Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / ExtraordinaryXMen

Go To

OR

Added: 570

Removed: 556

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Dork Age was renamed


* AudienceAlienatingEra: Not the title's fault per se, but it's emblematic of very contested direction the X-Men have been in since Comicbook/AvengersVsXMen (though some might say since Comicbook/HouseOfM). Namely, the decline of their general influence in the Marvel Universe and in real life as Disney/Marvel focused more on the properties they owned complete rights to film-wise. The fans finally had enough and responded with low sales for this title and other X-Men titles and the series ended in 2017 with a very hyped new direction after Comicbook/InhumansVsXmen.



* DorkAge: Not the title's fault per se, but it's emblematic of very contested direction the X-Men have been in since Comicbook/AvengersVsXMen (though some might say since Comicbook/HouseOfM). Namely, the decline of their general influence in the Marvel Universe and in real life as Disney/Marvel focused more on the properties they owned complete rights to film-wise. The fans finally had enough and responded with low sales for this title and other X-Men titles and the series ended in 2017 with a very hyped new direction after Comicbook/InhumansVsXmen.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Removing Flame Bait


* UnfortunateImplications: As [[http://comicsalliance.com/super-inhumans-vs-mutants/ this]] article notes, there is something disturbing about Marvel having a group that they've long used as a stand-in for the LGBT community getting wiped out in favor of the Inhumans, who've long represented intolerance and separatism.

to:

* UnfortunateImplications: As [[http://comicsalliance.com/super-inhumans-vs-mutants/ this]] article notes, there is something disturbing about Marvel having a group that they've long used as a stand-in for the LGBT community getting wiped out in favor of the Inhumans, who've long represented intolerance and separatism.

Added: 609

Removed: 617

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* DarknessInducedAudienceApathy: Creator/BrianMichaelBendis' X-Men run may have created a BrokenBase, but it's generally praised for showing some of the X-Men being more proactive in saving mutants and also a lot of humans being comfortable with mutants and supporting mutant rights. The sudden shift to seeing mutants (once again) being on the brink of extinction and being hated and feared -- to a level that's extreme, even for ''them'' -- once more hasn't sat well with the fanbase at all. It's even more jarring when ''All-New Wolverine'' and ''All-New X-Men'' barely deal with the Terrigen or hatred of mutants.


Added DiffLines:

* TooBleakStoppedCaring: Creator/BrianMichaelBendis' X-Men run may have created a BrokenBase, but it's generally praised for showing some of the X-Men being more proactive in saving mutants and also a lot of humans being comfortable with mutants and supporting mutant rights. The sudden shift to seeing mutants (once again) being on the brink of extinction and being hated and feared -- to a level that's extreme, even for ''them'' -- once more hasn't sat well with the fanbase at all. It's even more jarring when ''All-New Wolverine'' and ''All-New X-Men'' barely deal with the Terrigen or hatred of mutants.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArcFatigue: Whatever atrocity ComicBook/{{Cyclops}} committed that made him PersonaNonGrata to the world and the X-Men. All of the X-Men books, as well as ''Uncanny Inhumans'', have alluded to it without giving any hints whatsoever to the point that fans would rather they just spill it already instead of dancing around what exactly he did. It doesn't help that the way it's hidden is amazingly unnatural. Or that it was revealed [[ComicBook/DeathOfX he didn't actually do it]].

to:

* ArcFatigue: Whatever atrocity ComicBook/{{Cyclops}} committed that made him PersonaNonGrata to the world and the X-Men. All of the X-Men books, as well as ''Uncanny Inhumans'', have alluded to it without giving any hints whatsoever to the point that fans would rather they just spill it already instead of dancing around what exactly he did. It doesn't help that the way it's hidden is amazingly unnatural. Or that it was revealed [[ComicBook/DeathOfX he didn't actually do it]].it. Making the entire thing feel like a waste of reader's time]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArcFatigue: Whatever atrocity ComicBook/{{Cyclops}} committed that made him PersonaNonGrata to the world and the X-Men. All of the X-Men books, as well as ''Uncanny Inhumans'', have alluded to it without giving any hints whatsoever to the point that fans would rather they just spill it already instead of dancing around what exactly he did. It doesn't help that the way it's hidden is amazingly unnatural. Or it was revealed [[ComicBook/InhumansVsXMen he didn't did it]].

to:

* ArcFatigue: Whatever atrocity ComicBook/{{Cyclops}} committed that made him PersonaNonGrata to the world and the X-Men. All of the X-Men books, as well as ''Uncanny Inhumans'', have alluded to it without giving any hints whatsoever to the point that fans would rather they just spill it already instead of dancing around what exactly he did. It doesn't help that the way it's hidden is amazingly unnatural. Or that it was revealed [[ComicBook/InhumansVsXMen [[ComicBook/DeathOfX he didn't did actually do it]].

Top