Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / TheThanosImperative

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Trope was cut/disambiguated due to cleanup


** Actually, the Cancerverse's version of Thanos is seen ''in the event'': on Titan, as a statue, when Drax is fighting the main universe's Thanos. (This is a ContinuityNod to Thanos's status at the time of ''ComicBook/TheDeathOfCaptainMarvel'', which is where the Cancerverse [[ForWantOfANail diverged from the main universe]].) So, who Lord Mar–Vell slew in the Necroscopy is unknown, but it certainly wasn't Thanos.

to:

** Actually, the Cancerverse's version of Thanos is seen ''in the event'': on Titan, as a statue, when Drax is fighting the main universe's Thanos. (This is a ContinuityNod to Thanos's status at the time of ''ComicBook/TheDeathOfCaptainMarvel'', which is where the Cancerverse [[ForWantOfANail diverged from the main universe]].universe.) So, who Lord Mar–Vell slew in the Necroscopy is unknown, but it certainly wasn't Thanos.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Adding link


** Actually, the Cancerverse's version of Thanos is seen ''in the event'': on Titan, as a statue, when Drax is fighting the main universe's Thanos. (This is a ContinuityNod to Thanos's status at the time of ''The Death of Captain Marvel'', which is where the Cancerverse [[ForWantOfANail diverged from the main universe]].) So, who Lord Mar–Vell slew in the Necroscopy is unknown, but it certainly wasn't Thanos.

to:

** Actually, the Cancerverse's version of Thanos is seen ''in the event'': on Titan, as a statue, when Drax is fighting the main universe's Thanos. (This is a ContinuityNod to Thanos's status at the time of ''The Death of Captain Marvel'', ''ComicBook/TheDeathOfCaptainMarvel'', which is where the Cancerverse [[ForWantOfANail diverged from the main universe]].) So, who Lord Mar–Vell slew in the Necroscopy is unknown, but it certainly wasn't Thanos.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** My theory was always that Mar-Vell needed to perform the ritual in ''our'' universe's Sanctuary- his error was doing it again back on ''his'' plane, where it summoned but did not destroy Death. That's why Thanos taunts that Mar-Vell's one flaw was always that he was impulsive.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The Many-Angled Ones had a greater influence on the proto-Cancerverse, and we're able to influence Mar-Vell and the Avengers into performing a series of dark rituals that culminated in the death of...Death.

to:

** The Many-Angled Ones had a greater influence on the proto-Cancerverse, and we're were able to influence Mar-Vell and the Avengers into performing a series of dark rituals that culminated in the death of...Death.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Actually, the Cancerverse's version of Thanos is seen ''in the event'': on Titan, as a statue, when Drax is fighting the main universe's Thanos. (This is a ContinuityNod to Thanos's status at the time of ''The Death of Captain Marvel'', which is where the Cancerverse [[ForWantOfANail diverged from the main universe]].) So, who Lord Mar–Vell slew in the Necroscopy is unknown, but it certainly wasn't Thanos.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Well, while having a mortal Avatar ''does'' make Death vulnerable, it also allows her to influence the mortal realm. Death can't actually '''do''' much without a mortal Avatar to do things for her, so if she wants to do anything other than watch and hope for the best, she needs to accept that vulnerability. Again, Thanos is probably the best choice.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** He's wearing a shirt, so the tattoos on his chest were presumably still there, just not visible. As for the ones beneath his eyes, those weren't present when he was reborn during his mini-series before {{ComicBook/Annihilation}} and only appeared later, so presumably they were make–up and not actual tattoos. (Gamora's similar eye marks are definitely make–up, as they switch between red and yellow depending on her outfit, and are sometimes not present at all.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** If I recall correctly, during the Thanos mini that served as a prelude to the Annhilation event, Death does admit that she holds feelings for Thanos (to the extent Death can love somebody, at least), but the problem was that Thanos never knew how to court her proper. She was never interested in those cosmic demonstrations of power that he was so fond of.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Clearly Thanos isn't unkillable, since he was, you know, killed. And as for DidYouJustRomanceCthulhu... In the 616 universe at least Thanos' love affair with Death is fairly one-sided, Death doesn't really seem to respond to Thanos' emotions. We don't know for sure if it was the same way in the Cancerverse, but since that universe and the 616 universe apparently were similar up until the point where Captain Marvel was dying, there's no reason to think their relationship was any different.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Considering that Thanos is a now-[[CompleteImmortality immortal/-unkillable]] PhysicalGod, not really. As for the why, well... DidYouJustRomanceCthulhu comes to mind.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It was not enough just to kill Mar-Vell, because even if he died, his bosses and the whole Cancerverse would still exist and would still threaten to invade our universe. As was explicitly explained in the comic, in order to make the beings in the Cancerverse mortal again, Mar-Vell, the avatar of Life, needed to be killed in the same ritual place where had killed the avatar of Life. That's why Death waited until the moment Mar-Vell was there to get him.

to:

** It was not enough just to kill Mar-Vell, because even if he died, his bosses and the whole Cancerverse would still exist and would still threaten to invade our universe. As was explicitly explained in the comic, in order to make the beings in the Cancerverse mortal again, Mar-Vell, the avatar of Life, needed to be killed in the same ritual place where had killed the avatar of Life.Death. That's why Death waited until the moment Mar-Vell was there to get him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* If conquering Death is as easy as killing her avatar in a ritual, why does she even choose to have such an avatar? Doesn't that make her incredibly vulnerable?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* When Drax puts on his old costume, he doesn't seem to have any of the red tattoos that were part of his new character design. What happened to them?

Added: 463

Changed: 9

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why, to get Death close enough to Mar Vell, did Thanos have to be killed in that ritual place. Wouldn't Death have been summoned the moment Mar Vell killed anyone in the regular universe?

to:

* Why, to get Death close enough to Mar Vell, Mar-Vell, did Thanos have to be killed in that ritual place. Wouldn't Death have been summoned the moment Mar Vell Mar-Vell killed anyone in the regular universe?



** It was not enough just to kill Mar-Vell, because even if he died, his bosses and the whole Cancerverse would still exist and would still threaten to invade our universe. As was explicitly explained in the comic, in order to make the beings in the Cancerverse mortal again, Mar-Vell, the avatar of Life, needed to be killed in the same ritual place where had killed the avatar of Life. That's why Death waited until the moment Mar-Vell was there to get him.



** Presumably, Thanos did exist, and was the avatar of Death. And was killed by Mar Vell, as a part of the Necroscopy, to kill death.

to:

** Presumably, Thanos did exist, and was the avatar of Death. And was killed by Mar Vell, Mar-Vell, as a part of the Necroscopy, to kill death.



* How did the Scarlet Witch hold off the Man-angled ones when the other magic users couldn't? Weren't all the Avengers turned at once?
** It seems to be less a question of power, and more a question of choice. Keep in mind that all of this happened because they couldn't accept someone they cared for dying, so they made a deal with the devil. Scarlet Witch didn't want to make that deal, but pretended to go along with it.

to:

* How did the Scarlet Witch hold off the Man-angled Many-Angled ones when the other magic users couldn't? Weren't all the Avengers turned at once?
** It seems to be less a question of power, and more a question of choice. Keep in mind that all of this happened because they couldn't accept someone they cared for dying, so they made a deal with the devil. Scarlet Witch didn't want to make that deal, but pretended to go along with it.it.
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Adding some potential responses to headscratchers.


** It would appear that causing death is not enough- Mar Vell had to get close to Thanos, and in that place where Death was first killed, try to kill her again- Bringing himself extremely close to Death once again, but this time, with Death fore-warned about what was going to happen, so she could strike first. As Thanos says, he cheated death, and nobody does that twice- So yeah.



** Presumably, Thanos did exist, and was the avatar of Death. And was killed by Mar Vell, as a part of the Necroscopy, to kill death.



** Presumably, the Many-angled ones can't grow infinitely in a realm where they can die.



* How did the Scarlet Witch hold off the Man-angled ones when the other magic users couldn't? Weren't all the Avengers turned at once?

to:

* How did the Scarlet Witch hold off the Man-angled ones when the other magic users couldn't? Weren't all the Avengers turned at once?once?
** It seems to be less a question of power, and more a question of choice. Keep in mind that all of this happened because they couldn't accept someone they cared for dying, so they made a deal with the devil. Scarlet Witch didn't want to make that deal, but pretended to go along with it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The Revengers were shown to regenerate, unless Thanos offed them.

to:

* ** The Revengers were shown to regenerate, unless Thanos offed them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The Many-Angled Ones had a greater influence on the proto-Cancerverse, and we're able to influence Mar-Vell and the Avengers into performing a series of dark rituals that culminated in the death of...Death.


Added DiffLines:

* The Revengers were shown to regenerate, unless Thanos offed them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* What happened to anyone who gets obliterated in the Cancerverse if they cannot die?

to:

* What happened to anyone who gets obliterated in the Cancerverse if they cannot die?die?
* How did the Scarlet Witch hold off the Man-angled ones when the other magic users couldn't? Weren't all the Avengers turned at once?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Why, to get Death close enough to Mar Vell, did Thanos have to be killed in that ritual place. Wouldn't Death have been summoned the moment Mar Vell killed anyone in the regular universe?
* Did Thanos not exist in the Cancerverse ever? How did that happen?
* How did Cancerverse Captain Marvel kill Death? Has Captain Marvel always been that powerful?
* Why did the Many-angled ones need Death to invade?
* What happened to anyone who gets obliterated in the Cancerverse if they cannot die?

Top