Troperville
Editing Help
Tools
Toys
|
alt title(s): Warped Aesop; Family Unfriendly Moral; Politically Incorrect Aesop ... I leave it to be settled by whomsoever it may concern, whether the tendency of this work be altogether to recommend parental tyranny, or reward filial disobedience.
— Jane Austen, Northanger Abbey (final line)
" So, it's better to speculate about doing good then actually doing it?"
Rachel: (laughs) "Who cares how you win as long as you win?"
Cassie: "You don't really believe that, Rachel. No, wait a minute, you probably do."
And all my people that's drug dealin' just to get by/Stack ya money 'til it gets sky high
Everyone knows the Stock Aesops. Be happy with what you have, friendship is more important than money, dream of better things. Sometimes these morals contradict each other, but nobody is surprised to see any of them in a story.
But there are also morals that don't appear in fiction very often. Morals like " No good deed goes unpunished," " Don't automatically share, because some people are moochers," or "Peace is not always the answer". For a certain definition of morality, they aren't wrong, but it still seems... jarring, somehow.
Do this and you have a Family Unfriendly Aesop. If it appeared in a kids' television show, the network would get 32,845 angry e-mails from Moral Guardians in the first day after airing. And if it appeared in a show for adults, it would still seem jarring, even if it was actually very good advice.
A benefit — and problem — of the Family Unfriendly Aesop is that it's so unexpected. It can make for a strong Twist Ending, but it's so surprising that it may dominate the story. Instead of leaving the audience something to think about after the show, they're busy scratching their heads and wondering, "did they really say that? In public?"
A Family Unfriendly Aesop is not necessarily cynical. Shows on the idealistic end of the Sliding Scale Of Idealism Versus Cynicism can have them too, if they have morals like "take candy from strangers, because people are nice."
Note that just because something happens in a story, that doesn't necessarily mean it's a Family Unfriendly Aesop. A story about a criminal who gets away with murder is not necessarily teaching the moral that crime does pay. A story with a big Downer Ending does not mean it is trying to teach a lesson that life is pointless. If it's not the point of a story, it's not An Aesop.
Before adding an example to this list, think about whether the example is actually preaching a moral, or if it is simply telling a story to entertain. An unusual moral also doesn't count if it's played for laughs; that's a Spoof Aesop. If it started out as a good moral, but was broken, that doesn't count either; that's a Broken Aesop.
Due to Values Dissonance, a moral that is family unfriendly in one culture may be very family friendly in another, especially morals about race and sex. This list is for morals that were family unfriendly even for the culture that they were written in. A prime target for dropping anvils on.
Compare Clueless Aesop and some cases of Unfortunate Implications. See also The Complainer Is Always Wrong.
Note: We understand that not everything needs or has an Aesop.
Examples
open/close all folders
General
- Many Japanese films and anime seem to have the moral that children should hang out at will with whatever they find cool, even if it's really dangerous. The children in the Japanese superhero movies Prince of Space and Invasion of the Neptune Men, immediately come to mind. So do the children in several kaiju monster movies, who always seem to want to be as close to the monster as possible, even when it's tearing up downtown Tokyo. Yulie from Ronin Warriors is also a prime example. The moral of that show seems to be "No matter how weak and helpless you are, no matter how dangerous the situation, if you always stick close to the heroes, things will turn out fine no matter what."
- Susan gives us this gem while reading to the children she was taking care of in Hogfather: "...you can be excused just about anything if you're a hero, because no one asks inconvenient questions." Which would work well as a Spoof Aesop and/or a Lampshading, since it was the lesson of her version of Jack and the Beanstalk, except that it also works as a lesson of most action movies, video games, faerie tales, old stories, etc.
Anime & Manga
- Pet shop of Horrors is based entirely on this, due to the dubious morality of the Pet Shop owner, Count D. While he maintains that he is only giving humanity what they deserve, a good heart is no guarantee of a good outcome — several of the Count's shadier customers escape unscathed from their deals with the Count, while softer-hearted clients can be "punished" for a minor character flaw. Even if a character undergoes a positive change through being with their pet, such as developing a sense of compassion, they often fall victim to a tragic twist.
- Kaleido Star: "When everyone around you is treating you like dirt, if you just be really nice to them and generally act like a dogsbody, they'll come around eventually." While it's nice to see the genki girl's sweet personality overcoming all the odds and avoiding the risk of becoming a Purity Sue by having to work for her acceptance, some of the other Kaleido Stage performers could really have used a slap in the face, rather than getting away with some seriously obnoxious behavior (such as Layla's sort-of Girl Posse Julie and Charlotte, before their Heel Face Turn).
- And another one, from "Kalos Eido's Guide to Managing a Circus": "When your cast members are trying to kill each other, just leave them to it. It's a learning experience for them. While you're at it, why not try putting even more pressure on someone who's already being bullied?"
- And a third from the White Haired Pretty Boy: "It's okay to put an acrobatics partner at extreme risk by forcing her into an incredibly dangerous maneuver with no rehearsal, provided the result will look really cool if it works." Fortunately, when we see this on-screen it only results in the local girl getting her shoulder completely wrenched out of its socket and broken, but it's implied he's done this before and killed people.
- Bunta Fujiwara's parenting style in Initial D, if not his whole character, is a delivery vehicle for Family Unfriendly Aesops about skill and honor in illegal street racing.
- While the manga and anime itself has a Family Friendly Aesop, the creepy children's books in Monster were made like this purposefully by one of the characters to instill nihilism in children. They feature such lovely morals as "It doesn't matter whether you make a deal with the devil or not, because you're screwed either way."
- "Honesty is the Best Policy" is one of the Stock Aesops — face it, how many shows have you seen where a little lie leads to bigger ones, and Hilarity Ensues? So it's a bit surprising that Digimon has one episode drop an anvil that little white lies are justified if lives are on the line.
Comics
- An arguable implication of the editorially mandated last arc of the Batgirl series, and an inescapably blatant one in the Robin arc that supposedly followed up on it, was that no matter how much you try you cannot find redemption, even for "sins" born of ignorance, so of course you should give up on escaping your past and embrace it as your destiny. Several months later, this is revealed as a case of Brainwashed And Crazy, in a hasty Authors Saving Throw.
- In the Marvel Comics Crisis Crossover Civil War, the moral, according to Word Of God, was that sometimes a little liberty must be sacrificed for security, especially when it comes to people who can potentially destroy the world with their powers. But many fans thought the Word Of God was being sarcastic, and didn't realize it was serious. Why? Because Marvel Comics has done stories for over twenty years in which treating super-powered mutants differently is the same as racism. In the context of Marvel Comics fandom, this is a very Family Unfriendly Aesop. To make things worse, some of the individual writers in the story didn't agree with the Word Of God. Their stories clashed badly with the central theme, and turned it from a Family Unfriendly Aesop into a Broken Aesop.
- One of the main reasons why the fans pointed out just how broken the entire premise was hinged on the fact that the entire pro-registration side (which Word Of God essentially pointed to as being "right") consisted of a bunch of complete bastards who actively committed incredibly immoral acts in the name of their goals, freely interacted with villains, were willing to fight with lethal force, and were led by the most jerktastic version of Tony Stark to ever be written (which is quite a feat). Meanwhile, the anti-registration people were led by one of the most morally upright characters in the Marvel Universe, generally acted in a far more "heroic" manner, had a stance that echoed the "correct" viewpoint of 30+ years worth of Marvel continuity (that super-powers registration is bad), AND acted on beliefs ("government isn't always right", "persecution is wrong", and "sometimes, you have to fight for what you believe in") that would FAR more accurately reflect those of the target reading audience (ie, young males). If it wasn't for the Word Of God, there's almost NOTHING within the actual context of the story that would imply the reader was even REMOTELY supposed to see the pro-registration group as being in the right.
- You think that's bad? You wanna know Joe Quesada's rationale for Pete and MJ's marriage being cosmic retconned in One More Day ? That having Pete and MJ just get divorced would be a "bad example for the kids". As opposed to bargaining with Lucifer? "Remember, kiddos, divorce is bad, but dealing with the Devil himself is a-OK, because your friendly neighborhood Spider-man did it!"
- Further more, remember MJ was pregnant at the time, and the deal erased the pregnancy, so apparently, not even abortion is as bad as getting a divorce. Let's also remember that this was done because Quesada insisted that the couple wouldn't be "so irresponsible" as to have a child out of wedlock. Baby while you're unmarried? Bad. Selling your child's very existence to SATAN? The right thing to do.
- Chick Tracts generally have pretty screwy morals, which are usually some variation on "it's okay to be a bigot as long as you're a Christian", "Christians are automatically better people than non-Christians", and "Your life is worthless. Start preparing for the Afterlife now," but some specific examples that stand out:
- Catholics are worse than Satan. The Catholic church is based on false teachings even though we take all of our beliefs from the same teachings.
- Fat Cats: "Don't rebel against a genocidal dictator, you'll only make it worse."
- Lisa: "Child molesters should not be imprisoned." This one was so screwed up Chick himself ordered it recalled.
- Also, pornography is worse than pedophilia. Seriously, the doctor said that it was the pornography ruining his life, not raping his toddler.
- And if you'd just slept with your daughter-molesting husband more often after you realized he was molesting her, maybe he wouldn't have given your daughter herpes.
- Gunslinger: "Being a Karma Houdini is a good thing."
- The Wall: "Interracial marriage introduces you to hokey cults."
- Little Bride: "Muslims are pedophiles." Chick noticeably glosses over the Values Dissonance with regards to the age of consent in this one.
- Some more general ones that can be found in a variety of titles: It is a wonderful act of selflessness for an innocent to bear the punishment of the guilty, justice or fairness be damned. It doesn't matter how good you are to your fellow human beings, God hates you unless you're a Christian. Conversely, no matter how horribly you treated people in life, you can still be joyously welcomed into heaven if you accept Christ with your dying breath. People who belong to non-Christian religions are not just mistaken, but wilfully and actively evil.
- An issue of MAD Magazine once featured a choose-your-own-adventure comic strip that satirizes American elections, where the lesson appears to be "If you stick to your morals and integrity, you will lose; but if you lie, cheat, and bribe, you will win." Then again, this pretty much is the aesop behind politics in general...
- Dilbert intentionally has the moral that "trying to do your job is pointless — exploit the system instead." It is, of course, a satire of workplace bureaucracy which makes that viewpoint seem valid.
- Most superhero comics have either the aesop that "vigilantism is awesome, especially if you wear a silly costume", or the moral that "life sucks, and you can't even deal with it, since Authorities Are Useless until they're against you".
Fairy Tales
- In many old fairy tales and folk tales, the moral is "You have to lie, cheat and steal to save either yourself or your family. The more you do it, the better you are." Modern versions often Bowdlerize this, eliminating the original moral.
- Puss In Boots is an outstanding example. American McGee's Grimm seems to suggest that the lesson in Puss in Boots is that "Cats are sneaky little bastards, and humans can exploit this for their own ends."
- In the original version of Tom Thumb, Tom is saved from certain death by the Ogre's wife. He exploits her for all she's worth, and arranges for the ogre to murder his own children... but he's still the hero of the story, because it saves his family.
- In the Russian fairy tale Prince Ivan and the Firebird, Ivan saves the kingdom by breaking every promise he makes.
- Many other fairy tales have what appears to be this moral, but is actually Values Dissonance.
- Rumplestiltskin, for example. Not like any of the characters are particularly heroic, but the "happy ending" goes like this: The heroine got to marry the evil King and keep her child, while the fairy who had used his powers to save her life doesn't get paid for his kindness at all. There's no hint that he'd have done the kid harm... it appears that he deserved to get cheated out of his payment because he's a stranger, and strangers don't deserve to have their bargains honored.
- In some versions, Rumplestiltskin has song which includes the lines "To-morrow I brew, to-day I bake/And then the child away I'll take", which implies that he planned to cannibalize the child.
- Besides, when that story was first told, the mythology around faeries meant that being taken as a child by a faerie = bad is assumed. If not eaten, chances are the best they can look forward to is a life of enslavement.
- Of course, in one version where he dies, he gets so pissy that he traps himself in the floorboards and rips himself in half pulling himself out.
- Take it with a pinch of salt, but the original, unbowdlerized moral of Rumplestiltskin was that... well... Masturbation leads to Infertility. Apparently, the girl left in the room with the gold to spin got bored and, um, seized upon a small round block of wood. She was, well, quite surprised when it turned into a tiny dwarf. The thread-spinning, etc., proceeded the same as the Grimm brothers version from there, but instead of stamping his foot so hard he fell into the earth, he turned back into a block of wood and... uh... Blocked the, uh, well, yeah. Ahem.
- An easy way to confirm the "raunchy" origin of Rumplestiltskin is too look at it like this: what's a stilt with rumpled skin?
- One could also argue that Rumplestiltskin, while strictly honest in his bargains, exploited a woman who was in a very bad situation by offering to save her life in return for a truly mind-boggling price. If he had asked for something more reasonable, the Queen might have been happy to honour her promise (though that wouldn't have made for a very interesting story).
- The Tinderbox: Basically, the plot boils down to this: Hero encounters a poor, desperate witch who begs him for his help in retrieving her precious possession, a tinderbox. Witch tells hero how to safely retrieve the box, and offers him vast wealth in return. Hero retrieves box, after gathering as much gold as he can, and returns to witch. Witch thanks him and politely asks for her box, but hero decides to decapitate her instead. Later, he uses the box to kidnap a princess and murder her family/court. He and said princess are married and live happily ever after.
- Note that the decapitation is cut from many adaptations, and the witch simply gives the hero her Tinderbox as a reward or something.
- Some versions also strongly imply that the witch plans to leave him down there to die after he gets her the box, somewhat justifying her murder.
- The versions that miss both those cop-outs basically boil down to the Aesop that "Witches deserve to die because they're witches, duh!" Which is pretty much the way things worked back then.
- Russian fairy tales, in general, tend to be rather cynical. One story in a collection by 19th century folklorist Alexander Afanasyev has the moral "Old favors are soon forgotten."
- Deconstructed in the Sondheim musical Into the Woods: after Jack robs from and kills the giant at the top of the beanstalk, the giant's widow comes to seek revenge for her husband. The show's Aesop is the more family-friendly "Actions have consequences, and if you selfishly backstab people, it'll come around to bite you in the ass."
- The original ''The Farmer and the Viper: "Don't help Always Chaotic Evil creatures, they'll backstab you immediately".
- Similar to The Farmer and the Viper is The Frog and the Scorpion. The moral seems to be something along the lines of "Bad people do bad things, even when it doesn't make any sense."
- The fable of John Henry seems to have the moral that it's better to die than give up. A different reading might be that using technology to make things easier is inherently bad, which is also rather creepy.
- Possibly closer to Values Dissonance. Working hard to prove yourself and not sitting idle just because the job could theoretically be made a whole lot easier is a value from the days before steam engines.
- Many fairy tales center around a hero who is poor in some way (an idiot third son, a tailor, a musician, etc.) who wins a princess's hand in a perfectly legitimate way (guessing the colors hair on her head, offering the best gift for her birthday, guessing her riddle, etc.). And instead of honoring her promise, the princess is a rhymes-with-witch and adds more conditions to the tests just so that she won't have to marry a peasant. These include sending him to find the Apple of Life, get a ring out of a lake, sort various types of grain, spend the night in a stable with a wild bear, and almost always the tests are on pain of death. And inevitably the prince will overcome these additional conditions and go ahead and marry the princess anyway! What aesop does this teach, if a girl is rich and beautiful it's alright to marry her even if she totally hates you enough to try to kill you?
- A better example of this is the original version of The Frog Prince. In it, the princess drops her golden ball into a pond and the frog agrees to retrieve it for her if she in turn promises to let him live in the castle as her friend. She agrees but when he brings her the ball, she takes it and runs to the castle, leaving the frog behind. The frog makes its way to the castle and tells the king about the princess's promise and she is forced to go through with it, letting the frog sit by her at meals and follow her everywhere. The entire time, she is obviously disgusted by it. When she goes to bed, the frog asks to be allowed to sleep in her bed and the princess is so disgusted that she throws it against the wall, whereupon it turns into a handsome prince and the two were married. Never mind the fact that the princess was completely horrible and only broke the spell inadvertantly because she'd rather kill something that helped her out rather than let it use her bed also.
Films — Animation
- A few Disney films have morals that are a lot less sugary than you'd expect from Disney:
- They never say it bluntly, but there's a pretty obvious lesson stemming from the conclusion of the animated Hunchback of Notre Dame: you can be kind-hearted, brave, selfless and virtuous, but the genuinely ugly guy will have to wait until the direct-to-video sequel to get the girl.
- That could be more of a side effect of Disney prettying up the novel, in which Esmeralda does indeed end up with Phoebus; all three main characters are much less sympathetic, and all three end up dying at the end, with Quasimodo holding Esmeralda's body.
- The Land Before Time II seems to have the moral "If someone is from outside your culture, they're much dumber than you are, and have evil impulses that are almost certainly beyond their control."
- Happy Feet was supposed to have the stock aesop "Be yourself, different isn't bad", which everyone involved with the movie reminded everyone of as often as possible in interviews and promo shows. Unfortunately, this aesop kind of wound up drowned out under "religion is hokey, silly nonsense that should be ditched", "people only care about you if you're entertaining", and, perhaps most mind-boggling, "if something new comes along that scares the establishment, everyone needs to conform to the new thing."
- And of course, the narrator says to never drop the egg even after the events take place. Just wait a sec, let it sink in, wrap your mind around it. Now do you see what's wrong with it? No? Consider the effect of dropping the egg in the film. Understand now? No? You're hopeless.
- Don't forget the leason: "Don't eat fish, you're starving the dancing penguins!"
- In the sequels to An American Tail, trying repeatedly to start her own career makes Tanya either pushy or too distracted to help out around the house.
- Max Steel Vs. Elementor is pretty much Looten Plunder or Dr. Blight (probably mostly the later if not a hybrid) vs. Captain Planet...
Films — Live Action
- That sounds somewhat reasonable at first, but it contains the unfortunate implication that non-military personnel are less patriotic and thus aren't even second-class citizens — they can't vote at all. However, the whole film is an affectionate parody of those wacky nazis, so one should keep the MST3k mantra in mind.
- The third movie has the anvilicious aesop that religion is good, even if the god you've been talking to is actually the big bad bug. Having witnessed the possibilities, the fascist federation turns itself into a theocracy in the end. Um.. yay?
- The primary message in the 1939 film version of The Wizard of Oz is "Never dream of a better life. Just accept things as they are, even when your life is full of suck."
- Radio Flyer: Under absolutely no circumstances tell the police your stepdad's beating the shit out of your little brother, because they can't do anything. Especially don't tell your mom, because she's lonely and he's the only man she's got, and finding this out will make her sad.
- The Hannah Montana film pretty much states that you need to be fake to be accepted. This is evident when Miley stops her concert to reveal who she really is, and a little girl politely asks her to "please be Hannah Montana".
- The Swedish vampire film Let the Right One In gives some unfriendly (but effective) advice on how to deal with schoolyard bullies: "Hit back. Hard." To ends, tear them to bits.
- Similar to the above example, the So Bad Its Horrible Godzilla's Revenge has an ending moral of "beat up the bully and he'll respect you." But what warps it into the ULTIMATE family unfriendly aesop is the ending minute. Ichiro makes friends with the gang of bullies picking on him and goes around with them making mischief, including KNOCKING A POOR OLD PAINTER off his ladder and spilling paint in his face. He goes off to possibly be a deliquent.
- Hobgoblins has this coupled with Unfortunate Implications. The main character's girlfriend is a shrill shrew who insults him no matter what he does. Then the Hobgoblins' Lotus Eater Machine powers make her go to a local nightclub and strip. After breaking her free of the semi-Mind Control, she's loosened up and is a much nicer person. Or, as Crow T. Robot put it: "Amy wasn't fun until she became a slut".
- The Santa Clause series: When children don't get the toys they really really want for Christmas, they cease believing in Santa, become bitter and disillusioned, and have no sense of magic in their adult lives.
- Little Miss Sunshine? The moral appears to be "To hold your own against more experienced prematurely sexualised child beauty pagent entrants, you need to do an even more sexualised burlesque routine". To make matters worse, said burlesque routine is taught to the little girl by her Dirty Old Man grandpa. Squick.
- Any Coming of Age/High School comedy or drama where the lead is an outcast fringe-dweller who just wants to be accepted and popular, date the shallow Jerk Jock (who often then becomes the Jerk With A Heart Of Gold) or The Libby, and/or get chosen as best in a popularity contest (Homecoming royalty, study body president, etc.); and manages to achieve it by dropping his or her "weirdness" or nerdiness, turning away from the "freak" crowd he or she is hanging out with, and becoming a conformist and adopting the looks and/or attitudes of the popular crowd. Which is the vast majority of them, especially those aimed at a younger crowd. Often combined with an Unnecessary Makeover; it's usually a failed attempt at a Coming Out of the Shell plot.
- The very premise of Final Destination. You can't fight fate. Even if you see your own death coming a mile away. In fact, if you try to cheat death, it will spite you by torturing you, and then making your ultimate death as painful and violent as possible.
Literature
- The Marquis de Sade wrote two books, Justine and Juliette, which are practically made of this trope. The message is, to an extent, "morality and virtue are overrated." Given that this is the man from whose name we get the word "sadism", it isn't that surprising.
- The Marquis de Sade was a libertine. He saw no use in morality. Also, ever heard of The 120 Days of Sodom?
- Almost every children's fantasy book is about learning to Be Yourself and how special you are. It's a Family Unfriendly Aesop when they don't:
- The main character of Panda Ray is a young boy with amazing powers. After escaping from his overbearing mother, who threatens to "scoop him out", he enters a dreamlike parallel dimension, where he has all his secret fantasies made true; this makes him decide that he's "no better than" his mother, which, in turn, makes decide him go home, forsake his powers, and act like he's scooped out for the rest of his life. The moral: being special and different is bad, and the people who are trying to force you to be like everyone else know what's right.
- If you happened to be an imaginative child, probably some well-meaning adult read to you the picture book, Sam, Bangs, and Moonshine by Evaline Ness. The message, in theory, was probably meant to be something like "remember to separate reality from fantasy". The message in practice is more like, "using your imagination — and it isn't like this is anything you can just stop doing — might inadvertently kill your best friend."
- There is some debate, particularly on the book's Amazon.com page
, as to exactly what lesson we're supposed to get out of The Little Rabbit Who Wanted Red Wings by Carolyn Sherwin Bailey. For some, it's "Be proud of what you are", which is fine. For some, it's "Be Careful What You Wish For", which is okay. For others, however, the message seems to be, "Don't try to be anything you're not", which seems workable until you realize that this is like telling children Status Quo Really IS God and you shouldn't aspire to be anything better than you are. And finally, several people have detected the truly Family Unfriendly, "It's better to Just Be Normal, because if there is anything that makes you different or special, your family and friends will shun and abandon you."
- The Dr. Seuss story "Daisy Head Maisy", which was never published until after his death and was subsequently made into a direct to video cartoon, was about a little girl with a daisy growing out of the top of her head. She becomes a minor celebrity for this, but eventually faces a good amount of hostility from her parents, teachers, peers, and even the local government to remove the flower since it is "unnatural" and strange. After the flower is gone, everything goes back to normal for her. This could be interpreted as "celebrity/notoriety isn't all it's cracked up to be", but it seems more like if you're different, you might get some superficial attention for being "exotic", but you are ultimately unacceptable as an actual person within your community and you must conform. This is probably why the story wasn't initially published, even though it was written several years before Dr. Seuss's death.
- Dr. Seuss example number two: the book "Green Eggs and Ham" has a perfectly nice Aesop about not deciding you don't like something until you've tried it. However, it delivers said Aesop in the form of a little creature named "Sam I Am", who stalks and harasses the protagonist until he finally breaks down and agrees to try the eponymous meal. So, apparently, peer pressure and stalking can be good for you, if they deliver a nice moral lesson.
- In the famous science fiction short story The Cold Equations, the moral is "life is fundamentally unfair." This moral was a very deliberate Family Unfriendly Aesop, serving as a Deconstruction of stories where the day is always saved somehow. However, some people
were not impressed, feeling that the writer created a very contrived situation to justify the aesop.
- In Harriet the Spy, young writer Harriet learns that sometimes you have to lie to people to help them feel better about themselves so they won't hate you.
- There's also the fact that her mother forces her to "admit" she feels guilty about her friends hurt feelings after they read her private journal. Harriet makes a good point that it was her journal, she clearly forbade people from reading it, and that they had no right to do so. Mom seems to think that Harriet should feel guilty for writing the stuff down as well as for her friends negative reactions. Eventually, Harriet agrees with what her mom wants her to say, basically so Mom will stop with the badgering.
- A particularly jaw-dropping one appears in a Ray Bradbury story. The narrator's sedate, tranquil, lazy (and Irish) chauffeur picks him up one night and drives like a bat out of hell before revealing that every other enjoyable night, he was driving completely drunk. The narrator forces money on him and demands he get blotto before picking him up next, browbeating him into breaking Lent in the process.
- Most, if not all, of the works of HP Lovecraft emphasize the moral that life ultimately is pointless, and that the universe is a cold, unfeeling place. If there are Gods, they either do not care whether you live or die or are actively malevolent. Cheerful stuff.
- This doesn't exactly count as a Family Unfriendly Aesop, because that's exactly how Lovecraft himself imagined real horror to be like. In his opinion, the idea that humanity as a whole is just so beneath the notice of the greater powers in the universe that they could step on us and not notice was much, much worse than even the idea of an actively malevolent Devil, who at least cares about human souls and thus validates our existence. The idea that we are like ants looking at a mountain and that there is no one who can save us when the time comes is a large element of the horror in his stories.
- The famous shout "Ia! Ia! Cthulhu Ftaghn!" and the associated Cults are simply an extension of that sense of human insignificance. It's not an attempt to draw on Cthulhu's power, and it's certainly not an attempt to be reverant to a greater deity who happens to be asleep on our planet. We are the Whos down in Whoville, desperately attempting to convince Cthulhu that We are here! We are here! We are here!
- To be fair, Lovecraft himself wasn't the most cheerful person in the world.
- There's also a nice Aesop about cool nonhuman intelligences being mind-shattering by their very existence. Seemingly even more so for those with scientific knowledge and training. Because apparently Science isn't at all about new discoveries that change the way you see the world.
- The idea there, presumably, is that the more you know about the world and the way it works, the more absolute mind-raping violations of everything that should be you actually see. Show a normal person your absolutely terrible painting, he probably will just say it sucks. Show the same painting to an accomplished art scholar, and he'll spew Pinot Noir all over your shirt before launching into a furious diatribe and beating you half to death with the bottle. Same concept.
- This comes largely from Lovecraft's premise that humanity actually lives in a mindset that is more or less unsuited for the larger truths of the universe, like multi-dimensional aliens that just don't play by the same laws of physics our brain is made for. In Lovecraft's view, the effect would be like trying to force a square peg made of cheese through a round hole of iron: You end up mashed.
- It also comes from Lovecraft's personal experience. The idea of Einstein-ian physics and relativity was deeply disturbing to him, as it seemed to deny the very solid, objective underpinnings of Newtonian physics. While Newton would say "physics works the same way everywhere", Einstein would say "things work differently in different places, depending on the relative speed and position of the observer". Add in things like Heisenberg's Uncertainty Principle, and science actually seemed to be making things MORE confusing. Following this to a logical (if not entirely rational) conclusion, Lovecraft's fear was that we'd eventually discover enough to realize that nothing in the universe actually made any sense at all, and science would drive us all insane by showing us just how insignificant we all really were in the cosmic scheme of things. And considering some of the things that have popped up in Quantum Physics, along with our newfound understanding of just how vast space really is, it's not as if he was entirely wrong — modern science seems to be one long exercise in showing us just how stupid we actually are.
- A diffrent interpretation of the Aesop: "Discovering humanity is nowhere near being the coenter of the universe is so mindblowing, it will make you Go Mad From The Revelation".
- Lovecraft's The Horror at Red Hook has the moral that non-white people are innately evil, and if left to their own devices, will inevitably sink to acts of villainy and depravity that white men, with their superior morality, can't even comprehend, much less match. And no, this isn't a case of Accidental Aesop or Values Dissonance. Knowing Lovecraft, and reading his commentary on what inspired the story, this was clearly the intended message. This viewpoint among British (or Great Britain-influenced New England) 18th century writers is very common. Read pretty much any adventure/dime novel for the masses written during the end of the 18th century as an example of this.
- The perennial picture-book favorite If You Give a Mouse a Cookie seems to teach that you should never give anything to anyone, because if you do, they'll just keep freeloading off you until you stop giving them things. It's like Ayn Rand for kindergarteners.
- This was parodied in an incredibly over-the-top manner in Robot Chicken, where a mother tells her kid a version of the story where giving the mouse a cookie ended up cases a nuclear apocalypse. She then tells him she killed his dad for giving mouse a cookie.
- Perelandra, the second book of the Space trilogy by C. S. Lewis. The plot of the book is that the planet Venus is in the "Adam and Eve" phase and the devil has sent his agent — a man named Professor Weston — to corrupt "Eve". The angels send a man named Elwin Ransom to make sure that Tinidril chooses wisely. In the end, good triumphs over evil, but in an unexpected way: Ransom kills Weston and drops his body into a volcano.
- This is actually lampshaded by the protagonist, who assumed that the fight would be purely intellectual, that he would win by the sheer force of his argument; and was initially horrified at the idea that he'd have to make the fight a physical one. It was very much a Take That at the pacifists who opposed Great Britain's military opposition to the evils of Nazi Germany and promoted Neville Chamberlain's appeasment policy; and against the anti-confrontational passivity that was popular in much of the liberal Christian community.
- A character in Slaughterhouse Five suggests that The Bible's Aesop is that you should make sure someone doesn't have connections before you kill them.
- The Sword of Truth series has some pretty screwy morals, especially in the eighth book, Naked Empire: apparently, killing and torture are evil if the Bad Guys do them, but they're okay if the Good Guys do them — because, by being Bad Guys, they brought it upon themselves.
- Over the course of the series, Goodkind slowly works his way from formula fantasy to Objectivist philosophizing; culminating with Faith of the Fallen, which is in large part a re-writing of Ayn Rand's The Fountainhead. From that book onward, the characters' morals take on a distinctly Objectivist tone, with the good guys becoming Objectivist heroes bordering on Knights Templar, and the bad guys being collectivists and/or pacifists.
- In book 2 of Beyond The Spiderwick Chronicles, Laurie explains that she lies because "lying works" and nothing in the story contradicts this claim. This, from a book aimed at 6-12 year olds.
- Pick a Robert Silverberg story at random, and it's got a 50% chance of belonging on this list. As an example, How It Was When the Past Went Away begins with a fellow giving Easy Amnesia to an entire city through a drug in the water supply. A religion forms around the mantra "drink and forget," and life becomes utopian as people can erase their memories of all the bad deeds they've done. Not necessarily a bad Aesop, mind you, but rather an unconventional one.
- You remember that bit about Starship Troopers in the film section, above? Okay, now imagine it's not a satire. The book actually is a love letter to militarization. Unless you serve in the military, you are a second class citizen in the eyes of the government. What's more, not only does no one find this abhorrent, it's presented as some kind of great cultural achievement by the characters. Of course the movie flipped the aesop by taking away the power-armor, super-mechs, and tanks, and turning the MI into cannon fodder.
- The internal political organization of the human Federation is an utterly trivial matter compared to the REAL Family Unfriendly Aesop of the book: "Racial survival is the only universal morality." In other words, life in the universe is essentially a zero-sum struggle for Lebensraum, and when that is at stake, no species has any rights that any other is bound to respect. Peaceful coexistence is not an option. This is actually part of the doctrine that Federation officer-candidates are taught at the Academy. It cannot be stressed enough that the book, unlike the movie, presents this without the slightest trace of irony or satire. It is plain, pure Author Tract on Heinlein's part.
- Whereas the Starship Troopers military was well in advance of the 1950s in admitting people of all races, and well in advance of the 2000s in allowing women to serve as combat pilots.
- Indeed. At worst Starship Troopers in book form could be accused of being anthropocentric in that it made clear that mankind's survival was of greater importance to the body politic than "good relations with aliens." But the book also made very, very clear that absolutely nobody could be denied entry into public service (note: it is public service, not the military, the book states clearly that only a small minority of those who enlist for service do military duty), the protagonist is apparently Filipino (named Juan Rico, speaks Tagalog, so maybe Spanish/Filipino?), and women are not only permitted to do service, but eagerly sought after as pilots. The only conclusion is that Your Mileage May Vary on whether this is really a family unfriendly aesop; after all, being dutiful, patriotic, and egalatarian, and working for the good of humanity, aren't exactly considered family unfriendly morals in most circles.
- The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy is hilarious, but it has to be admitted that from the destruction of Arthur's house at the start of the first book, to the Vogon's destroying all possible Earth's at the end, that overiding theme, the overiding message, if any to be found, is that beauracracy is absurd, stupid, and not minutely evil... but always wins. Indeed, it is perhaps the most consistent theme of Douglas Adams' ouevre.
- Perhaps the message is more "Good/Smart doesn't always win", basically disproving the converse of "Might makes Right". At one point during the series, one of the character remarks about "the incompetent malevolence of the universe." That little phrase seems to sum up the world of Hitchhiker's Guide perfectly.
- L. Frank Baum's fifth Oz book, The Road to Oz begins with Dorothy leaving home with the Shaggy Man, an unkempt wanderer she met only minutes before. Then when they're alone he offers to show her his Love Magnet...
- Twilight has the wonderful aesops of "It doesn't matter if your boyfriend belittles you, threatens suicide if you leave, removes the engine from your car to stop you from visiting your best friend, and just generally abuses you — if he's good looking and says he loves you, it's okay."
- On the flip side it doesn't matter if a guy compliments you, carries your books, respects you, take you out on dates, and is all around a nice guy and a complete gentleman to you, it's okay to use him and call him names behind his back because he isn't beautiful and is a mere human.
- There's also "It's okay to drop your friends, family, and your humanity in general in exchange for a hot god-like soulmate boyfriend, a perfect baby, and rich, gorgeous, doting in-laws."
- The original version of The Little Mermaid had this delightful message to children: "Obey your parents and behave, or an innocent girl will lose her soul." Is it any wonder most people prefer the Disney version?
- The children's book Tootle is about a young (and sentient) locomotive who is learning to become a real train. However, he also enjoys going off of the rails and playing in the meadow, though this is considered taboo in his society. In the end, the townsfolk decide to teach him a lesson by waving red flags everywhere he goes when he leaves the rails. Eventually he stays on the track and never leaves it again. The main message of the book seems to be "It's not okay to do what you enjoy, unless it is approved by authority figures."
- Gor, quite infamously, has the moral that "all women secretly want to be slaves".
- Some people argue that the moral of Joe Abercrombie's The First Law is "people never change, they only delude themselves into thinking they've changed or trick others into thinking they've changed."
- Whatever the morals of The Giving Tree may be, a lot of people see it as having the family unfrendily aesop of "give the ones you love everything they ask for, even if it hurts yourself".
- Unless you're viewing it from the perspective of the man, in which case, the Aesop becomes even less family friendly "Walk all over the ones who care about you and be as demanding and selfish as you want with them, even if they suffer because of it."
- On the surface, the motivational book Who Stole My Cheese encourages being adaptive to changing situations in both your job and every day life. In actuality, it has several more prominent Family Unfriendly Aesops, including but not limited to: It's OK to let your friends starve to death while you fulfill your needs, if you're promised something and you don't get it, saying anything about it makes you an unsymphathetic whiner, and you'll never escape the rat race, so be content with being shuffled around by your shadowy, greedy overlords. It's unsurprising that most office workers that receive it as a gift from upper management immediately start updating their resumes.
Live Action TV
- Degrassi The Next Generation, despite it's heavy-handedness, frequently has morals that are widely believed by teenagers but are unusual for adults. This may be a huge part of the show's appeal to teens.
- The episode "This Charming Man" has the moral that no matter how horrible somebody is to you, squealing on them to the principal is worse.
- There was a double Family Unfriendly Aesop in "Queen of Hearts". Bitter Goth girl Ellie has to learn to trust people again after her boyfriend abandons her and sticks her with the rent. Specifically, she learns to trust both her new roommate — a recently reformed villain who wants to gamble with their rent money — and her mother, a recovering alcoholic who once burned their house down in a drunken stupor. Both of them turn out to be completely trustworthy. This is on the extreme idealistic end of the Sliding Scale Of Idealism Versus Cynicism, so idealistic that it can feel like "take candy from strangers".
- As the show progressed and several characters moved on to college, another Family Unfriendly Aesop emerged. Paige has a completely horrendous experience at Banting University. The next season, she's dropped out and despite working a high intensity fashion industry job, she's a lot happier. In season 9, Emma drops out of Smithdale due to the same issues Paige was facing. Spinner never goes to college and basically works a standard 9 to 5 restaurant job and couldn't be more content. The lesson of "College isn't for everyone/You can be successful and happy without going to college" pretty much flys in the face of almost every show aimed towards young audiences.
- Except that's not a Family Unfriendly Aesop. If you don't want to go to college and the job you want doesn't require you to go to college, then all you're doing by forcing yourself through is putting an extra burden on the system for the people that want to go. The "YOU MUST GO TO COLLEGE. OBEY. MARRY AND REPRODUCE." message espoused by most programming is closer to a Family Unfriendly Aesop, realistically speaking.
- In season 6, Craig returns to Toronto after dropping out of school in order to pursue a musical career. He also picked up a cocaine habit. His girlfriend Manny and "friend" Ellie react in different ways. Manny actually tries cocaine to get closer to Craig whom she thinks is interested in Ellie. Ellie tries to keep him away from Manny due to Craig's lying: She thinks Manny is the one with the problem. In the end, both realize that Craig has played them both. He gets absolutely no sympathy for his drug problem and both dump him harshly and he's sent to rehab alone. In season 9, Peter is still stigmatized by his friends after his meth binge. He's staying clean and meets his original dealer Victoria who is also trying to stay clean. They actually have a brief fling...but unfortunetely Victoria is using meth again. Peter dumps her immediately saying he can't be around that stuff or her. The lesson? Drug users are not worthy of any sympathy and in fact, they can drag others down with them. So don't even deal with them.
- Alli is constantly being rebuked by her boyfriend Johnny for not respecting their relationship boundaries - he wants to keep his reputation as a tough guy. So in order to get him to open up and show affection, she starts "sexting" him nude pics. However, whenever she embarrasses him in front of the whole school by showing off a lovey-dovey cute photograph of him, he sends her nude pics to his friend. At the end of the episode, the lesson presented appears to be that Alli was in the wrong, and it didn't matter that he sent those nude pics because she broke her promise in regards to their relationship rules and that was worse. Wow.
- Similarly, almost every episode of Radio Free Roscoe has the moral that Adults Are Useless, so teens should defy and disobey them whenever possible. What makes it even more interesting is that it's always played as an idealistic moral — not "adults will always screw you over," but "disobey adults and everything will turn out happy." An example: In "The Boxer", the jerkass principal is serving as a substitute history teacher on the Boxer Rebellion, which he knows nothing about. So his lectures are biased, inaccurate, and a bit racist... and in response, one of his students corrects every one of his errors, out loud, in front of the class. By the end of the episode, the principal and the student are teaming up to teach a better lesson. In a less idealistic show, the principal would have arbitrarily slapped the kid down with his authority.
- In many TV shows, any hero who takes ruthless measures is instantly condemned to becoming a Well Intentioned Extremist or Jumping Off The Slippery Slope. So it was startling when Star Trek Deep Space Nine didn't do that:
- In "For the Uniform", Sisko is hunting a terrorist with the goal of attacking Cardassian planets with "Cobalt diselenide", a bioweapon which makes the planet uninhabitable to Cardassians but is harmless to humans, forcing the Cardassian population to evacuate and allowing humans to colonize the planet. Sisko's way of capturing him? Threaten to drop "Trilithium resin", a bioweapon which makes planets uninhabitable by humans, but which is harmless to Cardassians, on every planet in the demilitarized zone unless the criminal surrenders. He refuses to surrender? He thinks it's a bluff? Carry out the threat against a planet. It works and the bad guy gives himself up, creating the Family Unfriendly Aesop of "Sometimes stooping to the other guys level works". To be fair, it is portrayed as a morally ambiguous act and the criminal calls Sisko on his actions:
Bad guy: Can't you see what's happening to you? You're going against everything you claim to believe in. And for what? To satisfy a personal vendetta? Sisko: You betrayed your uniform! Bad Guy: And you're betraying yours, right now! The sad part is that you don't even realize it. I feel sorry for you, captain. This obsession with me, look what it's cost you! Sisko: Major! Shut that thing off! Commander Worf, prepare to launch torpedoes!
- The Bad Guy in that episode romanticized his relationship with Sisko as being like the one between Jean Valjean and Inspector Javert from Les Miserables. Once Sisko realized this, he played up to the role. Family Unfriendly Aesop: "If your adversary thinks you're the villain, it's best not to disappoint."
- In "The Darkness and the Light", the villain is murdering Kira's friends one by one to get revenge. The villain carefully avoids killing anyone else, including taking steps to ensure that Kira, who was pregnant at the time, would safely give birth before he killed her; this leads directly to his defeat. At the end, a shaken Kira says that the villain was better than her because he took this care and that his failure was due to him not being as awful as she could be.
- A Family Unfriendly Aesop for a different reason: In "The Abandoned", the moral is that some alien species are inherently evil, even if good people raise them. There is nothing inherently wrong or awful about this moral, but given that Star Trek aliens are almost always used as metaphors for dealing with other human cultures, it feels highly unfriendly.
- Compare with "Hippocratic Oath", in which a Jem'Hadar who is not addicted to the White is shown to be fair and respectful of life. Perhaps the Aesop was that if someone is meddled with enough, they can lose their free will — a recurring theme in "Hard Time". In any case, it's more complex than a justification for racism.
- In "In The Pale Moonlight", Sisko decides the only way to win the war is to get the Romulans to join their side. How does he do this? He lies, creates forgeries, bribes Quark, gives material to make biogenic weapons to a disreputable scientist, and is an accessory in six murders. But he succeeds. Garak leaves him with this, though: "You may have just saved the entire Alpha Quadrant, and all it cost was the life of one Romulan Senator, one criminal... and the self-respect of one Starfleet officer. I don't know about you, but I'd call that a bargain."
- This episode is the most controversial in all Star Trek history, the one that long-time Trekkers accuse of being the most at total loggerheads with Gene Roddenberry's vision of the human future.
- Garak, who came from the society of the Cardassians, where being a Magnificent Bastard is the highest form of success, makes his own Family Unfriendly Aesop for laughs in the episode "Improbable Cause". Told the parable of "The Boy Who Cried Wolf", Garak concludes that the moral is "never tell the same lie twice."
- Sabrina The Teenage Witch episode "Geek Like Me". According to it, geeks can be just as ruthlessly oppressive as the popular crowd if given power, making them Not So Different. "What's inside that counts" reveals that Libby will always be a manipulative bitch and will never gain any empathy.
- Many people who hate the extreme Tastes Like Diabetes feeling of Barney and Friends also find it to contain many Family Unfriendly Aesops. For example, in one episode, children were told "A stranger is a friend you haven't met yet." Parents complained that it would be dangerous to tell that to young children, as it would make them vulnerable to criminals. The episode was never shown again.
- There is also a reoccuring theme of "everyone should be happy all the time!" The message is enforced to the point where more than one episode features Barney basically badgering a kid into cheering up after something bad happens. Most of the time, it's nothing major... losing a possession, or forgetting a homework assignment or the like. But there's one episode where the kid's pet passed away, and they just wouldn't let her be sad about it! Seems to teach a frighteningly blase lesson about mourning a loss.
- 24 has been criticized by some circles who interpret it as justifying torture as a tool of war by the U.S. Government. There's quite a bit of debate on that. It also seems to suggest that, even for the good guys, tasering your own employees to ensure their loyalty is good policy, and that you should expect them to go back to their cubicles immediately afterward without so much as a complaint. And, of course, Torture Always Works.
- An episode of Touched by an Angel had the moral that, no matter how nice they are, atheists are fundamentally bad people with whom believers should not associate. The episode is also a sequel episode to a season finale that dealt with accepting the death of a child. The death episode is much better in its message, though it borders on Family Unfriendly for the crowd who do not believe in an afterlife. What that vast crowd of non-afterlife-believing people is doing watching a show about angels? Don't ask us.
- Battlestar Galactica: Sometimes you have to Shoot The Dog, you can't always Take A Third Option, and you have to Know When To Fold Em.
- The season one Veronica Mars episode Drinking the Kool-Aid seemed to preach the moral that freaky cults are actually filled with nice people. It was actually the very family-friendly Aesop that evil and danger don't necessarily advertise themselves. Too many young people think that it's possible to tell whether someone is evil or dangerous by their looks or their temperament. See this picture.
◊ Notice how Churchill looks like a grumpy old man and Roosevelt looks like a skeleton. Stalin, however, looks nice, like he usually did. Now, which one of them came up with gulags... By the way, many people in freaky cults are nice people. Cults go out of their way to recruit nice people. This was one of the points of the episode: don't judge a group by how well their members treat you, judge it by its core values. Anyone can be nice.
- The whole underlying theme of this series seems to be to not trust law enforcement and take justice into your own hands — especially in Season Two. The biggest examples of this are when Veronica helps Duncan Kane kidnap his illegitimate daughter to avoid any chance of her custody going to her ultra-fundamentalist, abusive grandparents, then when Duncan has his family's security chief kill Aaron Echols because he killed his sister Lily but was acquitted. Of course, it was a noir show.
- Oh, Greys Anatomy... Shonda must have some warped morals! What with the "Marriage is nothing important", or the "no matter how awful you behave, everybody will love you and your punishment will be nothing more than a slap on the wrist"?
- Probably lifting Ms. Rand above advice to the letter, the famous "backwards" Seinfeld episode, "The Betrayal", showed Jerry and Kramer's first meeting, with Jerry insisting to Kramer that "what's mine is yours." So Yeah.
- One episode of the short-lived anthology series Night Visions told the story of a Town With A Dark Secret where music is banned and anyone who breaks the rules is swiftly and brutally dealt with. A drifter comes into town, realizes something is wrong and starts investigating: it turns out that the townspeople are all convinced that they're under a curse, and playing or creating any kind of music within the town will summon some sort of monster to kill them all. Of course, the drifter thinks they're all nuts, and in the inevitable climactic confrontation he delivers a heroic speech about how they have no proof that the monster actually exists, and they've been committing horrific acts in the name of blind superstition. The townspeople realize he's right, and he leads them all in a rousing rendition of "Amazing Grace." ... And then the monster comes to kill them all. Moral of the story: committing horrific acts in the name of blind superstition is a really good idea! For the record, Night Visions was chock full of family unfriendly or outright broken aesops. It's the sort of show you watch expecting a story about an abused wife to end with her being beaten to death by her husband, followed by host Henry Rollins delivering an aesop along the lines of "Next time your husband tells you to shut up, you should do it."
- For a show that could get borderline anvilicious at times, Full House tended to fall into this trope frequently in plots involving Michelle getting away with just about anything, especially in the later seasons.
- The Disney episode was particularly egregious; after half an episode of being a horrible brat and getting everything she wants, Michelle deliberately runs off in Disneyland after overhearing her sisters (rightfully) complain about how she always gets her way. Then, she's found and the older girls apologize for being mean to her! Never mind that she's old enough to know better, still runs off on a tantrum, and gets to ride in the parade (and is in no way punished) in the end regardless.
- She is reprimanded for running off, however.
- Basically anytime a police procedural uses wanting a lawyer as evidence of guilt. No matter how innocent you are, always get a lawyer.
- iCarly is stock full of these Aesops as well. One glaring example took place in "iMeet Fred": Freddie and the iCarly webshow are completely vilified for not liking Youtuber Fred's videos, causing Fred to quit making them. His two best friends Carly and Sam put up with the backlash (at least, Carly does at first) but as it continues and Fred extends an olive branch, the crew drive all the way over to Fred's house and PHYSICALLY FORCE Freddie to apologize! Sam even beats him up with a tennis racket! All of this in order to end the backlash, with absolutely no respect toward Freddie's opinion. The moral? "It's okay to stand up for what you believe in, until popular opinion dictates it's wrong."
- Not to mention the entire premise of iCarly is pretty Family Unfriendly. The webshow pretty much shows off Carly's apartment for the entire world to see, not to mention Sam has even given out their school's address on the air. The kids have even met with some viewers offline, sometimes not even with Carly's guardian Spencer with them. The only person they met offline that is remotely dangerous is a 9-year-old webcritic who they've dealt with handily. In this age of To Catch a Predator, the message of "Not everyone you meet offline wants to hurt you, and can sometimes lead to good friendships" isn't exactly FALSE, but kinda weird to show little kids.
- The whole Carrie/Big premise from Sex and the City. "It doesn't matter how many times a guy breaks your heart (or even marries someone else); if he's good-looking and the sex is great, keep going back to him." The same Aesop is applied with Grace/Leo on Will and Grace.
Music
- "Better the Devil You Know" by Kylie Minogue is about going back to the guy who treated you badly because "better the devil you know". This was probably meant to creep the listener out. Nick Cave called it the most disturbing song he had heard, in part because of Kylie's innocent image.
- Kylie and Nick went on to sing a duet, "Where The Wild Roses Grow," about a girl falling for a man who then bashes her head in with a rock so no one else can have her. Kylie is a very creepy soul in a very cute body.
- Avril Lavigne's "Girlfriend" is a really-very sarcastic song that, taken unironically, would have one of the most family unfriendly aesops ever. "If you're a girl who follows the Rule Of Cool and likes a taken boy, it's okay to throw yourself at the guy and steal him away because you know he likes you back, and his girlfriend is "like, so whatever". And the video points out it's okay to humiliate said girlfriend because she's a nerdy girl with glasses." Lavigne's Word Of God points out how it's criticizing shallow boy-crazy girls who act like that, but tell that to the song's Misaimed Fandom.
- And to everyone who thinks she's dead serious and hates that song accordingly.
- Another song on the same album features the lyrics 'I hate it when a guy/doesn't get the tab/I have to get my money out/and that looks bad'.
- The Bobbie Gentry song Fancy
has the moral "prostitution is the way out if you're a desperately-poor girl who happens to be pretty". The way it's presented is pure privileged fantasy; in reality, rich and powerful men choose their mistresses from the ranks of the demimonde — women who are raised with the mannerisms and accomplishments that will let them fit in with the upper classes. They don't just pick up a street hooker from the slums, no matter what she looks like.
- Having read the song's lyrics, it's implied that Fancy managed to use her looks and the "pretty dress" from the first verse to start out in a slightly better area than the slums, high enough that with time and effort she was able to get the education she needed to become a "lady." Still difficult, hugely difficult, at best, and still a dubious Aesop, but not pure fantasy.
- Madame du Barry lived this trope until she lost her head... La Paiva and Nell Gwyn even did it and lived out their lives in comfort.
- It's a Family Unfriendly Aesop, but not the one you think: it's difficult to see what the lyrics mean without the Reba McIntire video, which was written in consultation with Gentry and which reflects what she meant. Fancy is a beautiful Oklahoma teenager in the dustbowl 1930s who is given by her desperately poor mother to a rich man from the city in full knowledge that her daughter will be kept, but at least she'll be fed. Fancy returns to the deserted homestead thirty years later after a career as a successful kept woman in order to forgive her mother, who starved to death decades ago. The moral is, "it's better to sell your children into sexual slavery than to let them die slowly of starvation".
- The moral of Miley Cyrus's song "7 Things" is that you should stick with your boyfriend if you absolutely hate everything about him aside from his hair and eyes, his old jeans, being hypnotized when he kisses, and sentimental feelings about laughing, crying, and holding his hand. His vanity, games, insecurity, and unfaithfulness are qualities she hates, but is willing to overlook because of the aforementioned things she likes about him, and it's implied that his vanity, etc. also make her love him.
- Kingdom Hearts' opening theme song, "Simple and Clean," suggests some very dubious morals. For example, "Don't get me wrong I love you, But does that mean I have to meet your father?" suggests that the narrator's lover doesn't want to put out the effort to get acquainted with her family, and that, although the lover "wishes he could prove he loves her, he doesn't want to have to walk on water; when she's older she'll understand that it's enough when he says so." Apparently, "Hikari," the Japanese version of the song, makes much more sense, and is almost the complete opposite: "I'll introduce my family, You'll surely get along well."
- As far as relating the two - "Simple and Clean" and "Hikari" - they are not even translations of each other. At best, they tend to be vaguely similar.
- The Script 's popular Ballard 'The Man who Can't be Moved' is about a guy who was left by his ex, and is willing to stand on the corner of the street until she comes back. Though it's certainly a desperate romantic gesture (which a lot of people go mushy about) others really wish that he'd get on with his life. There's absolutely no way she's coming back, he's probably going to make himself ill, the chances of the news picking him up are absurd and it's probably not his fault that she went away anyway.
- These come up a fair few times in Lily Allen's music, prominent among them her singles "Fuck You" ("Conservatives are inherently tyrannical/hateful/war-mongering/generally terrible people who don't deserve to express their opinions") and "Not Fair" ("If your boyfriend is bad in bed, it more or less negates any positive traits he may have").
- The punk rock band NOFX's song "Drug Free America" is actually promoting an America where drugs are free of cost. Their song "Don't drink and drive" warns about the danger of spilling your drink while driving, and argues that drunk people are better drivers (NOFX use a lot of satire and believe that True Art Is Offensive).
Mythology
- Most mythologies were big on destiny. No matter what you do, no matter what you want to do, and no matter what kind of person you are, you can't change your fate. Was your fate to die in a fire, you will die in a fire, no matter what. As a matter of fact, if you try to fight it, your death will most likely be more painful. Poor Oedipus and his family never had a chance...
- Considering that they were the creators of all existence, the various deities and demigods/goddesses in Greek mythology were surprisingly jealous and promiscuous. On the other hand, some versions of myths do have various gods or goddesses realize the errors of some of their judgements and reverse them or have a different sympathetic god or goddess aide someone under a deity's wrath.
- Of course, in Greek mythology, the gods weren't the creators of the universe, and were subject to the same base emotions humans were. Which probably makes it more of a satire than an Aesop.
Tabletop Games
- Warhammer 40000 excels at these, played straight in-universe, while players tend to find them darkly amusing. Books and video games are often littered with aphorisms and Thoughts For The Day such as "it is better to die for the Emperor than live for yourself," "an open mind is like a fortress with its gates unbarred and unguarded," or "the loyal slave learns to love the lash."
- Not to mention that the Imperials are fervent believers of Dumb Is Good. Blame the aftermath of the Age of Strife for that, though.
- With "Always Chaotic Evil", Dungeons & Dragons left us with the basic message "Some people are just innately psychopathic madmen hellbent on burning your corpse, pillaging your home city, and selling your family into slavery."
Theater
Video Games
- In .hack//G.U. there is a player who first appears to be a brother and sister using the same character, but it actually turns out that the sister is a split personality of the brother. The game actually encourages you to convince the sister personality to stay, instead of letting the brother have full control of his body or receive psychological treatment.
- That's more of a Values Dissonance than anything. Is it better to kill one personality so that the other can have complete control, or let them both share the same body?
- The .hack series has a long running tendency to try and demonstrate that things that you wouldn't initially think as living beings should be considered as such, a big example being the A Is of the The World. By the game's normal standards, convincing Saku to surrender her own existence is essentially murder. Besides, Bo liked her and was comfortable with her around.
- On par with that, one could even ask the question "Is it better to try and pull away someone else's psychological crutches, or let them heal on their own until they no longer need them?" Endrance is certainly an example of someone who lost his emotional crutch (Mia/Macha) before he was ready, and never recovered because of it. Bo clearly isn't ready to let go of Saku, and forcing him to do so without any actual follow-up therapy in the real world would almost certainly leave him worse off. The entire core premise of the GU games is people (mainly Haseo, but also Atoli) growing up and learning to stand on their own without constantly depending on others or otherwise externalizing their self-esteem. This would actually tie well into that — Haseo can't help Bo by forcing Saku away, as much as Bo needs to come to terms with the fact that Saku doesn't exist, and addressing (and solving!) the reasons why he created her in the first place.
- Valkyria Chronicles. If you're overwhelmed by a major change in your ability to handle your problems, don't carefully examine your feelings, weigh your options, or take your situation and your resources into consideration; just jump to whatever wild conclusion comes to mind, because your boyfriend is just waiting for the right moment to bail you out with common sense.
- That one actually shows up twice. Alicia freaks out and tries to kill herself (and her friends) with her Valkyria flame, Captain Varrot almost murders a captured enemy officer because she's in a good position to do so; they both have to be talked out of it by their future husbands.
- The whole game has a thematic Aesop about the Power Of Friendship being able to overcome individual obstacles that are much stronger, which is fine. However, because the primary vehicle for this is Valkyria Powers, which are naturally latent and can be awakened, the Aesop becomes, "Natural talent is evil because talented people lose their perspective when they don't have to work hard to achieve, and because jealous onlookers will destroy themselves trying to match up."
- Blowing people up with lasers is horrible and puts a terrible burden on the souls of people who commit such atrocities; killing thousands of people with ordinary firearms is fine for everyone, and gets you a medal. If everyone does it, it's okay!
- Some people believe that Tales Of Vesperia glorifies vigilantism and murder. Major Your Mileage May Vary, though.
- Jade Empire had the arguably Family Unfriendly lesson of "respecting the position of the Gods and knowing your station in life is more important than saving millions from drought and famine". Of course, the developers were probably going for "power corrupts".
Web Comics
Web Original
- Cracked has at
least two lists on this.
Western Animation
|
|