Follow TV Tropes

Following

History ComicBook / Maus

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


%%* ArtStyleDissonance: Deliberate.

to:

%%* * ArtStyleDissonance: Deliberate.You wouldn't expect a Holocaust story being told through anthropomorphic animals.



** Early in the story it is mentioned that Vladek wanted to emigrate to the UsefulNotes/UnitedStates and was learning English. His knowledge of the language, which was rare for a Polish Jew in [[TheGreatDepression the 30s]], came in handy at a few points and probably saved his life.

to:

** Early in the story story, it is mentioned that Vladek wanted to emigrate to the UsefulNotes/UnitedStates and was learning English. His knowledge of the language, which was rare for a Polish Jew in [[TheGreatDepression the 30s]], came in handy at a few points and probably saved his life.



* GreedyJew: [[invoked]] Art is [[StopBeingStereotypical constantly frustrated]] by how much Vladek conforms to the GreedyJew stereotype and {{discuss|edTrope}}es it at one point with Mala, explaining that he feels awkward and very uneasy about portraying that part of his father's behavior honestly, as he fears what will happen from perpetuating the stereotype. It's implied that Anja's wealthy background was a big influence on Vladek's decision to court her, and in modern times he's an obnoxious miser who argues with cashiers over pennies.

to:

* GreedyJew: [[invoked]] It's implied that Anja's wealthy background was a big influence on Vladek's decision to court her, and in modern times he's an obnoxious miser who argues with cashiers over pennies. Art is [[StopBeingStereotypical constantly frustrated]] by how much Vladek conforms to the GreedyJew stereotype and {{discuss|edTrope}}es it at one point with Mala, explaining that he feels awkward and very uneasy about portraying that part of his father's behavior honestly, as he fears what will happen from perpetuating the stereotype. It's implied that Anja's wealthy background was a big influence on Vladek's decision to court her, and in modern times he's an obnoxious miser who argues with cashiers over pennies. stereotype.



* InformedAttractiveness: Vladek mentions several times how handsome he was in his youth, noting that he was often compared to a young Rudolph Valentino. A real-life picture late in the second book confirms that he was indeed a good-looking man. Vladek also notes that Lucia was more attractive than his eventual wife Anja, but he preferred her for her personality (and her money also probably helped).

to:

* InformedAttractiveness: Vladek mentions several times how handsome he was in his youth, noting that he was often compared to a young Rudolph Valentino. A real-life picture late in the second book confirms that he was indeed a good-looking man. Vladek also notes that Lucia was more attractive than his eventual wife Anja, but he preferred her Anja for her personality (and her money also probably helped).



** Americans are dogs, who are friendly and helpful and can drive away cats. This of course references the Americans who helped the Jews at the end of the war. Different races of Americans are given different breeds of dogs. There are also ''actual'' dogs seen at several points, such as when Vladek's family is hiding in their coal cabinet bunker.

to:

** Americans are dogs, who are friendly and helpful and can drive away cats. This of course references the Americans who helped the Jews at the end of the war. Different races of Americans are given different breeds of dogs. There are also ''actual'' dogs seen at several points, such as when Vladek's family is hiding in their coal cabinet bunker.points.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* GreedyJew: [[invoked]] Art is [[StopBeingStereotypical constantly frustrated]] by how much Vladek conforms to the GreedyJew stereotype and {{discuss|edTrope}}es it at one point with Mala, explaining that he feels awkward and very uneasy about portraying that part of his father's behavior honestly, as he fears perpetuating the trope and the inevitable UnfortunateImplications attached to it. It's implied that Anja's wealthy background was a big influence on Vladek's decision to court her, and in modern times he's an obnoxious miser who argues with cashiers over pennies.

to:

* GreedyJew: [[invoked]] Art is [[StopBeingStereotypical constantly frustrated]] by how much Vladek conforms to the GreedyJew stereotype and {{discuss|edTrope}}es it at one point with Mala, explaining that he feels awkward and very uneasy about portraying that part of his father's behavior honestly, as he fears what will happen from perpetuating the trope and the inevitable UnfortunateImplications attached to it.stereotype. It's implied that Anja's wealthy background was a big influence on Vladek's decision to court her, and in modern times he's an obnoxious miser who argues with cashiers over pennies.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Also, hyphens used as emdashes get spaces on either side; otherwise, this looks like a single hyphenated word.


** So is it Anja, Anna, or Anya? All three spellings are used at one point or another.
** Richieu's name in Polish was Rysio. Spiegelman says he had never seen the actual spelling until well after beginning work on ''Maus'' and was just guessing.

to:

** So is it Anja, Anna, or Anya? All three spellings are used at one point or another.
another. (It was originally spelled Andzia, but Spiegelman decided a more phonetic spelling would be easier for readers to grasp.)
** Richieu's name in Polish was Rysio.Rysio (a diminutive of Ryszard). Spiegelman says he had never seen the actual spelling until well after beginning work on ''Maus'' and was just guessing.



* TwoLinesNoWaiting: The narratives jumps between three timelines-Vladek's Holocaust survival, Art interviewing his father, and Art creating ''Maus''.

to:

* TwoLinesNoWaiting: The narratives jumps between three timelines-Vladek's timelines - Vladek's Holocaust survival, Art interviewing his father, and Art creating ''Maus''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
#$%&... Sweden isn't "alpine". The Alps spread from eastern France to northern Slovenia.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Lolek's father was Anja's brother; he was therefore a Zylberberg, not a Spiegelman. Also, Sweden isn't


* {{Bookworm}}: Lolek Spiegelman. He is scolded for reading over dinner and when he couldn't search for enough food, he fills his sack with books (much to the displeasure of the starving family).

to:

* {{Bookworm}}: Lolek Spiegelman.Zylberberg, Anja's nephew. He is scolded for reading over dinner and when he couldn't search for enough food, he fills his sack with books (much to the displeasure of the starving family).



* EverybodysDeadDave: Lolek was the only member of the Spiegelman clan besides Anja and Vladek to come out of Auschwitz alive, and he was notably consulted by Art in the making of ''Maus''.

to:

* EverybodysDeadDave: Lolek was the only member of the Spiegelman Spiegelman-Zylberberg clan besides Anja and Vladek to come out of Auschwitz alive, and he was notably consulted by Art in the making of ''Maus''.



** Swedes are reindeer, referencing their alpine nation.

to:

** Swedes are reindeer, referencing their alpine mountainous nation.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DraftDodging: Vladek's father often went through desperate lengths to avoid being drafted into the Tsarist army, [[note]]Since being drafted into the army meant spending up to ''25 years'' and antisemitic abuse if you were a Jewish draftee, it is understandable why he wanted to avoid such a fate[[/note]] including removing over a dozen of his teeth. Vladek's father also put his son through physical and emotional hell so he would be too sickly to be drafted into the Polish army.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* LastDayOfNormalcy: The first few chapters of Maus feature Vladek's life in interwar Poland, his courtship with Anja, and his early family life with Richieu.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheToothHurts: Vladek's father was so desperate not to be drafted into the Russian Army, that he yanked out a lot of his teeth.


Added DiffLines:

* TrainingFromHell: Inverted. Vladek's father would put him through starvation and sleep deprivation to keep his son from being drafted into the Polish army.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* OppressedMinorityVeteran: An AmbiguouslyJewish concentration camp prisoner claims to have fought in World War I and earned "medals from the Kaiser." According to Vladek, the guards beat him to death when they got tired of his complaints.

to:

* OppressedMinorityVeteran: An AmbiguouslyJewish concentration camp prisoner claims to have fought in World War I and earned "medals from the Kaiser." Kaiser", and his own son is a soldier now. According to Vladek, the guards beat him to death when they got tired of his complaints.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** An Israeli Jew is portrayed as a somewhat stuffy and well-fed mouse. His question to Art is how he would have portrayed an Israeli. Art quips, "I have no idea... porcupines?" (likely a reference to the term "sabra" (a Jew born in the Land of Israel, taken from the Hebrew word for a cactus))

to:

*** An Israeli Jew is portrayed as a somewhat stuffy and well-fed mouse. His question to Art is how he would have portrayed an Israeli. Art quips, "I have no idea... porcupines?" (likely a reference to the term "sabra" (a "sabra", a Jew born in the Land of Israel, taken from the Hebrew word for a cactus))cactus).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HadToBeSharp: Thoroughly deconstructed. Vladek's stinginess and ingenuity in squeezing something out of every cent he has is what enabled him to survive many situations during the Holocaust that another person would have died to, but his portrayal in the modern day expressly outlines that ''those traits are not desirable in a normal person in an average situation,'' and that Vladek continuing to be "sharp" regardless of what is going on makes him into an abrasive and unpleasant old man. Also, Art's therapist points out how respecting one's "strength" in a horrifying spits on the memory of those who died.

to:

* HadToBeSharp: Thoroughly deconstructed. Vladek's stinginess and ingenuity in squeezing something out of every cent he has is what enabled him to survive many situations during the Holocaust that another person would have died to, but his portrayal in the modern day expressly outlines that ''those traits are not desirable in a normal person in an average situation,'' and that Vladek continuing to be "sharp" regardless of what is going on makes him into an abrasive and unpleasant old man. Also, Art's therapist points out how respecting one's "strength" in a horrifying situation spits on the memory of those who died.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HadToBeSharp: Thoroughly deconstructed. Vladek's stinginess and ingenuity in squeezing something out of every cent he has is what enabled him to survive many situations during the Holocaust that another person would have died to, but his portrayal in the modern day expressly outlines that ''those traits are not desirable in a normal person in an average situation,'' and that Vladek continuing to be "sharp" regardless of what is going on makes him into an abrasive and unpleasant old man.

to:

* HadToBeSharp: Thoroughly deconstructed. Vladek's stinginess and ingenuity in squeezing something out of every cent he has is what enabled him to survive many situations during the Holocaust that another person would have died to, but his portrayal in the modern day expressly outlines that ''those traits are not desirable in a normal person in an average situation,'' and that Vladek continuing to be "sharp" regardless of what is going on makes him into an abrasive and unpleasant old man. Also, Art's therapist points out how respecting one's "strength" in a horrifying spits on the memory of those who died.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArmorPiercingQuestion: When Art is in therapy, he mentions that after hearing all of his father's stories, he gained some respect for him and considered him a "winner" for surviving the Holocaust. This leads the shrink to ask him if the therefore thought everyone who didn't make it was a ''loser'', which catches him offguard. In the end, he adjusts his stance to say that there weren't any "winners" or "losers" in that era, just people whose lives were left to pure luck.

to:

* ArmorPiercingQuestion: When Art is in therapy, he mentions that after hearing all of his father's stories, he gained some respect for him and considered him a "winner" for surviving the Holocaust. This leads the shrink to ask him if the he therefore thought thinks everyone who didn't make it was a ''loser'', which catches him offguard.off guard. In the end, he adjusts his stance to say that there weren't any "winners" or "losers" in that era, just people whose lives were left to pure luck.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArmorPiercingQuestion: When Art is giving an interview, he mentions that after hearing all of his father's stories, he gained some respect for him and considered him a "winner" for surviving the Holocaust. This leads the interviewer to ask him if the therefore thought everyone who didn't make it was a ''loser'', which catches him offguard. In the end, he adjusts his stance to say that there weren't any "winners" or "losers" in that era, just people whose lives were left to pure luck.

to:

* ArmorPiercingQuestion: When Art is giving an interview, in therapy, he mentions that after hearing all of his father's stories, he gained some respect for him and considered him a "winner" for surviving the Holocaust. This leads the interviewer shrink to ask him if the therefore thought everyone who didn't make it was a ''loser'', which catches him offguard. In the end, he adjusts his stance to say that there weren't any "winners" or "losers" in that era, just people whose lives were left to pure luck.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HadToBeSharp: Thoroughly deconstructed. Vladek's stinginess and ingenuity in squeezing something out of every cent he has is what enabled him to survive many situations during the Holocaust that another person would have died to, but his portrayal in the modern day expressly outlines that ''those traits are not desirable in a normal person in an average situation,'' and that Vladek continuing to be "sharp" regardless of what is going on makes him into an abrasive and unpleasant old man.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ArmorPiercingQuestion: When Art is giving an interview, he mentions that after hearing all of his father's stories, he gained some respect for him and considered him a "winner" for surviving the Holocaust. This leads the interviewer to ask him if the therefore thought everyone who didn't make it was a ''loser'', which catches him offguard. In the end, he adjusts his stance to say that there weren't any "winners" or "losers" in that era, just people whose lives were left to pure luck.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Hid zce example


* ReleasedToElsewhere

to:

* %%* ReleasedToElsewhere
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AbuseOfReturnPolicy: During the present, Vladek attempts to return a half-eaten, nearly empty, box of cereal to the grocery store. He succeeds after using his backstory as a Holocaust survivor to elicit pity from the store manager (and actually manages to get ''more'' than the value of the cereal back), but his son realizes they can never return to that store ever again in shame.

to:

* AbuseOfReturnPolicy: During the present, Vladek attempts to return a half-eaten, nearly empty, box of cereal to the grocery store. He succeeds after using his backstory as a Holocaust survivor to elicit pity from the store manager (and actually manages to get ''more'' than the value of the cereal back), but his son realizes in shame that they can never return to that store ever again in shame.again.



* EvilOldFolks: Anja was nearly exposed as a Jew by a mean old lady. Thankfully for her, everyone disregarded as a senile old bat.

to:

* EvilOldFolks: Anja was nearly exposed as a Jew by a mean old lady. Thankfully for her, everyone disregarded her as a senile old bat.



*** An Israeli Jew is portrayed as a somewhat stuffy and well-fed mouse. His question to Art is how he would have portrayed an Israeli. Art quips, "I have no idea... porcupines?" (likely a reference to the term "sabra" (a Jew born in Israel resp. Eretz Yisrael, taken from the Hebrew word for a cactus))

to:

*** An Israeli Jew is portrayed as a somewhat stuffy and well-fed mouse. His question to Art is how he would have portrayed an Israeli. Art quips, "I have no idea... porcupines?" (likely a reference to the term "sabra" (a Jew born in Israel resp. Eretz Yisrael, the Land of Israel, taken from the Hebrew word for a cactus))



* TheUnfavourite: It's implied that Vladek's first family, Anja and Richieu, will always be closer to his heart than his later son and second wife. Art says that he had a sibling rivalry with his late brother, who died at a young age years ago. He worries that all of his faults are being compared to his parents' idealized memory of Richieu. [[spoiler:The penultimate panel of the book has the tired and sick Vladek call Art "Richieu."]]

to:

* TheUnfavourite: It's implied that Vladek's first family, Anja and Richieu, will always be closer to his heart than his later son and second wife. Art says that he had a sibling rivalry with his late brother, who died at a young age years ago.before Art was even born. He worries that all of his faults are being compared to his parents' idealized memory of Richieu. [[spoiler:The penultimate panel of the book has the tired and sick Vladek call Art "Richieu."]]



* {{Yandere}}: Lucia Greenberg, Vladek's ex from before he met Anja, is a minor example - the worst she does is attempt to sabotage his new relationship with Anja by telling her disgusting rumors, but fails. When Vladek leaves her, she falls to his feet and begs him not to go. This may be a case of AlternativeCharacterInterpretation, and this is how Vladek perceived her many years later. Art himself even lampshades this how his father tries to make himself look better in the stories.

to:

* {{Yandere}}: Lucia Greenberg, Vladek's ex from before he met Anja, is a minor example - the worst she does is attempt to sabotage his new relationship with Anja by telling her disgusting rumors, but fails. When Vladek leaves her, she falls to his feet and begs him not to go. This may be a case of AlternativeCharacterInterpretation, UnreliableNarrator, and this is how Vladek perceived her many years later. Art himself even lampshades this how his father tries to make himself look better in the stories.

Added: 725

Changed: 264

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* PayEvilUntoEvil: Soon after the German surrender, Vladek and Shivek encounter a German family in Würzburg who have lost everything due to American bombing. They come away from the encounter happy that the Germans were getting back a little of what they had inflicted on the Jews.

to:

* PayEvilUntoEvil: PayEvilUntoEvil:
** Vladek and his family create a hidden bunker to escape the liquidation of the Środula ghetto, but another Jew stumbles across it. [[HeKnowsTooMuch They debate killing him to protect themselves]], but ultimately take pity on him and let him go with a little food, [[UngratefulBastard after which he reports them to the Nazis.]] Vladek's cousin Haskel, the chief of the Jewish police, arranges for the SS to kill the informant, and Vladek ends up burying him.
**
Soon after the German surrender, Vladek and Shivek encounter a German family in Würzburg who have lost everything due to American bombing. They come away from the encounter happy that the Germans were getting back a little of what they had inflicted on the Jews.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SurvivorshipBias: Art's therapist, another Holocaust survivor, pushes him to avoid succumbing to this trap while depicting his father's story.
-->'''Pavel''': Then you think it's admirable to survive. Does that mean it's ''not'' admirable to ''not'' survive?
-->'''Art''': Whoosh. I-I think I see what you mean. It's as if life equals winning so death equals losing.
-->'''Pavel''': Yes. Life always takes the side of life, and somehow the victims are blamed. But it wasn't the best people who survived, nor did the best ones die. It was ''random!''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* PayEvilUntoEvil: Soon after the German surrender, Vladek and Shivek encounter a German family in Würzburg who have lost everything due to American bombing. They come away from the encounter happy that the Germans were getting back a little of what they had inflicted on the Jews.

Changed: 213

Removed: 329

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Removing gushing.


''Maus'' is in two parts, both released to heavy critical acclaim: "Part I (My Father Bleeds History)" in 1986 and "Part II (And Here My Troubles Began)" in 1991. It is probably one the best arguments in western discourse that comic books could be [[TrueArtIsAngsty a legitimate art form]], and was treated as such when it was first released. In 1992, it received a special Pulitzer prize as an acknowledgment of all this.

Anyone who thinks comics don't get respect simply must read this. This is the kind of thing you would read for your literature class, if it weren't a comic book -- and, indeed, some literature classes [[SchoolStudyMedia have started using it anyway]]. So has the German government's [=BPB=] or Federal Agency for Civic Education.

to:

''Maus'' is in two parts, both released to heavy critical acclaim: "Part I (My Father Bleeds History)" in 1986 and "Part II (And Here My Troubles Began)" in 1991. It is probably one the best arguments in western discourse that comic books could be [[TrueArtIsAngsty a legitimate art form]], and was treated as such when it was first released. In 1992, it received a special Pulitzer prize as an acknowledgment of all this.

Anyone who thinks comics don't get respect simply must read this. This is the kind of thing you would read for your literature class, if it weren't a comic book -- and, indeed, some literature classes [[SchoolStudyMedia have started using it anyway]]. So has the German government's [=BPB=] or Federal Agency for Civic Education.
prize.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


->''"If you lock them together in a room with no food for a week...''then'' you could see what it is, friends!"

to:

->''"If you lock them together in a room with no food for a week...''then'' you could see what it is, friends!"friends!"''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

->''"If you lock them together in a room with no food for a week...''then'' you could see what it is, friends!"
-->--'''Vladek Spiegelman'''

Added: 151

Changed: 355

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AmbiguousDisorder: Anja suffered a host of psychological issues; postpartum depression and a generally fragile mental state that eventually drove her to suicide.

to:

* AmbiguousDisorder: Anja suffered a host of psychological issues; postpartum depression and a generally fragile mental state that eventually drove her to suicide. Her last moment with Art was her asking him a ''very'' loaded question about love, implying that she may have had an emotional dependency.



** Discussed and zigzagged. Anja is long dead before Art starts trying to tell her and Vladek's story, and he seems to hold her in a good light because she served as a buffer between him and Vladek. The ''Prisoner on Hell Planet'' comic, however, reveals that he resented how Anja killed herself and that they didn't really understand each other while she was alive. When Vladek dies mid-story, Art is left to deal with his grief and suffers serious WritersBlock along with doubt about if he's the best person to tell the story. He admits at the end that Vladek was doing his best as a parent but was very flawed.

to:

** Discussed and zigzagged. Anja is long dead before Art starts trying to tell her and Vladek's story, and he seems to hold her in a good light because she served as a buffer between him and Vladek. The ''Prisoner on Hell Planet'' comic, however, reveals that he resented how Anja killed herself and that they didn't really understand each other while she was alive.alive, and her last moment with Art was her engaging in a bit of emotional manipulation. When Vladek dies mid-story, Art is left to deal with his grief and suffers serious WritersBlock along with doubt about if he's the best person to tell the story. He admits at the end that Vladek was doing his best as a parent but was very flawed.



* HappyEndingOverride: In a sense: while Vladek and Anja both survive the war, the former grew into a miserable cheapskate, while Anja killed herself.



** Vladek gives Art a key to his safety deposit box while talking about Haskel. Later, he finds photographs from the war that Art can use for reference.

to:

** Vladek gives Art a key to his safety deposit box while talking about Haskel. Later, he finds photographs from the war that Art can use for reference. Despite being upset after reading Art's comic about Anja's suicide, he tells Art it was a good way for him to deal with his feelings.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* OOCIsSeriousBusiness: During one visit, Art finds Vladek treating him [[TranquilFury especially coldly]]. It is because he read the comic strip Art wrote after Anja's suicide.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* UnreliableNarrator: In the end, the tired, sick and depressed Vladek says that he and Anja lived happily ever after. However, we know that Anja suffered from mental problems and killed herself about twenty years later.

to:

* UnreliableNarrator: In the end, the tired, sick and depressed Vladek says that he and Anja lived happily ever after.HappilyEverAfter. However, we know that Anja suffered from mental problems and killed herself about twenty years later.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MiseryBuildsCharacter: Vladek states several times that, although his time in the concentration camps was horrific beyond measure, he learned several skills that would serve him well later in his life.

to:

* MiseryBuildsCharacter: Vladek states several times that, although his time in the concentration camps was horrific beyond measure, he learned several skills that would serve him well later in his life. However, Art's therapist somewhat deconstructs this attitude, saying that it only justifies suffering.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Not So Different has been renamed, and it needs to be dewicked/moved


** Vladek is occasionally shown to be this way. He accuses Mala of being a GoldDigger, but it's implied that he originally pursued Anja because she was from a wealthy family. Art also points out that Vladek's racism toward black people is {{not so different}} from how anti-semites regard Jews.

to:

** Vladek is occasionally shown to be this way. He accuses Mala of being a GoldDigger, but it's implied that he originally pursued Anja because she was from a wealthy family. Art also points out that Vladek's racism toward black people is {{not isn't so different}} different from how anti-semites regard Jews.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MockingTheMourner: In a comic that Art wrote, a relative is shown telling Art he should have cried while his mother was still alive

to:

* MockingTheMourner: In a comic that Art wrote, a relative is shown telling Art he should have cried while his mother was still alivealive.



** Art's therapist, Pavel points out that Art's great respect for his father's ability to survive the Holocaust makes him dangerously susceptible to the eugenecist mindset that caused it in the first place.

to:

** Art's therapist, Pavel Pavel, points out that Art's great respect for his father's ability to survive the Holocaust makes him dangerously susceptible to the eugenecist mindset that caused it in the first place.

Top