[001]
magnum12
Current Version
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
Yasu not being a real, literal person on the island doesn\'t deny her all important connection to Beatrice. The Rosatrice theory contends that Yasu exists and is indeed intimately connected to Beatrice, but Yasu herself doesn\'t literately exist. Yasu is the persona rather than the body. The Yasu persona was born out of Rosa\'s guilt over her involvement in Beatrice II\'s death and became \
to:
Yasu not being a real, literal person on the island doesn\\\'t deny her all important connection to Beatrice. The Rosatrice theory contends that Yasu exists and is indeed intimately connected to Beatrice, but Yasu herself doesn\\\'t literately exist. Yasu is the persona rather than the body. The Yasu persona was born out of Rosa\\\'s guilt over her involvement in Beatrice II\\\'s death and became \\\"Beatrice\\\" at a later time. This is what I mean by the term \\\"larval state\\\". The Rosatrice theory contends that the death of Beatrice II is Rosa\\\'s StartOfDarkness and that the term \\\"furniture\\\" represents low social status. Its very odd that the only people that use the word \\\"furniture\\\" are the servants, Beatrice, and Rosa. Chick Beatrice symbolizes Rosa\\\'s original personality before \\\"her fall\\\". This theory about Chick Beatrice is supported by some of Battler\\\'s statements in which his father said that Rosa UsedToBeASweetKid.
Rosa\\\'s motive in the mass murders is to 1. attempt to ressurect Beatrice II through the witche\\\'s epitaph and 2. she wants to be loved and understood. In her screwed up head, she believes that enacting the epitaph litereately will restore everything that was lost. Having been bullied by her siblings, ditched by her dead beat husband, having a difficult time finding and keeping a boyfriend, stuck as a single mother, and beliving herself to be unworthy of her father\\\'s love over the death of Beatrice II, it can be safe to say that Rosa\\\'s life lacks love (of any kind under TheFourLoves). Despite her split personality treatment of Maria (most likely over her screwed up life), I\\\'m pretty certain that Rosa legitimately loves Maria and probably uses the \\\"Beatrice\\\" persona to atone for the bad things she does to Maria. This atonement is also a motive for why Rosa would do an emergency breakage of the rules of Beatrice. The epitaph is something that is more absolute in the rules context, since \\\"Beatrice\\\" plays fair.
How does this relate to Battler and the \\\"Love Narrative\\\" that\\\'s so important to Umineko. Quite a lot actually, but Rosa does NOT desire Eros (romantic love) from Battler. She seeks understanding/unconditional love (Agape) and Storge (familial love) from him. Something interesting that shows up is that the only people who are upset about Battler spliting off on his own are Shannon and Rosa (who says something about how she\\\'s going to miss him with a rather sad expression on her face). Everyone else believes that this is a great growth opprutunity for him or something else positive. The Rosatrice theory believes that the assumed definition of love (Eros) is actually part of the trap R7 set for us in the Core arcs (he even said he was going to set an elaborate trap that he expected most of the fan base to fall for in an interview before the 5th game). The cheese puzzle may be a warning about assumed definitions.
As for Eva\\\'s journal, the Rosatrice Theory believes that the cover up as it relates to Ange is related to Ange\\\'s hopes regarding Battler\\\'s fate. Eva wants Ange to be able to hope that one day Battler will come back. Rudolf\\\'s suspicious, shady character is likely the same ploy R7 used with the Sonozaki family. In essence, a RedHerring. Eva\\\'s motive for covering up the culprit and her willingness to allow others to believe she was the culprit makes the most sense if it was indeed George who was a culprit.
Speaking of George, what I\\\'m refering to in regards to red flags regarding him being a yandere is his response to the sacrifice test. His option of kill everyone else reflects a willingness to destroy anyone who gets in the way of his relationship with Shannon, which is a trademark trait of a Yandere (possessive subtype I believe). In regards to martial arts training, it actually serves as an alternate explaination to the 4th-6th twilight of the 2nd game. Something about the \\\"heavy object suicide\\\" explaination for Shannon doesn\\\'t seem right. If her death was a suicide, why is the penetration of the stake so low and why is there no exit wound in Shannon\\\'s head. Even with a pistol, close range wounds (as per your typical suicide) are much more gruesome than long range ballistics wounds, with a large exit wound being certain. In fact, in the 4th game, there is indeed an exit wound in the back of Shannon\\\'s head, which supports both her commiting suicide and someone else killing her. Martial arts training actually allows the user much greater access to a human\\\'s \\\"reserve strength\\\". The low penetration of the stake suggests the notion that the stake itself was the weapon. Even if the stake is a paper weight (5th game), that elevated access to reserve strength can make that stake much more dangerous than in the hands of an ordinary person. The room being the mess that it is indicates a struggle, with George accidentally killing Shannon in a rage and Shannon shooting George with a pistol in self defense. The pistol most likely did not kill George instantly (he bled out). Realizing what he had done, he most likely hid the pistol and placed the stake in his wound so no one would blame Shannon. Gohda was most likely killed first.
Rosa\\\'s motive in the mass murders is to 1. attempt to ressurect Beatrice II through the witche\\\'s epitaph and 2. she wants to be loved and understood. In her screwed up head, she believes that enacting the epitaph litereately will restore everything that was lost. Having been bullied by her siblings, ditched by her dead beat husband, having a difficult time finding and keeping a boyfriend, stuck as a single mother, and beliving herself to be unworthy of her father\\\'s love over the death of Beatrice II, it can be safe to say that Rosa\\\'s life lacks love (of any kind under TheFourLoves). Despite her split personality treatment of Maria (most likely over her screwed up life), I\\\'m pretty certain that Rosa legitimately loves Maria and probably uses the \\\"Beatrice\\\" persona to atone for the bad things she does to Maria. This atonement is also a motive for why Rosa would do an emergency breakage of the rules of Beatrice. The epitaph is something that is more absolute in the rules context, since \\\"Beatrice\\\" plays fair.
How does this relate to Battler and the \\\"Love Narrative\\\" that\\\'s so important to Umineko. Quite a lot actually, but Rosa does NOT desire Eros (romantic love) from Battler. She seeks understanding/unconditional love (Agape) and Storge (familial love) from him. Something interesting that shows up is that the only people who are upset about Battler spliting off on his own are Shannon and Rosa (who says something about how she\\\'s going to miss him with a rather sad expression on her face). Everyone else believes that this is a great growth opprutunity for him or something else positive. The Rosatrice theory believes that the assumed definition of love (Eros) is actually part of the trap R7 set for us in the Core arcs (he even said he was going to set an elaborate trap that he expected most of the fan base to fall for in an interview before the 5th game). The cheese puzzle may be a warning about assumed definitions.
As for Eva\\\'s journal, the Rosatrice Theory believes that the cover up as it relates to Ange is related to Ange\\\'s hopes regarding Battler\\\'s fate. Eva wants Ange to be able to hope that one day Battler will come back. Rudolf\\\'s suspicious, shady character is likely the same ploy R7 used with the Sonozaki family. In essence, a RedHerring. Eva\\\'s motive for covering up the culprit and her willingness to allow others to believe she was the culprit makes the most sense if it was indeed George who was a culprit.
Speaking of George, what I\\\'m refering to in regards to red flags regarding him being a yandere is his response to the sacrifice test. His option of kill everyone else reflects a willingness to destroy anyone who gets in the way of his relationship with Shannon, which is a trademark trait of a Yandere (possessive subtype I believe). In regards to martial arts training, it actually serves as an alternate explaination to the 4th-6th twilight of the 2nd game. Something about the \\\"heavy object suicide\\\" explaination for Shannon doesn\\\'t seem right. If her death was a suicide, why is the penetration of the stake so low and why is there no exit wound in Shannon\\\'s head. Even with a pistol, close range wounds (as per your typical suicide) are much more gruesome than long range ballistics wounds, with a large exit wound being certain. In fact, in the 4th game, there is indeed an exit wound in the back of Shannon\\\'s head, which supports both her commiting suicide and someone else killing her. Martial arts training actually allows the user much greater access to a human\\\'s \\\"reserve strength\\\". The low penetration of the stake suggests the notion that the stake itself was the weapon. Even if the stake is a paper weight (5th game), that elevated access to reserve strength can make that stake much more dangerous than in the hands of an ordinary person. The room being the mess that it is indicates a struggle, with George accidentally killing Shannon in a rage and Shannon shooting George with a pistol in self defense. The pistol most likely did not kill George instantly (he bled out). Realizing what he had done, he most likely hid the pistol and placed the stake in his wound so no one would blame Shannon. Gohda was most likely killed first.
