Page Action: WWII Made Japan And Germany Joined At The Hip

Wrestling NamespaceWWII Made Japan And Germany Joined At The Hip X
Page Action
Page Action: WWII Made Japan And Germany Joined At The Hip
What would be the best way to fix the page?
At issue:
This issue has been resolved and voting is closed.
+6 (yeas:16 nays:10)
This page has been cut.

Cutlist it. All the few working examples would be redistributed to other tropes.

Premise:
WWII Made Japan And Germany Joined At The Hip actually consists of 3 different parts:
  • #1. That Japanese like Germans and Germany, and so they're often used in Japanese fiction.
  • #2. That Germany and Japan tend to be mishmashed or confused in non-Japanese and non-German media.
    • It could be an actual trope if it had, you know, actual examples.
  • #3. Coincidences, like "in that cartoon, there's a scene where you see flags of many countries, and German and Japanese flags are totally near each other!"

Discussion: [1]
-2 (yeas:4 nays:6)
Limit it to only #1 and #2, which is how it should be now, so in effect do nothing.

Premise:
WWII Made Japan And Germany Joined At The Hip actually consists of 3 different parts:
  • #1. That Japanese like Germans and Germany, and so they're often used in Japanese fiction.
  • #2. That Germany and Japan tend to be mishmashed or confused in non-Japanese and non-German media.
    • It could be an actual trope if it had, you know, actual examples.
  • #3. Coincidences, like "in that cartoon, there's a scene where you see flags of many countries, and German and Japanese flags are totally near each other!"

Discussion: [1]
-5 (yeas:1 nays:6)
Limit it to #1, with an appropriate rename. This means you can actually prove this is a distinct trope, and not just a part of Gratuitous German.

Premise:
WWII Made Japan And Germany Joined At The Hip actually consists of 3 different parts:
  • #1. That Japanese like Germans and Germany, and so they're often used in Japanese fiction.
  • #2. That Germany and Japan tend to be mishmashed or confused in non-Japanese and non-German media.
    • It could be an actual trope if it had, you know, actual examples.
  • #3. Coincidences, like "in that cartoon, there's a scene where you see flags of many countries, and German and Japanese flags are totally near each other!"

Discussion: [1]
-7 (yeas:1 nays:8)
Limit it to #2, with an appropriate rename, and adding actual examples. This means you are actually able to provide some of them.

Premise:
WWII Made Japan And Germany Joined At The Hip actually consists of 3 different parts:
  • #1. That Japanese like Germans and Germany, and so they're often used in Japanese fiction.
  • #2. That Germany and Japan tend to be mishmashed or confused in non-Japanese and non-German media.
    • It could be an actual trope if it had, you know, actual examples.
  • #3. Coincidences, like "in that cartoon, there's a scene where you see flags of many countries, and German and Japanese flags are totally near each other!"

Discussion: [1]
-5 (yeas:1 nays:6)
Split it into 2 pages: one for #1, and one for #2, with appropriate renames, etc., etc.

Premise:
WWII Made Japan And Germany Joined At The Hip actually consists of 3 different parts:
  • #1. That Japanese like Germans and Germany, and so they're often used in Japanese fiction.
  • #2. That Germany and Japan tend to be mishmashed or confused in non-Japanese and non-German media.
    • It could be an actual trope if it had, you know, actual examples.
  • #3. Coincidences, like "in that cartoon, there's a scene where you see flags of many countries, and German and Japanese flags are totally near each other!"

Discussion: [1]
Total number: 5. Number shown: 5.

Total number of votes: 59

Wrestling NamespaceWWII Made Japan And Germany Joined At The Hip X
Page Action
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/crowner.php/PageAction/WWIIMadeJapanAndGermanyJoinedAtTheHip?openall=yes