Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / Rapunzel

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


##If she did leave and come back, Gothel would have noticed that she left (i.e ''Barbie As Repunzel'')
##She wouldn't have gotten real far nor would she really be able to fend for herself outside of the tower.

to:

##If she did leave and come back, Gothel would have noticed that she left (i.e ''Barbie As Repunzel'')
Rapunzel'')
##She wouldn't have gotten real far nor would she really be able to fend for herself outside of the tower. On top of that, where would she have gone?

Added: 435

Changed: 29

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


----

to:

----**A few possible reasons:
##If she did leave and come back, Gothel would have noticed that she left (i.e ''Barbie As Repunzel'')
##She wouldn't have gotten real far nor would she really be able to fend for herself outside of the tower.
##Using her hair would be too obvious and, in the variants where she's pregnant, it'd be harder to climb down safely with only her hair (depending how far along she is by that point).
##Or she just never really thought about it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


[[WMG: Here's an obvious question I never see anyone ask... if Rapunzel's hair can be used to let ''other people'' in and out of the tower... how come she never used it to get ''herself'' out of the tower and instead always asks for rope or ladder? She wouldn't even need to cut her hair or anything.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

***He could have traded something for the vegetables, as bartering was a thing in that time period, then again, he did when the Witch caught him stealing, so I guess it's even.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Medieval superstition said it was terrible luck to deny a pregnant woman something she was craving. So maybe his wife was craving the vegetables at night, and he just didn't want to piss the witch off by waking her up. She's a witch so he has no idea what she'll do if he knocks on her door at night, demanding vegetables from her garden instantly.

to:

* Medieval superstition said Preindustrial society thought it was terrible luck to deny a pregnant woman something she was craving. So maybe his wife was craving the vegetables at night, and he just didn't want to piss the witch off by waking her up. She's a witch so he has no idea what she'll do if he knocks on her door at night, demanding vegetables from her garden instantly.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Medieval superstition said it was terrible luck to deny a pregnant woman any kind of food she was craving. So maybe his wife was craving the vegetables at night, and he just didn't want to piss the witch off by waking her up. She's a witch so he has no idea what she'll do if he knocks on her door at night, demanding vegetables from her garden instantly.

to:

* Medieval superstition said it was terrible luck to deny a pregnant woman any kind of food something she was craving. So maybe his wife was craving the vegetables at night, and he just didn't want to piss the witch off by waking her up. She's a witch so he has no idea what she'll do if he knocks on her door at night, demanding vegetables from her garden instantly.



** Plus if they were living next-door to a witch and DIDN'T think of buying rampion from literally any other gardener, [[SympatheticCriminal they probably couldn't AFFORD to buy it.]]

to:

** Plus In addition to the time-crunch issues, if they were living next-door to a witch and DIDN'T think of buying rampion from literally any other gardener, anyone else, [[SympatheticCriminal they probably couldn't AFFORD to buy it.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** In many versions of the tale, Rapunzel hooks her hair to a metal loop or a hook. This would distribute the weight away from her scalp and allow others to climb it without scalping her or breaking her neck. ''WesternAnimation/{{Tangled}}'' actually demonstrates this perfectly in action by having Rapunzel use her hair as a pulley.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In the Disney version, Disney/{{Tangled}}, they show that there is indeed a door at the base of the tower. It has since been covered by bricks and hedges, and leads to a trapdoor on the tower's ground floor, which Rapunzel may or may not know about. Not that she needs the door, as her hair is long enough for her to rappel herself down from the top floor window. Her imprisonment in this version is mostly psychological. The tower was there mainly to keep other people out... though the "prince" manages to scale it without Rapunzel's help.

to:

** In the Disney version, Disney/{{Tangled}}, WesternAnimation/{{Tangled}}, they show that there is indeed a door at the base of the tower. It has since been covered by bricks and hedges, and leads to a trapdoor on the tower's ground floor, which Rapunzel may or may not know about. Not that she needs the door, as her hair is long enough for her to rappel herself down from the top floor window. Her imprisonment in this version is mostly psychological. The tower was there mainly to keep other people out... though the "prince" manages to scale it without Rapunzel's help.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In some versions, Rapunzel asks for some thread/rope so she can make a ladder. Cutting her hair and going down from it could have helped too... only the witch was smart enought to think of that...

to:

* In some versions, Rapunzel asks for some thread/rope so she can make a ladder. Cutting her hair and going down from it could have helped too... only the witch was smart enought enough to think of that...

Added: 328

Changed: 490

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Spelling/grammar, indentation, This Troper language


* In some versions, Rapunzel asks for some thread/rope so she can make ladder. Cutting her hair and going down from it could have helped too... only the witch was smart enought to think of that...

to:

* In some versions, Rapunzel asks for some thread/rope so she can make a ladder. Cutting her hair and going down from it could have helped too... only the witch was smart enought to think of that...



* Seeing as the original version had Rapunzel getting knocked up halfway through, it's possible that the prince was having a bit too much... fun during the visits to want to hurry the rescue along.
* This troper read one version where the prince does promise Rapunzel on their first meeting that he'll come back the next day with a ladder. Unfortunately, Rapunzel [[IdiotBall spills the beans to the witch]] before then.
[[WMG:How did the Witch climbed to the tower before Rapunzel hair was long enough?]]
Or did she just make her to grow her hair to save herself the bother of carrying each time a huge ladder? Another thing: If the witch needed Rapunzel to get into the tower, how did she get Rapunzel up there in the first place? Throw her?

to:

* ** Seeing as the original version had Rapunzel getting knocked up halfway through, it's possible that the prince was having a bit too much... fun during the visits to want to hurry the rescue along.
* This troper read ** There's one version where the prince does promise Rapunzel on their first meeting that he'll come back the next day with a ladder. Unfortunately, Rapunzel [[IdiotBall spills the beans to the witch]] before then.
then.

[[WMG:How did the Witch climbed to climb up the tower before Rapunzel Rapunzel's hair was long enough?]]
Or did she just make her to grow her hair to save herself the bother of carrying each time a huge ladder? ladder each time? Another thing: If the witch needed Rapunzel to get into the tower, how did she get Rapunzel up there in the first place? Throw her?



* The building could originally had a door and stairs, which were destroyed after they took everything they needed inside and covered with more bricks, or maybe they just used a ladder.

to:

* The building could originally have had a door and stairs, which were destroyed and covered with more bricks after they took everything they needed inside and covered with more bricks, inside; or maybe they just used a ladder.






** Most versions have her wrapping her hair around a post before the witch or prince climb her hair, which, by the way, would be totally possible. Healthy hair is strong enough to hold up a car.
*** ... How did they find that out?

to:

** * Most versions have her wrapping her hair around a post before the witch or prince climb her hair, which, by the way, would be totally possible. Healthy hair is strong enough to hold up a car.
*** ... ** ...How did they find that out?



*** I don't know about cars, but Kari climbed down a several-story building with a "rope" made of braided-together ponytails.
[[WMG: Why didn't the husband offer to ''buy'' some of the Witch's plants vs stealing them?]]

to:

*** ** I don't know about cars, but Kari climbed down a several-story building with a "rope" made of braided-together ponytails.
ponytails.

[[WMG: Why didn't the husband offer to ''buy'' some of the Witch's plants vs vs. stealing them?]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[WMG: Why didn't the husband offer to ''buy'' some of the Witch's plants vs stealing them.]]

to:

[[WMG: Why didn't the husband offer to ''buy'' some of the Witch's plants vs stealing them.]]them?]]

Added: 183

Changed: 21

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[WMG: Another one is why didn't the husband offer to ''buy'' some of the Witch's plants vs stealing them.]]

to:

[[WMG: Another one is why Why didn't the husband offer to ''buy'' some of the Witch's plants vs stealing them.]]



** And in some versions the witch hypnotises the wife into wanting the vegetables in the first place, so it's possible she hypnotised the husband into stealing them.

to:

** And in some versions the witch hypnotises hypnotizes the wife into wanting the vegetables in the first place, so it's possible she hypnotised hypnotized the husband into stealing them. them.
** Plus if they were living next-door to a witch and DIDN'T think of buying rampion from literally any other gardener, [[SympatheticCriminal they probably couldn't AFFORD to buy it.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In the Disney version, Disney/{{Tangled}}, they show that there is indeed a door at the base of the tower. It has since been covered by bricks and hedges, and leads to a trapdoor on the tower's ground floor, which Rapunzel may or may not know about. Not that she needs the door, as her hair is long enough for her to repel herself down from the top floor window. Her imprisonment in this version is mostly psychological. The tower was there mainly to keep other people out... though the "prince" manages to scale it without Rapunzel's help.

to:

** In the Disney version, Disney/{{Tangled}}, they show that there is indeed a door at the base of the tower. It has since been covered by bricks and hedges, and leads to a trapdoor on the tower's ground floor, which Rapunzel may or may not know about. Not that she needs the door, as her hair is long enough for her to repel rappel herself down from the top floor window. Her imprisonment in this version is mostly psychological. The tower was there mainly to keep other people out... though the "prince" manages to scale it without Rapunzel's help.

Added: 631

Changed: 9

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* How didn't her neck break from the prince's weight?

to:

* [[WMG: How didn't her neck break from the prince's weight?weight?]]


Added DiffLines:

[[WMG: Another one is why didn't the husband offer to ''buy'' some of the Witch's plants vs stealing them.]]
* Medieval superstition said it was terrible luck to deny a pregnant woman any kind of food she was craving. So maybe his wife was craving the vegetables at night, and he just didn't want to piss the witch off by waking her up. She's a witch so he has no idea what she'll do if he knocks on her door at night, demanding vegetables from her garden instantly.
** And in some versions the witch hypnotises the wife into wanting the vegetables in the first place, so it's possible she hypnotised the husband into stealing them.

Added: 126

Changed: 7

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** ''{{Mythbusters}}'', I think.

to:

*** ''{{Mythbusters}}'', ''Series/{{Mythbusters}}'', I think.think.
**** I don't know about cars, but Kari climbed down a several-story building with a "rope" made of braided-together ponytails.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In the Disney version, {{Tangled}}, they show that there is indeed a door at the base of the tower. It has since been covered by bricks and hedges, and leads to a trapdoor on the tower's ground floor, which Rapunzel may or may not know about. Not that she needs the door, as her hair is long enough for her to repel herself down from the top floor window. Her imprisonment in this version is mostly psychological. The tower was there mainly to keep other people out... though the "prince" manages to scale it without Rapunzel's help.

to:

** In the Disney version, {{Tangled}}, Disney/{{Tangled}}, they show that there is indeed a door at the base of the tower. It has since been covered by bricks and hedges, and leads to a trapdoor on the tower's ground floor, which Rapunzel may or may not know about. Not that she needs the door, as her hair is long enough for her to repel herself down from the top floor window. Her imprisonment in this version is mostly psychological. The tower was there mainly to keep other people out... though the "prince" manages to scale it without Rapunzel's help.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** ''{{Mythbusters}}'', I think.

Changed: 19

Removed: 16

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[RuleOfFunny Yes.]]

to:

* [[RuleOfFunny Yes.]]Yes]].



** In the Disney version, [[Tangled]], they show that there is indeed a door at the base of the tower. It has since been covered by bricks and ivy, and leads to a trapdoor on the tower's ground floor, which Rapunzel may or may not know about. Not that she needs the door, as her hair is long enough for her to repel herself down from the top floor window. Her imprisonment in this version is mostly psychological. The tower was there mainly to keep other people out... though the "prince" manages to scale it without Rapunzel's help.

to:

** In the Disney version, [[Tangled]], {{Tangled}}, they show that there is indeed a door at the base of the tower. It has since been covered by bricks and ivy, hedges, and leads to a trapdoor on the tower's ground floor, which Rapunzel may or may not know about. Not that she needs the door, as her hair is long enough for her to repel herself down from the top floor window. Her imprisonment in this version is mostly psychological. The tower was there mainly to keep other people out... though the "prince" manages to scale it without Rapunzel's help.



----
<<|JustBugsMe|>>

to:

----
<<|JustBugsMe|>>
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** In the Disney version, [[Tangled]], they show that there is indeed a door at the base of the tower. It has since been covered by bricks and ivy, and leads to a trapdoor on the tower's ground floor, which Rapunzel may or may not know about. Not that she needs the door, as her hair is long enough for her to repel herself down from the top floor window. Her imprisonment in this version is mostly psychological. The tower was there mainly to keep other people out... though the "prince" manages to scale it without Rapunzel's help.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** ... How did they find that out?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* This troper read one version where the prince does promise Rapunzel on their first meeting that he'll come back the next day with a ladder. Unfortunately, Rapunzel [[IdiotBall spills the beans to the witch]] before then.

Added: 193

Changed: 9

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[How didn't her neck broke from the prince's weight?]]

to:

[[How *How didn't her neck broke break from the prince's weight?]]weight?
**Most versions have her wrapping her hair around a post before the witch or prince climb her hair, which, by the way, would be totally possible. Healthy hair is strong enough to hold up a car.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

[[How didn't her neck broke from the prince's weight?]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* AWizardDidIt.

Top