I was going to address your points about the battle, but it's very off-topic. I'll just point out that Weiss's action distracts everyone to the point of being what brings Blake to the room, and Weiss's reaction alerts the room to Blake's presence. Yang staring at Blake in realisation shows Emerald and Mercury in the background turning back to Hazel and Weiss.
to:
I was going to address your points about the battle, but it\'s very off-topic. I\'ll just point out that Weiss\'s action distracts everyone to the point of being what brings Blake to the room, and Weiss\'s reaction alerts the room to Blake\'s presence. Yang staring at Blake in realisation shows Emerald and Mercury in the background turning back to Hazel and Weiss.
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
[[quoteblock]]It's an idiot moment because, if she reasoned, instead of acting like an idiot (this is what the trope is about), Emerald would've either used her weapon or, more effectively, her semblance. [[/quoteblock]]
to:
[[quoteblock]]It\'s an idiot moment because, if she reasoned, instead of acting like an idiot (this is what the trope is about), Emerald would\'ve either used her weapon or, more effectively, her semblance. [[/quoteblock]]
Changed line(s) 10 from:
n
The entry is claiming the scene sets up Emerald as having the time to reason through her options and that there's absolutely no doubt that the Semblance or chain would have stopped Yang had they been used. If this is the case, then fans can indeed have the YMMV option of using the WhatAnIdiot trope.
to:
The entry is claiming the scene sets up Emerald as having the time to reason through her options and that there\'s absolutely no doubt that the Semblance or chain would have stopped Yang had they been used. If this is the case, then fans can indeed have the YMMV option of using the WhatAnIdiot trope.
Changed line(s) 12 from:
n
Unfortunately for this entry, the scene is actually set up to have Emerald react reflexively, on instinct, and there is absolutely no indication that the chain or Semblance would have been more effective than the bare hands. The parameters of the trope therefore don't exist.
This entry is therefore a shoehorn based on misrepresenting a scene using a justification that is based on something that never happened.
to:
Unfortunately for this entry, the scene is actually set up to have Emerald react reflexively, on instinct, and there is absolutely no indication that the chain or Semblance would have been more effective than the bare hands. The parameters of the trope therefore don\'t exist, which is why this entry is a shoehorn (based on misrepresenting a scene using a justification that is based on something that never happened).
I was going to address your points about the battle, but it's very off-topic. I'll just point out that Weiss's action distracts everyone to the point of being what brings Blake to the room, and Weiss's reaction alerts the room to Blake's presence. Yang staring at Blake in realisation shows Emerald and Mercury in the background turning back to Hazel and Weiss.
to:
I was going to address your points about the battle, but it\'s very off-topic. I\'ll just point out that Weiss\'s action distracts everyone to the point of being what brings Blake to the room, and Weiss\'s reaction alerts the room to Blake\'s presence. Yang staring at Blake in realisation shows Emerald and Mercury in the background turning back to Hazel and Weiss.
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
[[quoteblock]]It's an idiot moment because, if she reasoned, instead of acting like an idiot (this is what the trope is about), Emerald would've either used her weapon or, more effectively, her semblance. [[/quoteblock]]
to:
[[quoteblock]]It\'s an idiot moment because, if she reasoned, instead of acting like an idiot (this is what the trope is about), Emerald would\'ve either used her weapon or, more effectively, her semblance. [[/quoteblock]]
Changed line(s) 10 from:
n
The entry is claiming the scene sets up Emerald as having the time to reason through her options and that there's absolutely no doubt that the Semblance or chain would have stopped Yang had they been used. If this is the case, then fans can indeed have the YMMV option of using the WhatAnIdiot trope.
to:
The entry is claiming the scene sets up Emerald as having the time to reason through her options and that there\'s absolutely no doubt that the Semblance or chain would have stopped Yang had they been used. If this is the case, then fans can indeed have the YMMV option of using the WhatAnIdiot trope.
Changed line(s) 12 from:
n
Unfortunately for this entry, the scene is actually set up to have Emerald react reflexively, on instinct, and there is absolutely no indication that the chain or Semblance would have been more effective than the bare hands.
to:
Unfortunately for this entry, the scene is actually set up to have Emerald react reflexively, on instinct, and there is absolutely no indication that the chain or Semblance would have been more effective than the bare hands. The parameters of the trope therefore don\'t exist.
I was going to address your points about the battle, but it's very off-topic. I'll just point out that Weiss's action distracts everyone to the point of being what brings Blake to the room, and Weiss's reaction alerts the room to Blake's presence. Yang staring at Blake in realisation shows Emerald and Mercury in the background turning back to Hazel and Weiss.
to:
I was going to address your points about the battle, but it\'s very off-topic. I\'ll just point out that Weiss\'s action distracts everyone to the point of being what brings Blake to the room, and Weiss\'s reaction alerts the room to Blake\'s presence. Yang staring at Blake in realisation shows Emerald and Mercury in the background turning back to Hazel and Weiss.
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
[[quoteblock]]It's an idiot moment because, if she reasoned, instead of acting like an idiot (this is what the trope is about), Emerald would've either used her weapon or, more effectively, her semblance. [[/quoteblock]]
to:
[[quoteblock]]It\'s an idiot moment because, if she reasoned, instead of acting like an idiot (this is what the trope is about), Emerald would\'ve either used her weapon or, more effectively, her semblance. [[/quoteblock]]
Changed line(s) 10 from:
n
The entry is claiming the scene sets up Emerald as having the time to reason through her options and that there's absolutely no doubt that the Semblance or chain would have stopped Yang had they been used.
to:
The entry is claiming the scene sets up Emerald as having the time to reason through her options and that there\'s absolutely no doubt that the Semblance or chain would have stopped Yang had they been used. If this is the case, then fans can indeed have the YMMV option of using the WhatAnIdiot trope.
I was going to address your points about the battle, but it's very off-topic. I'll just point out that Weiss's action distracts everyone to the point of being what brings Blake to the room, and Weiss's reaction alerts the room to Blake's presence. Yang staring at Blake in realisation shows Emerald and Mercury in the background turning back to Hazel and Weiss.
to:
I was going to address your points about the battle, but it\'s very off-topic. I\'ll just point out that Weiss\'s action distracts everyone to the point of being what brings Blake to the room, and Weiss\'s reaction alerts the room to Blake\'s presence. Yang staring at Blake in realisation shows Emerald and Mercury in the background turning back to Hazel and Weiss.
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
[[quoteblock]]It's an idiot moment because, if she reasoned, instead of acting like an idiot (this is what the trope is about)... [[/quoteblock]]
to:
[[quoteblock]]It\'s an idiot moment because, if she reasoned, instead of acting like an idiot (this is what the trope is about), Emerald would\'ve either used her weapon or, more effectively, her semblance. [[/quoteblock]]
Changed line(s) 10 from:
n
The entry is claiming the scene sets up Emerald as having the time to reason through her options and that there's absolutely no doubt that the Semblance or chain would have stopped Yang had they been used.
to:
The entry is claiming the scene sets up Emerald as having the time to reason through her options and that there\'s absolutely no doubt that the Semblance or chain would have stopped Yang had they been used.
I was going to address your points about the battle, but it's very off-topic. I'll just point out that Weiss's action distracts everyone to the point of being what brings Blake to the room, and Weiss's reaction alerts the room to Blake's presence. Yang staring at Blake in realisation shows Emerald and Mercury in the background turning back to Hazel and Weiss.
to:
I was going to address your points about the battle, but it\'s very off-topic. I\'ll just point out that Weiss\'s action distracts everyone to the point of being what brings Blake to the room, and Weiss\'s reaction alerts the room to Blake\'s presence. Yang staring at Blake in realisation shows Emerald and Mercury in the background turning back to Hazel and Weiss.
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
[[quoteblock]]It's an idiot moment because, if she reasoned, instead of acting like an idiot (this is what the trope is about)... [[/quoteblock]]
to:
[[quoteblock]]It\'s an idiot moment because, if she reasoned, instead of acting like an idiot (this is what the trope is about)... [[/quoteblock]]
Changed line(s) 10 from:
n
The entry is claiming the scene sets up Emerald as having the time to reason through her options and that there's absolutely no doubt that the Semblance or chain would have stopped Yang had they been used.
to:
The entry is claiming the scene sets up Emerald as having the time to reason through her options and that there\'s absolutely no doubt that the Semblance or chain would have stopped Yang had they been used.
Changed line(s) 13 from:
n
This entry is therefore a shoehorn based on misrepresenting a scene using a justification based on something that never happened.
to:
This entry is therefore a shoehorn based on misrepresenting a scene using a justification that is based on something that never happened.
I was going to address your points about the battle, but it's very off-topic. I'll just point out that Weiss's action is what brings Blake to the room, and Weiss's reaction alerts the room to Blake's presence. Yang staring at Blake in realisation shows Emerald and Mercury in the background turning back to Hazel and Weiss.
to:
I was going to address your points about the battle, but it\'s very off-topic. I\'ll just point out that Weiss\'s action distracts everyone to the point of being what brings Blake to the room, and Weiss\'s reaction alerts the room to Blake\'s presence. Yang staring at Blake in realisation shows Emerald and Mercury in the background turning back to Hazel and Weiss.
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
[[quoteblock]]It's an idiot moment because, if she reasoned, instead of acting like an idiot (this is what the trope is about)... [[/quoteblock]]
to:
[[quoteblock]]It\'s an idiot moment because, if she reasoned, instead of acting like an idiot (this is what the trope is about)... [[/quoteblock]]
Changed line(s) 10 from:
n
The entry is claiming the scene sets up Emerald as having the time to reason through her options and that there's absolutely no doubt that the Semblance or chain would have stopped Yang had they been used.
to:
The entry is claiming the scene sets up Emerald as having the time to reason through her options and that there\'s absolutely no doubt that the Semblance or chain would have stopped Yang had they been used.
