[001]
fishysaur
Current Version
Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
Yeah, about the battle it's very off-topic.
to:
Yeah, about the battle it\'s very off-topic.
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
to:
\"Unfortunately for this entry, the scene is actually set up to have Emerald react reflexively, on instinct, and there is absolutely no indication that the chain or Semblance would have been more effective than the bare hands.\" (can\'t copy like you XD)
-Heck, for that matter, using the already existing entry as example there\'s no indication that Weiss fighting without trying to summon the knight would\'ve been more effective, but it applies because the audience reaction was \"Weiss, why do you keep summoning the knight if it doesn\'t work?\"
And in Emerald\'s case, the audience thought \"Emerald, why did you jump instead of using your weapon or your semblance?\"
Maybe you didn\'t thought it (my first thought was \"With all the time you have, you now react?\") but a YMMV it\'s about subjective audicence reaction, if a good chunck think this, it apply (Btw do you think the dive would be as or more effective than using her weapon or her semblance?)
Again, as you see, Emerald and Mercury turned \'\'back\'\' to Hazel and Weiss. Why? Because so at least they could see a fight? (Just a joke). Otherwise, I think that turning back to Weiss instead of attacking Yang and Ruby after seeing that they have turned the back, it\'s a case of WhatAnIdiot
The problem I have with this entry it\'s that it mainly originated from a video (I.e. one person) that got really popular and many agreed with him (to be fair, he\'s not very nice when he speaks, but he\'s got a point)
Yeah, the battle argument it\'s off topic, and it would be too long explaining every instance that explain why it\'s a case of IdiotPlot
P.s. the entry could also says that this moment it\'s partially justified because Emerald had little time to react.
-Heck, for that matter, using the already existing entry as example there\'s no indication that Weiss fighting without trying to summon the knight would\'ve been more effective, but it applies because the audience reaction was \"Weiss, why do you keep summoning the knight if it doesn\'t work?\"
And in Emerald\'s case, the audience thought \"Emerald, why did you jump instead of using your weapon or your semblance?\"
Maybe you didn\'t thought it (my first thought was \"With all the time you have, you now react?\") but a YMMV it\'s about subjective audicence reaction, if a good chunck think this, it apply (Btw do you think the dive would be as or more effective than using her weapon or her semblance?)
Again, as you see, Emerald and Mercury turned \'\'back\'\' to Hazel and Weiss. Why? Because so at least they could see a fight? (Just a joke). Otherwise, I think that turning back to Weiss instead of attacking Yang and Ruby after seeing that they have turned the back, it\'s a case of WhatAnIdiot
The problem I have with this entry it\'s that it mainly originated from a video (I.e. one person) that got really popular and many agreed with him (to be fair, he\'s not very nice when he speaks, but he\'s got a point)
Yeah, the battle argument it\'s off topic, and it would be too long explaining every instance that explain why it\'s a case of IdiotPlot
P.s. the entry could also says that this moment it\'s partially justified because Emerald had little time to react.
