Follow TV Tropes

Following

Discussion History Characters / TheSilmarillion

Go To

Changed line(s) 9 from:
n
I was only objecting to A. the yelling, which I now realize had ended before I posted. B. adding Fanon (\
to:
I was only objecting to A. the yelling, which I now realize had ended before I posted. B. adding Fanon (\\\"rape is impossible\\\") that a fan \\\'\\\'just made up\\\'\\\', which isn\\\'t OK on any work page that I know of, And C. the statement that stuff should be deleted because it is not in The Silmarillion when the page says the info is from multiple books. Maybe the page needs splitting or a rename, I don\\\'t know. But that is a separate question.

But I think clearly this conversation isn\\\'t going anywhere fun. I\\\'m not angry, but I don\\\'t need this. I\\\'m bowing out. Whatever.
Changed line(s) 4 from:
to:
I didn\\\'t actually object to the fact you deleted that stuff, since it hadn\\\'t been written clearly in the first place. I was mostly responding to Maia Maiden\\\'s claims about what appears to be total Fanon.
Changed line(s) 7 from:
n
I was only objecting to A. the yelling, which I now realize had ended before I posted. B. adding Fanon (\
to:
I was only objecting to A. the yelling, which I now realize had ended before I posted. B. adding Fanon (\\\"rape is impossible\\\") that isn\\\'t actually in any book, that a fan \\\'\\\'just made up\\\'\\\', which isn\\\'t OK on any work page that I know of, And C. the statement that stuff should be deleted because it is not in The Silmarillion when the page says the info is from multiple books. Maybe the page needs splitting or a rename, I don\\\'t know. But that is a separate question.

But I think clearly this conversation isn\\\'t going anywhere fun. I\\\'m not angry, but I don\\\'t need other peoples\\\' fanrage. I\\\'m bowing out. Whatever.
Changed line(s) 7 from:
n
I was only objecting to A. the yelling, which I now realize had ended before I posted. B. adding Fanon (\
to:
I was only objecting to A. the yelling, which I now realize had ended before I posted. B. adding Fanon (\\\"rape is impossible\\\") that isn\\\'t actually in any book, that a fan \\\'\\\'just made up\\\'\\\', which isn\\\'t OK on any work page that I know of, And C. the statement that stuff should be deleted because it is not in The Silmarillion when the page says the info is from multiple books. Maybe the page needs splitting or a rename, I don\\\'t know. But that is a separate question.

But I think clearly this conversation isn\\\'t going anywhere fun. I\\\'m not angry, but I don\\\'t need other peoples\\\' fanrage. I\\\'m bowing out. Whatever.
Changed line(s) 7 from:
n
I was only objecting to A. the yelling, which I now realize had ended before I posted. B. adding Fanon (\
to:
I was only objecting to A. the yelling, which I now realize had ended before I posted. B. adding Fanon (\\\"rape is impossible\\\") that isn\\\'t actually in any book, that a fan \\\'\\\'just made up\\\'\\\', which isn\\\'t OK on any work page that I know of, And C. the statement that stuff should be deleted because it is not in The Silmarillion when the page says the info is from multiple books. Maybe the page needs splitting or a rename, I don\\\'t know. But that is a separate question.

But I think clearly this conversation isn\\\'t going anywhere fun. I don\\\'t have any fanrage, but I don\\\'t need other peoples\\\' fanrage. I\\\'m bowing out. Whatever.
Changed line(s) 7 from:
n
I was only objecting to A. the yelling. B. adding Fanon that isn\'t actually in any book, that a fan \'\'just made up\'\', which isn\'t OK on any work page that I know of, And C. the statement that stuff should be deleted because it is not in The Silmarillion when the page says the info is from multiple books. Maybe the page needs splitting or a rename, I don\'t know. But that is a separate question.
to:
I was only objecting to A. the yelling, which I now realize had ended before I posted. B. adding Fanon (\\\"rape is impossible\\\") that isn\\\'t actually in any book, that a fan \\\'\\\'just made up\\\'\\\', which isn\\\'t OK on any work page that I know of, And C. the statement that stuff should be deleted because it is not in The Silmarillion when the page says the info is from multiple books. Maybe the page needs splitting or a rename, I don\\\'t know. But that is a separate question.

But I think clearly this conversation isn\\\'t going anywhere fun. I\\\'m bowing out. Whatever.
Top