Follow TV Tropes

Following

Discussion History Manga / StopHibarikun

Go To

[001] Pine182 Current Version
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
I think I\'ve made it clear but I write out how I feel it should be handled here. While I would prefer she/her pronouns as the character canonically chooses to be seen as a girl, I feel that they/them pronouns and not taking a stance on Hibari\'s gender is an excellent compromise and would be understandable given the ambiguity of the situation, while he/him would be a gross misrepresentation of the character and her own canonical choices of how to be referred. In addition to that, the ambiguity of the situation should be fully mentioned regardless of which pronouns are used, and not just in little blurbs either, it\'s clear to me that for this series painting any other perspectives as just some fans head canon would be not only be extremely dishonest but actively harmful to this pages ability to correctly convey information. No matter what is done it should NOT be reverted back to IdumeanPatriot\'s edits, as there were very biased.
to:
I think I\\\'ve made it clear but I write out how I feel it should be handled here. While I would prefer she/her pronouns as the character canonically chooses to be seen as a girl, I feel that they/them pronouns and not taking a stance on Hibari\\\'s gender is an excellent compromise and would be understandable given the ambiguity of the situation, while he/him would be a gross misrepresentation of the character and her own canonical choices of how to be referred. In addition to that, the ambiguity of the situation should be fully mentioned regardless of which pronouns are used, and not just in little blurbs either, it\\\'s clear to me that for this series painting any other perspectives as just some fans head canon would be not only be extremely dishonest but actively harmful to this pages ability to correctly convey information. No matter what is done it should NOT be reverted back to IdumeanPatriot\\\'s edits, as they were very biased.
Top