Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / BowAndSwordInAccord

Go To

OR

Added: 670

Changed: 2135

Removed: 1015

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Heavy Horse Archers are usually this. Cataphracts (Parthian, Sassanid and Byzantine) as well as Mamluk and Spahi elites carried bows as well as their maces or swords while wearing not too heavy but still considerable armour. One wonders what would have happened if the [[LeeroyJenkins Western European knight]] had picked up on this approach.
** Then you basically get Russian Boyars. They started off as heavy cavalry armed primarily with spears, but somewhere around the 9th century learned to use the bow to counter steppe nomads they usually fought. In effect becoming either heavy horse archers who were well armored and extremely good in melee, often surprising the more Western armies like Polish and Germans.

to:

* Until the wide adoption of repeating firearms the Central Asian style of mounted archery was nearly unstoppable. The use of mobile archery from the ancient Parthians on was nearly unstoppable. The sword and lance were used at close range and on those rare occasions when fighting was on foot, but they were always secondary tools.
** The Muslim world pretty much abandoned its previous weapons and tactics upon contact with tribes such as the Mongols and Seljuks. The straight sword gave way to the shamshir and its variants.
Heavy Horse Archers are usually this. Cataphracts (Parthian, Sassanid and Byzantine) as well as Mamluk and Spahi elites carried bows as well as their maces or swords while wearing not too heavy but still considerable armour. One wonders what would have happened if the [[LeeroyJenkins Western European knight]] had picked up on this approach.
** Then you basically get Russian Boyars. They started off as heavy cavalry armed primarily with spears, but somewhere around the 9th century learned to use the bow to counter steppe nomads they usually fought. In effect becoming either heavy
infantry was largely replaced by horse archers who were well armored archery. And so on.
*** Even in an earlier era the Prophet Mohamed said that all Muslim men should know archery
and extremely good in melee, often surprising said that the more Western armies like Polish value of prayer was multiplied if one wore a sword.
** The Russians, Georgians, Poles
and Germans.Hungarians adopted similar styles of arms and tactics. The Hungarian bow is a variant of the Asian asymmetric compound bow.



** (Note) Longbowmen were commoners and could not bear chivalric arms such as the sword. When they were overrun by regular infantry let alone horse they tended to get slaughtered. Much of the strategy at Crecy and Agincourt centered around protecting the archers from French horsemen and maximizing the time the French stayed in the killing ground.



* The Vikings weren't averse to using archery to open battle, not to mention chucking spears, despite their {{Blood Knight}} reputation.
* Even though [[YourMileageMayVary they believe]] KatanasAreJustBetter, the Samurai were just as skilled at shooting a bow from horseback before entering the fray with their better-known swords.
** Samurai were originally mounted archers. The katanas came later in history; their legendary code of honor, "Bushido" or "Way of the Warrior", was originally known as "Kyuba No Michi", or "Way of the Horse and Bow".
** For all that they were a signature weapon, and almost a holy relic. The Katana was not even the Samurai's primary battle weapon (it was used predominantly for duelling); that honour went to the Naginata. So the samurai are best described as Bow and {{Polearm}} In Accord.
*** And even the Naginata went out of fashion as Yari pike formations became more popular--just as in Europe, rows of men with pikes became more important than an individual skilled warrior.
* The modern rifleman is essentially this. He is taught to dominate the enemy with ranged fire (from his rifle) but simultaneously to close in on said enemy. When he gets within close range, he is then taught to throw grenades, rush in and end the fight at close quarters. (Usually by this point, the other guys are either dead or gone...)
** This has been true of infantry since the invention of the bayonet, especially once the socket bayonet allowed the soldier to seamlessly switch from ranged combat to direct combat and back without interruption.

to:

* The Vikings weren't averse to using archery to open battle, not to mention chucking spears, despite their {{Blood Knight}} reputation.
* Even though [[YourMileageMayVary they believe]] KatanasAreJustBetter, the primary weapon of the Samurai were just as skilled at shooting a bow from horseback before entering the fray with their better-known swords.
** Samurai were
was originally mounted archers. the bow. The katanas katana came later in history; their legendary code of honor, "Bushido" or "Way of the Warrior", was originally known as "Kyuba No Michi", or "Way of the Horse and Bow".
** For all that they were a signature weapon, and almost a holy relic. The Katana cult of the sword was not even the Samurai's primary battle weapon (it was used predominantly for duelling); that honour went to the Naginata. So the samurai are best described as Bow and {{Polearm}} In Accord.
*** And even the Naginata went out of fashion as Yari pike formations became more popular--just as in Europe, rows of men with pikes became more
often important than an in Japan; it was never the primary weapon of war. That place was held by the spear and the Naginata, a halberd-like {{Polearm}}.
* Since the military adoption of
individual skilled warrior.
* The modern rifleman is essentially this. He is taught to dominate
firearms the enemy with ranged fire (from his rifle) but simultaneously to infantryman has had analogous training. For centuries bullets were used at long ranges. At close in on said enemy. When he gets within close range, he is then taught to throw grenades, rush in and end range the fight at close quarters. (Usually by this point, the other guys are either dead or gone...)
** This has been true of infantry since the invention of the bayonet, especially once the socket
bayonet allowed took over, often in massed charges. While the soldier to seamlessly switch from ranged combat to direct combat and back without interruption.bayonet is still part of many soldiers' training its use declined with the adoption of reliable repeating firearms.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** This has been true of infantry since the invention of the bayonet, especially once the socket bayonet allowed the soldier to seamlessly switch from ranged combat to direct combat and back without interruption.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[quoteright:330:[[WarhammerFantasy http://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/Shade_2_1451.jpg]]]]

to:

[[quoteright:330:[[WarhammerFantasy [[WarhammerFantasy http://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/Shade_2_1451.jpg]]]]jpg]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[caption-width:307: [[CompletelyMissingThePoint Isn't that a crossbow?]]]]]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

[[caption-width:307: [[CompletelyMissingThePoint Isn't that a crossbow?]]]]]]

Changed: 57

Removed: 146

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Link carries a slingshot, then an actual bow, in ''{{Legend Of Zelda}}'' games. Of course, that's [[HyperspaceArsenal hardly the only weaponry combination he's capable of]], but his sword and bow are generally his most powerful weapons and required to defeat the FinalBoss.
** DidNotDoTheResearch. There are only a few games where he upgrades from the slingshot to the bow. In almost all of them, he simply gets the bow.

to:

* Link carries a slingshot, then either upgrades to or, more frequently, simply picks up an actual bow, bow in ''{{Legend Of Zelda}}'' games. Of course, that's [[HyperspaceArsenal hardly the only weaponry combination he's capable of]], but his sword and bow are generally his most powerful weapons and required to defeat the FinalBoss.
** DidNotDoTheResearch. There are only a few games where he upgrades from the slingshot to the bow. In almost all of them, he simply gets the bow.
FinalBoss.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** DidNotDoTheResearch. There are only a few games where he upgrades from the slingshot to the bow. In almost all of them, he simply gets the bow.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Actually, that is not quite true. They had a variety of weapons of this sort. The ''veruta'' were shorter and lighter and used for skirmishing and the ''spicula'' replaced the ''pila'' later in the Empire. Also, iron is soft by nature. The bending action would be caused by the replacement of one of the iron pins with a wooden pin (which held the point onto the wooden haft). This made it easy to fix after the battle, but useless (especially if it were embedding in your shield or armour) after its first use. Roman legionaries did carry quite a bit of weaponry though. [[WalkingArmory A]] ''[[WalkingArmory gladius, pugio]]'', [[WalkingArmory set of]] ''[[WalkingArmory pila]]'', [[WalkingArmory possibly another sort of javelin, possibly up to five]] ''[[WalkingArmory plumbatae]]'' [[WalkingArmory(large weighted darts) plus the formidable]] ''[[WalkingArmory scutum]]'' [[WalkingArmory (shield) would possibly be carried.]]

to:

** Actually, that is not quite true. They had a variety of weapons of this sort. The ''veruta'' were shorter and lighter and used for skirmishing and the ''spicula'' replaced the ''pila'' later in the Empire. Also, iron is soft by nature. The bending action would be caused by the replacement of one of the iron pins with a wooden pin (which held the point onto the wooden haft). This made it easy to fix after the battle, but useless (especially if it were embedding in your shield or armour) after its first use. Roman legionaries did carry quite a bit of weaponry though. [[WalkingArmory A]] ''[[WalkingArmory gladius, pugio]]'', [[WalkingArmory set of]] ''[[WalkingArmory pila]]'', [[WalkingArmory possibly another sort of javelin, possibly up to five]] ''[[WalkingArmory plumbatae]]'' [[WalkingArmory(large [[WalkingArmory (large weighted darts) plus the formidable]] ''[[WalkingArmory scutum]]'' [[WalkingArmory (shield) would possibly be carried.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Actually, that is not quite true. They had a variety of weapons of this sort. The ''veruta'' were shorter and lighter and used for skirmishing and the ''spicula'' replaced the ''pila'' later in the Empire. Also, iron is soft by nature. The bending action would be caused by the replacement of one of the iron pins with a wooden pin (which held the point onto the wooden haft). This made it easy to fix after the battle, but useless (especially if it were embedding in your shield or armour) after its first use. Roman legionaries did carry quite a bit of weaponry though. [[WalkingArmoury A]] ''[[WalkingArmoury gladius, pugio]]'', [[WalkingArmoury set of]] ''[[WalkingArmoury pila]]'', [[WalkingArmoury possibly another sort of javelin, possibly up to five]] ''[[WalkingArmoury plumbatae]]'' [[WalkingArmoury(large weighted darts) plus the formidable]] ''[[WalkingArmoury scutum]]'' [[WalkingArmoury (shield) would possibly be carried.]]

to:

** Actually, that is not quite true. They had a variety of weapons of this sort. The ''veruta'' were shorter and lighter and used for skirmishing and the ''spicula'' replaced the ''pila'' later in the Empire. Also, iron is soft by nature. The bending action would be caused by the replacement of one of the iron pins with a wooden pin (which held the point onto the wooden haft). This made it easy to fix after the battle, but useless (especially if it were embedding in your shield or armour) after its first use. Roman legionaries did carry quite a bit of weaponry though. [[WalkingArmoury [[WalkingArmory A]] ''[[WalkingArmoury ''[[WalkingArmory gladius, pugio]]'', [[WalkingArmoury [[WalkingArmory set of]] ''[[WalkingArmoury ''[[WalkingArmory pila]]'', [[WalkingArmoury [[WalkingArmory possibly another sort of javelin, possibly up to five]] ''[[WalkingArmoury ''[[WalkingArmory plumbatae]]'' [[WalkingArmoury(large [[WalkingArmory(large weighted darts) plus the formidable]] ''[[WalkingArmoury ''[[WalkingArmory scutum]]'' [[WalkingArmoury [[WalkingArmory (shield) would possibly be carried.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Actually, that is not quite true. They had a variety of weapons of this sort. The ''veruta'' were shorter and lighter and used for skirmishing and the ''spicula'' replaced the ''pila'' later in the Empire. Also, iron is soft by nature. The bending action would be caused by the replacement of one of the iron pins with a wooden pin (which held the point onto the wooden haft). This made it easy to fix after the battle, but useless (especially if it were embedding in your shield or armour) after its first use. Roman legionaries did carry quite a bit of weaponry though. A ''gladius, pugio'', set of ''pila'', possibly another sort of javelin, possibly up to five ''plumbatae'' (large weighted darts) plus the formidable ''scutum'' (shield) would possibly be carried.

to:

** Actually, that is not quite true. They had a variety of weapons of this sort. The ''veruta'' were shorter and lighter and used for skirmishing and the ''spicula'' replaced the ''pila'' later in the Empire. Also, iron is soft by nature. The bending action would be caused by the replacement of one of the iron pins with a wooden pin (which held the point onto the wooden haft). This made it easy to fix after the battle, but useless (especially if it were embedding in your shield or armour) after its first use. Roman legionaries did carry quite a bit of weaponry though. A ''gladius, pugio'', [[WalkingArmoury A]] ''[[WalkingArmoury gladius, pugio]]'', [[WalkingArmoury set of ''pila'', of]] ''[[WalkingArmoury pila]]'', [[WalkingArmoury possibly another sort of javelin, possibly up to five ''plumbatae'' (large five]] ''[[WalkingArmoury plumbatae]]'' [[WalkingArmoury(large weighted darts) plus the formidable ''scutum'' formidable]] ''[[WalkingArmoury scutum]]'' [[WalkingArmoury (shield) would possibly be carried.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* The modern rifleman is essentially this. He is taught to dominate the enemy with ranged fire (from his rifle) but simultaneously to close in on said enemy. When he gets within close range, he is then taught to throw grenades, rush in and end the fight at close quarters. (Usually by this point, the other guys are either dead or gone...)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[AC:{{Webcomics}}]]
* Momba Kawunei in ''TheWaterPhoenixKing'' is always seen in flashbacks to the war with his massive recurve bow, "Eye-Biter," but he carried a katana then, too -- though recently has upgraded to a {{Magitek}} blade capable of cleaving just about anything.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


It's worth noting that this trope used to be called The Ranger, from the LordOfTheRings rangers. Any references to rangers on this page are likely from when the trope was in YKTTW.

to:

It's worth noting that this trope used to be called The Ranger, {{Ranger}}, from the LordOfTheRings rangers. Any references to rangers on this page are likely from when the trope was in YKTTW.



* An AwesomeYetPractical tactic in Assassain'sCreedBrotherhood. Angry up some guards, crossbow half of them, chainkill the rest, finish up with crossbowing any cowards.

to:

* In ''[=~Assassin's Creed~=]'' and its sequel, pretty much every archer also packs a sword or bludgeon for CQC. In ''Brotherhood'' the crossbowmen intriguingly do ''not'' pack close-quarters weapons, but with the crossbow finally in his hands after being foreshadowed back in the first game's first trailer, Ezio can do this. An AwesomeYetPractical tactic in Assassain'sCreedBrotherhood. Angry up is to anger some guards, crossbow half of them, chainkill the rest, finish up with crossbowing any cowards.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Guts of ''{{Berserk}}'' also fits the ranger profile, using a repeating crossbow along with his {{BFS}}. He deviates from the general profile by being heavily armoured (since he's a mercenary who mainly favours melee) and by having a ''third'' weapon (a [[ArmCannon gunpowder cannon built into his arm]]) as a nasty surprise for any demons who think they have him beat.

to:

* Guts of ''{{Berserk}}'' also fits the ranger profile, using throwing knives and a repeating crossbow along with his {{BFS}}. He deviates from the general profile by being heavily armoured (since he's a mercenary who mainly favours melee) and by also having a ''third'' ''fourth'' weapon (a [[ArmCannon gunpowder cannon built into his arm]]) as a nasty surprise for any demons who think they have him beat.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Then you basically get Russian Boyars. They started off as heavy cavalry armed primarily with spears, but somewhere around the 9th century learned to use the bow to counter steppe nomads they usually fought. In effect becoming either heavy horse archers who were well armored and extremely good in melee, often surprising the more Western armies like Polish and Germans.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Detritus doesn't have to carry a sword, but his crossbow is more than enough to make up for it.
*** By which they mean its a ballista.
**** Which has been altered to fire a cross between a fireball and a flechette storm.


Added DiffLines:

* An AwesomeYetPractical tactic in Assassain'sCreedBrotherhood. Angry up some guards, crossbow half of them, chainkill the rest, finish up with crossbowing any cowards.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** The Knights in the same game gain the ability to use bows upon promotion to the General class.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** The Knights in the same game gain the ability to use bows upon promotion to the General class.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* You could argue Edgar from FinalFantasyVI is this. He can equip a sword as his weapon, but you know he is going to be useing his autocrossbow most of the time.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* ''DragonAge: Origins'' allows you to switch between two full sets of weapons. Given the thrust of the game as being somewhat more tactical, it's almost unheard of that even one character doesn't switch to a bow. (Even mages, whose staves automatically hit at range, can do a lot more damage with a bow if they hit often enough.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Archer of ''FateStayNight'' frequently uses two short scimitars instead of a bow. He also occasionally uses swords as arrows.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''Team Fortress 2'', The Sniper can pull this off if you use the Huntsman, since his melee weapon is a kukiri. You can even include a shield, albeit an almost unusable one.

to:

* In ''Team Fortress 2'', ''TeamFortress2'', The Sniper can pull this off if you use the Huntsman, since his melee weapon is a kukiri. You can even include a shield, albeit an almost unusable one.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Rambo uses a modern variant, with a compound bow and a large bowie knife (in addition to whatever guns he can get his hands on).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[quoteright:328:http://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/BowAndSword.gif]]

to:

[[quoteright:328:http://static.[[quoteright:330:[[WarhammerFantasy http://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/BowAndSword.gif]]
org/pmwiki/pub/images/Shade_2_1451.jpg]]]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None




to:

\n* [[LadyOfWar Signum]] of ''MagicalGirlLyricalNanoha''. In her case, she's a swordswoman first [[SwissArmyWeapon and only switches]] to a bow when an enemy can't be fought at melee range or if she's going for a long-ranged sneak attack.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Actually, there IS a sword, in its scabbard, extending down from the figure's hand, though the hilt is covered. I see no reason not to replace it with a better picture, but not with nothing.

Added DiffLines:

[[quoteright:328:http://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/BowAndSword.gif]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
No sword. Like at all. How is that a good image?


[[quoteright:328:http://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/BowAndSword.gif]]
[[caption-width-right:328:A [[TheLateMiddleAges Fifteenth Century]] Woodcut of RobinHood]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Richard in TheSwordOfTruth is very skilled with his sword, but his gift also makes him a perfect marksman.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* As of the Dawn Solution, Solars in ''{{Exalted}}'' have a Charm that specifically facilitates this combat style: Elegant Dance of Bow and Blade.

to:

* As of the Dawn Solution, Solars in ''{{Exalted}}'' have a Charm that specifically facilitates this combat style: Elegant Dance of Bow and Blade.
Blade. Furthermore, they can switch between weapons ''mid-combat'' via HyperspaceArsenal.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* As of the Dawn Solution, Solars in ''{{Exalted}}'' have a Charm that specifically facilitates this combat style: Elegant Dance of Bow and Blade.

Top