[003]
174.65.11.127
Current Version
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
It\'s textbook DisproportionateRetribution, because the geth didn\'t only kill those responsible for the decision, they killed \'\'everyone\'\', period. Is it proportionate if, in response to a guy trying to murder me and my family, I kill him then proceed to track down and murder anyone related to him? For anyone doubting this, aside from basic logic, we have several in-universe statements telling us that the geth did this, including Tali in MassEffect1 and Anderson on page 116 of Mass Effect: Revelations, where he describes the Morning War as a \
to:
It\\\'s textbook DisproportionateRetribution, because the geth didn\\\'t only kill those responsible for the decision, they killed \\\'\\\'everyone\\\'\\\', period. Is it proportionate if, in response to a guy trying to murder me and my family, I kill him then proceed to track down and murder anyone related to him? For anyone doubting this, aside from basic logic, we have several in-universe statements telling us that the geth did this, including Tali in MassEffect1 and Anderson on page 116 of Mass Effect: Revelations, where he describes the Morning War as a \\\"genocide\\\" that the quarians \\\"had neither the number nor the ability to stand against\\\", and goes on to say that \\\"only a few million survivors- less than 1% of the population- managed to escape the genocide\\\". This is never contradicted anywhere and fits everything else we know about the war, like chemical/biological weapons being used by the geth on Rannoch.
And no, we don\\\'t \\\"know for sure\\\" anything Shaoken listed. We know that\\\'s what the \\\'\\\'\\\'geth\\\'\\\'\\\' \\\'\\\'told us\\\'\\\'. I find it rather funny that quarian accounts can be dismissed as \\\"bias\\\" while the geth are taken 100% at their word, when the geth are the only ones who have actually outright lied to us, via Legion.
And no, we don\\\'t \\\"know for sure\\\" anything Shaoken listed. We know that\\\'s what the \\\'\\\'\\\'geth\\\'\\\'\\\' \\\'\\\'told us\\\'\\\'. I find it rather funny that quarian accounts can be dismissed as \\\"bias\\\" while the geth are taken 100% at their word, when the geth are the only ones who have actually outright lied to us, via Legion.
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
It\'s textbook DisproportionateRetribution, because the geth didn\'t only kill those responsible for the decision, they killed \'\'everyone\'\', period. For anyone doubting this, aside from basic logic, we have several in-universe statements telling us that the geth did this, including Tali in MassEffect1 and Anderson on page 116 of Mass Effect: Revelations, where he describes the Morning War as a \
to:
It\\\'s textbook DisproportionateRetribution, because the geth didn\\\'t only kill those responsible for the decision, they killed \\\'\\\'everyone\\\'\\\', period. Is it proportionate if, in response to a guy trying to murder me and my family, I kill him then proceed to track down and murder anyone related to him? For anyone doubting this, aside from basic logic, we have several in-universe statements telling us that the geth did this, including Tali in MassEffect1 and Anderson on page 116 of Mass Effect: Revelations, where he describes the Morning War as a \\\"genocide\\\" that the quarians \\\"had neither the number nor the ability to stand against\\\", and goes on to say that \\\"only a few million survivors- less than 1% of the population- managed to escape the genocide\\\". This is never contradicted anywhere and fits everything else we know about the war, like chemical/biological weapons being used by the geth on Rannoch.
And no, we don\\\'t \\\"know for sure\\\" anything Shaoken listed. We know that\\\'s what the \\\'\\\'\\\'geth\\\'\\\'\\\' \\\'\\\'told us\\\'\\\'.
And no, we don\\\'t \\\"know for sure\\\" anything Shaoken listed. We know that\\\'s what the \\\'\\\'\\\'geth\\\'\\\'\\\' \\\'\\\'told us\\\'\\\'.
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
It\'s textbook DisproportionateRetribution, because the geth didn\'t only kill those responsible for the decision, they killed \'\'everyone\'\', period. For anyone doubting this, aside from basic logic, we have several in-universe statements telling us that the geth did this, including Tali in MassEffect1 and Anderson on page 116 of Mass Effect: Revelations, where he describes the Morning War as a \
to:
It\\\'s textbook DisproportionateRetribution, because the geth didn\\\'t only kill those responsible for the decision, they killed \\\'\\\'everyone\\\'\\\', period. For anyone doubting this, aside from basic logic, we have several in-universe statements telling us that the geth did this, including Tali in MassEffect1 and Anderson on page 116 of Mass Effect: Revelations, where he describes the Morning War as a \\\"genocide\\\" that the quarians \\\"had neither the number nor the ability to stand against\\\", and goes on to say that \\\"only a few million survivors- less than 1% of the population- managed to escape the genocide\\\". This is never contradicted anywhere and fits everything else we know about the war, like chemical/biological weapons being used by the geth on Rannoch.
And no, we don\\\'t \\\"know for sure\\\" anything Shaoken listed. We know that\\\'s what the \\\'\\\'\\\'geth\\\'\\\'\\\' \\\'\\\'told us\\\'\\\'.
And no, we don\\\'t \\\"know for sure\\\" anything Shaoken listed. We know that\\\'s what the \\\'\\\'\\\'geth\\\'\\\'\\\' \\\'\\\'told us\\\'\\\'.
