Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 33 (click to see context) from:
-->"If it weren't for the stupidity of some of their people-and, by God, of some of ours-we wouldn't be at war."
to:
-->"If it weren't for the stupidity of some of their people-and, people -- and, by God, of some of ours-we ours -- we wouldn't be at war."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 21 (click to see context) from:
* FamousNamedForeigner: Demetrios Polyorketes shares his name with [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demetrius_I_of_Macedon the second king of the Macedonian Antigonid dynasty]].
to:
* FamousNamedForeigner: Demetrios Polyorketes shares his name with [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demetrius_I_of_Macedon the second king of the Macedonian Antigonid dynasty]]. Also something of an IronicName, as "Polyorketes" literally means "Besieger" (which the original certainly was), but when the situation calls for someone to step up to seize back the ship, he proves to be just as much all talk and no action as the others (except Mullen).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
* FamousNamedForeigner: Demetrios Polyorketes shares his name with [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demetrius_I_of_Macedon the second king of the Macedonian Antigonid dynasty]].
Added DiffLines:
** Even Polyorketes -- who viciously hates the Kloros over his brother's death, and is the most hostile toward Stuart -- finds himself inwardly conceding that the man has a point. He's disgusted to realize that his brother died over such a petty issue, one which had no relevance to either of them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
* CareerEndingInjury: Stuart's prosthetics are too weak for him to keep piloting, so he was transferred to paperwork.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 28 (click to see context) from:
* PetTheDog: Stuart points out that the Kloros are actually treating their prisoners better than humans would under similar circumstances by keeping an oxygen-filled room aside for them. His own lack of hate is because the Kloros surgeons took the trouble to create new hands for him despite his alien biochemistry.
to:
* PetTheDog: Stuart points out that the Kloros are actually treating their prisoners better than humans would under similar circumstances by keeping an oxygen-filled room aside for them. His own lack of hate is because the Kloros surgeons took the trouble to create new hands for him despite his alien biochemistry. Pointing this out only gets him labelled as an alien sympathizer.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
* PetTheDog: Stuart points out that the Kloros are actually treating their prisoners better than humans would under similar circumstances by keeping an oxygen-filled room aside for them. His own lack of hate is because the Kloros surgeons took the trouble to create new hands for him despite his alien biochemistry.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
* AtomPunk: The references to 'steam-nozzles' seem strange, but they are actually using atomic-heated steam like a modern nuclear reactor would.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 16 (click to see context) from:
* CranialProcessingUnit: Mullen crushes the alien's head-stalk when he sticks it into the steam-nozzle, but realises too late that the brain is in its body when the Kloros rises again and starts stumbling blindly around the bridge after him.
to:
* CranialProcessingUnit: Mullen crushes the alien's head-stalk [[EyeOnAStalk head-stalk]] when he sticks it into the steam-nozzle, but realises too late that the brain is in its body when the Kloros rises again and starts stumbling blindly around the bridge after him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
* CranialProcessingUnit: Mullen crushes the alien's head-stalk when he sticks it into the steam-nozzle, but realises too late that the brain is in its body when the Kloros rises again and starts stumbling blindly around the bridge after him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 33 (click to see context) from:
* YouKilledMyFather: Demetrios Polyorketes hates the Kloros because they killed his brother, Aristides, when they boarded the ship at the start of the story.
to:
* YouKilledMyFather: Demetrios Polyorketes hates the Kloros because they killed his brother, Aristides, when they boarded the ship at the start of the story. This is despite the fact that Aristides panicked and ran out into the crossfire, and could just has easily been killed by a human defender.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Added DiffLines:
* DisabledSnarker: Stuart lost his hands, and admits this is behind his [[HannibalLecture tendency to question to motives of others]]. Mullen points out he has nothing to complain about, as his ArtificialLimbs are less obvious than [[HeightAngst Mullen's lack of height]].
Added DiffLines:
* ImprovisedWeapon: Mullen takes a spare oxygen cylinder with him in case he's blasted free of the ship, so he would at least have a chance of getting back by using it for ImprovisedMicrogravityManeuvering. As the Kloros are chlorine breathers he ends up using it to kill them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Changed line(s) 19 (click to see context) from:
-->"A small man can have no respectable emotions. Is there anything more ridiculous than a man like myself in a state of rage? I'm five feet and one-half inch tall, and one hundred and two pounds in weight, if you care for exact figures. I insist on the half inch and the two pounds." -- '''Randolph Mullen'''.
to:
* HitlerCam: Lampshaded when Mullen muses that they'll uses a close-up and low-set camera when pinning a medal on him.
* ItsTheOnlyWay: Mullen points out that there ''is'' a practical means of entering the bridge that the Kloros won't be expecting--they put on a spacesuit and go out the C-chute used for BurialInSpace, then enter through the steam-nozzles used to maneuver the spacecraft. Of course there's a lot that can go wrong. If the nozzles fire when you are in them, you'll be crushed to death or [[DramaticSpaceDrifting blasted free of the ship to die a slow death in space]]. Also there's no way to re-enter the ship once you're inside the nozzle--Mullen has to enter the nozzle (which is wide enough to allow maintenance) and bang on the hull and hope that the aliens inside will think something has gotten caught inside and open it to investigate.
Added DiffLines:
* WhoWillBellTheCat: Mullen comes up with a dangerous plan, but no-one is willing to carry it out, so he decides to do it himself.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Page Creation
Added DiffLines:
This story was first published in ''Magazine/GalaxyScienceFiction'' (October 1951 issue), by Creator/IsaacAsimov. The CentralTheme is "What makes a hero?"
During the current Earth-Kloros war, a civilian transport ship is captured. Six humans survive the hostile takeover, forced together despite their wildly different attitudes towards their captors. They all want to go home, but only meek little Mullen is willing to risk his life to do anything about it.
John Stuart takes a leadership role within the group due to having the greatest familiarity with the Kloros. Colonel Anthony Windham, the oldest passenger, is a nationalistic WarHawk within the group. He encourages them to fight the alien menace, but makes excuses for not leading the charge. Ben Porter had been to visit the Kloros to negotiate trade in canned foods, and is terrified of the indefinite internment. Claude Leblanc is a recently married young man, who is utterly lost with the current crisis. Demetrios Polyorketes is mourning his (possibly twin) brother, Aristides, who was killed by Kloros when they boarded the human ship. Finally, there's Randolph Mullen, a small and unassuming man, who has spent around ten years in the Arcturian System, working as a clerk.
These six passengers come up with a plan to retake the ship and bring it back to human-controlled space. The only problem is, who will be brave enough to try, and why?
"C-Chute" has been adapted into an episode of ''Radio/XMinusOne'', and republished at least nine times; ''Literature/ShadowOfTomorrow'' (1953), ''{{Magazine/Urania}}'' (issue #12, October 1953), ''Literature/SecondGalaxyReaderOfScienceFiction'' (1954), ''Literature/ThroughAGlassClearly'' (1967), ''Literature/NightfallAndOtherStories'' (1969), ''Literature/TheBestOfIsaacAsimov'' (1973), ''Literature/OtherWorldsOfIsaacAsimov'' (1987), ''Literature/SpaceDreadnoughts'' (1990), and ''Literature/TheCompleteStories, Volume 1'' (1990).
----
!!"C-Chute" contains examples of:
* TwentyMinutesIntoTheFuture: The setting is a future with FTL interstellar travel, and humanity has recently encountered their first alien species. Both groups have colonized multiple star systems.
* ArtificialLimbs: While a guest of the Kloros, John Stuart had mangled his hands irreparably. Since they couldn't fix the human hands, they used their advanced chemistry knowledge to grow artificial hands out of artiplasm instead. The new hands are weaker than the originals, and require delicate care.
* BizarreAlienPsychology: Stuart reminds the other humans that Kloros aren't just physically different, they are also psychologically different. The Kloros will assume that any group is a social union deeper than family bonds, even a group that just happen to share a ride on a transport.
* CentralTheme: Each of the characters has a reason why they don't want to be prisoners of the Kloros, whether it is due to their pride/honour or their fear. However, the character who actually takes action against the aliens doesn't give a reason until after the climax; [[spoiler:he was homesick]].
* DeflectorShields: The ship's use of force fields occur off-screen, but Colonel Anthony Windham is familiar enough with space combat to be able to identify the sequence of events despite being in the passenger area. He knows when the "screens" fail and the ship is forced into evasive maneuvers to avoid boarding action.
* FantasticRacism: Once humanity went to war against the Kloros, most humans became blindly nationalistic and think the Kloros are a horde of savages, and those humans who point out that they are perfectly civilized, merely on the other side of the war, are accused of being traitors to their species.
* HeightAngst: Randolph Mullen is the shortest of our protagonists. He is about five feet tall, putting him eight inches below average, something he is very aware of. He claims to have had a [[TheNapoleon Napoleon Complex]], but realized that outwardly expressing any emotions simply turned him into an object of ridicule, so he trained himself to be TheSpock.
-->"A small man can have no respectable emotions. Is there anything more ridiculous than a man like myself in a state of rage? I'm five feet and one-half inch tall, and one hundred and two pounds in weight, if you care for exact figures. I insist on the half inch and the two pounds." -- '''Randolph Mullen'''.
* NarrativeProfanityFilter: Col Windham tries to inspire common ground with Stuart by citing national identity and FantasticRacism. Stuart, however, disagrees with an "unprintable" response.
* OnlySaneMan: John Stuart appears to be the only one of the surviving passengers who understands that the aliens are just combatants on the other side of a war and not AlwaysChaoticEvil monsters. He happens to be stuck with an armchair general and [[WarHawk naive jingoist]], a man so [[YouKilledMyFather blinded by revenge]] that he wants to kill the aliens indiscriminately, a paranoiac who accuses him of being a species traitor, a newly married young man, and a bookish fellow whom everybody assumes to be a nebbish clerk.
* RayGun: When Demetrios Polyorketes tries to ambush one of the Kloros that boarded their ship, it blasts him with a pinkish ray that leaves him paralyzed and in great pain.
* SillyReasonForWar: Humanity and the Kloros went to war over the mining rights of an asteroid. None of the protagonists describe this in very positive terms, from naked [[WarHawk nationalism]] and [[FantasticRacism bigotry]], to outright describing it as foolishness.
-->"If it weren't for the stupidity of some of their people-and, by God, of some of ours-we wouldn't be at war."
* TheSpock: Randolph Mullen acts like a stereotypical bookkeeper; small, nebbish, and neat. When involved in discussion, he only makes logical arguments, resisting the impulse to express an emotional reaction. After the climax, he explains to Stuart that it was because [[HeightAngst short people look ridiculous when emotional]], so the only way he could be respected was to be logical.
* SwitchingPOV: Each of the six protagonists takes a turn narrating the events, starting with Colonel Windham, and cycling around until the story ends with Stuart's perspective.
* WarHawk: Colonel Anthony Windham, the oldest passenger, regrets his age/infirmity, but is very willing to stir up anti-Kloros feeling amoung the remaining passengers. His idea for preventing the Kloros from taking the ship is to charge the occupied bridge and activate the ship's self-destruct before they die.
* YouKilledMyFather: Demetrios Polyorketes hates the Kloros because they killed his brother, Aristides, when they boarded the ship at the start of the story.
----
During the current Earth-Kloros war, a civilian transport ship is captured. Six humans survive the hostile takeover, forced together despite their wildly different attitudes towards their captors. They all want to go home, but only meek little Mullen is willing to risk his life to do anything about it.
John Stuart takes a leadership role within the group due to having the greatest familiarity with the Kloros. Colonel Anthony Windham, the oldest passenger, is a nationalistic WarHawk within the group. He encourages them to fight the alien menace, but makes excuses for not leading the charge. Ben Porter had been to visit the Kloros to negotiate trade in canned foods, and is terrified of the indefinite internment. Claude Leblanc is a recently married young man, who is utterly lost with the current crisis. Demetrios Polyorketes is mourning his (possibly twin) brother, Aristides, who was killed by Kloros when they boarded the human ship. Finally, there's Randolph Mullen, a small and unassuming man, who has spent around ten years in the Arcturian System, working as a clerk.
These six passengers come up with a plan to retake the ship and bring it back to human-controlled space. The only problem is, who will be brave enough to try, and why?
"C-Chute" has been adapted into an episode of ''Radio/XMinusOne'', and republished at least nine times; ''Literature/ShadowOfTomorrow'' (1953), ''{{Magazine/Urania}}'' (issue #12, October 1953), ''Literature/SecondGalaxyReaderOfScienceFiction'' (1954), ''Literature/ThroughAGlassClearly'' (1967), ''Literature/NightfallAndOtherStories'' (1969), ''Literature/TheBestOfIsaacAsimov'' (1973), ''Literature/OtherWorldsOfIsaacAsimov'' (1987), ''Literature/SpaceDreadnoughts'' (1990), and ''Literature/TheCompleteStories, Volume 1'' (1990).
----
!!"C-Chute" contains examples of:
* TwentyMinutesIntoTheFuture: The setting is a future with FTL interstellar travel, and humanity has recently encountered their first alien species. Both groups have colonized multiple star systems.
* ArtificialLimbs: While a guest of the Kloros, John Stuart had mangled his hands irreparably. Since they couldn't fix the human hands, they used their advanced chemistry knowledge to grow artificial hands out of artiplasm instead. The new hands are weaker than the originals, and require delicate care.
* BizarreAlienPsychology: Stuart reminds the other humans that Kloros aren't just physically different, they are also psychologically different. The Kloros will assume that any group is a social union deeper than family bonds, even a group that just happen to share a ride on a transport.
* CentralTheme: Each of the characters has a reason why they don't want to be prisoners of the Kloros, whether it is due to their pride/honour or their fear. However, the character who actually takes action against the aliens doesn't give a reason until after the climax; [[spoiler:he was homesick]].
* DeflectorShields: The ship's use of force fields occur off-screen, but Colonel Anthony Windham is familiar enough with space combat to be able to identify the sequence of events despite being in the passenger area. He knows when the "screens" fail and the ship is forced into evasive maneuvers to avoid boarding action.
* FantasticRacism: Once humanity went to war against the Kloros, most humans became blindly nationalistic and think the Kloros are a horde of savages, and those humans who point out that they are perfectly civilized, merely on the other side of the war, are accused of being traitors to their species.
* HeightAngst: Randolph Mullen is the shortest of our protagonists. He is about five feet tall, putting him eight inches below average, something he is very aware of. He claims to have had a [[TheNapoleon Napoleon Complex]], but realized that outwardly expressing any emotions simply turned him into an object of ridicule, so he trained himself to be TheSpock.
-->"A small man can have no respectable emotions. Is there anything more ridiculous than a man like myself in a state of rage? I'm five feet and one-half inch tall, and one hundred and two pounds in weight, if you care for exact figures. I insist on the half inch and the two pounds." -- '''Randolph Mullen'''.
* NarrativeProfanityFilter: Col Windham tries to inspire common ground with Stuart by citing national identity and FantasticRacism. Stuart, however, disagrees with an "unprintable" response.
* OnlySaneMan: John Stuart appears to be the only one of the surviving passengers who understands that the aliens are just combatants on the other side of a war and not AlwaysChaoticEvil monsters. He happens to be stuck with an armchair general and [[WarHawk naive jingoist]], a man so [[YouKilledMyFather blinded by revenge]] that he wants to kill the aliens indiscriminately, a paranoiac who accuses him of being a species traitor, a newly married young man, and a bookish fellow whom everybody assumes to be a nebbish clerk.
* RayGun: When Demetrios Polyorketes tries to ambush one of the Kloros that boarded their ship, it blasts him with a pinkish ray that leaves him paralyzed and in great pain.
* SillyReasonForWar: Humanity and the Kloros went to war over the mining rights of an asteroid. None of the protagonists describe this in very positive terms, from naked [[WarHawk nationalism]] and [[FantasticRacism bigotry]], to outright describing it as foolishness.
-->"If it weren't for the stupidity of some of their people-and, by God, of some of ours-we wouldn't be at war."
* TheSpock: Randolph Mullen acts like a stereotypical bookkeeper; small, nebbish, and neat. When involved in discussion, he only makes logical arguments, resisting the impulse to express an emotional reaction. After the climax, he explains to Stuart that it was because [[HeightAngst short people look ridiculous when emotional]], so the only way he could be respected was to be logical.
* SwitchingPOV: Each of the six protagonists takes a turn narrating the events, starting with Colonel Windham, and cycling around until the story ends with Stuart's perspective.
* WarHawk: Colonel Anthony Windham, the oldest passenger, regrets his age/infirmity, but is very willing to stir up anti-Kloros feeling amoung the remaining passengers. His idea for preventing the Kloros from taking the ship is to charge the occupied bridge and activate the ship's self-destruct before they die.
* YouKilledMyFather: Demetrios Polyorketes hates the Kloros because they killed his brother, Aristides, when they boarded the ship at the start of the story.
----
