[002]
71.57.52.184
Current Version
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
It\'s not that I agree with your points, but there\'s a difference between saying that Renly has personality qualities that make him a good fit with House Tyrell (something that would be good to put on the Analysis tab) and saying that \
to:
I don\\\'t disagree with that interpretation, but there\\\'s a difference between saying that Renly has personality qualities that make him a good fit with House Tyrell (something that would be good to put on the Analysis tab) and saying that \\\"the show presents Renly as a Tyrell who happens to have the Baratheon name\\\" (which is what you are saying and is [[Film/TheBigLebowski just like your opinion, man]]).
I think a lot of your opinions are quite plausible, but they are still your opinions, unless there is some direct statement of intent by the showrunners, people in the production staff, etc.
As a contrast, take the case of Theon- Theon clearly dresses more like a Stark when living at Winterfell and then changes to an Iron Islands dress style when he returns home/betrays Robb. Theon later is given a quote about Ned being his true father. In Theon\\\'s case, there is a lot more direct show evidence about his clothing and its symbolism.
Also, you kind of have a SingleIssueWonk about how Renly was the greatest guy ever and how his romance with Loras is the greatest thing ever...
I think a lot of your opinions are quite plausible, but they are still your opinions, unless there is some direct statement of intent by the showrunners, people in the production staff, etc.
As a contrast, take the case of Theon- Theon clearly dresses more like a Stark when living at Winterfell and then changes to an Iron Islands dress style when he returns home/betrays Robb. Theon later is given a quote about Ned being his true father. In Theon\\\'s case, there is a lot more direct show evidence about his clothing and its symbolism.
Also, you kind of have a SingleIssueWonk about how Renly was the greatest guy ever and how his romance with Loras is the greatest thing ever...
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
It\'s not that I agree with your points, but there\'s a difference between saying that Renly has personality qualities that make him a good fit with House Tyrell (something that would be good to put on the Analysis tab) and saying that \
to:
It\\\'s not that I agree with your points, but there\\\'s a difference between saying that Renly has personality qualities that make him a good fit with House Tyrell (something that would be good to put on the Analysis tab) and saying that \\\"the show presents Renly as a Tyrell who happens to have the Baratheon name\\\" (which is what you are saying and is [[Film/TheBigLebowski just like your opinion, man]]).
I think a lot of your opinions are quite plausible, but they are still your opinions, unless there is some direct statement of intent by the showrunners, people in the production staff, etc.
Also, you kind of have a SingleIssueWonk about how Renly was the greatest guy ever and how his romance with Loras is the greatest thing ever...
I think a lot of your opinions are quite plausible, but they are still your opinions, unless there is some direct statement of intent by the showrunners, people in the production staff, etc.
Also, you kind of have a SingleIssueWonk about how Renly was the greatest guy ever and how his romance with Loras is the greatest thing ever...
