REV6Pilot on May 25th 2017 at 7:45:27 AM
Last Edited By:
REV6Pilot on Jun 13th 2018 at 9:24:59 AM
Page Type: trope
Commonly, in video games, especially first-person ones, the lighting item doesn't have to be held in his hand, even if it's a big Maglite-style flashlight, a candle (especially if it's the nuclear type), or a photographer's floodlight set. In a variation, the light source might not even appear on the character model, though the light beam certainly does.
Depending on the developer's view on how the lighting is supposed to affect gameplay, can be an example of Acceptable Breaks from Reality. Compare Hollywood Darkness, where the lighting juggle is simplified for similar reasons.
Please note that true hands-free lights like headlamps, tactical gunlights or equippable items like clothing and armor enchanted with a light-giving spell don't fit this trope, even as aversionsnote ; after all, hands-free lighting items providing hands-free light like they're supposed to is just something that happens, not a trope. This is exclusively for light sources that are meant to be handheld but for some very unusual or just plain unexplained reason simply aren't, like in the page image.
- Dante doesn't have to hold the chunk of Luminite that he uses as a lantern in the first Devil May Cry. Admittedly, he's a half-devil with magical powers, but the jury's out on whether that works as a Hand Wave or if it's in play because lugging around the Luminite by hand would bog down the fun from the fast-paced gameplay.
- Averted in Dark Souls. Any light source that is not an enchanted piece of gear or a spell occupies a hand slot, so holding a lit torch or lantern will keep one of your hands busy.
- The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess: The lantern only needs to be held to burn webs or light torches. Link can hook it into his belt when using other items or weapons.
- Averted in Unturned. The flashlight has to be equipped and held by hand to be used as a light source, and it actually qualifies as a melee weapon. Any other source of light is either weapon-mounted, has to be thrown or placed on the ground, or features a headband.
- Played straight in Unreal. Both the tubular flashlight and the cumbersome-looking searchlight don't have to be fiddled with by hand, and the flares aren't tossed manually, they simply spawn and fly off in front of the player when activated.
- Averted in Doom 3, which based most of the visuals on the game having a lot of light and shadow contrast. As such, even if the static transfer power source gives it infinite power, it's not possible to have your flashlight on all the time unless you're fanatical about using it as a whacking stick. Not many people liked that design decision, however, and in fact one of the biggest complaints about the game at the time of launch was that the game is way too dark and being forced to swap light for weapon all the time was a chore. Corroborating this, the very first Game Mod to come out was a script change that attaches a light to the machine gun and shotgun, under the name "Duct Tape". The BFG Edition Updated Re Release does away with this entirely by having the flashlight mounted to the Marine's armor+ .
- Nightmare House. The flashlight itself plays it straight, but the flares avert it. They're props as far as the Source engine goes, not equipment, so you have to pick them up to carry them, and you can't use a weapon while you're doing it; to compensate at least a little, they themselves can be used as weapons by setting enemies on fire.
- Prey (2006): how exactly Tommy holds his Zippo without burning himself if he can keep it lit while holding a gun is unknown. It doesn't show up even when he's using one-handed hardware like the wrench.
- In both Left 4 Dead games, the only flashlights that the survivors possess are on the guns. That doesn't stop you from still having a light, perfectly centered on the screen at that, when wielding non-gun items like medkits and grenades. There are flashlights and floodlights in certain maps for Mood Lighting or indicating something important, usually around corpses, but they're impossible to pick up even if they do work.
- Downplayed almost to full aversion in Contagion. The light sources available are tactical lights on certain firearms, the cell phone (which you can't wield at the same time as a gun or item), and the rare angle-head pocket light. That last one does allow a survivor to have a light while wielding other items, but it takes up one precious inventory slot out of four total, and even then, it's subpar: when you're using it alongside a light-less gun it points awkwardly in a fixed direction that is rarely where you're looking or aiming at and it bobs everywhere when you're movingnote ; to have it point where you want it, you have to hold it in your hand, and you already have the phone for thatnote . The only aspects played straight are that the Player Characters don't have to move their hands to operate the light in their pocketnote , and the pocket light isn't modeled on the character's pocket when it's being used as such.
- In Far Cry, the beam of the angle-head light you can find is always on the center of the screen like it's being worn as a headlamp. It's never shown in Jack's character model when it can be seen in cutscenes either.
- Played straight with Barney in Half-Life: Blue Shift. He's shown from Gordon's perspective at the start of the core game clearly holding a flashlight, but when you play as him his light is exactly the same as Gordon's suit-mounted lamp, including the hands-free operation.
- In Serious Sam 3: BFE, Sam has a light that he turns on regardless of player input in basements and crypts where the sunlight doesn't reach. It's never shown where he carries it in his person or how he operates it. In an odd twist, the assault rifle has a mounted flashlight that Sam never uses.
"Let there be light!"
- In Bloodborne, the Hand Lantern is hung onto the user's belt, leaving both hands free to hold weapons while illuminating the surrounding area. However, it provides a weaker source of light than the always-handheld torches.
- Silent Hill:
- Heather plays it straight in Silent Hill 3 when she's using an alternate costume. Normally her light is an angle-head that goes into her breast pocket, as usual in the series, but when she's wearing anything else, her chest projects a beam with no material source.
- Averted in Silent Hill: Downpour. Murphy can clip the floodlight to the side of his belt by its handle, but it'll only shine straight ahead. He has to hold it in his hand to point it in another direction.
- Cry of Fear zig-zags it. When Simon holds the phone in his hand, it works with a typical flashlight beam; on the other hand, he can store it in his bag and light will shine around him like a dim lantern, though it's considerably brighter than one might expect from a phone's LED shining through the canvas of a dark-colored backpack. Dual Wielding is a major mechanic that allows Simon to use the phone light (and later on, a proper flashlight) alongside the Glock pistol, but it's unwieldy - you can only fire from the hip for whatever reason and accuracy is greatly reduced. The only truly hands-free lighting item is a tactical light that fits the Glock.
- Resident Evil 7 plays it straight with Ethan's and Mia's lights. They're never shown to have one on them, and can hold their weapons totally unencumbered by it.
- Zig-zagged in The Last of Us. Allies keep their flashlights in their hands, while Joel keeps his taped to his backpack's straps. Later when you get to play Ellie, she also tapes her flashlight to her backpack, despite holding it in her hands as an NPC.
- Played straight in The Evil Within 2: the flashlight clipped to Sebastian's body always points to wherever the camera's looking. Then again, the game does take place within the mental realm created by the STEM system.
- Averted in No More Room In Hell. The only light sources are a Zippo lighter and a big Maglite torch (that also takes up inventory space), and both have to be held to be used. To have a light shining while you're using another weapon, you must have the Maglite, and even then the weapon has to be one-handed, like a smaller melee weapon or a handgun, because the left hand is shown holding the Maglite.
- Stranded Deep used to play it straight, but later alphas came to avert it. Now both the floodlight and the lantern have to be handheld, though the lantern can be dropped on the ground as a static light source.
- Deadly Premonition: York has a regular tactical light, as can be seen in the morgue when he's examining Anna Graham's corpse. During gameplay, however, the beam just projects out of his front with no source.
Non-Video Game Examples
- Robin Series: At one point Tim held a small flashlight in his mouth in order to keep his hands free while dangling upside down from a skylight and trying to see what records were stolen from an old phone company database. When his line was cut he lost the flashlight as he opened his mouth to yell.
- The metafictional My Little Pony: Friendship Is Magic fic Daring Do and the Secret of the Fourth Wall mixes this trope with deliberate Plot Holes. In a few scenes, Rainbow Dash finds herself carrying a torch—even though there's no logical way she could have been carrying it for the last few minutes, and she can't remember picking it up. As the scene goes, Dash relights the torch after it was extinguished, then tries to pick it up in her mouth and tastes how disgusting it is. This gets her wondering how she held the torch before. It definitely wasn't in her mouth, or she would have tasted it, and both of her forelegs were occupied with a floor tile that she was examining—with the torch's light. So there's no way she could have been holding the torch, but it was just there somehow. It's one of several clues that she's somehow gotten stuck inside a fictional story.
- Pathfinder has a curious example: it formalizes a commonly-used kludge from Dungeons & Dragons with the Ioun Torch, a burnt-out Limited-Use Magical Device whose only remaining enchantment is to orbit its owner's head, subsequently enchanted with a Continual Flame spell to produce a torch that doesn't have to be held.
- Florence Ambrose of Freefall attached a rubber flange to a standard cylindrical flashlight in the Friday, 10 March 2000 strip. This allows her to hold the device in her teeth while keeping the light shining forward, which, as the page image shows, makes it seem like the torch is just hovering by the side of her muzzle.
- An urban legend from the Darwin Award website involves a burglar who held a flashlight in his mouth while breaking into a store via the skylight. He fell and landed on his face, driving the flashlight through the back of his throat like a bullet.
- Avatar: The Last Airbender: Sokka and Katara find themselves underground, using luminescent rocks to see. Katara holds it in her hand, while Sokka straps his to his head, leaving his hands free... to hold up his pants, as his belt is currently holding the rock on his forehead.
- A smaller flashlight* can be attached to the brim of a hat like a baseball cap or hard hat if its pocket clip is bezel-upnote . How well it works varies depending on the length and toughness of the pocket clip, the size and weight of the light, and how tough or flexible the hat's brim is.
- Much like Florence's example above, holding a light in your mouth if it's a small one is common practice among repairmen, plumbers and so on. The fact that aluminium, especially if it has a knurled texture, is murder on tooth enamel and dentures alike leads the people that do it often to wrap the part they bite down on with a softer material, going from rubber flanges and gaskets to duct tape.
Feedback: 32 replies