Follow TV Tropes

Following

Context YMMV / PrincessJellyfish

Go To

1* BaseBreakingCharacter: Many think that Mayaya's constant overreactions and [[NoIndoorVoice tendency to scream most of her dialogue]] are annoying. This turns a lot of readers off, and especially viewers of the anime, where she's [[CompressedAdaptation reduced to a gag character]]. Later in the manga, she gets more time to help with the Jellyfish clothing line along with the other Amars, as well as an [[HiddenDepths expanded backstory]]. Some readers still point to more damning actions in her backstory [[spoiler:like running away from her home when her mother asked her to do some basic chores and stealing money from her senile grandfather,]] while other readers look past these transgressions and appreciate the sympathetic light placed on a character with greater difficulties socializing than even the other Amars, as well as her growth over the story. There's also plenty of anime-onlies that find her antics and overreactions hilarious.
2* BrokenBase: The resolution of the manga's RomanceArc, and the LoveTriangle between Shu, Tsukimi and Kuranosuke. In the ending, [[spoiler:Kuranosuke and Shu are still in love with her, but decide to live together with the Amars with Tsukimi platonically and basically let fate decide if one day Tsukimi will choose one of them. This is bound to leave Kuranosuke/Tsukimi fans, who argue that the manga was essentially those two characters' relationship's journey, unsatisfied, and leaves the smaller Shu/Tsukimi camp hopeful, as Shu states that he hasn't given up on her, but ultimately with nothing to go on. Another camp just hates the lack of resolution itself]]. Of course, some people did like the ending, stating that it's not nonsensical for a manga that doesn't often go the traditional way to end like this (indeed, the narrator, presumably the mangaka herself, tells you to not pay much attention to it, as it is a 21st century princess tale, after all), that ''Princess Jellyfish'' [[spoiler: was never ''that'' focused on the romance anyway, and that the ending manages to preserve the friendship between the three characters for a longer time (which is clearly Kuranosuke's way of thinking in the manga itself when suggesting that they all live together)]].
3* CargoShip: Hanamori will do anything for his Benzs.
4* GermansLoveDavidHasselhoff: While the manga is no slacker in its home country, it is ''very'' popular in the West. The author even comments on it in an omake, stating she was surprised with this popularity and with ''Princess Jellyfish'' being chosen as one of the 50 books for teens by the New York Public Library, as well as with the amount of cosplayers of the series in manga events overseas. Hilariously, her editor is also drawn in the same omake saying that he has no idea how this happened, as they didn't do anything in particular with this goal in mind.
5* HollywoodHomely: Even in her frumpy clothes, Tsukimi is still pretty adorable. Which actually may be the point, anyway.
6* HollywoodPudgy: In addition to this, most people probably wouldn't even realize Tsukimi is meant to be chubby, if not for some offhand dialogue about how she can't fit into Kuranosuke's mother's clothes and the fact that she has to wear a size large for a dress from her own brand. You can only really tell in some of the colored pin-ups -- most of the time she's just as cartoonishly skinny as everyone else.
7* HoYay: Several male characters find Kuranosuke very attractive as Kurako, which isn't all surprising given that they don't know his true gender. Hanamori on the other hand, knows the secret and still mentions that he gets turned on by him sometimes, and that if Kuranosuke was a woman, he'd hit on him on spot.
8* MemeticMutation: AFROSEALED!
9* MoralEventHorizon: Inari [[SlippingAMickey slipping Shuu a mickey]], molesting him, and tricking him into thinking they slept together.
10* TheScrappy: Inari, though it does tend to depend on whether the fan in question has only watched the anime or continued on with the manga. For those who stopped with the series, she's often the most hated character in the show (see MoralEventHorizon for their reasoning). But for those who carried on with the manga, she's liked better or at least tolerated. It doesn't help that just as she was starting to get the tiniest bit of development beyond amoral FemmeFatale, the anime ended and cut it short. Even for some manga fans, the damage was done.
11* {{Squick}}: Any scene with Kuranosuke's uncle, the PM, lusting after the cross-dressed Kuranosuke.
12* UnintentionallyUnsympathetic: The Amars. We're meant to sympathize with them for not fitting into society, but the hostility they show towards pretty/fashionable women, even ones who are being nice to them, comes off as elitist.
13* UnnecessaryMakeover: Tsukimi is arguably a lot better-looking sans makeup and flashy clothes. The same argument could likely be applied to the rest of the Nuns as well.
14* ValuesDissonance:
15** Kuranosuke's father not only brings Kuranosuke, the fruit of his affair, under the same roof as his wife; she also ''leaves home for some period of time when the lover and her son arrive, so nobody is uncomfortable''.
16** Also, Kuranosuke's mother despairs about being parted with her son, stating, that if he was a girl, he "could" live with her. Apparently, with HeirClubForMen she just has no say in this.
17* TheWoobie: Shu. He's a romantically inept virgin at 30-years-old who shuns romantic relationships thanks to the trauma of witnessing [[spoiler:his father having an affair with Kuranosuke's mother]]. Then, he was sexually assaulted by Inari, who made him believe they had sex while he was drugged and blackmailed him with this. To make things worse, his father encouraged the relationship despite his obvious terror of her. He also falls in love with Tsukimi, but even though she seemed to like him back, she eventually turns down his proposal, having seemingly fell for his brother instead.

Top