Follow TV Tropes

Strong, Independent Woman Syndrom

Go To

The writers work so hard to avoid writing a Damsel in Distress that they forget to make the love interest her own character.

This trope has been Nuked
Proposed By:
MadeofAwesome on Oct 5th 2012 at 2:54:35 PM
Name Space: Main
Page Type: Trope

You're creating a movie, and you need a love interest for your main character. You don't want to make her a weak Damsel-in-Distress type, so you make sure she's strong and independent. She doesn't need to change to be good enough for a man, the man needs to change to be good enough for her.

The problem? You go a bit too far. You're so busy not making her weak, you forget to give her any character flaws. Or weaknesses to overcome. Or lessons to learn. Or struggles of any sort. Or any storyline at all, outside of her romance with the main character.

In short, you forget to tell her story, or even make her a three-dimensional character. She only exists to play a specific role in a male character's story.

Examples include Captain Americaís Peggy, The Muppetís Miss Piggy and Mary, and The Artistís Peppy Miller.

Feedback: 9 replies

Oct 5th 2012 at 5:32:05 PM

Um... isn't this Mary Sue or God Mode Sue, more or less? Also, it sounds like a complaining trope, which we aren't keen on these days.

Oct 5th 2012 at 6:47:27 PM

No, it's neither. And Strugeons Tropes are a reality and young writers should be warned about them.

But, well, I disagree with the Peppy Miller example. She's... kind of flat... but then again most everyone in that film is, even the protagonist.

But, yeah, female leads in Give Geeks A Chance plots tend to have this trait, as does many an Action Girl, but it's not like the male Bad Ass has a lot of personality either, as a norm.

I think something good can be hammered out of this idea, but it might take work.

Oct 5th 2012 at 6:58:25 PM

^ It's probably a completely different YKTTW as well so I don't see any point in keeping this one.

Oct 5th 2012 at 7:56:15 PM

@Drac Monster i think it would be the bitch/Jerk Sue, also i'm not sure, but think The Nostalgia Chick review videos may be a good place to search for examples

Oct 5th 2012 at 9:50:00 PM

I think this looks like some variation on Mary Sue. Please give some context for your examples. I'm not very familiar with Captain America, but Miss Piggy is no flatter than any of the other muppets (I love The Muppets dearly, but they're not exactly known for being intricately-developed characters), and I quite liked Peppy Miller's character in The Artist. I think her development was understated, but it was definitely present.

Does this relate to Real Women Never Wear Dresses?

Oct 5th 2012 at 10:59:38 PM

I thought the point of Mary Sue was that the audience is supposed to want to identify with Mary Sue because she's so perfect. In this trope, it looks like the audience is supposed to want to identify with the male lead because he's got such a perfect girlfriend.

Definitely looks like the beginnings of a good idea, although I'm amazed T.V. Tropes doesn't have something like this already!

Oct 6th 2012 at 5:51:14 AM

<Mod speaking>

This concept is covered in the tropes mentioned above, in ways that are much less vague. Discarding this.