Impossibly Mundane Explanation
Bob is acting unusually. Maybe he knows something he shouldn't or is spouting highly advanced facts about nuclear physics in Latin. The leading theory is extraordinary — maybe he's possessed, or maybe his Evil Twin
has taken his place. Someone will propose a mundane alternative like, "He read a book about it". Everyone rejects it out of hand because it would be out of character for Bob, and they return to the extraordinary theory.
This mostly occurs in Speculative Fiction
. It serves to reinforce our characters' comfort with the extraordinary while simultaneously reinforcing characterization. The rejection will frequently be nonverbal, consisting instead of "Are you crazy?" looks.
Bonus points if said mundane explanation actually is
Note that not every case of characters choosing an extraordinary explanation over a mundane one is this trope. This is only if the mundane explanation is rejected out of hand because it would be completely out of character for said person.
Related to Arkham's Razor
, which is where the weirdest solution is most likely to be the true one.
open/close all folders
- Dirk Gently does this to some extent in The Long Dark Tea-Time of the Soul. When he meets a girl who constantly recites the previous day's stock quotes (in real time, just with a 24-hour delay), he rejects the assumption that she's just memorizing them somehow (after all, the information is out there!) in favor of some more mystical explanation, because nobody would ever go to that much trouble. It's a little different since he's arguing on the basis of general human nature, not specific character, but the principle is the same. Dirk sums this up by reversing Sherlock Holmes' usual maxim: Eliminate the improbable, and whatever remains, however impossible, must be the truth.
- At the climax of Cold Days, Harry Dresden faces off against another hero, set on him by one of The Fair Folk, who told Fix that Harry is the villain. After getting his butt thoroughly kicked, Harry sums up the situation thusly: Either a being who Cannot Tell a Lie has, or Harry Blackstone Copperfield Dresden is an evil mastermind. Faced with the evidence, Fix realizes he's been used.
- The Stargate SG-1 episode "Window of Opportunity": Jack has prior knowledge of a briefing Carter is giving, and claims that he's remembering things from the future. Carter suggests, "Maybe he read my report?". Daniel gives her a look and repeats, "Maybe he read your report?" as if it was the most ludicrous suggestion. Everyone else (O'Neill included) seems to agree.
- Buffy the Vampire Slayer
- The gang is attempting to contact Buffy:
Xander: Well, she didn't go home. I let the phone ring a few hundred times before I remembered her mom is out of town.
Giles: Well, maybe Buffy unplugged the phone.
Xander: No, it's a statistical impossibility for a 16-year-old girl to unplug her phone.
- There's also the time that Xander was possessed by a hyena. Buffy quickly figured out he was possessed while Giles believed he was just being a teenage boy. Knowing Giles' teen years, this assumption makes a bit more sense.
- Played with in Dexter, when Astor asks what Lumen is doing in Dexter's house. Dexter claims they're not dating, and she's just a tenant. While she's much more than that, Dexter never lied. They aren't dating at this point.
- On Two and a Half Men, Evelyn Harper steps in to fund her grandson Jake's college expenses. Jake's dad, Alan, finds himself losing his drive, first losing interest in his job, and then expressing a very real fear that he may commit suicide. This provides the Eureka Moment for Alan's brother Charlie, who had been trying to figure out why Evelyn is behaving uncharacteristically. Alan briefly refuses to believe this, until:
- Freefall has some fun with this. Apparently, Florence is a vampire. Either that, or she really swam in the cold water a bit too long.
- El Goonish Shive has a borderline example.
- In The Order of the Stick, there are five Gates keeping an Eldritch Abomination called "the Snarl" contained. The paladins of the Sapphire Order are responsible for guarding one of them. However (due to disagreements on behalf of the people who established them), they all swore an oath not to look into the status or even location of the others. The villains find this difficult to believe, to say the least.
: I find it far
more probable that you are somehow resisting my magic. This "Soon's Oath"
story is just that — a cover story designed by your leaders. [...]
O'chul: You find the idea that I have some sort of secret knowledge implanted in my brain by the elders of the Sapphire Guard that has been so deeply suppressed that no magical effect can unearth it to be simpler... than the idea that I just don't know anything?
Redcloak: I liked the way I phrased it better.
O'chul: No doubt.