Page Action: Something They Would Never Say

Some Anvils Need To Be DroppedSomething They Would Never Say Son Of An Ape
Alternative TitlesPage Action
Page Action: Something They Would Never Say
What would be the best way to fix the page?
At issue:
Not all options are mutually exclusive.

Something They Would Never Say is losing the battle against Trope Decay — misuse has increased from 35% to 45% between June and October 2011.

  • Actual definition: A character can't directly tell their friends that they're in danger, so they send a message with a deliberately out of character remark added that the bad guys won't even be aware of, but the friends will pick up on and identify that they're in trouble.

  • Prevelant misuse: Any time a character appears to say something out of character. May be a case of Spotting The Thread or OOC Is Serious Business.

It can be argued the name simply covers too much ground for the given definition. What do we do?
This issue has been resolved and voting is closed.
+12 (yeas:12 nays:0)
Rename and Transplant

  • Decide on a new title for this trope and rename.
  • Clean up wikilinks which are correct usages of the trope.
  • Make "Something They Would Never Say" a redirect for whatever trope represents the largest share of misuse. Optionally leave those wikilinks alone.

Pro

Con

+3 (yeas:5 nays:2)
Redefine trope

  • May be combined with any of the "rename" options.
  • Add a requirement to the trope's definition that the OOC clue is an improvised gesture.
  • Create a YKTTW for examples of characters being known/trained to use an official "covert distress code".

Pro

  • There's a thematic difference between an OOC behavior that alerts their friends that something is wrong (but the friends have to figure out the rest on their own), and an explicitly coded message delivered through cryptic means.

Con

+2 (yeas:4 nays:2)
Rename and disambig

  • Decide on a new name for this trope and rename.
  • Turn "Something They Would Never Say" into a disambig pointing at various tropes which might prompt the phrase.
  • Clean up wikilinks

Pro

  • May help prevent future misuse by providing a disambig page.
  • Disambig pages don't list examples.

Con

  • A disambiguation page is essentially a page about the Stock Phrase. We don't do Stock Phrases anymore.
-3 (yeas:1 nays:4)
Rename and redirect

Pro

Con

  • The increasing misuse ratio of the current title is still a concern.
Total number: 4. Number shown: 4.

Total number of votes: 30

Some Anvils Need To Be DroppedSomething They Would Never Say Son Of An Ape
Alternative TitlesPage Action
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/crowner.php/PageAction/SomethingTheyWouldNeverSay?openall=yes