YMMV: The Spooge Monster
- Crosses the Line Twice: Garfield saying that Jon shoved his spare tire up his ass when he was trying to play Goatse-Man.
- Heck, everything that comes out of Garfield's mouth (okay, not actually, but still)
- Padding: Dear LORD. The entire opening being played in reverse, Jon attempting not to carry out Rock Bottom, the ending...
- So Bad, It's Good: Both parts are terrible, between the overly long gags, vulgar lines, and strange endings. The first is liked, the second not so much.
- Squick: "That's not a lake.".