Follow TV Tropes

Following

Discussion History Main / Musicians

Go To

[003] random3 Current Version
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
For example, Shana is a LN, which is inherently shounen or shoujo, but the anime aired at like 0125.
to:
For example, Shana is a LN, which is inherently shounen or shoujo, but the anime aired at like 0130.
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
I never stated that you were antagonizing me. I do in fact think you are somewhat insulted that someone disagrees with your idea as, even in your first response, you\'ve claimed that I\'m trying to make \
to:
I never stated that you were antagonizing me. I do in fact think you are somewhat insulted that someone disagrees with your idea as, even in your first response, you\\\'ve claimed that I\\\'m trying to make \\\"arbitrary rules,\\\" but that\\\'s beside the point.

All I did was point out your double standard. You claimed that the \\\"ramifications\\\" of my idea who require me to police the whole damn page, but yet, if your idea goes through, you don\\\'t have to. I have to analyze every hot tip, but you don\\\'t have to make sure that every artist is hottiped with every single guest musician, even if they only appear on one song.

Again, I cite Avantasia and Ayreon. You claimed that Apocalyptica should have hottips for their guests because its part of their gimmick, but then you turned around and stated that you don\\\'t have to worry about Avantasia and Ayreon because you \\\"don\\\'t care.\\\"

I never stated any fucking intent to make sure all of the hottips are correct, but you\\\'re basically claiming that I have. I simply stated that a guest position isn\\\'t enough to connect two otherwise unrelated acts together. Most of these guest positions are only for one song.

As for Portnoy: HE ISN\\\'T A MEMBER OF DREAM THEATER ANYMORE AND THEREFOR IS NOT RELATED TO THEM. WE DON\\\'T HAVE A PAGE FOR HIM, SO THERE IS NO REASON TO HOTTIP HIM AS RELATED TO AVENGED SEVENFOLD EVEN IF HE WERE ASSOCIATED TO THEM BEYOND A GUEST SPOT.

You\\\'ve blown this out of proportion. All I did was delete an edit I disagreed with and stated my reasons for the disagreement. You\\\'ve put words in my mouth, ignored my reasoning, called me a hypocrite and have shown yourself to be a hypocrite in the process.

I have stated it multiple times and you seem to completely fucking miss it: I am not against hottips, I am against excessive hottips because this page is an index and is meant to show people where to go to find pages with actual information on them. If guest musicians are important, then list them on the pages themselves, but as they don\\\'t link the bands together, then they should not be hottiped on the index because THEY AREN\\\'T FUCKING RELATED.
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
I never stated that you were antagonizing me. I do in fact think you are somewhat insulted that someone disagrees with your idea as, even in your first response, you\'ve claimed that I\'m trying to make \
to:
I never stated that you were antagonizing me. I do in fact think you are somewhat insulted that someone disagrees with your idea as, even in your first response, you\\\'ve claimed that I\\\'m trying to make \\\"arbitrary rules,\\\" but that\\\'s beside the point.

All I did was point out your double standard. You claimed that the \\\"ramifications\\\" of my idea who require me to police the whole damn page, but yet, if your idea goes through, you don\\\'t have to. I have to analyze every hot tip, but you don\\\'t have to make sure that every artist is hottiped with every single guest musician, even if they only appear on one song.

Again, I cite Avantasia and Ayreon. You claimed that Apocalyptica should have hottips for their guests because its part of their gimmick, but then you turned around and stated that you don\\\'t have to worry about Avantasia and Ayreon because you \\\"don\\\'t care.\\\"

I never stated any fucking intent to make sure all of the hottips are correct, but you\\\'re basically claiming that I have. I simply stated that a guest position isn\\\'t enough to connect two otherwise unrelated acts together. Most of these guest positions are only for one song.

As for Portnoy: HE ISN\\\'T A MEMBER OF DREAM THEATER ANYMORE AND THEREFOR IS NOT RELATED TO THEM. WE DON\\\'T HAVE A PAGE FOR HIM, SO THERE IS NO REASON TO HOTTIP HIM AS RELATED TO AVENGED SEVENFOLD EVEN IF HE WERE ASSOCIATED TO THEM BEYOND A GUEST SPOT.

You\\\'ve blown this out of proportion. All I did was delete an edit I disagreed with and stated my reasons for the disagreement. You\\\'ve put words in my mouth, ignored my reasoning, called me a hypocrite and have shown yourself to be a hypocrite in the process.

I have stated it multiple times and you seem to completely fucking miss it: I am not against hottips, I am against excessive hottips because this page is an index and is meant to show people where to go to find pages with actual information on them. If guest musicians are important, then list them on the pages themselves, but as they don\\\'t link the bands together, then they should not be hottiped on the index.
Top