Follow TV Tropes

Following

History NightmareFuel / JonathanCreek

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Mother Redcap'' manages to combine NothingIsScarier with RealismInducedHorror in one fell swoop. First, there is the terrifying tale of the pub where people would drop dead in sheer terror after seeing something through one of the rear windows. Then comes the reveal that [[spoiler: the victims were actually being electrocuted to death by a trap set up by the landlord.]] Both the legend and the truth manage to be equally disturbing.

to:

* ''Mother Redcap'' manages to combine NothingIsScarier with RealismInducedHorror in one fell swoop. First, there is the terrifying tale of the pub where people would drop dead in sheer terror after seeing something through one of the rear windows. Then comes the reveal that [[spoiler: the victims were actually being electrocuted to death by a trap set up by the landlord.]] Both the legend and the truth manage to be equally disturbing.disturbing.
* ''Gorgons Wood'' is one of the grimmer episodes of the already-dark fourth season especially after the midpoint [[spoiler:with the introduction of the disfigured prostitute and her violent pimp, and the uncle-niece IncestSubtext component of the plot becoming clear.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Made even worse at the end of the episode -- it turns out he's flying back to States with a package (heavily implied to contain that head). After seeing that scene, you will be REALLY glad for all those X-ray machines at the airports that ensure people can't bring severed human heads to planes anymore.

to:

** Made even worse at the end of the episode -- it turns out he's flying back to States with a package (heavily implied to contain that head). After seeing that scene, you will be REALLY glad for all those X-ray machines at the airports that ensure people can't bring severed human heads to planes anymore.anymore.
* ''Mother Redcap'' manages to combine NothingIsScarier with RealismInducedHorror in one fell swoop. First, there is the terrifying tale of the pub where people would drop dead in sheer terror after seeing something through one of the rear windows. Then comes the reveal that [[spoiler: the victims were actually being electrocuted to death by a trap set up by the landlord.]] Both the legend and the truth manage to be equally disturbing.

Added: 923

Changed: 1193

Removed: 292

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In the 1998 Christmas special, ''Black Canary'', the backstory involves a magician's assistant who died when some equipment spectacularly malfunctioned and she got sliced in half by a table saw... lengthwise. Gruesome, but it just seems like your run-of-the-mill sort of gruesome--until you really think about the concept of ''lengthwise''. From the bottom up. Maddy sums it up best: "I'm gonna have to sleep with a saucepan between my legs!" Even worse, later there are several flashbacks to this incident, which show that the poor woman was conscious and screaming for ''entirely'' too long.
** To make it worse, there are hints that her twin sister deliberately sabotaged the trick so she could take her place. To make it EVEN WORSE, it COULD have just been an exploit of a real accident -- since everyone involved is dead, the family has no way to ever find out the truth.

to:

* In ''Jack in the Box'', it turns out the murderer actually bricked himself up at the crime scene then committed suicide. Meaning that every single time Jonathan and Maddy investigate the murder scene for clues ''there was an unseen dead body right behind the wall''.
** Also, the murderer turns out to have been the man who was let out of prison at the start of the episode thanks in no small part to Maddy getting involved in his family's campaign to clear his name -- and that he ''actually had'' committed the murder that led to him going to prison in the first place. Meaning that Maddy, a journalist who's dedicated to exposing injustice, has helped a murderer get out of prison and kill again.
* In the 1998 Christmas special, ''Black Canary'', the backstory involves a magician's assistant magician who died during a rehearsal when some equipment spectacularly malfunctioned and she got sliced in half by a table saw...saw ... lengthwise. Gruesome, but it just seems like your run-of-the-mill sort of gruesome--until gruesome -- until you really think ''really think'' about the concept of ''lengthwise''. From the bottom up. Maddy sums it up best: "I'm gonna have to sleep with a saucepan between my legs!" Even worse, later there are several flashbacks to this incident, which show that the poor woman was conscious and screaming for ''entirely'' ''far'' too long.
** To make it worse, there are hints that her twin sister deliberately sabotaged the trick so that she could kill her and take her place. place.
***
To make it EVEN WORSE, it COULD could have just been an exploit of a real genuine accident -- which the sister decided to exploit. However, since everyone involved is dead, she later dies, the family has no way to ever find out the truth.



** Made even worse at the end of the episode -- it turns out he's flying back to States with a package (heavily implied to contain that head). After seeing that scene, you will be REALLY glad for all those X-ray machines at the airports that ensure people can't bring severed human heads to planes anymore.
* In only the second episode ''Jack in the Box'', it turns out the murderer actually bricked himself up at the crime scene then committed suicide. Meaning that every single time Jonathan and Maddy investigate the murder scene for clues ''there was an unseen dead body right behind the wall''.

to:

** Made even worse at the end of the episode -- it turns out he's flying back to States with a package (heavily implied to contain that head). After seeing that scene, you will be REALLY glad for all those X-ray machines at the airports that ensure people can't bring severed human heads to planes anymore.
* In only the second episode ''Jack in the Box'', it turns out the murderer actually bricked himself up at the crime scene then committed suicide. Meaning that every single time Jonathan and Maddy investigate the murder scene for clues ''there was an unseen dead body right behind the wall''.
anymore.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Made even worse at the end of the episode -- it turns out he's flying back to States with a package (heavily implied to contain that head). After seeing that scene, you will be REALLY glad for all those X-ray machines at the airports that ensure people can't bring severed human heads to planes anymore.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** To make it worse, there are hints that her twin sister deliberately sabotaged the trick so she could take her place. To make it EVEN WORSE, it COULD have just been an exploit of a real accident -- since everyone involved is dead, the family has no way to ever find out the truth.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The stalker in ''Danse Macabre''. Initially his presence is only mildly unsettling - until [[spoiler:he chops the head off of the corpse of his obsession.]]

to:

* The stalker in ''Danse Macabre''. Initially his presence is only mildly unsettling - until [[spoiler:he chops the head off of the corpse of his obsession.]]]]
* In only the second episode ''Jack in the Box'', it turns out the murderer actually bricked himself up at the crime scene then committed suicide. Meaning that every single time Jonathan and Maddy investigate the murder scene for clues ''there was an unseen dead body right behind the wall''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''The Eyes of Tiresias'', a woman is having nightmares about people who are eventually murdered. At first nothing special, just your average ''Jonathan Creek'' episode. Then we get to see one of her dreams, in which a one-eyed man stabs her to death with a sword. Firstly, the amount of blood is really creepy, but then he turns around and has an actually pretty horrible looking mask on. It can really shock you when you're not ready for it.

to:

* ''The Eyes of Tiresias'', a woman is having nightmares about people who are eventually murdered. At first nothing special, just your average ''Jonathan Creek'' episode. Then we get to see one of her dreams, in which a one-eyed man stabs her to death with a sword. Firstly, the amount of blood is really creepy, but then he turns around and has an actually pretty horrible looking mask on. It can really shock you when you're not ready for it.it.
* The stalker in ''Danse Macabre''. Initially his presence is only mildly unsettling - until [[spoiler:he chops the head off of the corpse of his obsession.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Moved from the general Live Action TV NF page.

Added DiffLines:

A series about locked room murder mysteries is expected to be somewhat scary. But sometimes, ''Series/JonathanCreek'' goes that extra mile.

Heavy spoilers below.

----
* ''The Grinning Man'': The water tank. There are likely several people swearing off baths forever because of that scene.
** The picture of said "Grinning Man" himself is very strong NightmareFuel.
* ''The Three Gamblers'': An evil old man is killed after a drug deal goes wrong. He gets six bullets in the head, and is dumped in the cellar of an abandoned house nearby; they put a wardrobe in front of the door. Terrified that the old guy will still come back for revenge, one of the killers insists on going back to check he hasn't moved... only ''he has'', crawled to the top of the stairs and apparently clawed at the door, despite being very dead. And looking it. He ''was'' dead, but the cellar had flooded, and the body had floated to the top of the stairs, and still looked creepy as hell.
* In the 1998 Christmas special, ''Black Canary'', the backstory involves a magician's assistant who died when some equipment spectacularly malfunctioned and she got sliced in half by a table saw... lengthwise. Gruesome, but it just seems like your run-of-the-mill sort of gruesome--until you really think about the concept of ''lengthwise''. From the bottom up. Maddy sums it up best: "I'm gonna have to sleep with a saucepan between my legs!" Even worse, later there are several flashbacks to this incident, which show that the poor woman was conscious and screaming for ''entirely'' too long.
* ''The Eyes of Tiresias'', a woman is having nightmares about people who are eventually murdered. At first nothing special, just your average ''Jonathan Creek'' episode. Then we get to see one of her dreams, in which a one-eyed man stabs her to death with a sword. Firstly, the amount of blood is really creepy, but then he turns around and has an actually pretty horrible looking mask on. It can really shock you when you're not ready for it.

Top