As noted under the heartwarming page: In the first episode Tacoma points out that what he writes almost never makes it into the final product. In the second episode, his speech does and Donnie says it's perfect.
In the first episode, Rebecca came off as a Strange Girl ditz who was oblivious that she accidentally killed her cat. With what she said about how actresses get treated in episode four, she was very likely putting on a front for people she didn't know too well yet.
From "Blue Patches" we find that Donnie's films may have been intentionally bad due to his personal issues with Hollywood.
"The Review Must Go On" can be seen as a dramatization of Doug's internal conflict over ending the Nostalgia Critic, and whether he should bring him back or not.
All the special effects and costumes that appeared in the parodies of The Sixth Sense and Batman but nowhere else could be explained as Donnie having no idea how to budget anything and throwing his wife's money away, then having very little left over.
Donnie's stalker tendencies in the pilot and towards Rob Paulsen sound a bit out of character considering his past history of being a child actor abused by strangers, but we also know he made bad remakes to get revenge at Hollywood by trying to destroy things they liked. No reason why he couldn't have the same vindictiveness towards actors too.
Rebecca knows Cat for trapped in the washer while it's on. Carl lampshades this.
What exactly happened to Rebecca when she left alone with Uncle Frank for twenty minutes to think she would be more normal if it didn't?
In episode four, the guys who kidnapped Donnie abandon him in a forest with a working camera, which he's surprised by. Out-of-verse it's so Doug can shoot a Blair Witch parody, but in-verse - as they were given orders by the leader to let him die - does that mean they wanted footage of him starving to death/getting killed?
Just when were the Yandere family going to let Donnie go?
With The Reveal of Donnie being a Former Child Star who got shouted at in the streets, plus the family thinking that complimenting his facial structure as a kid wouldn't creep him out, plus how he flirts with everyone and doesn't seem to remember he's married sometimes, you have to wonder what other kind of abuse happened to him. And just how long is "always" when it comes to Slash Fic, especially when he had no other knowledge of fandom trends?
And when Rebecca's “Uncle Frank” first comes up, he and Tacoma clearly know what it means, but while Tacoma starts fretting over her at this point, he shrugs it off like it's nothing.
The newspaper, in their infinite wisdom, showed Donnie's picture in their article. So the people calling him a horrible person probably knew what had happened, but abused him anyway.
Where was the camera that was attatched to the turkey's head? It was never visible on the prop despite seeing turkey cam.
Quinn and Carl clearly aren't carrying the cameras for their POV shots either, and Tacoma speaks into the camera despite being alone with both hands full.
Minicams made by German Engineering?
In the Blue Patches episode, the loss of the SD card they had just copied their movie onto is treated as though the movie itself was irretrievably lost. Shouldn't they still have the file on the computer, plus the editing file? It was definitely running off the computer earlier, the video files they were watching for the last few episodes are clearly organized on the desktop.
Thought processes don't mix well with stress. They'll realize it after. We also never see the destroyed SD card. He couldve missed
Why does a Swedish actor have the Anglo name of Tom Collins?