Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Heartwarming / BlackButler

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Some of the pictures Yana has drawn of the Red Duo long after the JTR storyline has featured them having a girls' night out or being in each other's company. One ticket illustration for 15th anniversary event also includes the two posing as a couple.

to:

** Some of the pictures Yana has drawn of the Red Duo long after the JTR storyline has featured them having a girls' night out or being in each other's company. One ticket illustration for a 15th anniversary event also includes the two posing as a couple.

Changed: 24

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Some of the pictures Yana has drawn of the Red Duo long after the JTR storyline has featured them having a girls' night out or being in each other's company. The ticket for 15th anniversary event also includes one of the two posing as a couple.

to:

** Some of the pictures Yana has drawn of the Red Duo long after the JTR storyline has featured them having a girls' night out or being in each other's company. The One ticket illustration for 15th anniversary event also includes one of the two posing as a couple.

Changed: 109

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** A couple extra pictures that Yana has drawn of the Red Duo long after the JTR storyline has featured them having a girls' night out or being in each other's company.

to:

** A couple extra Some of the pictures that Yana has drawn of the Red Duo long after the JTR storyline has featured them having a girls' night out or being in each other's company.company. The ticket for 15th anniversary event also includes one of the two posing as a couple.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Ciel laying a red dress over Angelina's body during her funeral. No matter what Grell may say or think, in Ciel's eyes red was truly the color that represented his aunt.

Added: 162

Changed: 183

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Chapter 111: There's just something incredibly heartwarming about seeing Sebastian the BattleButler, OneManArmy and [[DemonLordsAndArchdevils soul-eating Demon]] cooing over a cat, giving it a big hug while letting it play with the silver charm, then taking it into the carriage to give it a good meal, even saying that if Ciel weren't allergic he would take the little guy home with him.

to:

* Chapter 111: There's just something incredibly heartwarming about seeing Sebastian the BattleButler, OneManArmy and [[DemonLordsAndArchdevils soul-eating Demon]] cooing over a cat, giving it a big hug while letting it play with the silver charm, then taking it into the carriage to give it a good meal, even saying that if Ciel weren't allergic he would take the little guy one home with him.



* The look on Sieglinde's face when Sebastian gives her the blood samples for her to test is nothing short of adorable. The fact that she has also been getting quite comfy in her role as a scientist and has even found a way to walk on her own is also sweet considering her origin.

to:

* The look on Sieglinde's face when Sebastian gives her the blood samples for her to test is nothing short of adorable. Added sweetness since Sebastian was quite ruthless to her during her etiquette lessons.
**
The fact that she has also been getting quite comfy in her role as a scientist and has even found a way to walk on her own is also sweet nice considering her origin.

Changed: 161

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The look on Sieglinde's face when Sebastian gives her the blood samples for her to test is nothing short of adorable.

to:

* The look on Sieglinde's face when Sebastian gives her the blood samples for her to test is nothing short of adorable. The fact that she has also been getting quite comfy in her role as a scientist and has even found a way to walk on her own is also sweet considering her origin.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In a very twisted variant Sebastian's final thoughts in this arc: He admits that he sees humans as base creatures who will always trample on each other in order to advance their own goals or simply make it to the other side of the hills, but this is actually one of the reasons why he finds humanity so interesting.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Alternative interpretation is that those were merely hallucinations Ciel and Sebastian were having. While they still have quite the low opinion of the troupe and humanity in general going by their final pieces of dialogue (Ciel in particular spitting on their whole plight in his LaughingMad moment), this makes it appear that even they believe in whatever capacity that the troupe, in death, are at peace.

to:

** Alternative interpretation is that those were merely hallucinations Ciel and Sebastian were having. While they still have quite the low opinion of the troupe and humanity in general going by their final pieces of dialogue (Ciel in particular spitting on their the troupe's whole plight in his LaughingMad moment), this makes it appear that even they believe in whatever capacity that the troupe, in death, are at peace.

Changed: 187

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Alternative interpretation is that those were not the circus performers' spirits but instead hallucinations Ciel and Sebastian were having. While they still have quite the low opinion of the troupe (and humanity in general) going by their final pieces of dialogue, this makes it appear that even they believe in whatever capacity that the troupe, in death, are at peace.
** Counts as meta too, given the scene was added by one of the writing directors so that the troupe could leave on a positive note; he was prepared to delete it if Toboso didn't approve (they were involved in child kidnaping and trafficking after all, even if clearly under duress), but she was so moved (to the point of tears) by his warm feelings for the troupe that she told him to include it.

to:

** Alternative interpretation is that those were not the circus performers' spirits but instead merely hallucinations Ciel and Sebastian were having. While they still have quite the low opinion of the troupe (and and humanity in general) general going by their final pieces of dialogue, dialogue (Ciel in particular spitting on their whole plight in his LaughingMad moment), this makes it appear that even they believe in whatever capacity that the troupe, in death, are at peace.
** Counts as meta too, given the scene was added by one of the writing directors so that the troupe could leave on a positive note; he was prepared to delete it if Toboso didn't approve (they were involved in child kidnaping and trafficking after all, even if clearly under duress), but she was so moved (to to the point of tears) by his warm feelings for the troupe tears that she told gave him to include it.the go ahead.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Counts as meta too, given the scene was added by one of the writing directors so that the troupe could leave on a positive note; he was prepared to delete it if Toboso didn't approve, but she was so moved (to the point of tears) by his warm feelings for the troupe that she told him to include it.

to:

** Counts as meta too, given the scene was added by one of the writing directors so that the troupe could leave on a positive note; he was prepared to delete it if Toboso didn't approve, approve (they were involved in child kidnaping and trafficking after all, even if clearly under duress), but she was so moved (to the point of tears) by his warm feelings for the troupe that she told him to include it.

Added: 289

Changed: -2

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Chapter 126. Sweet, naïve, obnoxious Soma [[spoiler: knew all along that Ciel doesn't care for him nor even like him, and that Ciel is royally fucked up in the head. He doesn't care- he wants to try to help nurture Ciel's potential for goodness, fully aware he might get hurt because he believes the risks are worth it.]]

to:

* Chapter 126. Sweet, naïve, obnoxious Soma [[spoiler: knew all along that Ciel doesn't care for him nor even like him, and that Ciel is royally fucked up in the head. He doesn't care- he wants to try to help nurture Ciel's potential for goodness, fully aware he might get hurt because he believes the risks are worth it.]]


Added DiffLines:

* Another example from said OVA is Sebastian protecting Ciel from falling debris, not even minding that his ankle got broken as long as "his master" was alright. Yet another is when the director allows the cast to give Sebastian a mini birthday party complete with a pretty chocolate cake.

Added: 287

Changed: 228

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Chapter 107: Even though Lizzie was willing to attack Ciel for what looked like him cheating on her, she went after Ciel and not Sieglinde because she believed he was the one at fault and not the girl he was with (which, in many situations like this, is not always the case). However, once everything is explained Lizzie was very quick to apologize to Ciel, not to mention it seems she has accepted Sieglinde as a friend (even giving her the nickname "Suli-Chan/Sully").
** Also in 107: Even though the etiquette lessons were needed due to the upcoming audience with the queen, it was still nice to see Soma call out Sebastian's rather harsh tutoring tactics on Sieglinde, the second time resulting in Lizzie deciding to have everyone help her along.

to:

* Chapter 107: Even though Lizzie was willing to attack Ciel for what looked like him cheating on her, her when he wasn't, she went after Ciel and not Sieglinde because she believed he was the one at fault and not the girl he was with (which, in many situations like this, is not always the case). However, once everything is explained Lizzie was very quick to apologize to Ciel, not to mention it seems she has accepted Sieglinde as a friend (even giving her the nickname "Suli-Chan/Sully").
** Also in 107: Even though the etiquette lessons were needed due to the upcoming audience with the queen, queen it was still nice to see Soma call out Sebastian's rather harsh tutoring tactics on Sieglinde, the Sieglinde despite it goeing mute. The second time resulting in when Lizzie also notices results in her deciding to have everyone help her Sieglinde along.



* The look on Sieglinde's face when Sebastian gives her the blood samples for her to test is nothing short of adorable.



* Chapter 126. Sweet, naive, obnoxious Soma [[spoiler: knew all along that Ciel doesn't care for him, and that Ciel is fucked up in the head. He doesn't care- he wants to try to help nurture Ciel's potential for goodness, fully aware he might get hurt because he believes the risks are worth it.]]

to:

* Chapter 126. Sweet, naive, naïve, obnoxious Soma [[spoiler: knew all along that Ciel doesn't care for him nor even like him, and that Ciel is royally fucked up in the head. He doesn't care- he wants to try to help nurture Ciel's potential for goodness, fully aware he might get hurt because he believes the risks are worth it.]]



* The OVA "Making of Kuroshitsuji II": The AnimatedActors for Grell and Angelina "Red" Dalles [[RelationshipUpgrade appear to be a couple]] or are on very good terms with one another. The two of them arrive together, and despite no longer having a role Angelina shows up on set so she can support Grell.

to:

* The OVA "Making of Kuroshitsuji II": The AnimatedActors for Grell and Angelina "Red" Dalles [[RelationshipUpgrade appear to be a couple]] or are at least on very good terms with one another. The two of them arrive together, and despite no longer having a role Angelina shows up on set so she can support Grell.Grell (including wiping a footprint off Grell's face after Sebastian kicked her on purpose).
** A couple extra pictures that Yana has drawn of the Red Duo long after the JTR storyline has featured them having a girls' night out or being in each other's company.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Mey-Rin and Ran Mao not only complete their mission at the manor but also manage to do so without any casualties. And once the maids are awakened and freed they gang up on the bastard that took advantage of them and beat the ever-loving shit out of him.

Added: 616

Removed: 541

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Then entirety of Ch. 131 is probably one of the biggest heartwarmers of the entire series, showing that [[spoiler: the real Ciel Phantomhive was once a caring sibling to his younger twin brother, the boy that the manga follows, and loved him dearly.]] Ch. 132 and Ch. 133 have also showed instances of this.
* Mey-Rin being taken in by Ciel and given her first warm meal for the first time in her life softens the ColdSniper. It was this act of kindness that made her leave her old gang and become incredibly loyal to the young Phantomhive.


Added DiffLines:

[[folder:Blue Memory Arc]]
* Then entirety of Ch. 131 is probably one of the biggest heartwarmers of the entire series, showing that [[spoiler: the real Ciel Phantomhive was once a caring sibling to his younger twin brother, the boy that the manga follows, and loved him dearly.]] Ch. 132 and Ch. 133 have also showed instances of this.
[[/folder]]

[[folder:Blue Revenge Arc]]
* Mey-Rin being taken in by Ciel and given her first warm meal for the first time in her life softens the ColdSniper. It was this act of kindness that made her leave her old gang and become incredibly loyal to the young Phantomhive.
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*Season one, episode seven where Angela gives Finny a little kiss on the cheek and promises to meet him again. [[spoiler:This quickly turns heartbreaking when you realise they never do.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Mey-Rin being taken in by Ciel and given her first warm meal for the first time in her life softens the ColdSniper. It was this act of kindness that made her leave her old gang and become incredibly loyal to the young Phantomhive.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Ciel telling Snake to get onto one of the rescue boats instead of him, even citing that Snake's snake-friends can't survive in the cold water.

Changed: 18

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The OVA "Making of Kuroshitsuji II": The AnimatedActors for Grell and Angelina "Red" Dalles [[RelationshipUpgrade appear to be a couple]] or are at the very least on very good terms with one another. The two of them arrive together, and despite no longer having a role Angelina shows up on set so she can support Grell.

to:

* The OVA "Making of Kuroshitsuji II": The AnimatedActors for Grell and Angelina "Red" Dalles [[RelationshipUpgrade appear to be a couple]] or are at the very least on very good terms with one another. The two of them arrive together, and despite no longer having a role Angelina shows up on set so she can support Grell.

Changed: 63

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The OVA "Making of Kuroshitsuji II": The AnimatedActors for Grell and Angelina "Red" Dalles [[RelationshipUpgrade appear to be a couple.]] The two of them arrive together, and despite no longer having a role Angelina shows up on set so she can support Grell.

to:

* The OVA "Making of Kuroshitsuji II": The AnimatedActors for Grell and Angelina "Red" Dalles [[RelationshipUpgrade appear to be a couple.]] couple]] or are at the very least on very good terms with one another. The two of them arrive together, and despite no longer having a role Angelina shows up on set so she can support Grell.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[folder:Jack the Ripper Arc]]
* [[https://www.mangareader.net/kuroshitsuji/8/14 Ciel giving Madame Red a tender kiss on the cheek.]] Ciel is known to never let anyone (save Sebastian) touch him. Shows just how much he loves his aunt Anne.
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Chapter 85, which takes place between the Public School arc and the Emerald Witch arc, has Ciel and Sebastian taking the servants out to London for a day of shopping. It's quite sweet, from Finny's {Squee} at seeing the sights to Ciel grabbing Bard candy cigarettes to help with his smoking problem.

to:

* Chapter 85, which takes place between the Public School arc and the Emerald Witch arc, has Ciel and Sebastian taking the servants out to London for a day of shopping. It's quite sweet, from Finny's {Squee} {{Squee}} at seeing the sights to Ciel grabbing Bard candy cigarettes to help with his smoking problem.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Chapter 85, which takes place between the Public School arc and the Emerald Witch arc, has Ciel and Sebastian taking the servants out to London for a day of shopping. It's quite sweet, from Finny's {Squee} at seeing the sights to Ciel grabbing Bard candy cigarettes to help with his smoking problem.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The OVA "Making of Kuroshitsuji II": The AnimatedActors for Grell and Angelina "Red" Dalles [[RelationshipUpgrade appear to be a couple.]] The two of them arrive together, and Angelina shows up on set despite no longer having a role so she can support Grell.

to:

* The OVA "Making of Kuroshitsuji II": The AnimatedActors for Grell and Angelina "Red" Dalles [[RelationshipUpgrade appear to be a couple.]] The two of them arrive together, and Angelina shows up on set despite no longer having a role Angelina shows up on set so she can support Grell.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The AnimatedActors OVA "Making of Kuroshitsuji II" for Grell and Angelina "Red" Dalles [[RelationshipUpgrade appear to be a couple.]] Despite no longer having a role, Angelina shows up on set to support Grell.

to:

* The AnimatedActors OVA "Making of Kuroshitsuji II" II": The AnimatedActors for Grell and Angelina "Red" Dalles [[RelationshipUpgrade appear to be a couple.]] Despite no longer having a role, The two of them arrive together, and Angelina shows up on set to despite no longer having a role so she can support Grell.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* The AnimatedActors OVA "Making of Kuroshitsuji II" for Grell and Angelina "Red" Dalles [[RelationshipUpgrade appear to be a couple.]] Despite no longer having a role, Angelina shows up on set to support Grell.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Then entirety of Ch. 131 is probably one of the biggest heartwarmers of the entire series, showing that [[spoiler: the real Ciel Phantomhive was once a loving and caring sibling to his younger twin brother, the boy that the manga follows.]]

to:

* Then entirety of Ch. 131 is probably one of the biggest heartwarmers of the entire series, showing that [[spoiler: the real Ciel Phantomhive was once a loving and caring sibling to his younger twin brother, the boy that the manga follows.]]follows, and loved him dearly.]] Ch. 132 and Ch. 133 have also showed instances of this.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The melody that plays during the scene is one of the softest and sweetest played throughout the whole series.

Added: 242

Changed: 31

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In what could very well been his final go, [[spoiler: Agni showing what it truly means to be a butler by doing whatever it took, up to sacrificing his own life, to protect the life of his master, to the point that ''Sebastian'' showed proper respect for Agni's dedication for Soma.]]

to:

* In what could very well been his final go, [[spoiler: Agni showing showed what it truly means to be a butler by doing whatever it took, up to sacrificing his own life, to protect the life of his master, to the point that ''Sebastian'' showed proper respect for Agni's dedication for Soma.]]
* Then entirety of Ch. 131 is probably one of the biggest heartwarmers of the entire series, showing that [[spoiler: the real Ciel Phantomhive was once a loving and caring sibling to his younger twin brother, the boy that the manga follows.
]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[/folder]]

to:

[[/folder]][[/folder]]
----

Top