unsure about? Ducks are yummy very smart.

edited 9th Jan '13 1:19:37 PM by Madrugada

Older was better.

I think they're about the same. Can we find a clnr version of 1.1?

I found a cleaner version and put it back on the page and tagged it. Do we want to caption it?

I think it speaks for itself.

What do you mean, "do we want to caption it"? It already was captioned. I say leave it.

I pick Snideley with his title. Of course, you could always use the single cover for Taylor Swift's "Mean"...unless you want that for Chained to a Railway.

That doesn't actually show this trope. It shows something such a character is likely to do, but not the character himself. Duplicate images are also frowned upon.

The old caption did absolutely nothing for the pic except set up a JAFAAC situation.

Except it's not JAFAAC, considering he looks dastardly.

Not seeing a consensus for anything, so let's just leave it as is; if someone comes up with a caption, go for it. Locking up.