Agreed, this is an absolutely dreadful page that instantly brings back bad memories of the age of troper tales and the like. Far too run on, unfocused and full of edgy theories that seem to have been created only for shock value. Delete it all.
Edited by protowizard
Is it okay if I added the "The Woodlanders ARE in a Religion" theory from Redwall's WMG page here?
Edited by DongwaChan
This page is way over the size limit, and needs to be split. I can't think of a way to do it, so if no one else can come up with anything better in a couple days, I'm going to just chop it into archives.
Cut this and put it here. Perhaps some of the joss-points are true; but Carcer's being crazy doesn't affect things one way or the other (not all psychopaths are murderers). And arguing that he must have committed murder because he's wanted for murder is arguing in a circle — the WMG is about people being mistaken about his being a murderer. (The WMG also disputes that he did kill Stronginthearm.)
- Thankfully, I don't think that works. Carcer is clearly psychopathic, he was already wanted for murder when he killed Stronginthearm, and his final confrontation with Vimes makes it clear that, whatever's driving him, self-defence is the last thing on his mind.
Honestly, I'm not even sure if most of this page should even exist on the Main Wiki, this just sounds like a recipe for word cruft and natter, especially with the "Complaining about Shows you Don't Watch" effect and the Rule of Cautious Editing Judgement... well... things. I think a better home for Poison Oak Epileptic Trees would be on the forums.
Edited by kinker Hide / Show Replies