[001]
NonoRobot
Current Version
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
So, I know we are on the YMMV page, but I think we need to take a closer look at the tropes present on this page. Recently, the main characters of Fairy Tail, who were discussed under TheScrappy trope, were moved to the BaseBreaker trope. However, the way the examples were written wasn\'t modified, so much that the examples still made references to the preceding trope they were belonging to, \
to:
So, I know we are on the YMMV page, but I think we need to take a closer look at the tropes present on this page. Recently, the main characters of Fairy Tail, who were discussed under TheScrappy trope, were moved to the BaseBreaker trope. However, the way the examples were written wasn\\\'t modified, so much that the examples still made references to the preceding trope they were belonging to, \\\"TheScrappy\\\" trope. Copy/pasting examples isn\\\'t a good thing when you are moving them to an another trope.
However, I\\\'m wondering where some examples really belong: do some of them belong to the BaseBreaker trope, others to TheScrappy trope, or both ? There\\\'s also the option to not include them in these tropes at all, though it would be rather difficult for some (and, well, that\\\'s the difficulty when we are discussing YMMV tropes). I think we need a discussion about the characters in question. Also, I kinda feel that TheScrappy trope became way too general and thus could be applied to nearly anyone (just \\\'\\\'look\\\'\\\' at the list of examples present on the trope page !), but that\\\'s an another subject.
So, I would like to hear your opinions about the following main characters:
* Natsu
* Erza (also, I\\\'m wondering if she could be listed under the GodModeSue trope).
* Lucy (her example needs at least some rewriting: she\\\'s no \\\"ordinary girl\\\", and \\\'\\\'I think\\\'\\\' (that\\\'s just my opinion) that she\\\'s perfectly able to take care of herself, though her victory records aren\\\'t very flattering).
Thank you very much for your help and inputs.
However, I\\\'m wondering where some examples really belong: do some of them belong to the BaseBreaker trope, others to TheScrappy trope, or both ? There\\\'s also the option to not include them in these tropes at all, though it would be rather difficult for some (and, well, that\\\'s the difficulty when we are discussing YMMV tropes). I think we need a discussion about the characters in question. Also, I kinda feel that TheScrappy trope became way too general and thus could be applied to nearly anyone (just \\\'\\\'look\\\'\\\' at the list of examples present on the trope page !), but that\\\'s an another subject.
So, I would like to hear your opinions about the following main characters:
* Natsu
* Erza (also, I\\\'m wondering if she could be listed under the GodModeSue trope).
* Lucy (her example needs at least some rewriting: she\\\'s no \\\"ordinary girl\\\", and \\\'\\\'I think\\\'\\\' (that\\\'s just my opinion) that she\\\'s perfectly able to take care of herself, though her victory records aren\\\'t very flattering).
Thank you very much for your help and inputs.
