Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Blog / TheComicsCurmudgeon

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** [[http://joshreads.com/?p=3113 Josh speculating on what sort of offscreen rowdiness ''ComicStrip/GilThorp'' characters had gotten up to:]]

to:

** [[http://joshreads.com/?p=3113 Josh speculating speculating]] on what sort of offscreen rowdiness ''ComicStrip/GilThorp'' characters had gotten up to:]]to:

Changed: 1

Removed: 4

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ThinkOfTheChildren: What he says of a ''ComicStrip/HiAndLois'' [[http://joshreads.com/?p=229 strip depicting a heart-shaped candy box as black even in color]], [[UnfortunateImplications implying that the title characters are in an S&M relation ship]].

to:

* ThinkOfTheChildren: What he says of a ''ComicStrip/HiAndLois'' [[http://joshreads.com/?p=229 strip depicting a heart-shaped candy box as black even in color]], [[UnfortunateImplications implying that the title characters are in an S&M relation ship]].relationship]].



* WorldOfSnark: But of course! The Curmudgeon's ''raison d'etre''...

----

to:

* WorldOfSnark: But of course! The Curmudgeon's ''raison d'etre''...

----
d'etre''...

Changed: 249

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


%%* SoBadItWasBetter:[[invoked]] His thoughts on ComicStrip/DickTracy.

to:

%%* * SoBadItWasBetter:[[invoked]] His thoughts on ComicStrip/DickTracy.''ComicStrip/DickTracy'' are that it was at its best in the years when it was completely terrible, and when the new team signed on and cleaned it up significantly, it was no longer enjoyable to mock. What happened to the days when Dick Tracy was a complete psychopath?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Josh has also developed a great deal of {{Running Gag}}s within the blog, including Aldo Kelrast, a character in ''ComicStrip/MaryWorth'', whose storyline became one of the strip's most popular after Josh began joking about it. ''[[Franchise/ArchieComics Archie]]'' has even made reference to one of the blog's running gags. He also coined the trope name ''{{Nephewism}}''.

to:

Josh has also developed a great deal of {{Running Gag}}s within the blog, including Aldo Kelrast, a character in ''ComicStrip/MaryWorth'', whose storyline became one of the strip's most popular after Josh began joking about it. ''[[Franchise/ArchieComics ''[[ComicBook/ArchieComics Archie]]'' has even made reference to one of the blog's running gags. He also coined the trope name ''{{Nephewism}}''.



** ''[[Franchise/ArchieComics Archie]]'' being written by a sterile computer, the ''Archie Joke-Generating Laugh Unit 3000'', that "almost, but doesn't quite, understand humor."

to:

** ''[[Franchise/ArchieComics ''[[ComicBook/ArchieComics Archie]]'' being written by a sterile computer, the ''Archie Joke-Generating Laugh Unit 3000'', that "almost, but doesn't quite, understand humor."

Added: 70

Removed: 78

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
This was renamed


* ILikedItBetterWhenItSucked:[[invoked]] His thoughts on ComicStrip/DickTracy.


Added DiffLines:

%%* SoBadItWasBetter:[[invoked]] His thoughts on ComicStrip/DickTracy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
fixed typo


Over time, the blog has developed a great deal of media attention as the authors of many comics have discovered it. Some comic artists or writers are even fans of the blog, including Chris Browne (''ComicStrip/HagarTheHorrible''), Mark Tatulli (''ComicStrip/{{Lio}}'', ''ComicStrip/HeartOfTheCity''), Francesco Marciuliano (''[[ComicStrip/SallyForthHoward Sally Forth]]'' and also the web comic ''Medium Large''), Ed Power (''ComicStrip/MyCage''), "Jumble Jeff" Knurek (the ''Jumble'' puzzle/comic), James Allen (Jack Elrod's assistant/successor on ''ComicStrip/MarkTrail''), and Bob Weber, Jr. (''ComicStrip/SlylockFox''). Marciuliano, who is also registered on the boards, even created a logo for the site (and the image for this page) during a major site redesign in early 2010. Also, Bob Weber has actually used the blog to sell official ''Shylock Fox'' merchandise directed at the adult fans of his strip.

to:

Over time, the blog has developed a great deal of media attention as the authors of many comics have discovered it. Some comic artists or writers are even fans of the blog, including Chris Browne (''ComicStrip/HagarTheHorrible''), Mark Tatulli (''ComicStrip/{{Lio}}'', ''ComicStrip/HeartOfTheCity''), Francesco Marciuliano (''[[ComicStrip/SallyForthHoward Sally Forth]]'' and also the web comic ''Medium Large''), Ed Power (''ComicStrip/MyCage''), "Jumble Jeff" Knurek (the ''Jumble'' puzzle/comic), James Allen (Jack Elrod's assistant/successor on ''ComicStrip/MarkTrail''), and Bob Weber, Jr. (''ComicStrip/SlylockFox''). Marciuliano, who is also registered on the boards, even created a logo for the site (and the image for this page) during a major site redesign in early 2010. Also, Bob Weber has actually used the blog to sell official ''Shylock ''Slylock Fox'' merchandise directed at the adult fans of his strip.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AnimalIsTheNewMan: According to Josh, ''ComicStrip/SlylockFox'' is set in the wake of the "animapocalypse". All animals mysteriously gained sentience on a single fateful day, then killed off most of humanity and hijacked human civilization.

Added: 219

Removed: 219

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
in alphabetical order, A-N goes before A-R


* ArsonMurderAndJaywalking: (In a commentary on ''ComicStrip/MaryWorth'') "Place your bets on what this 'troubling' medical condition may be: pregnancy, venereal disease, dementia, Electra Complex, droopy-ponytail-itis"


Added DiffLines:

* ArsonMurderAndJaywalking: (In a commentary on ''ComicStrip/MaryWorth'') "Place your bets on what this 'troubling' medical condition may be: pregnancy, venereal disease, dementia, Electra Complex, droopy-ponytail-itis"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DepartmentOfRedundancyDepartment: The title "[[http://joshreads.com/?p=1656 This week's COTW of the week!]]" Note that [=COTW=] stands for Comments Of The Week.
** From [[https://joshreads.com/2007/04/josh-does-too-read-the-comics-so-you-dont-have-to/ 2007-02-04]]:
--> '''Josh:''' In part one of Soap Opera Strips I Haven’t Been Discussing Because They Have Been Boring To Me, ''ComicStrip/ApartmentThreeG''’s interminable Lu Ann vs. Ghost Albert Pinkham Ryder storyline has been boring to me. [...] In part two of Soap Opera Strips I Haven’t Been Discussing Because They Have Been Boring To Me, ''ComicStrip/ThePhantom''’s interminable Old Man Mozz Is A Hostage To Bank Robbers storyline has been boring to me.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Also, jokes about the kids being drooling retards

to:

*** Also, jokes about the kids being drooling retardsincredibly dumb.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AfraidOfNeedles: Josh himself, as he admits [[https://joshreads.com/2018/08/hope-you-like-salmon-scented-dog-farts-buddy/ here]]


Added DiffLines:

* WhyDidItHaveToBeSnakes: Josh admits he's got a phobia of bees.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** [[http://joshreads.com/?p=3113 Josh speculating on what sort of offscreen rowdiness Gil Thorp characters had gotten up to:]]

to:

** [[http://joshreads.com/?p=3113 Josh speculating on what sort of offscreen rowdiness Gil Thorp ''ComicStrip/GilThorp'' characters had gotten up to:]]



** Josh once referred to a ''Gil Thorp'' plot as [[http://joshreads.com/?p=3113 "A roller-coaster ride, if roller-coasters had no hills and didn't move at all."]]

to:

** Josh once referred to a ''Gil Thorp'' ''ComicStrip/GilThorp'' plot as [[http://joshreads.com/?p=3113 "A roller-coaster ride, if roller-coasters had no hills and didn't move at all."]]



* EnsembleDarkhorse (In-Universe): Aldo Kelrast, naturally, but Josh appreciates pretty much any more colorful single-arc character that diverts focus from a boring main cast, especially if said characters have the audacity to insult them; past fascinations include fraudulent Negro Leagues star Clambake from ''Gil Thorp'', the "drunken, vomitous" Celeste Black from ''Judge Parker'', or the recurring Frank Nelson salesclerk guy from ''Gasoline Alley''.

to:

* EnsembleDarkhorse (In-Universe): Aldo Kelrast, naturally, but Josh appreciates pretty much any more colorful single-arc character that diverts focus from a boring main cast, especially if said characters have the audacity to insult them; past fascinations include fraudulent Negro Leagues star Clambake from ''Gil Thorp'', ''ComicStrip/GilThorp'', the "drunken, vomitous" Celeste Black from ''Judge Parker'', or the recurring Frank Nelson salesclerk guy from ''Gasoline Alley''.



* ScunthorpeProblem: At one point the comment system's spam filter kept catching posts containing "MILF"...and ''Gil Thorp'' takes place in ''Milford''.

to:

* ScunthorpeProblem: At one point the comment system's spam filter kept catching posts containing "MILF"...and ''Gil Thorp'' ''ComicStrip/GilThorp'' takes place in ''Milford''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added reason you suck speech

Added DiffLines:

* TheReasonYouSuckSpeech: Josh [[https://joshreads.com/2006/04/filth-foreigners-doom/ dropped a big one on Pluggers]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ActuallyPrettyFunny: Josh is perfectly willing to give credit where it's due.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added a bit to Enhance Button.

Added DiffLines:

** Also happened in the [[https://joshreads.com/2018/03/eight-arms-to-hold-you/ March 15th, 2018 Mary Worth]] to point out a coloring error on Wilbur's arm. Josh comes to the [[BlatantLies completely logical]] conclusion that Wilbur is secretly [[EldritchAbomination an Old One.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
useful notes are not tropes


* UsefulNotes/FurryFandom: Mocks this in ''ComicStrip/SlylockFox'' but his dislike/fear of the uprising seemingly extends to any form of TalkingAnimal, [[PettingZooPeople petting zoo]] or [[FunnyAnimal funny]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
added Eye Take example

Added DiffLines:

* EyeTake: Josh noticed how often these come up in ''ComicStrip/{{Shoe}}'', and dubbed them "the Patented ''Shoe'' Goggle Eyes of Horror".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Josh has also developed a great deal of {{Running Gag}}s within the blog, including Aldo Kelrast, a character in ''ComicStrip/MaryWorth'', whose storyline became one of the strip's most popular after Josh began joking about it. ''[[Franchise/ArchieComics Archie]]'' has even made reference to one of the blog's running gags. He also coined the trope name ''[[nephewism]]''.

to:

Josh has also developed a great deal of {{Running Gag}}s within the blog, including Aldo Kelrast, a character in ''ComicStrip/MaryWorth'', whose storyline became one of the strip's most popular after Josh began joking about it. ''[[Franchise/ArchieComics Archie]]'' has even made reference to one of the blog's running gags. He also coined the trope name ''[[nephewism]]''.
''{{Nephewism}}''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Josh has also developed a great deal of {{Running Gag}}s within the blog, including Aldo Kelrast, a character in ''ComicStrip/MaryWorth'', whose storyline became one of the strip's most popular after Josh began joking about it. ''[[Franchise/ArchieComics Archie]]'' has even made reference to one of the blog's running gags. He also coined the trope name [[Nephewism]].

to:

Josh has also developed a great deal of {{Running Gag}}s within the blog, including Aldo Kelrast, a character in ''ComicStrip/MaryWorth'', whose storyline became one of the strip's most popular after Josh began joking about it. ''[[Franchise/ArchieComics Archie]]'' has even made reference to one of the blog's running gags. He also coined the trope name [[Nephewism]].
''[[nephewism]]''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Josh has also developed a great deal of {{Running Gag}}s within the blog, including Aldo Kelrast, a character in ''ComicStrip/MaryWorth'', whose storyline became one of the strip's most popular after Josh began joking about it. ''[[Franchise/ArchieComics Archie]]'' has even made reference to one of the blog's running gags. He also coined the trope name [[nephewism]].

to:

Josh has also developed a great deal of {{Running Gag}}s within the blog, including Aldo Kelrast, a character in ''ComicStrip/MaryWorth'', whose storyline became one of the strip's most popular after Josh began joking about it. ''[[Franchise/ArchieComics Archie]]'' has even made reference to one of the blog's running gags. He also coined the trope name [[nephewism]].
[[Nephewism]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Josh has also developed a great deal of {{Running Gag}}s within the blog, including Aldo Kelrast, a character in ''ComicStrip/MaryWorth'', whose storyline became one of the strip's most popular after Josh began joking about it. ''[[Franchise/ArchieComics Archie]]'' has even made reference to one of the blog's running gags.

to:

Josh has also developed a great deal of {{Running Gag}}s within the blog, including Aldo Kelrast, a character in ''ComicStrip/MaryWorth'', whose storyline became one of the strip's most popular after Josh began joking about it. ''[[Franchise/ArchieComics Archie]]'' has even made reference to one of the blog's running gags.
gags. He also coined the trope name [[nephewism]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added Date With Rosie Palms and Enhance Button.

Added DiffLines:

* ADateWithRosiePalms: Josh attempts to make one of these jokes about [[https://joshreads.com/2016/12/lotta-bird-metaphors-flying-around-hnn-hq/ December 22nd, 2016 Mary Worth]]:
-->'''Wilbur:''' My '''work''' for the day is '''done.''' Now... (thinks about Iris) on to matters of the '''heart!'''
-->'''Josh:''' Ahh, yes, Wilbur’s finished his writing for the day and now it’s time for him to engage his imagination and indulge in some solo erot[my keyboard, computer, and cable modem simultaneously melt down in a desperate attempt to prevent me from finishing that sentence]
-->'''Josh:''' [I sign in with my phone]Those fingerless gloves he had on in yesterday’s strip should make the whole thing eas[the entire cell network for southern California goes up in flames in an act of species preservation]


Added DiffLines:

* EnhanceButton: From the [[https://joshreads.com/2017/08/erotic-soapy-developments/ August 10th, 2017 Mary Worth]]:
-->'''Josh:''' COMPUTER, ENHANCE.
-->''(Extreme close up of Jared)''
-->'''Josh:''' COMPUTER, DE-ENHANCE, NOBODY NEEDS TO SEE JARED'S SEX-RAGE IN SUCH DETAIL.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ViewersAreGeniuses: One of the blog's many charms are its occasional very erudite historical, philosophical and literary references.

to:

* ViewersAreGeniuses: One of the blog's many charms are its occasional very is that it doesn't shy away from erudite historical, philosophical and literary references.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ViewersAreGeniuses: One of the blog's many charms are its occasional very erudite historical, philosophical and literary references.


* TheyJustDidntCare: [[invoked]]What Josh [[http://joshreads.com/?p=781 says]] of ''Gil Thorp'' and ''ComicBook/{{Shoe}}'' in regards to paying tribute to ''ComicStrip/DickTracy''[='=]s 75th anniversary.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Over time, the blog has developed a great deal of media attention as the authors of many comics have discovered it. Some comic artists or writers are even fans of the blog, including Chris Browne (''ComicStrip/HagarTheHorrible''), Mark Tatulli (''Lio'', ''Heart of the City''), Francesco Marciuliano (''[[ComicStrip/SallyForthHoward Sally Forth]]'' and also the web comic ''Medium Large''), Ed Power (''ComicStrip/MyCage''), "Jumble Jeff" Knurek (the ''Jumble'' puzzle/comic), James Allen (Jack Elrod's assistant/successor on ''ComicStrip/MarkTrail''), and Bob Weber, Jr. (''ComicStrip/SlylockFox''). Marciuliano, who is also registered on the boards, even created a logo for the site (and the image for this page) during a major site redesign in early 2010. Also, Bob Weber has actually used the blog to sell official ''Shylock Fox'' merchandise directed at the adult fans of his strip.

to:

Over time, the blog has developed a great deal of media attention as the authors of many comics have discovered it. Some comic artists or writers are even fans of the blog, including Chris Browne (''ComicStrip/HagarTheHorrible''), Mark Tatulli (''Lio'', ''Heart of the City''), (''ComicStrip/{{Lio}}'', ''ComicStrip/HeartOfTheCity''), Francesco Marciuliano (''[[ComicStrip/SallyForthHoward Sally Forth]]'' and also the web comic ''Medium Large''), Ed Power (''ComicStrip/MyCage''), "Jumble Jeff" Knurek (the ''Jumble'' puzzle/comic), James Allen (Jack Elrod's assistant/successor on ''ComicStrip/MarkTrail''), and Bob Weber, Jr. (''ComicStrip/SlylockFox''). Marciuliano, who is also registered on the boards, even created a logo for the site (and the image for this page) during a major site redesign in early 2010. Also, Bob Weber has actually used the blog to sell official ''Shylock Fox'' merchandise directed at the adult fans of his strip.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* OverlyNarrowSuperlative: August 18, 2016 featured "the best ever instance of [[ComicStrip/MarkTrail Mark]] keeping a straight face while a government bureaucrat spells out an entire URL over the phone for some reason."

to:

* OverlyNarrowSuperlative: [[http://joshreads.com/?p=28104 August 18, 2016 2016]] featured "the best ever instance of [[ComicStrip/MarkTrail Mark]] keeping a straight face while a government bureaucrat spells out an entire URL over the phone for some reason."

Added: 220

Changed: 125

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NewMediaAreEvil: While Josh himself doesn't believe this, he does point out the more obnoxious or ridiculous examples of the comics.

to:

* NewMediaAreEvil: While Josh himself doesn't believe this, he does point Comics that convey this message are frequently called out the more obnoxious or ridiculous examples of the comics.and mocked for it.


Added DiffLines:

* OverlyNarrowSuperlative: August 18, 2016 featured "the best ever instance of [[ComicStrip/MarkTrail Mark]] keeping a straight face while a government bureaucrat spells out an entire URL over the phone for some reason."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** he constantly compares ''ComicStrip/HagarTheHorrible'' to the (not at all family friendly) real life vikings. Implying that Hagar is still no different, and rapes and murders off-panel.

to:

** he He constantly compares ''ComicStrip/HagarTheHorrible'' to the (not at all family friendly) real life vikings. Implying that Hagar is still no different, and rapes and murders off-panel.

Added: 544

Changed: 542

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NeverSpeakIllOfTheDead: When [[http://joshreads.com/?p=11816 Bil Keane]], creator of ''ComicStrip/TheFamilyCircus'', died in 2011, Josh was very somber, recalling the era when the strip was a lot edgier, and how the man himself [[SelfDeprecation had a great sense of humor about all the parodies of his work]]. Even the comments section has nothing but respect for the man, everybody agreeing that their mocking was in good jest, and that despite how unfunny many may have found the comic, every single commentor still respected him as a cartoonist and human being.

to:

* NeverSpeakIllOfTheDead: NeverSpeakIllOfTheDead:
**
When [[http://joshreads.com/?p=11816 Bil Keane]], creator of ''ComicStrip/TheFamilyCircus'', died in 2011, Josh was very somber, recalling the era when the strip was a lot edgier, and how the man himself [[SelfDeprecation had a great sense of humor about all the parodies of his work]]. Even the comments section has nothing but respect for the man, everybody agreeing that their mocking was in good jest, and that despite how unfunny many may have found the comic, every single commentor still respected him as a cartoonist and human being.

Top