Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Literature / AStormOfSwords

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** When Oberyn Martell duels the Mountain, he brings up the [[YouKilledMyFather murder of his sister Elia.]] The Mountain's response is "Who?" Presumably this was a deliberate taunt; it's hard to imagine even Gregor would forget raping and murdering the wife of the heir to the throne...

to:

** When Oberyn Martell duels the Mountain, he brings up the [[YouKilledMyFather murder of his sister Elia.]] The Mountain's response is "Who?" Presumably [[spoiler: Considering he then proceeds to recall and repeat the exact circumstances of her murder, it can be assumed this was is a deliberate taunt; it's hard to imagine even Gregor would forget raping and murdering the wife of the heir to the throne...]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
That was in the 5th book


* DisproportionateRetribution: The Red Wedding is the result of a hodgepodge of various old grudges, resentments and jealousies: [[spoiler:Walder Frey has Robb Stark, his mother Catelyn and half his bannermen murdered because Robb broke a promise to marry one of Frey's daughters.]] Lady Barbrey Dustin backs the Boltons' involvement because she resents the fact that she doesn't get to marry any of [[spoiler:the Starks.]] She expresses a desire to feed [[spoiler:Ned Stark's]] bones to her dogs.

to:

* DisproportionateRetribution: The Red Wedding is the result of a hodgepodge of various old grudges, resentments and jealousies: [[spoiler:Walder Frey has Robb Stark, his mother Catelyn and half his bannermen murdered because Robb broke a promise to marry one of Frey's daughters.]] Lady Barbrey Dustin backs the Boltons' involvement because she resents the fact that she doesn't get to marry any of [[spoiler:the Starks.]] She expresses a desire to feed [[spoiler:Ned Stark's]] bones to her dogs.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Roose Bolten actually chuckles in response to one of Jaime's witticisms at dinner.

to:

** Roose Bolten Bolton actually chuckles in response to one of Jaime's witticisms at dinner.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FailedState: Daenerys overthrows the slaver aristocracy of the city-state of Astapor, installs a government of freedmen, and moves on to conquer the other cities of Slaver's Bay. Not long afterwards, a man named Cleon claims the new government to be plotting to return power to the slavers, has them excluded, and names himself king. Cleon proves to be an inept ruler and, under his attempted oversight, Astapor rapidly degenerates into an anarchic state, where each ziggurat palace becomes an independent armed camp and the markets grow empty of food and necessities.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TroubledToybreaker: After Arya [[spoiler:witnesses the betrayal and murder of her mother, older brother, and their House's soldiers at the Red Wedding]], she comes very close to falling into the DespairEventHorizon. While she and Sandor are staying at a nameless Riverlands village, the village elder's daughter takes to following her around, no matter how many times Arya tells her to go away. When the girl shows Arya her soldier doll and boasts that it will protect her, she tears out its stuffing, throws it in the river, and snaps, "Now he looks like a real soldier!"

Added: 514

Changed: 783

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ExactWords: Used for a darkly humorous moment in the epilogue, when the Brotherhood Without Banners captures Merrett Frey. Lem Lemoncloak is preparing to hang him, but Tom Sevenstrings presses him for information about the war, promising to tell Lem to let him go if he tells them anything useful. Merrett cooperates, so Tom honors his promise. He tells Lem to let him go, and Lem [[NoSell tells him to go bugger himself]].

to:

* ExactWords: Used for a darkly humorous moment in the epilogue, when the Brotherhood Without Banners captures Merrett Frey. Lem Lemoncloak is preparing to hang him, but Tom Sevenstrings presses him for information about the war, promising to tell Lem to let him go if he tells them anything useful. Merrett cooperates, so Tom honors his promise. He tells Lem to let him go, and Lem [[NoSell tells him to go bugger himself]]. [[BlackComedy Tom shrugs and starts to play "The Day They Hanged Black Robin".]]



* HopeSpot: The fight between Oberyn Martell, the Red Viper and the ''evil, evil'' Gregor Clegane, the Mountain that Rides, includes not merely a hope spot but a giant hope searchlight. At first the Viper looks rather outclassed by the Mountain. Then the Viper turns it around and puts the Mountain on his back, badly wounded by a poisoned spear. He steps on the Mountain's chest to finish him off -- and the Mountain grabs his foot, yanks him down, and taunts him horribly before smashing his skull with one enormous fist.

to:

* HopeSpot: HopeSpot:
**
The fight between Oberyn Martell, the Red Viper and the ''evil, evil'' Gregor Clegane, the Mountain that Rides, includes not merely a hope spot but a giant hope searchlight. At first the Viper looks rather outclassed by the Mountain. Then the Viper turns it around and puts the Mountain on his back, badly wounded by a poisoned spear. He steps on the Mountain's chest to finish him off -- and the Mountain grabs his foot, yanks him down, and taunts him horribly before smashing his skull with one enormous fist.



** [[BreakTheCutie Sansa]] looks like she's about to escape [[DecadentCourt King's Landing]] and [[GodSaveUsFromTheQueen Cersei]] with Ser Dontos, who gets her off the grounds, through a forest, and to a ship, where she finds out the one behind her rescue was none other than [[spoiler:[[MagnificentBastard Littlefinger]], the closest thing the series has to a BigBad who's already given off some creepy vibes for her.]]

to:

** [[BreakTheCutie Sansa]] looks like she's about to escape [[DecadentCourt King's Landing]] and [[GodSaveUsFromTheQueen Cersei]] with Ser Dontos, who gets her off the grounds, through a forest, and to a ship, where she finds out the one behind her rescue was none other than [[spoiler:[[MagnificentBastard Littlefinger]], the closest thing the series has to a BigBad who's already given off some creepy vibes for her.]]]] A {{Downplayed|Trope}} example, though, as she ''does'' still get out of King's Landing, and she's still arguably better off with [[spoiler:Littlefinger]] than she was under the Lannisters.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HuntingTheRogue: A number of Night's Watch brothers commit mutiny at Craster's Keep, murdering Lord Commander Jeor Mormont and Craster, chasing out any loyalists, and setting up the place as their base in the Lands Beyond The Wall, where they can eat, drink, and fuck to their hearts' content. They are all exterminated by Coldhands.

Added: 256

Changed: 93

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EverythingsWorseWithBears: One of the wights that attacks the Night's Watch at the Fist of the First Men is a ''bear.''

to:

* EverythingsWorseWithBears: EverythingsWorseWithBears:
**
One of the wights that attacks the Night's Watch at the Fist of the First Men is a ''bear.''''
** At Harrenhal, Vargo Hoat throws Brienne in the bear pit with the bear that previously tore apart Amory Lorch. [[spoiler:This time Jaime manages to save her.]]

Added: 608

Changed: 334

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** When The Hound tells Arya that he's taking her to The Twins to ransom her to Robb rather than back to King's Landing like she feared, he finishes by telling her to stop making trouble "and maybe we'll even be in time for your uncle's bloody wedding." [[spoiler:As it turns out, they do arrive literally just in time to catch what turns out to be a ''very'' bloody wedding indeed.]]



* KickTheDog: Invoked metaphorically by Varys after Tyrion says he should kill him even though he's come to break Tyrion out of jail the night before his execution:
-->The faithful dog is kicked, and no matter how the spider weaves, he is never loved.

to:

* KickTheDog: KickTheDog:
**
Invoked metaphorically by Varys after Tyrion says he should kill him even though he's come to break Tyrion out of jail the night before his execution:
-->The --->The faithful dog is kicked, and no matter how the spider weaves, he is never loved.loved.
** Also invoked by Sandor Clegane when he tells Arya why he's done with serving the Lannisters.
--->Even a dog gets tired of being kicked.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** When Jaime hears from Roose Bolton that Tyrion has been married to [[spoiler:Sansa]] he remembers how happy Tyrion had briefly been with his first wife Tysha, who Jaime remembers as [[spoiler:"his little crofter's daughter". At the end of the book he admits to Tyrion that Tywin had forced him to lie to him about Tysha really being a whore he'd hired to pretend to love Tyrion, with devastating effects on [[DespairEventHorizon Tyrion's psyche]], [[WeUsedToBeFriends their relationship]], and [[{{Patricide}} Twyin's bowels]].]]

to:

** When Jaime is thinking about his family while the Bloody Mummers are taking him and Brienne to Harrenhal he thinks of Tyrion as "his little brother, who loved him [[spoiler:for a lie]]". Later, when he hears from Roose Bolton that Tyrion has been married to [[spoiler:Sansa]] he remembers how happy Tyrion had briefly been with his first wife Tysha, who Jaime remembers as [[spoiler:"his little crofter's daughter". At the end of the book he admits to Tyrion that Tywin had forced him to lie to him about Tysha really being a whore he'd hired to pretend to love Tyrion, with devastating effects on [[DespairEventHorizon Tyrion's psyche]], [[WeUsedToBeFriends their relationship]], and [[{{Patricide}} Twyin's bowels]].]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FalseReassurance: Whitebeard tells Daenerys that Westeros still remembers her brother Rheagar as being wise, and noble and brave. When Daenerys asks about [[TheCaligula her father]], he hesitates and replies that [[ExactWords they remember him too]].

to:

* FalseReassurance: Whitebeard tells Daenerys that Westeros still remembers her brother Rheagar Rhaegar as being wise, and noble and brave. When Daenerys asks about [[TheCaligula her father]], he hesitates and replies that [[ExactWords they remember him too]].



* HeirInLaw: Lord Tywin's desire for Tyrion to go through with a marriage to another member of the [[spoiler:Stark family, Sansa]], since she's supposed to be the last heir of the family and also Tywin has no wish of ever letting Tyrion inherit Casterly Rock. [[spoiler:Robb Stark goes so far as to name Jon Snow his heir in the event of him dying childless]].]]

to:

* HeirInLaw: Lord Tywin's desire for Tyrion to go through with a marriage to another member of the [[spoiler:Stark family, Sansa]], since she's supposed to be the last heir of the family and also Tywin has no wish of ever letting Tyrion inherit Casterly Rock. [[spoiler:Robb Stark goes so far as to name Jon Snow his heir in the event of him dying childless]].]]

Added: 355

Changed: 682

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DramaticIrony: While staying at an inn/brothel called the Peach, one of the "serving girls" jokingly tells Arya and Gendry that she might be King Robert's bastard. Arya does note her Baratheon-esque black hair, but internally dismisses the notion--"That didn't mean anything though. Gendry has the same kind of hair too. Lots of people have black hair."

to:

* DramaticallyMissingThePoint: After Meera finishes telling Bran the story of the Knight of the Laughing Tree (while repeatedly questioning whether Ned had ever told it to him before), Bran criticises parts of it, making suggestions about how he thinks it should have gone. He failed to realise that it wasn't a fable, but a true recounting of the events of Lord Whent's great tourney at Harrenhal involving his own family, and all the characters she mentioned (the little crannogman, the she-wolf, the quiet wolf and so on) were real people (her father Howland Reed, his aunt Lyanna Stark, and his father Ned).
* DramaticIrony: While staying at an inn/brothel called the Peach, one of the "serving girls" jokingly tells Arya and Gendry that she might be King Robert's bastard. Arya does note her Baratheon-esque black hair, but internally dismisses the notion--"That notion- "That didn't mean anything though. Gendry has the same kind of hair too. Lots of people have black hair."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* NextThingTheyKnew: Robb, injured after a difficult battle and grieving after hearing of Bran and Rickon's supposed deaths, is "[[IsThatWhatTheyreCallingItNow comforted]]" by Jeyne Westerling.

to:

* NextThingTheyKnew: Robb, injured after a difficult battle and grieving after hearing of Bran and Rickon's supposed deaths, is "[[IsThatWhatTheyreCallingItNow comforted]]" "comforted" by Jeyne Westerling.

Added: 1522

Changed: 267

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ActuallyPrettyFunny: Tyrion Lannister's response to seeing his brother's severed right hand for the first time is to crack up laughing at the apparent conspiracy to chop chunks off of Lannisters. It's at least partly hysterical, given that Jaime is probably his favourite family member.

to:

* ActuallyPrettyFunny: ActuallyPrettyFunny:
**
Tyrion Lannister's response to seeing his brother's severed right hand for the first time is to crack up laughing at the apparent conspiracy to chop chunks off of Lannisters. It's at least partly hysterical, given that Jaime is probably his favourite family member.
** Roose Bolten actually chuckles in response to one of Jaime's witticisms at dinner.
** Jaime laughs when Ser Balon Swann answers his question about what he'd do if he found himself having to choose between his kin and his king, as Jaime once did, by saying he would ''not'' do what Jaime did. Although Balon was certainly not trying to be humorous.


Added DiffLines:

* AppealToObscurity: Use by Roose Bolton when explaining why Vargo Hoat erred in accepting lordship of Harrenhal as a bribe to betray the Lannisters.
-->'''Roose:''' Our goat should have consulted the Tarbecks or the Reynes. They might have warned him how your lord father deals with betrayal.\\
'''Jaime:''' There are no Tarbecks or Reynes.\\
'''Roose:''' My point precisely.


Added DiffLines:

** When Jaime hears from Roose Bolton that Tyrion has been married to [[spoiler:Sansa]] he remembers how happy Tyrion had briefly been with his first wife Tysha, who Jaime remembers as [[spoiler:"his little crofter's daughter". At the end of the book he admits to Tyrion that Tywin had forced him to lie to him about Tysha really being a whore he'd hired to pretend to love Tyrion, with devastating effects on [[DespairEventHorizon Tyrion's psyche]], [[WeUsedToBeFriends their relationship]], and [[{{Patricide}} Twyin's bowels]].]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DrunkenSong: At the Red Wedding, the Greatjon gets drunk and sings "The Bear and the Maiden Fair"... while the musicians are playing a different song.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Baleful Polymorph was renamed per TRS


** A [[RuleOfThree third example]] comes when Bran remembers the legend of The Rat Cook who was [[BalefulPolymorph transformed into a rat and cursed to eat his own young]], the gods cursed him not for committing murder, or for serving his victim in a pie to his father, but because the prince was his guest.

to:

** A [[RuleOfThree third example]] comes when Bran remembers the legend of The Rat Cook who was [[BalefulPolymorph [[ForcedTransformation transformed into a rat and cursed to eat his own young]], the gods cursed him not for committing murder, or for serving his victim in a pie to his father, but because the prince was his guest.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ChekhovsGunman: Mormont's raven, who disappears shortly after the mutiny at Craster's Kpee, and reappears during [[spoiler:the election of the next Lord Commander to turn the tides in favor of Jon.]]

to:

* ChekhovsGunman: Mormont's raven, who disappears shortly after the mutiny at Craster's Kpee, Keep, and reappears during [[spoiler:the election of the next Lord Commander to turn the tides in favor of Jon.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* MrsHypothetical: Lame Lothar Frey mentions that his sister has been taking part in this after hearing of her engagement to Edmure Tully.
-->"Queen Jeyne has a loving heart, I see," said Lame Lothar Frey to Catelyn. "Not unlike my own sisters. Why, I would wager a guess that even now Roslin is dancing around the Twins chanting, 'Lady ''Tully'', Lady ''Tully'', Lady ''Roslin'' Tully."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* RedHerring: Although Robb agonizes over the decision about whether or not to execute Rickard Karstark for his treason and what that will mean to his campaign, the decision ultimately has no impact because most of Karstark's soldiers had already secretly left by that point and it's some of Robb's ''other'' allies that prove his doom. Even two books later, the only reference to the decision is a bare nod to it by Karstark's daughter who ends up asking Robb's brother Jon for help anyway and doesn't seem to show much concern about it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DidntThinkThisThrough: Tyrion laments to himself that he let Joffrey [[CatapultToGlory execute]] the Antler Men [[note]]A group of rich merchants planning to open King's Landing's gates to Stannis[[/note]] after discovering as Master of Coin how much money they owed the crown, particularly since trying to get the money from their heirs will be an exercise in futility.
** Tyrion regrets having baited Joffrey [[spoiler: by hinting that he knows Joffrey was behind the attempt on Bran Stark's life]], since Joffrey will [[HeKnowsTooMuch likely try to kill him now for it]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


->''Soon comes the cold, and the night that never ends.''

to:

->''Soon ->''"Soon comes the cold, and the night that never ends.''"''



---> [[spoiler:She was no whore. I never bought her for you. That was a lie that Father commanded me to tell. Tysha was... she was what she seemed to be. A crofter’s daughter, chance met on the road.]]

to:

---> [[spoiler:She was no whore. I never bought her for you. That was a lie that Father commanded me to tell. Tysha was... she was what she seemed to be. A crofter’s crofter's daughter, chance met on the road.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SpottingTheThread: An innocuous comment made by or about Joffrey in their presence clue Tyrion and Jaime into the fact that [[spoiler: Joffrey was behind the attempt on Bran Stark's life in the first book. Tyrion figures out the how (after Joffrey brags about knowing his way around Valyrian steel, Tyrion works out Joffrey stole the Valyrian steel dagger used in the assassination attempt from among King Robert's weapons and paid a random cutthroat to do the deed) while Jaime works out the why (when Cersei mentions that Robert [[InVinoVeritas drunkenly said]] [[MercyKill it would be kinder to put the crippled Bran out of his misery]] in Joffrey's presence, Jaime realises Joffrey arranged the killing [[WellDoneSonGuy in a bid to gain Robert's approval]].]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SomberBackstoryRevelation: Everyone already knows that Jaime betrayed and murdered the previous king, with him being known as the Kingslayer. He's frequently mocked or derided for it. However, while he's badly wounded and feverish at Harrenhal, he ends up talking about it in-depth to Brienne, explaining why he did it. It turns out that Mad King Aerys had refused to surrender to Tywin despite Jaime's pleas, resulting in the city being sacked, at which point the king ordered Jaime to kill his father and gave orders to blow up the city with wildfire. Jaime was unable to kill his own father and watch thousands of innocent people be burned alive, so he killed Aerys to protect them. When Brienne asks why he never told anyone this, Jaime says he doubts he would be believed and that everyone already assumed the worst of him, given kingslaying and treachery are considered heinous actions in his culture (even against a king like Aerys). Brienne views Jaime more sympathetically after this and Jaime starts becoming kinder.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** When Brienne asks Jaime [[spoiler: why she's ordering her to find and protect Sansa if Jaime believes she killed Joffrey]], Jaime's thoughts on his late son are clear.

to:

** When Brienne asks Jaime [[spoiler: why she's he's ordering her to find and protect Sansa if Jaime believes she killed Joffrey]], Joffrey, Jaime's thoughts on his late son are clear.clear]].



* SympathyForTheDevil: While Tyrion and Sansa suffer more horrific and relentless abuse under Joffrey than anyone else in King's Landing, they feel perhaps more genuine pity for [[spoiler:his death]] that anyone else (except his mother), as they realize during [[spoiler:his dying moments, as he's choking to death]] that in the end he's just a spoiled, helpless 13-year-old boy.

to:

* SympathyForTheDevil: While Tyrion and Sansa suffer more horrific and relentless abuse under Joffrey than anyone else in King's Landing, they feel perhaps more genuine pity for [[spoiler:his death]] that than anyone else (except his mother), as they realize during [[spoiler:his dying moments, as he's choking to death]] that in the end he's just a spoiled, helpless 13-year-old boy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* ObligatoryWarCrimeScene: The murder of prisoners Willem Lannister and Tion Frey by Rickard Karstark. The dead bodies of the young boys who died unarmed are described in detail to drive the point home.

Added: 761

Changed: 3

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TakingYouWithMe: Jaime reveals to Brienne [[spoiler: why he killed the Mad King. After a succession of military defeats, Aerys started to fear Robert's rebellion could actually defeat him, so he had caches of [[GreekFire wildfire]] buried beneath King's Landing, intending to detonate them if the rebels laid siege to the capital and take the entire city with him, [[EvilIsPetty rather than suffer defeat on his enemies' terms]] (Jaime also speculates Aerys was so deranged by that point, he believed he wouldn't die in the blaze, but would be [[OneWingedAngel transformed into a dragon]].]]



* TournamentArc: The [[LetMeTellYouAStory story told by Meera to Bran]] involves a [[TheTourney tourney]] with a [[BlackKnight mysterious knight]], [[spoiler: which is heavily implied to be the Tourney of Harrenhal, where all the major players of Robert's Rebellion met, and most of all where Prince Rhaegar and Lyanna Stark met, while the mysterious knight is speculated to be Lyanna Stark herself. All this things are probably the reason why Bran has never heard such story.]]

to:

* TournamentArc: The [[LetMeTellYouAStory story told by Meera to Bran]] involves a [[TheTourney tourney]] with a [[BlackKnight mysterious knight]], [[spoiler: which is heavily implied to be the Tourney of Harrenhal, where all the major players of Robert's Rebellion met, and most of all where Prince Rhaegar and Lyanna Stark met, while the mysterious knight is speculated to be Lyanna Stark herself. All this these things are probably the reason why Bran has never heard such story.]]


Added DiffLines:

** [[spoiler: Jaime's motive for killing the Mad King are revealed as stopping Aerys from razing King's Landing to the ground as a spiteful last gesture of defiance]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Stannis also recalls his father taking him and Robert to court and both boys being awed by the man they saw sitting on the Iron Throne. Stannis then relates that years later, King Aerys had injured himself on the throne earlier that day, so the man they saw was Tywin Lannister (Aerys' Hand of the King) sitting in his place.

to:

** Stannis also recalls his father taking him and Robert to court and as boys, where both boys being of them were awed by the regal and imposing man they saw sitting on the Iron Throne. Stannis then relates that years later, their father told them King Aerys had injured himself on the throne earlier that day, so the man they saw was Tywin Lannister (Aerys' Hand of the King) sitting in his place.

Top