Season 3, Episode 8:
A Very Supernatural ChristmasWritten by Jeremy Carver.Directed by J. Miller Tobin.Airdate: December 13, 2007.In this Christmas-themed episode, Sam and Dean encounter a twisted couple of pagan gods in Ypsilanti, Michigan that share a craving for human meat. Flashbacks follow the Winchesters during Christmas sixteen years ago in Broken Bow, Nebraska when Sam first learned that the supernatural existed and that his father hunted it.
Body countFor this episode = 3 humans and 2 gods.For the series so far = At least 230 humans, 17 ghosts, 8 demons, 10 vampires, 6 changelings, 3 gods, 2 shapeshifters, 2 werewolves, 1 djinn, 1 rakshasa, 1 rawhead, 1 shtriga, 1 wendigo, and 1 zombie.
- Affably Evil: Despite the whole eating-people thing, the two pagan gods genuinely get along with their neighbors, playing bridge and "assimilating", as they call it, into modern society.
- An Asskicking Christmas: Dean and Sam spend Christmas fighting pagan gods.
- Bad Santa: Sam originally thinks that the killings are caused by some kind of "anti-Claus".
- Berserk Button: Mentioning Mary Winchester is one for young Dean.
- Blatant Lies: "I was just testing you."
- Broken Masquerade: Young Sam reads John's diary and learns that monsters are real.
- Christmas Episode: Duh.
- Christmas Song: "Have Yourself A Merry Little Christmas" is used as the BGM.
- Convenience Store Gift Shopping: Justified as their Christmas was thrown together at the last minute and a convenience store/gas station was pretty much the only place open on Christmas Eve!
- Creepy Basement: Filled with chopped-up dead humans, bloody knives and power saws.
- Death of the Old Gods: The pagan gods reflect on how they used to have numerous followers and sacrifices until Christianity came along.
- Do They Know It's Christmas Time?: Justified in that it's to be Dean's last Christmas, and he wants to make the most of it.
- Evil Old Folks: The two pagan gods appear as a semi-elderly Happily Married couple, with the man wearing a Mr. Rogers sweater.
- Faux Affably Evil: Some of the gods' affability is a mask, as shown when they step on the fruitcake a neighbor offered.
- Fingore: Shown onscreen even! Sam gets a fingernail ripped off by the pagans.
- Flashbacks: To 1991, the year Sam learned monsters are real and gave Dean his amulet.
- Evil Smoking: The old man smokes a pipe.
- Gosh Darn It to Heck!: In-Universe, the pagan gods frown upon swearing, and suggest to an irate Dean that he use "fudge" when he wants to swear.
- Hijacked by Jesus: In-Universe. Discussed as Sam and the pagan gods mention how Christianity appropriated pagan customs like winter solstice celebrations and transformed them into Christian holidays (Christmas).
- Humanoid Abomination/Physical God: This is what the two pagan gods look like; they look very human and innocent, but have at one point wanted sacrifices..
- Impaled with Extreme Prejudice: The two pagan gods are sent to Hell when Sam and Dean impale them on Christmas tree branches.
- Leaving Food for Santa: The evil Santa is seen eating cookies that have been left out.
- Mall Santa: The Winchesters investigate a drunken, pot-smoking, porn-watching Mall Santa.
- Memento MacGuffin: Dean's necklace (originally meant for John) was given to him by Sam sixteen years ago.
- Mistaken for Pedophile: Sam and Dean get some funny looks—two adult men walking into a fake Santa's workshop. Sam makes it worse by saying "We only came here to watch".
- Parental Abandonment: John is out on a hunt in 1991 and doesn't show up for Christmas. Dean tries to make it look like their dad came back for Sam, but Sam's not fooled.
- Rustproof Blood
- The Krampus: Mentioned by Sam when researching evil Santa.
- The Tooth Hurts: Subverted: as Dean is about to get his tooth pulled out, the doorbell rings.
- Unholy Matrimony: The two pagan gods are an old married couple that have been around a long time.
- Wooden Stake: The pagan gods can be killed with evergreen stakes.