Please don't list this on a work's page as a trope. Examples can go on the work's YMMV tab.
Nightmare Fuel: My Name Is Earl
They managed to make sex with Jenna Elfman, as a highly flexible cheerleader, and turn it into the scaryby making her disfigured.
Little Chubby's batting cage scene. Fearing a potential Groin Attack has never been that scary.
Randy on shark adrenaline.
The reveal that the doorstop for the bathroom door is actually the original owner of the Crab Shack, who's dead body had been encased in cement into the floor with his nose sticking up.
And then Randy (assuming he's still alive) staying behind to clamp his nose shutnote He's still upset over fish wings not being served every night. to kill him (assuming, again, he's still alive). Seeing Randy do that? Wow.