Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / MilitariesAreUseless

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Downplayed when they finally admit that aliens are indeed invading : their only response is to send some Redshirts die to support the main cast, and give them heavy weaponry to toy with.

to:

** Downplayed when they finally admit that aliens are indeed invading : their only response is to they send some Redshirts die to support the main cast, and give them heavy weaponry to toy with.with, but don't have a very important role in the end.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[SubvertedTrope Subverted]] in ''FullMetalAlchemist'' : at the very beginning, [[TheHero Edward Elric]] confronts the Head of the local CorruptChurch without any help of the army. He later explains that, after dealing with the leader, he sent a report to his superiors in the military, who reacted by sending troops to deal with the trouble created by the collapsing of the church. [[spoiler: It's then revealed that those troops were sent to replace those of the General in charge of the region, because they were dealing ''too well'' with the population, while his superiors needed a bloodshed]].

to:

* [[SubvertedTrope Subverted]] in ''FullMetalAlchemist'' : ''Manga/FullmetalAlchemist'': at the very beginning, [[TheHero Edward Elric]] confronts the Head of the local CorruptChurch without any help of the army. He later explains that, after dealing with the leader, he sent a report to his superiors in the military, who reacted by sending troops to deal with the trouble created by the collapsing of the church. [[spoiler: It's [[spoiler:It's then revealed that those troops were sent to replace those of the General in charge of the region, because they were dealing ''too well'' with the population, while his superiors needed a bloodshed]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Deleted the comma after \"Edward Elric\"


* [[SubvertedTrope Subverted]] in ''FullMetalAlchemist'' : at the very beginning, [[TheHero Edward Elric]], confronts the Head of the local CorruptChurch without any help of the army. He later explains that, after dealing with the leader, he sent a report to his superiors in the military, who reacted by sending troops to deal with the trouble created by the collapsing of the church. [[spoiler: It's then revealed that those troops were sent to replace those of the General in charge of the region, because they were dealing ''too well'' with the population, while his superiors needed a bloodshed]].

to:

* [[SubvertedTrope Subverted]] in ''FullMetalAlchemist'' : at the very beginning, [[TheHero Edward Elric]], Elric]] confronts the Head of the local CorruptChurch without any help of the army. He later explains that, after dealing with the leader, he sent a report to his superiors in the military, who reacted by sending troops to deal with the trouble created by the collapsing of the church. [[spoiler: It's then revealed that those troops were sent to replace those of the General in charge of the region, because they were dealing ''too well'' with the population, while his superiors needed a bloodshed]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[SubvertedTrope Subverted]] in ''FullMetalAlchemist'' : in the very beginning, [[TheHero Edward Elric]], confronts the Head of the local CorruptChurch without any help of the army. He later explains that, after dealing with the leader, he sent a report to his superiors in the military, who reacted by sending troops to deal with the trouble created by the collapsing of the church. [[spoiler: It's then revealed that those troops were sent to replace those of the General in charge of the region, because they were dealing ''too well'' with the population, while his superiors needed a bloodshed]].

to:

* [[SubvertedTrope Subverted]] in ''FullMetalAlchemist'' : in at the very beginning, [[TheHero Edward Elric]], confronts the Head of the local CorruptChurch without any help of the army. He later explains that, after dealing with the leader, he sent a report to his superiors in the military, who reacted by sending troops to deal with the trouble created by the collapsing of the church. [[spoiler: It's then revealed that those troops were sent to replace those of the General in charge of the region, because they were dealing ''too well'' with the population, while his superiors needed a bloodshed]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* [[SubvertedTrope Subverted]] in ''FullMetalAlchemist'' : in the very beginning, [[TheHero Edward Elric]], confronts the Head of the local CorruptChurch without any help of the army. He later explains that, after dealing with the leader, he sent a report to his superiors in the military, who reacted by sending troops to deal with the trouble created by the collapsing of the church. [[spoiler: It's then revealed that those troops were sent to replace those of the General in charge of the region, because they were dealing ''too well'' with the population, while his superiors needed a bloodshed]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

However, this tends to be averted when the story follows at least one character in the military, especially when they're the one(s) giving orders : after all, it's not very interesting to follow the story of someone making bad decision after bad decision, while having the army make good ones without being an important part of the narrative can take the tension away from the actual characters. In some cases, a middle ground is reached : the military ''does'' help the characters, and thus aren't completely useless, but since they aren't the main part of the story they don't take actual initiatives, and let the protagonists do most of the job.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
I guess that\'s what fit the best. Unless it\'s \"Too dumb to live\"


* This was invoked in ''Film/PacificRim'', since director Creator/GuillermoDelToro is a pacifist and wanted to avoid the military-shilling of the ''{{Film/Transformers}}'' films. Of note is that the conventional military took '''six days''' to defeat the first {{Kaiju}}, and subsequent battles usually ended with nukes after tons of collateral damage. Once [[HumongousMecha the Jaeger Program]] arrived, the world began getting greater victories, but [[UngratefulBastard the governments quickly cut their support for it]] once the Kaiju began matching Jaegers in power. By 2025, the Jaeger Program is a partially autonomous organization but on its last legs as its funding drains.

to:

* This was invoked in ''Film/PacificRim'', since director Creator/GuillermoDelToro is a pacifist and wanted to avoid the military-shilling of the ''{{Film/Transformers}}'' films. Of note is that the conventional military took '''six days''' to defeat the first {{Kaiju}}, and subsequent battles usually ended with nukes after tons of collateral damage. Once [[HumongousMecha the Jaeger Program]] arrived, the world began getting greater victories, but [[UngratefulBastard [[NoHeroDiscount the governments quickly cut their support for it]] once the Kaiju began matching Jaegers in power. By 2025, the Jaeger Program is a partially autonomous organization but on its last legs as its funding drains.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Re-re-re-added the animorphs example (more precisions in the discussion page).

Added DiffLines:

* Played straight in most of ''Literature/{{Animorphs}}'', due to the AdultsAreUseless setting : the military doesn't seem very worried about the Earth being invaded by aliens. [[spoiler:Even after losing an aircraft carrier (and everybody on it), the kid's hometown being quarantined, and the governor of California (no, [[ArnoldSchwarzenegger not this one]]) making an official speech about how the aliens are invading the world,]] [[ExtraStrengthMasquerade they simply consider this as a hoax]] and don't bother investigate.
** Downplayed when they finally admit that aliens are indeed invading : their only response is to send some Redshirts die to support the main cast, and give them heavy weaponry to toy with.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* This was invoked in ''Film/PacificRim'', since director Creator/GuillermoDelToro is a pacifist and wanted to avoid the military-shilling of the ''{{Film/Transformers}}'' films. Of note is that the conventional military took '''six days''' to defeat the first {{Kaiju}}, and subsequent battles usually ended with nukes after tons of collateral damage. Once [[HumongousMecha the Jaeger Program]] arrived, the world began getting greater victories, but [[DudeWheresMyRespect the governments quickly cut their support for it]] once the Kaiju began matching Jaegers in power. By 2025, the Jaeger Program is a partially autonomous organization but on its last legs as its funding drains.

to:

* This was invoked in ''Film/PacificRim'', since director Creator/GuillermoDelToro is a pacifist and wanted to avoid the military-shilling of the ''{{Film/Transformers}}'' films. Of note is that the conventional military took '''six days''' to defeat the first {{Kaiju}}, and subsequent battles usually ended with nukes after tons of collateral damage. Once [[HumongousMecha the Jaeger Program]] arrived, the world began getting greater victories, but [[DudeWheresMyRespect [[UngratefulBastard the governments quickly cut their support for it]] once the Kaiju began matching Jaegers in power. By 2025, the Jaeger Program is a partially autonomous organization but on its last legs as its funding drains.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* This was invoked in ''Film/PacificRim'', since director Creator/GuillermoDelToro is a pacifist and wanted to avoid the military-shilling of the ''{{Film/Transformers}}'' films. Of note is that the conventional military took '''six days''' to defeat the first {{Kaiju}}, and subsequent battles usually ended with nukes after tons of collateral damage. Once [[HumongousMecha the Jaeger Program]] was arrived, the world began getting greater victories, but [[DudeWheresMyRespect the governments quickly cut their support for it]] once the Kaiju began matching Jaegers in power. By 2025, the Jaeger Program is a partially autonomous organization but on its last legs as its funding drains.

to:

* This was invoked in ''Film/PacificRim'', since director Creator/GuillermoDelToro is a pacifist and wanted to avoid the military-shilling of the ''{{Film/Transformers}}'' films. Of note is that the conventional military took '''six days''' to defeat the first {{Kaiju}}, and subsequent battles usually ended with nukes after tons of collateral damage. Once [[HumongousMecha the Jaeger Program]] was arrived, the world began getting greater victories, but [[DudeWheresMyRespect the governments quickly cut their support for it]] once the Kaiju began matching Jaegers in power. By 2025, the Jaeger Program is a partially autonomous organization but on its last legs as its funding drains.

Added: 89

Changed: 687

Removed: 716

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Only response? It\'s what Jake ASKED them to do.



to:

* This was invoked in ''Film/PacificRim'', since director Creator/GuillermoDelToro is a pacifist and wanted to avoid the military-shilling of the ''{{Film/Transformers}}'' films. Of note is that the conventional military took '''six days''' to defeat the first {{Kaiju}}, and subsequent battles usually ended with nukes after tons of collateral damage. Once [[HumongousMecha the Jaeger Program]] was arrived, the world began getting greater victories, but [[DudeWheresMyRespect the governments quickly cut their support for it]] once the Kaiju began matching Jaegers in power. By 2025, the Jaeger Program is a partially autonomous organization but on its last legs as its funding drains.
-->'''Stacker Pentecost''': We're not an army anymore, Mr. Beckett. We're the resistance.



* Played straight in most of ''Literature/{{Animorphs}}'', due to the AdultsAreUseless setting : the military doesn't seem very worried about the Earth being invaded by aliens. [[spoiler:Even after losing an aircraft carrier (and everybody on it), the kid's hometown being quarantined, and the governor of California (no, [[ArnoldSchwarzenegger not this one]]) making an official speech about how the aliens are invading the world,]] [[ExtraStrengthMasquerade they simply consider this as a hoax]] and don't bother investigate.
** Downplayed when they finally admit that aliens are indeed invading : their only response is to send some Redshirts die to support the main cast, and give them heavy weaponry to toy with.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The aim, of course, is to make he Hero the only one who can defeat the bad guys: how can you save your world when it can defend itself with no problem thanks to its competent army? That's why you often find this in {{Superhero}} settings. It's also quite frequent in stories about an AlienInvasion or a ZombieApocalypse, because a war consisting of large open {{CurbStompBattle}}s is a quicker way to show how the enemy won than the long and complex battles that would have occurred had the military been competent. And of course, don't expect anything from them when AdultsAreUseless: since most armies are made of adults, they're unlikely to help.

to:

The aim, of course, is to make he the Hero the only one who can defeat the bad guys: how can you save your world when it can defend itself with no problem thanks to its competent army? That's why you often find this in {{Superhero}} settings. It's also quite frequent in stories about an AlienInvasion or a ZombieApocalypse, because a war consisting of large open {{CurbStompBattle}}s is a quicker way to show how the enemy won than the long and complex battles that would have occurred had the military been competent. And of course, don't expect anything from them when AdultsAreUseless: since most armies are made of adults, they're unlikely to help.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Deleted a redundant pothole


The aim, of course, is to make the {{Hero}} the only one who can defeat the bad guys: how can you save your world when it can defend itself with no problem thanks to its competent army? That's why you often find this in {{Superhero}} settings. It's also quite frequent in stories about an AlienInvasion or a ZombieApocalypse, because a war consisting of large open {{CurbStompBattle}}s is a quicker way to show how the enemy won than the long and complex battles that would have occurred had the military been competent. And of course, don't expect anything from them when AdultsAreUseless: since most armies are made of adults, they're unlikely to help.

to:

The aim, of course, is to make the {{Hero}} he Hero the only one who can defeat the bad guys: how can you save your world when it can defend itself with no problem thanks to its competent army? That's why you often find this in {{Superhero}} settings. It's also quite frequent in stories about an AlienInvasion or a ZombieApocalypse, because a war consisting of large open {{CurbStompBattle}}s is a quicker way to show how the enemy won than the long and complex battles that would have occurred had the military been competent. And of course, don't expect anything from them when AdultsAreUseless: since most armies are made of adults, they're unlikely to help.

Added: 1094

Changed: 378

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Played straight in most of ''Literature/{{Animorphs}}'', due to the AdultsAreUseless setting : the military doesn't seem very worried about the Earth being invaded by aliens. [[spoiler:Even after losing an aircraft carrier (and everybody on it), the kid's hometown being quarantined, and the governor of California (no, [[ArnoldSchwarzenegger not this one]]) making an official speech about how the aliens are invading the world,]] [[ExtraStrengthMasquerade they simply consider this as a hoax]] and don't bother investigate.
** Downplayed when they finally admit that aliens are indeed invading : their only response is to send some Redshirts die to support the main cast, and give them heavy weaponry to toy with.
* The aurors in ''Literature/HarryPotter'' may qualify, depending on whether you consider them as an army or not. In the sixth book, they fail to kill or capture any Death Eater, put innocents in jail ([[NiceJobBreakingItHero where they are captured]] and {{Brainwashed}} by said Death Eaters) instead, and do nothing to prevent the ministry from being infiltrated by Voldemort.



* The aurors in ''Literature/HarryPotter'' may qualify, depending on whether you consider them as an army or not. In the sixth book, they fail to kill or capture any Death Eater, put innocents in jail ([[NiceJobBreakingItHero where they are captured]] and {{Brainwashed}} by said Death Eaters) instead, and do nothing to prevent the ministry from being infiltrated by Voldemort.

to:

* The aurors in ''Literature/HarryPotter'' may qualify, depending on whether you consider them as an army or not. In the sixth book, they fail to kill or capture any Death Eater, put innocents in jail ([[NiceJobBreakingItHero where they are captured]] and {{Brainwashed}} by said Death Eaters) instead, and do nothing to prevent the ministry from being infiltrated by Voldemort.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The aim, of course, is to make the {{Hero}} the only one who can defeat the bad guys: how can you save your world when it can defend itself with no problem thanks to its competent army? That's why you often find this in {{Superhero}} settings. It's also quite frequent in stories about an AlienInvasion or a ZombieApocalypse, because a war consisting of large open [[CurbStompBattle Curb-Stomp Battles]] is a quicker way to show how the enemy won than the long and complex battles that would have occurred had the military been competent. And of course, don't expect anything from them when AdultsAreUseless: since most armies are made of adults, they're unlikely to help.

to:

The aim, of course, is to make the {{Hero}} the only one who can defeat the bad guys: how can you save your world when it can defend itself with no problem thanks to its competent army? That's why you often find this in {{Superhero}} settings. It's also quite frequent in stories about an AlienInvasion or a ZombieApocalypse, because a war consisting of large open [[CurbStompBattle Curb-Stomp Battles]] {{CurbStompBattle}}s is a quicker way to show how the enemy won than the long and complex battles that would have occurred had the military been competent. And of course, don't expect anything from them when AdultsAreUseless: since most armies are made of adults, they're unlikely to help.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* At the end of ''WesternAnimation/TheIncredibles'', when the [[spoiler: [[AttackOfThe50FootWhatever Giant Omnidroid]] attacks some random cities]], the army's response is basically "send some guys attack it with tanks [[FiveRoundsRapid and submachine-guns]], [[ScrewThisImOutOfHere then run]]!" EMI bombs, anyone?

to:

* At the end of ''WesternAnimation/TheIncredibles'', when the [[spoiler: [[AttackOfThe50FootWhatever Giant Omnidroid]] attacks some random cities]], the army's response is basically "send some guys attack it with tanks [[FiveRoundsRapid and submachine-guns]], [[ScrewThisImOutOfHere then run]]!" EMI EMP bombs, anyone?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The aim, of course, is to make the {{Hero}} the only one who can defeat the bag guys : how can you save your world when it can defend itself with no problem thanks to its competent army ? That's why you often find this in {{Superhero}} settings. It's also quite frequent in stories about an AlienInvasion or a ZombieApocalypse, because a war consisting of large open [[CurbStompBattle Curb-Stomp Battles]] is a quicker way to show how the enemy won than the long and complex battles that would have occurred had the military been competent. And of course, don't expect anything from them when AdultsAreUseless : since most armies are made of adults, they're unlikely to help.

Note that this trope isn't about lots of soldiers dying: that's the RedShirtArmy. A military can achieve great victories by [[ZergRush swarming the enemy with disposable soldiers]], or loose everything while keeping a low casulaty record. This trope comes when the military as an institution has no use.

to:

The aim, of course, is to make the {{Hero}} the only one who can defeat the bag guys : bad guys: how can you save your world when it can defend itself with no problem thanks to its competent army ? army? That's why you often find this in {{Superhero}} settings. It's also quite frequent in stories about an AlienInvasion or a ZombieApocalypse, because a war consisting of large open [[CurbStompBattle Curb-Stomp Battles]] is a quicker way to show how the enemy won than the long and complex battles that would have occurred had the military been competent. And of course, don't expect anything from them when AdultsAreUseless : AdultsAreUseless: since most armies are made of adults, they're unlikely to help.

Note that this trope isn't about lots of soldiers dying: that's the RedShirtArmy. A military can achieve great victories by [[ZergRush swarming the enemy with disposable soldiers]], or loose everything while keeping a low casulaty casualty record. This trope comes when the military as an institution has is of no use.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
The aurors are what\'s the most close to a military in the Potter Verse. Plus, they don\'t qualify as Police Are Useless in the sixth book (only the fith) since they do try to help. They\'re just that bad at it.



to:

* The aurors in ''Literature/HarryPotter'' may qualify, depending on whether you consider them as an army or not. In the sixth book, they fail to kill or capture any Death Eater, put innocents in jail ([[NiceJobBreakingItHero where they are captured]] and {{Brainwashed}} by said Death Eaters) instead, and do nothing to prevent the ministry from being infiltrated by Voldemort.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Tanks For Nothing isn\'t really a subtrope : it\'s closer to Redshirt Army than to this


First cause of EasilyConqueredWorld, though some countries in TV Land can have the worst possible army without being conquered. Can include PoliceAreUseless and NoFEMAResponse, where they don't even try to help. Often overlap with ConservationOfNinjutsu. Supertrope of TanksForNothing. Sister trope of ArmiesAreEvil.

to:

First cause of EasilyConqueredWorld, though some countries in TV Land can have the worst possible army without being conquered. Can include PoliceAreUseless and NoFEMAResponse, where they don't even try to help. Often overlap with ConservationOfNinjutsu. Supertrope of ConservationOfNinjutsu, and TanksForNothing. Sister trope of ArmiesAreEvil.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* At the end of ''WesternAnimation/TheIncredibles'', when the [[spoiler: [[AttackOfThe50FootWhatever Giant Omnidroid]] attacks some random cities]], the army's response is basically "send some guys attack it with tanks [[FiveRoundsRapid and submachine-guns]], then do nothing". EMI bombs, anyone?

to:

* At the end of ''WesternAnimation/TheIncredibles'', when the [[spoiler: [[AttackOfThe50FootWhatever Giant Omnidroid]] attacks some random cities]], the army's response is basically "send some guys attack it with tanks [[FiveRoundsRapid and submachine-guns]], [[ScrewThisImOutOfHere then do nothing". run]]!" EMI bombs, anyone?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
They helped with giving the kids bombs to blow up the Yeerk Pool, something the kids couldn\'t do since the beginning of the series.

Changed: 4

Removed: 623

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Also not true. They weren\'t unintentionally redshirts. They specifically staged a diversion to keep Visser One from uncovering The Plan.


* ''{{LuckyLuke}}'' is an AffectionateParody of the Western genre, so of course the cavalry is always either critically late to the action, or completely useless despite anything they might attempt.

to:

* ''{{LuckyLuke}}'' ''LuckyLuke'' is an AffectionateParody of the Western genre, so of course the cavalry is always either critically late to the action, or completely useless despite anything they might attempt.



* In ''Literature/{{Animorphs}}'', due to the AdultsAreUseless setting, the military doesn't seem very worried about the Earth being invaded by aliens. Even after losing an aircraft carrier (and everybody on it), the kid's hometown being quarantined, and the governor of California (no, [[ArnoldSchwarzenegger not this one]]) making an official speech about how the aliens are invading the world, [[ExtraStrengthMasquerade they simply consider this as a hoax]] and don't bother investigate. When they finally admit that aliens are indeed invading, their only response is to send some Redshirts die to support the main cast.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Not true. The Army IS shown briefly arriving at New York and setting up position, and they did assist with the film, as seen in the Trivia tab.


* In ''Film/TheAvengers'', the army doesn't send any troops to help the titular heroes defending New York against the alien invasion. And of course, they don't think one second about sending a single missile to destroy the one building on which the phlobetonium supporting the invasion stands, or sending some nukes in the two-way portal to take down the exposed enemy spaceship. [[SarcasmMode Nuking the city seems so far more sensible]].
* At the end of ''TheIncredibles'', when the [[spoiler: [[AttackOfThe50FootWhatever Giant Omnidroid]] attacks some random cities]], the army's response is basically "send some guys attack it with tanks [[FiveRoundsRapid and submachine-guns]], then do nothing". EMI bombs, anyone?

to:

* In ''Film/TheAvengers'', the army doesn't send any troops to help the titular heroes defending New York against the alien invasion. And of course, they don't think one second about sending a single missile to destroy the one building on which the phlobetonium supporting the invasion stands, or sending some nukes in the two-way portal to take down the exposed enemy spaceship. [[SarcasmMode Nuking the city seems so far more sensible]].
* At the end of ''TheIncredibles'', ''WesternAnimation/TheIncredibles'', when the [[spoiler: [[AttackOfThe50FootWhatever Giant Omnidroid]] attacks some random cities]], the army's response is basically "send some guys attack it with tanks [[FiveRoundsRapid and submachine-guns]], then do nothing". EMI bombs, anyone?

Added: 211

Removed: 378

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Aurors are supposed to correspond to police and there already is an entry in PAU for them


[[AC:Comics]]
* ''{{LuckyLuke}}'' is an AffectionateParody of the Western genre, so of course the cavalry is always either critically late to the action, or completely useless despite anything they might attempt.



* The aurors in ''Literature/HarryPotter'' may qualify, depending on whether you consider them as an army or not. In the sixth book, they fail to kill or capture any Death Eater, put innocents in jail ([[NiceJobBreakingItHero where they are captured]] and {{Brainwashed}} by said Death Eaters) instead, and do nothing to prevent the ministry from being infiltrated by Voldemort.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


First cause of EasilyConqueredWorld, though some countries in TV Land can have the worst possible army without being conquered. Can include PoliceAreUseless and NoFEMAResponse, where they don't even try to help. Often overlap with ConservationOfNinjutsu. Sister trope of ArmiesAreEvil.

to:

First cause of EasilyConqueredWorld, though some countries in TV Land can have the worst possible army without being conquered. Can include PoliceAreUseless and NoFEMAResponse, where they don't even try to help. Often overlap with ConservationOfNinjutsu. Supertrope of TanksForNothing. Sister trope of ArmiesAreEvil.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* ''{{Godzilla}}''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Note that this trope isn't about lots of soldiers dying : that's the RedShirtArmy. A military can achieve great victories by [[ZergRush swarming the enemy with disposable soldiers]], or loose everything while keeping a low casulaty record. This trope comes when the military as an institution has no use.

to:

Note that this trope isn't about lots of soldiers dying : dying: that's the RedShirtArmy. A military can achieve great victories by [[ZergRush swarming the enemy with disposable soldiers]], or loose everything while keeping a low casulaty record. This trope comes when the military as an institution has no use.



[[AC: Anime and Manga]]

to:

[[AC: Anime [[AC:Anime and Manga]]



[[AC: Film]]

to:

[[AC: Film]][[AC:Film]]



[[AC: Literature]]

to:

[[AC: Literature]][[AC:Literature]]



[[AC: Video Games]]

to:

[[AC: Video [[AC:Video Games]]

Changed: 16

Removed: 105

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The aim, of course, is to make the {{Hero}} the only one who can defeat the bag guys : how can you save your world when it can defend itself thanks to its competent army ? That's why you often find this in {{Superhero}} settings. It's also quite frequent in stories about an AlienInvasion or a ZombieApocalypse, because a war consisting of large open [[CurbStompBattle Curb-Stomp Battles]] is a quicker way to show how the enemy won than the long and complex battles that would have occurred had the military been competent. And of course, don't expect anything from them when AdultsAreUseless : since most armies are made of adults, they're unlikely to help.

to:

The aim, of course, is to make the {{Hero}} the only one who can defeat the bag guys : how can you save your world when it can defend itself with no problem thanks to its competent army ? That's why you often find this in {{Superhero}} settings. It's also quite frequent in stories about an AlienInvasion or a ZombieApocalypse, because a war consisting of large open [[CurbStompBattle Curb-Stomp Battles]] is a quicker way to show how the enemy won than the long and complex battles that would have occurred had the military been competent. And of course, don't expect anything from them when AdultsAreUseless : since most armies are made of adults, they're unlikely to help.



Previous name : Armies are useless.
Possible other names : No Armed Force reponse, Armies are incompetent.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''Literature/{{Animorphs}}'', due to the AdultsAreUseless setting, the military doesn't seem very worried about the Earth being invaded by aliens. Even after losing an aircraft carrier, the hometown of the animorphs being quarantined, and the governor of California (no, [[ArnoldSchwarzenegger not this one]]) making an official speech about how the aliens are invading the world, they simply consider this as a hoax and don't bother investigate. Obviously, even after admitting that yes, aliens are invading, their only purpose is to send some Redshirts die to support the main cast.

to:

* In ''Literature/{{Animorphs}}'', due to the AdultsAreUseless setting, the military doesn't seem very worried about the Earth being invaded by aliens. Even after losing an aircraft carrier, carrier (and everybody on it), the kid's hometown of the animorphs being quarantined, and the governor of California (no, [[ArnoldSchwarzenegger not this one]]) making an official speech about how the aliens are invading the world, [[ExtraStrengthMasquerade they simply consider this as a hoax hoax]] and don't bother investigate. Obviously, even after admitting When they finally admit that yes, aliens are indeed invading, their only purpose response is to send some Redshirts die to support the main cast.



[[AC: VideoGames]]

to:

[[AC: VideoGames]]Video Games]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Creating the article

Added DiffLines:

In some shows, when a country is attacked by some enemy (alien, monster, evil overlord), their armed forces, which are probably made specifically to defend said country, show themselves rather bad at defending it : they use HollywoodTactics (FiveRoundsRapid is a very popular one in those settings) instead of more efficient and logical ones, [[ArmiesAreEvil do evil stuff]] that just [[EvilWillFail undermine]] their side for no reason, and refuse to cooperate with TheHero. The reason ? In these shows, [[TitleDrop the military is useless]].

The aim, of course, is to make the {{Hero}} the only one who can defeat the bag guys : how can you save your world when it can defend itself thanks to its competent army ? That's why you often find this in {{Superhero}} settings. It's also quite frequent in stories about an AlienInvasion or a ZombieApocalypse, because a war consisting of large open [[CurbStompBattle Curb-Stomp Battles]] is a quicker way to show how the enemy won than the long and complex battles that would have occurred had the military been competent. And of course, don't expect anything from them when AdultsAreUseless : since most armies are made of adults, they're unlikely to help.

Note that this trope isn't about lots of soldiers dying : that's the RedShirtArmy. A military can achieve great victories by [[ZergRush swarming the enemy with disposable soldiers]], or loose everything while keeping a low casulaty record. This trope comes when the military as an institution has no use.

First cause of EasilyConqueredWorld, though some countries in TV Land can have the worst possible army without being conquered. Can include PoliceAreUseless and NoFEMAResponse, where they don't even try to help. Often overlap with ConservationOfNinjutsu. Sister trope of ArmiesAreEvil.

Previous name : Armies are useless.
Possible other names : No Armed Force reponse, Armies are incompetent.

----

!! Examples

[[AC: Anime and Manga]]
* ''Manga/{{Bleach}}''. The Gotei 13 is a glaring example. Their military is comprised of roughly 6,000 soldiers, yet, their strength rests almost entirely on its thirteen Captains, thirteen Lieutenants and the seated officers, who're always sent to the front lines while the rest of their divisions stay behind. They also have an entire spy network ([[{{Ninja}} the Onmistukido]]), and a [[MagicKnight Kidou Corp.]] which never get used.

[[AC: Film]]
* In ''Film/TheAvengers'', the army doesn't send any troops to help the titular heroes defending New York against the alien invasion. And of course, they don't think one second about sending a single missile to destroy the one building on which the phlobetonium supporting the invasion stands, or sending some nukes in the two-way portal to take down the exposed enemy spaceship. [[SarcasmMode Nuking the city seems so far more sensible]].
* ''{{Godzilla}}''
* At the end of ''TheIncredibles'', when the [[spoiler: [[AttackOfThe50FootWhatever Giant Omnidroid]] attacks some random cities]], the army's response is basically "send some guys attack it with tanks [[FiveRoundsRapid and submachine-guns]], then do nothing". EMI bombs, anyone?

[[AC: Literature]]
* In ''Literature/{{Animorphs}}'', due to the AdultsAreUseless setting, the military doesn't seem very worried about the Earth being invaded by aliens. Even after losing an aircraft carrier, the hometown of the animorphs being quarantined, and the governor of California (no, [[ArnoldSchwarzenegger not this one]]) making an official speech about how the aliens are invading the world, they simply consider this as a hoax and don't bother investigate. Obviously, even after admitting that yes, aliens are invading, their only purpose is to send some Redshirts die to support the main cast.
* The aurors in ''Literature/HarryPotter'' may qualify, depending on whether you consider them as an army or not. In the sixth book, they fail to kill or capture any Death Eater, put innocents in jail ([[NiceJobBreakingItHero where they are captured]] and {{Brainwashed}} by said Death Eaters) instead, and do nothing to prevent the ministry from being infiltrated by Voldemort.
* In the first half of ''Literature/WorldWarZ'', every single armed force of the world (save for Israel and... that's all) holds the IdiotBall until the world gets really screwed. For example, the Battle of Yonkers, where the military [[spoiler: ''fails to bring enough ammo'' to wipe out the waves of zombies]].

[[AC: VideoGames]]
* While the soldiers of ''VideoGame/HalfLife1'' are pretty tough, the guy who give them order is probably very, very dumb. The lab accident engineered an inter-dimensional alien invasion ? Let's kill the security guards to prevent them from doing their job ! A particular scientist seems pretty good at killing loads of aliens for us ? Let's put all our resources in taking him down ! Now because of all this mess we have [[LeaveNoWitnesses plenty of witnesses to kill]] ? Let's shoot them on sight instead of gathering them (and ''then'' shooting them) ! And now our marines are slaughtered by the aliens that keep invading ? Let's send assassins kill the marines ! No wonder why [[EasilyConqueredWorld they lost the following war in seven hour]].
* ''VideoGame/Left4Dead''
** In the comic ''The Sacrifice'', the soldiers are quite bad at fighting zombies. If [[RagtagBunchOfMisfits three civilians and a Viet veteran]] can kill hundreds of infected with hand-made weapons in the worst possible places (airport, hospital, church), do you think that trained soldiers in a base with twenty feet high walls, barbed wires, artillery, choke points and choppers can do the same ? Of course they can't, they're soldiers.
** ''VideoGame/Left4Dead2'' is an aversion. While the CEDA is quickly overwhelmed by the zombie invasion, the military is both [[BadCopIncompetentCop far more ruthless and more efficient]] at dealing with it; the evacuation points of the army are still operational, and for what we know of it, they do manage to save people from the zombie invasion.
* Commented on in ''VideoGame/{{Solatorobo}}'', where one character asks what the hell the army was doing when {{Kaiju}} were attacking his city.

Top