Follow TV Tropes

Following

Discussion History Main / Subtext

Go To

[002] Cider Current Version
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
The fact is 67% of the Sira(to say nothing of the Hadiths) is devoted to offensive war or struggle or Jihad if those are more politically correct as opposed to say, 34 mentions in the Old Testament, 9 in the Qu\'ran or 0 in the New Testament. Perhaps for this reason it should be noted [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quranism some Muslims only hold the Qu\'ran to any authority]] despite the fact it makes up less of a third of the official Islamic trilogy and one cannot even know all five pillars with only the Qu\'ran. (for comparison, there is an entire page about how ChristianityIsCatholic or rather is not)
to:
The fact is 67% of the Sira(to say nothing of the Hadiths) is devoted to offensive war or struggle or Jihad if those are more politically correct as opposed to say, 34 mentions in the Old Testament, 9 in the Qu\\\'ran or 0 in the New Testament(and it should be noted the Old Testament is longer than the Qu\\\'ran, so though it has more mentions the Qu\\\'ran has a higher frequency of violent Jihad). Perhaps for this reason it should be noted [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quranism some Muslims only hold the Qu\\\'ran to any authority]] despite the fact it makes up less of a third of the official Islamic trilogy and one cannot even know all five pillars with only the Qu\\\'ran. (for comparison, there is an entire page about how ChristianityIsCatholic or rather is not)
Changed line(s) 5 from:
n
I suppose just complaining about why something is not being added should be met with \
to:
I suppose just complaining about why something is not being added should be met with \\\"You could add it yourself\\\" and we definitely should not be passing much judgment beyond how accurate are fictional works portraying a subject on a useful notes page but discussion on how to go about adding text, how they may be interpreted (what parts of the Qu\\\'ran abrogate each other, which Hadiths are most authentic, ect) is valid in my view.
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
The fact is 67% of the Sira(to say nothing of the Hadiths) is devoted to offensive war or struggle or Jihad if those are more politically correct as opposed to say, 34% of the Old Testament, 9% of the Qu\'ran or 0% of the New Testament. Perhaps for this reason it should be noted [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quranism some Muslims only hold the Qu\'ran to any authority]] despite the fact it makes up less of a third of the official Islamic trilogy and one cannot even know all five pillars with only the Qu\'ran. (for comparison, there is an entire page about how ChristianityIsCatholic or rather is not)
to:
The fact is 67% of the Sira(to say nothing of the Hadiths) is devoted to offensive war or struggle or Jihad if those are more politically correct as opposed to say, 34 mentions in the Old Testament, 9 in the Qu\\\'ran or 0 in the New Testament. Perhaps for this reason it should be noted [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quranism some Muslims only hold the Qu\\\'ran to any authority]] despite the fact it makes up less of a third of the official Islamic trilogy and one cannot even know all five pillars with only the Qu\\\'ran. (for comparison, there is an entire page about how ChristianityIsCatholic or rather is not)
Changed line(s) 5 from:
n
I suppose just complaining about why something is not being added should be met with \
to:
I suppose just complaining about why something is not being added should be met with \\\"You could add it yourself\\\" and we definitely should not be passing much judgment beyond how accurate are fictional works portraying a subject on a useful notes page but discussion on how to go about adding text, how they may be interpreted (what parts of the Qu\\\'ran abrogate each other, which Hadiths are most authentic, ect) is valid in my view.
Top