Follow TV Tropes

Following

Discussion History YMMV / RWBY

Go To

[007] Wyldchyld Current Version
Changed line(s) 17 from:
n
So, right now, the legitimate entry we have is as follows (the trick is to rewrite these so they\'re not semi-complaining):
to:
Right now, the legitimate entry we have is as follows (the trick is to rewrite these so they\\\'re not semi-complaining):
Changed line(s) 15 from:
n
* Penny\'s \'\'second\'\' death has caused an outcry and is probably a legitimate example, but needs to be written as such. However, have Vine, Watts and Ironwood produced scaled up outbursts from the fandom? Most of the fandom seems focussed on Penny\'s death, overshadowing the others, which suggests that Penny\'s the only example here.
to:
* Have Vine, Watts and Ironwood produced scaled up outbursts from the fandom? Most of the fandom seems focussed on Penny\\\'s death, overshadowing the others, which suggests that Penny\\\'s the only example here.
Changed line(s) 22 from:
n
** Volume 8 produced a big response from the fandom due to how the finale unfolded. [[spoilers:After investing in Penny\'s journey to become a real girl, just like her inspiration Pinocchio, Penny\'s success being unexpectedly subverted by having her die shortly afterwards led to an outcry for a couple of reasons ranging from the unexpected use of assisted suicide traumatising another character to fans feeling bereaved of any pay-off from the \'real girl\' storyline.]]
to:
** Volume 8 produced a big response from the fandom due to how the finale unfolded. [[spoiler:After investing in Penny\\\'s journey to become a real girl, just like her inspiration Pinocchio, Penny\\\'s success being unexpectedly subverted by having her die shortly afterwards led to an outcry for a couple of reasons ranging from the unexpected use of assisted suicide traumatising another character to fans feeling bereaved of any pay-off from the \\\'real girl\\\' storyline.]]
Changed line(s) 17 from:
n
So, right now, the legitimate entry we have is as follows:
to:
So, right now, the legitimate entry we have is as follows (the trick is to rewrite these so they\\\'re not semi-complaining):
Changed line(s) 23 from:
n

Penny\'s death occurs after an entire volume of the heroes trying to save Penny\'s life; they finally make her a living being only for her to then be killed off moments later. The fandom was
to:
Changed line(s) 9 from:
n
Everything here is ZCE except for the Volume 3 and Volume 7 entries. They\'re legitimate examples. They explain why there was a huge fandom outcry. Everything else is just \'character dies, part of the fandom is sad\'. That\'s Administrivia/PeopleSitOnChairs. It\'s not a trope of any kind. Most characters will have fans that are sad when the character gets killed off.
to:
Everything here is ZCE except for the Volume 3 and Volume 7 entries. They\\\'re legitimate examples. They explain why there was a huge fandom outcry. Everything else is just \\\'character dies, part of the fandom is sad\\\'. That\\\'s Administrivia/PeopleSitOnChairs. Most characters in most works will have fans that are upset when the character gets killed off.
Changed line(s) 11 from:
n
ViewersInMourning is for an exceptional outburst from the fandom. In Volume 3, this happened for Pyrrha and Roman, but it did not happen for Penny because the overriding belief was that, as a robot, she might return. Clover\'s death was a shitshow and the write-up covers that.
to:
ViewersInMourning is for an exceptional outburst from the fandom. In Volume 3, this happened for Pyrrha and Roman, but it did not happen for Penny because the overriding belief was that, as a robot, she might return. Clover\\\'s death was massive for the reason his entry mentions. In V8, Penny is an example, given the outcry, but is ZCE in the original entry.
Changed line(s) 15 from:
to:

So, right now, the legitimate entry we have is as follows:

* ViewersInMourning:
** Volume 3 created a big impact on the fandom with the dramatic events that occurred. [[spoiler:The villains\\\' assault on Beacon Academy saw the deaths of popular characters such as Pyrrha and Roman, generating a range of emotional outbursts from mourning extremely popular characters and the loss off a potential Jaune/Pyrrha romance to refusal to accept they were dead, anger over how they died, and feelings that the show was getting too dark.]]
** Volume 7 brought yet another wave of mourners. [[spoiler:The fandom became very invested in the possibility of the show\\\'s first male-on-male ship with Clover and Qrow\\\'s chemistry on-screen, creating a massive backlash when Clover was instead killed off.]]
** Volume 8 produced a big response from the fandom due to how the finale unfolded. [[spoilers:After investing in Penny\\\'s journey to become a real girl, just like her inspiration Pinocchio, Penny\\\'s success being unexpectedly subverted by having her die shortly afterwards led to an outcry for a couple of reasons ranging from the unexpected use of assisted suicide traumatising another character to fans feeling bereaved of any pay-off from the \\\'real girl\\\' storyline.]]

Penny\\\'s death occurs after an entire volume of the heroes trying to save Penny\\\'s life; they finally make her a living being only for her to then be killed off moments later. The fandom was
Top