Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / TheAndyGriffithShow

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* EarWorm: You know the one.
** Also "Dooley" played by The Dillards, who played the Darling family on the show.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Color episode "The Return of Barney Fife" includes [[spoiler: Barney's utter heartbreak when he finds that Thelma Lou has married another man since he moved to Raleigh. Seeing Barney, plucky Barney, [[DrowningMySorrows being utterly devasted by this revelation]] is equally as heartbreaking for the audience.]]

to:

** Color episode "The Return of Barney Fife" includes [[spoiler: Barney's utter heartbreak when he finds that Thelma Lou has married another man since he moved to Raleigh. Seeing Barney, plucky Barney, [[DrowningMySorrows being utterly devasted devastated by this revelation]] is equally as heartbreaking for the audience.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** One episode involved Opie being bullied. When Andy found out about this, he refused to contact the bullies' parents or school about it because he wanted Opie to learn to stand up for himself, later telling Opie a story about how he was bullied as a child and how when he stood up for himself the bully ended up backing down. The episode ends with Opie apparently beating the bully up. While back then this may have been seen as a valid way to deal with a bully, these days as many experts and bully-victims can attest, this usually ''never'' works; if anything, it'll end up making the bullying situation ''even worse'' since bullies frequently go after people they ''know'' aren't strong enough to stand up/beat them in a fight, and attempting to stand up to them usually results in the bully forcefully showing them ''why'' they shouldn't. If the episode was made today, contacting the school/parents would usually be the first thing the parents of the bully victim would do.

to:

** One episode involved Opie being bullied. When Andy found out about this, he refused to contact the bullies' parents or school about it because he wanted Opie to learn to stand up for himself, later telling Opie a story about how he was bullied as a child and how when he stood up for himself the bully ended up backing down. The episode ends with Opie apparently beating the bully up. While back then this may have been seen as a valid way to deal with a bully, these days as many experts and bully-victims can attest, this usually ''never'' works; if anything, it'll end up making the bullying situation ''even worse'' since bullies frequently go after people they ''know'' aren't strong enough to stand up/beat them in a fight, and attempting to stand up to them usually results in the bully forcefully showing them ''why'' they shouldn't. In addition, even if the bully backs down, the bully victim, more often than not, is usually the one who's going to end up being disciplined by the school, especially in schools with zero tolerance policies. If the episode was made today, contacting the school/parents would usually be the first thing the parents of the bully victim would do.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Not an example since the episode Portrays Barney attitude old fashion.


** In "A Wife for Andy," Barney immediately disregards Helen Crump as a potential LoveInterest for Andy purely on the grounds that she can't cook very well and that she wants to keep her job after getting married. Lampshaded by Andy himself as the episode quickly moves Barney into JerkAss territory when he tries to sabotage their burgeoning relationship... [[StayInTheKitchen simply on the grounds that she refuses to fulfill the role of a traditional housewife like a good little girl]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** As a counterpoint to Barney's clumsiness, Andy rarely ever carries a gun on duty, wanting to be respected by the citizens of Mayberry more than feared. As such, it synchronizes surprisingly well with today's issues with police shootings and subsequent calls for police to be better trained in conflict resolution.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** George Lindsey would later play another similar character named "Goober" on ''Series/HeeHaw''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** One episode has Andy giving a young boy a gun to hold. While there was no bullets in the chamber and Andy does stress the importance of gun safety, a scene like that would never be shown on modern TV.

to:

** One episode has Andy giving a young boy a gun to hold. While there was are no bullets in the chamber and Andy does stress the importance of gun safety, a scene like that would never be shown on modern TV.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** One episode involved Opie being bullied. When Andy found out about this, he refused to contact the bullies parents or school about it because he wanted Opie to learn to stand up for himself, later telling Opie a story about how he was bullied as a child and how when he stood up for himself the bully ended up backing down. The episode ends with Opie apparently beating the bully up. While back then this may have been seen as a valid way to deal with a bully, these days as many experts and bully-victims can attest, this usually ''never'' works; if anything, it'll end up making the bullying situation ''even worse'' since bullies frequently go after people they ''know'' aren't strong enough to stand up/beat them in a fight, and attempting to stand up to them usually results in the bully forcefully showing them ''why'' they shouldn't. If the episode was made today, contacting the school/parents would usually be the first thing the parents of the bully victim would do.

to:

** One episode involved Opie being bullied. When Andy found out about this, he refused to contact the bullies bullies' parents or school about it because he wanted Opie to learn to stand up for himself, later telling Opie a story about how he was bullied as a child and how when he stood up for himself the bully ended up backing down. The episode ends with Opie apparently beating the bully up. While back then this may have been seen as a valid way to deal with a bully, these days as many experts and bully-victims can attest, this usually ''never'' works; if anything, it'll end up making the bullying situation ''even worse'' since bullies frequently go after people they ''know'' aren't strong enough to stand up/beat them in a fight, and attempting to stand up to them usually results in the bully forcefully showing them ''why'' they shouldn't. If the episode was made today, contacting the school/parents would usually be the first thing the parents of the bully victim would do.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** One episode has Andy giving a young boy a gun to hold. While there was no bullets in the chamber and Andy does stress the importance of gun safety, a scene like that would never be shown on modern tv.

to:

** One episode has Andy giving a young boy a gun to hold. While there was no bullets in the chamber and Andy does stress the importance of gun safety, a scene like that would never be shown on modern tv.TV.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Also "Dooley" played by The Dillards, who played the Darling family on the show.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TooGoodToLast: CBS/Paramount's efforts to release the show on UsefulNotes/BluRay stopped at season one, due to low sales of the expensive set.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Or, more accurately, according to the wording on the Family Unfriendly Aesop page, it has to be a lesson that can be logically drawn from the events of the story. Saying "this episode had a Downer Ending, therefore the moral is that life is pointless" is not logical. Saying "this episode makes a big deal out of destroying the arguments for why homeless people can't get jobs and argues that homeless people are just con men too lazy to work" is NOT illogical. I can't prove it was the writers' intent... but it is a logical conclusion to come to. That's why it's Your Mileage May Vary. So unless you have something from Word Of God explicitly 100% stating that that wasn't the intended message, then it stays.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Um, no, it is actually about what you read into it. That's why it's YMMV. As long as it's at least plausible it counts, and there is a wiki rule against deleting YMMV items.

Added DiffLines:

* FamilyUnfriendlyAesop:
** One episode has Opie, attempting to emulate Robin Hood, stealing food to give to a homeless man faking a bad leg. To teach Opie a lesson Andy goes up to the man and offers to assist him in finding a series of jobs he believes the man could do in spite of his leg. The man keeps making excuses for why he can't do each one, until he runs off, revealing himself to be a fraud. In short, "never help the homeless, they're just lazy." Bizarrely, the finale scene has Opie point out that none of the jobs Andy offered were actually available, so if the man had been telling the truth and accepted one of them, Andy would have looked like a complete jerk.
** Just three episodes after that we get "Aunt Bee the Crusader" in which Aunt Bee tries to stop Andy from evicting a man because of a highway project. Both sides make some really good points, but in the end it all turns out to be moot because the man was a moonshiner. As a result the message comes across as "never fight for someone else's rights, because they're probably criminals anyway."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** One episode involved Opie being bullied. When Andy found out about this, he refused to contact the bullies parents or school about it because he wanted Opie to learn to stand up for himself, later telling Opie a story about how he was bullied as a child and how when he stood up for himself the bully ended up backing down. The episode ends with Opie apparently beating the bully up. While back then this may have been seen as a valid way to deal with a bully, these days as many experts and bully-victims can attest, this usually ''never'' works; if anything, it'll end up making the bullying situation ''even worse'' since bullies frequently go after people they ''know'' aren't strong enough to stand up/beat them in a fight, and attempting to stand up to them usually results in the bully forcefully showing them ''why'' they shouldn't. If the episode was made today, contacting the school/parents would usually be the first thing the parents of the bully victim would do.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ReplacementScrappy: Warren Ferguson. The guy didn't have an ounce of what made Barney so funny. The fact that he tried to fill Barney's role, but ultimately failed, is what made his character particularly unfunny.

to:

* ReplacementScrappy: Warren Ferguson. The guy didn't have an ounce of what made Barney so funny. The fact that he tried to fill Ferguson, Barney's role, but ultimately failed, is what made his character particularly unfunny.SuspiciouslySimilarSubstitute.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Much earlier, a pre-''Series/IDreamOfJeannie'' Barbara Eden arrives in Mayberry as the town's pretty new manicurist in "The Manicurist".

to:

** Much earlier, a pre-''Series/IDreamOfJeannie'' Barbara Eden Creator/BarbaraEden arrives in Mayberry as the town's pretty new manicurist in "The Manicurist".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** One episode has Andy giving a young boy a gun to hold. While there was no bullets in the chamber and Andy does stress the importance of gun safety, a scene like that would never be shown on modern tv.


Added DiffLines:

** Andy's concern on trying to afford a college education for Opie still holds true to modern parents. Even those with well paying jobs will find college very expensive.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The RunningGag of Barney being careless with his gun and having to keep a single bullet in his pocket for emergencies loses much of its humour in the face of repeat questionable shootings by police officers.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Arte Johnson- later of ''Series/RowanAndMartinsLaughIn''- appeared as a hotel clerk in "Andy and Barney in the Big City".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Howard Morris directed eight episodes. Morris is best known for being in ''front'' of the camera on the show as Ernest T. Bass, and would go on to greater fame for voicing Gopher in ''Disney/TheManyAdventuresOfWinnieThePooh'', Hamburglar and Mayor McCheese for UsefulNotes/McDonalds, Carl Sweetchuck and The Professor in ''WesternAnimation/PoliceAcademyTheAnimatedSeries'', and Wade Duck in ''WesternAnimation/GarfieldAndFriends''.

to:

** Howard Morris directed eight episodes. Morris is best known for being in ''front'' of the camera on the show as Ernest T. Bass, and would go on to greater fame for voicing Gopher in ''Disney/TheManyAdventuresOfWinnieThePooh'', Hamburglar and Mayor McCheese [=McCheese=] for UsefulNotes/McDonalds, Carl Sweetchuck and The Professor in ''WesternAnimation/PoliceAcademyTheAnimatedSeries'', and Wade Duck in ''WesternAnimation/GarfieldAndFriends''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Much earlier, a pre-[[Series/IDreamOfJeannie Jeannie]] Barbara Eden arrives in Mayberry as the town's pretty new manicurist in "The Manicurist".

to:

** Much earlier, a pre-[[Series/IDreamOfJeannie Jeannie]] pre-''Series/IDreamOfJeannie'' Barbara Eden arrives in Mayberry as the town's pretty new manicurist in "The Manicurist".



** Howard Morris directed eight episodes. Morris is best known for being in ''front'' of the camera on the show as Ernest T. Bass, and would go on to greater fame as the voice of Gopher in ''Disney/TheManyAdventuresOfWinnieThePooh'' and Wade Duck on ''WesternAnimation/GarfieldAndFriends''.

to:

** Howard Morris directed eight episodes. Morris is best known for being in ''front'' of the camera on the show as Ernest T. Bass, and would go on to greater fame as the voice of for voicing Gopher in ''Disney/TheManyAdventuresOfWinnieThePooh'' ''Disney/TheManyAdventuresOfWinnieThePooh'', Hamburglar and Mayor McCheese for UsefulNotes/McDonalds, Carl Sweetchuck and The Professor in ''WesternAnimation/PoliceAcademyTheAnimatedSeries'', and Wade Duck on in ''WesternAnimation/GarfieldAndFriends''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** A then-unknown Creator/JackNicholson in some brief scenes in the episode "Opie Finds a Baby".

to:

** A then-unknown Creator/JackNicholson in some brief scenes in the episode episodes "Opie Finds a Baby".Baby" and "Aunt Bee the Juror".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Creator/LeeVanCleef, in a ''very'' small role as--surprise--a bad guy in the carnival episode.
** A then-unknown Creator/JackNicholson in some brief scenes in one of the later episodes.
** Pre-''Series/{{MASH}}'' Jamie Farr and William Christopher had made memorable guest appearances; Farr as part of a band of gypsies, and Christopher as Mayberry's new town doctor, Doc Peterson.
** Much earlier, a pre-[[Series/IDreamOfJeannie Jeannie]] Barbara Eden arrives in Mayberry as the town's pretty new manicurist.

to:

** Creator/LeeVanCleef, in a ''very'' small role as--surprise--a bad guy in the carnival episode.
episode "Banjo-Playing Deputy".
** A then-unknown Creator/JackNicholson in some brief scenes in one of the later episodes.
episode "Opie Finds a Baby".
** Pre-''Series/{{MASH}}'' Jamie Farr and William Christopher had made memorable guest appearances; Farr as part of a band of gypsies, gypsies in "The Gypsies", and Christopher in two episodes: as a tax collector in "Aunt Bee on TV", and as Mayberry's new town doctor, Doc Peterson.
Peterson, in "A New Doctor in Town".
** Much earlier, a pre-[[Series/IDreamOfJeannie Jeannie]] Barbara Eden arrives in Mayberry as the town's pretty new manicurist.manicurist in "The Manicurist".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
I want to cut the Main redirect.


** In the episode "Man In a Hurry", the titular character happened to be named [[TheThickOfIt Malcolm Tucker.]]

to:

** In the episode "Man In a Hurry", the titular character happened to be named [[TheThickOfIt [[Series/TheThickOfIt Malcolm Tucker.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HoYay: In "Mountain Wedding", Ernest T. Bass doesn't seem to mind the fact that Barney's a guy after seeing him disguised in Charlene Darling's wedding dress, even asking him to dance at Charlene's wedding party.

Added: 427

Changed: 111

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TearJerker: Opie's horror when he realizes that he accidentally killed a bird with his new slingshot in "Opie The Birdman".

to:

* TearJerker: TearJerker:
**
Opie's horror when he realizes that he accidentally killed a bird with his new slingshot in "Opie The Birdman".Birdman".
** Color episode "The Return of Barney Fife" includes [[spoiler: Barney's utter heartbreak when he finds that Thelma Lou has married another man since he moved to Raleigh. Seeing Barney, plucky Barney, [[DrowningMySorrows being utterly devasted by this revelation]] is equally as heartbreaking for the audience.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** In "The Farmer Takes a Wife", Alan Hale Jr. plays a farmer who often calls Barney "little buddy". Hale would later use that phrase on his co-star in [[Series/GilligansIsland another television series]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The episode "Alcohol and Old Lace" involves two sisters selling moonshine and justifying their crime because "we're not like those other moonshiners, they sell liquor for drinking purposes; our elixir is for special occasions." Naturally, the town's drinkers are making up excuses to take a nip. One particular scene involves a man pretending to be a Muslim celebrating Mohammed's birthday. It's not a super big deal, but the lightness of it is just a little strange [[TheWarOnTerror given current events]].

to:

** The episode "Alcohol and Old Lace" involves two sisters selling moonshine and justifying their crime because "we're not like those other moonshiners, they sell liquor for drinking purposes; our elixir is for special occasions." Naturally, the town's drinkers are making up excuses to take a nip. One particular scene involves a man pretending to be a Muslim celebrating Mohammed's birthday. It's not necessarily a super big deal, scene that couldn't work today, but the lightness of it is just it's hard to imagine any show after TheWarOnTerror dropping such a little strange [[TheWarOnTerror given current events]].scene in so casually.

Added: 1251

Changed: 1113

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ValuesDissonance: In "A Wife for Andy," Barney immediately disregards Helen Crump as a potential LoveInterest for Andy purely on the grounds that she can't cook very well and that she wants to keep her job after getting married. Lampshaded by Andy himself as the episode quickly moves Barney into JerkAss territory when he tries to sabotage their burgeoning relationship... [[StayInTheKitchen simply on the grounds that she refuses to fulfill the role of a traditional housewife like a good little girl]].
* ValuesResonance: A clip of Andy erasing a recording Opie made of a conversation of a suspect and his lawyer made in secret while defending the right to privacy and attorney-client privilege has been making the rounds on Website/YouTube ever since the revelations of the NSA's spying program.

to:

* ValuesDissonance: ValuesDissonance:
**
In "A Wife for Andy," Barney immediately disregards Helen Crump as a potential LoveInterest for Andy purely on the grounds that she can't cook very well and that she wants to keep her job after getting married. Lampshaded by Andy himself as the episode quickly moves Barney into JerkAss territory when he tries to sabotage their burgeoning relationship... [[StayInTheKitchen simply on the grounds that she refuses to fulfill the role of a traditional housewife like a good little girl]].
** The episode "Alcohol and Old Lace" involves two sisters selling moonshine and justifying their crime because "we're not like those other moonshiners, they sell liquor for drinking purposes; our elixir is for special occasions." Naturally, the town's drinkers are making up excuses to take a nip. One particular scene involves a man pretending to be a Muslim celebrating Mohammed's birthday. It's not a super big deal, but the lightness of it is just a little strange [[TheWarOnTerror given current events]].
* ValuesResonance: ValuesResonance:
**
A clip of Andy erasing a recording Opie made of a conversation of a suspect and his lawyer made in secret while defending the right to privacy and attorney-client privilege has been making the rounds on Website/YouTube ever since the revelations of the NSA's spying program.program.
** There's also a clip from the end of "Opie and the Spoiled Kid" involving the titular spoiled kid raising a fuss after Andy confiscated his bike for riding on the sidewalk. His temper tantrum gets more and more out of control, culminating in the boy's father promising to sell the bike and implying the boy is going to get a spanking. This clip has also been passed around a lot on Website/YouTube and social media among proponents of spanking.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Barney has shown sexist thoughts before like his attitude to a skeet shooter woman that Andy was dating.


* ValuesDissonance: In "A Wife for Andy," Barney immediately disregards Helen Crump as a potential LoveInterest for Andy purely on the grounds that she can't cook very well and that she wants to keep her job after getting married. Lampshaded by Andy himself as the episode quickly moves Barney into JerkAss territory when he tries to sabotage their burgeoning relationship... [[StayInTheKitchen simply on the grounds that she refuses to fulfill the role of a traditional housewife like a good little girl]], and comes across as a rather dickish OutOfCharacterMoment for the flawed but overall likable Barney.

to:

* ValuesDissonance: In "A Wife for Andy," Barney immediately disregards Helen Crump as a potential LoveInterest for Andy purely on the grounds that she can't cook very well and that she wants to keep her job after getting married. Lampshaded by Andy himself as the episode quickly moves Barney into JerkAss territory when he tries to sabotage their burgeoning relationship... [[StayInTheKitchen simply on the grounds that she refuses to fulfill the role of a traditional housewife like a good little girl]], and comes across as a rather dickish OutOfCharacterMoment for the flawed but overall likable Barney.girl]].

Top