Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Fanfic / TheCuriousCaseOfMrPamuk

Go To

OR

Added: 119

Changed: 202

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AbsurdlyElderlyMother: Implied with Viscount Branksome and his offscreen wife, considering that Branksome is mentioned to have been close to Violet's age (he is mentioned as a contemporary of her husband the previous Earl) and his son Evelyn is only a few years older than Mary.

to:

* AbsurdlyElderlyMother: Implied with Viscount Branksome and his offscreen wife, considering that Branksome is mentioned to have been close to Violet's age (he is mentioned as a contemporary of her husband the previous Earl) and his son Evelyn is and unnamed daughter are only a few years older than Mary.



* BigBad: [[spoiler:Evelyn Napier masterminded Kemal Pamuk's death on behalf of the British government.]]

to:

* BigBad: [[spoiler:Evelyn Napier masterminded Kemal Pamuk's death on behalf of the British government.government, which also makes him responsible for Pamuk haunting Mary.]]



** The story suggests why there's a cat in Episode 5 of Series 1 when O'Brien is startled by a mouse and she suggests raising a cat to catch them.

to:

** The story suggests why there's a cat in the Downton kitchen during Series 1 Episode 5 of Series 1 when O'Brien is startled by a mouse and she suggests raising a cat to catch them.



* EekAMouse: O'Brien is startled by a mouse while talking with Thomas. This being O'Brien she's more angry than scared.



* JerkassHasAPoint: Mary often belittles Edith, but even Anna, who rarely has a bad word to say about anyone, has to privately criticize Edith's fashion choices when she notes a particular dress makes her look like a frog and is tempted to steal and bury it so Edith won't find it.

to:

* JerkassHasAPoint: Mary often belittles Edith, but even Anna, who rarely has a bad word to say about anyone, has to privately criticize Edith's fashion choices when she notes a particular dress makes her look like a frog and is tempted to steal and bury it a dress so Edith won't find it.

Added: 339

Changed: 11

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DrivingQuestion: Who killed Kemal Pamuk?



* FamilyBusiness: [[spoiler:Viscount Branksome, his son Evelyn, and their cousin William Melville have all held posts in the foreign office or secret service.]]



* JerkassHasAPoint: Mary often belittles Edith, but even Anna, who rarely has a bad word to say about anyone, has to privately criticize Edith's fashion choices when she notes a particular dress makes her look like a frog and is tempted to steal and bury it so Edith won't be able to find it.

to:

* JerkassHasAPoint: Mary often belittles Edith, but even Anna, who rarely has a bad word to say about anyone, has to privately criticize Edith's fashion choices when she notes a particular dress makes her look like a frog and is tempted to steal and bury it so Edith won't be able to find it.


Added DiffLines:

* TraumaButton: Kemal Pamuk has turned into one for Mary, as a few mentions of him nearly cause her to have a fainting fit during dinner.

Added: 798

Changed: 536

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptationExpansion: Bates' backstory. Between his work with Molesley and serving in the Beor Wars, he'd served [[spoiler:the Napiers, where he'd been friends with the young Evelyn.]] Furthermore, [[spoiler:the theft of the regimental silver Bates was imprisoned for was an even messier affair than in canon because Vera's accomplice attacked and wounded one of the guards. It was because of Evelyn's father that Bates only served a couple years for the theft and the rest of the details omitted, a debt that Bates pays by helping Napier get rid of Pamuk.]]

to:

* AdaptationExpansion: AdaptationExpansion:
**
Bates' backstory. Between his work with Molesley and serving in the Beor Wars, he'd served [[spoiler:the Napiers, where he'd been friends with the young Evelyn.]] Furthermore, [[spoiler:the theft of the regimental silver Bates was imprisoned for was an even messier affair than in canon because Vera's accomplice attacked and wounded one of the guards. It was because of Evelyn's father that Bates only served a couple years for the theft and the rest of the details omitted, a debt that Bates pays by helping Napier get rid of Pamuk.]]]]
** The story also fleshes out the first few days after Pamuk died, particularly Mary's interactions with Matthew.


Added DiffLines:

** The story suggests why there's a cat in Episode 5 of Series 1 when O'Brien is startled by a mouse and she suggests raising a cat to catch them.

Added: 280

Removed: 216

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AbsurdlyElderlyMother: Implied with Viscount Branksome and his offscreen wife, considering that Branksome is mentioned to have been close to Violet's age (he is mentioned as a contemporary of her husband the previous Earl) and his son Evelyn is only a few years older than Mary.



* AgeGapRomance: Implied with Viscount Branksome and his offscreen wife, considering that Branksome is mentioned to have been close to the Dowager Countess' age and his son Evelyn is only a few years older than Mary.

Added: 431

Changed: 21

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptationExpansion: Bates' backstory. Between his work with Molesley and serving in the Beor Wars, he'd served [[spoiler:the Napiers, where he'd been friends with the young Evelyn.]] Furthermore, [[spoiler:the theft of the regimental silver Bates was imprisoned for was an even messier affair than in canon because Vera's accomplice attacked and wounded one of the guards. It was because of Evelyn's father that Bates only served a couple years for the theft and the rest of the details omitted, a debt that Bates pays by assisting Napier get rid of Pamuk.]]

to:

* AdaptationExpansion: Bates' backstory. Between his work with Molesley and serving in the Beor Wars, he'd served [[spoiler:the Napiers, where he'd been friends with the young Evelyn.]] Furthermore, [[spoiler:the theft of the regimental silver Bates was imprisoned for was an even messier affair than in canon because Vera's accomplice attacked and wounded one of the guards. It was because of Evelyn's father that Bates only served a couple years for the theft and the rest of the details omitted, a debt that Bates pays by assisting helping Napier get rid of Pamuk.]]



* DeadlyPrank: Subverted. Bates believes that [[spoiler:Napier confused aconite for laudanum in an attempt to make Pamuk fall asleep, instead giving him a fatal overdose. However, it turns out that Napier deceived Bates into believing he only meant to prank Pamuk; he had planned to kill him all along.]]



* MedicationTampering: It turns out that [[spoiler:Kemal Pamuk was poisoned via an overdose of his aconite heart medication.]]



* TheNondescript: Evelyn Napier's valet... Alan? Adam? Alec? His appearance and even his name are easily forgotten, which makes him a RedHerring.

to:

* TheNondescript: Evelyn Napier's valet... Alan? Adam? Alec? His appearance and even his name are easily forgotten, which makes him a convenient RedHerring.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BaitAndSwitch: Mary and Anna are in the Crawley mausoleum when a shadowy figure enters and Anna at first thinks it's Patrick Crawley, back from the sea to claim his bride. Then the light reveals it to be Matthew.


Added DiffLines:

* GracefulLoser: [[spoiler:Evelyn Napier silently acknowledges that he's lost his chance for Mary.]]
-->"Take your chance, Matthew Crawley. Love her, and she may love you."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheHeavy: Anna's plotline to solve Kemal Pamuk's murder is driven by his ghost, which nearly causes Lady Mary to kill herself at least once.

to:

* TheHeavy: Anna's plotline efforts to solve Kemal Pamuk's murder is are driven by his ghost, which nearly causes Lady Mary to kill herself at least once.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BittersweetEnding: [[spoiler:Anna solves Kemal Pamuk's murder and saves Lady Mary, but nobody can reveal how he died and the British government's plan to kill Pamuk went off without a hitch.]]


Added DiffLines:

* TheHeavy: Anna's plotline to solve Kemal Pamuk's murder is driven by his ghost, which nearly causes Lady Mary to kill herself at least once.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheNondescript: Evelyn Napier's valet Alec... or Alex. His appearance and even his name are easily forgotten, which makes him a RedHerring.

to:

* TheNondescript: Evelyn Napier's valet Alec... or Alex. valet... Alan? Adam? Alec? His appearance and even his name are easily forgotten, which makes him a RedHerring.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheNondescript: Evelyn Napier's valet Alec... or Alex. His appearance and even his name are easily forgotten, which makes him a RedHerring.

Added: 242

Changed: 107

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EveryoneHasStandards: It's implied that [[spoiler:Melville argued against killing Pamuk, if at least because he didn't think the outcome was a desirable one.]]



* HistoricalDomainCharacter: [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_Melville William Melville]], head of Scotland Yard's Special Branch. The Napiers are [[HistoricalCharactersFictionalRelative cousins]] of his.

to:

* HistoricalDomainCharacter: [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_Melville William Melville]], head of Scotland Yard's Special Branch.Branch and later the British Secret Service. The Napiers are [[HistoricalCharactersFictionalRelative cousins]] of his.



* JerkassHasAPoint: Mary often belittles Edith, but even Anna, who rarely has a bad word to say about anyone, has to privately criticize Edith's fashion choices when she notes a particular dress makes her look like a frog.

to:

* JerkassHasAPoint: Mary often belittles Edith, but even Anna, who rarely has a bad word to say about anyone, has to privately criticize Edith's fashion choices when she notes a particular dress makes her look like a frog.frog and is tempted to steal and bury it so Edith won't be able to find it.


Added DiffLines:

* TheSpymaster: [[spoiler:William Melville, head of the British Secret Service.]]

Added: 561

Changed: 8

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptationExpansion: Bates' backstory. Between his work with Molesley and serving in the Beor Wars, he'd served [[spoiler:the Napiers, where he'd been friends with the young Evelyn.]] Furthermore, [[spoiler:the theft of the regimental silver Bates was imprisoned for was an even messier affair than in canon because Vera's accomplice attacked and wounded one of the guards. It was because of Evelyn's father that Bates only served a couple years for the theft and the rest of the details omitted, a debt that Bates pays by assisting Napier get rid of Pamuk.]]



* AssholeVictim: [[spoiler:Both Bates and Napier believe that poison was too good for someone like Pamuk.]]

to:

* AssholeVictim: [[spoiler:Both Bates and Napier believe agree that poison was too good for someone like Pamuk.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BigBad: [[spoiler:Evelyn Napier masterminded Kemal Pamuk's death on behalf of the British government.]]


Added DiffLines:

* ForgottenFirstMeeting: Matthew mentions he actually met Patrick Crawley a few months before his death while Patrick was working in the Intelligence Office.

Added: 151

Changed: 37

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DrivenToSuicide: Mary nearly jumps out a window due to her guilt about Pamuk.



* TheMole: [[spoiler:Bates keeps Napier informed of events at Downton.]]



* ObfuscatingStupidity: [[spoiler:Viscount Branksome (Evelyn Napier's father) pretended to be an oaf only interested in hunting and horse-racing. In reality, he was an agent in the British foreign office who's heavily implied to have killed for the British government.]]

to:

* ObfuscatingStupidity: [[spoiler:Viscount Branksome (Evelyn Napier's father) pretended to be an oaf only interested in hunting and horse-racing. In reality, he was an agent in the British foreign office who's heavily implied to have killed for the British government. This also applies to Evelyn himself.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Edith is already making writings on current events.


Added DiffLines:

* JerkassHasAPoint: Mary often belittles Edith, but even Anna, who rarely has a bad word to say about anyone, has to privately criticize Edith's fashion choices when she notes a particular dress makes her look like a frog.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AdaptationalAngstUpgrade: The story shows that Mary is wracked with guilt because Pamuk died while having sex with her, thinking it was her fault or that she was cursed.


Added DiffLines:

* ChristmasEpisode: Chapter 24 depicts Patrick Crawley's last Christmas at Downton in 1911.

Added: 223

Changed: 19

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GenreShift: ''Downton Abbey'' was primarily a historical drama, but moves into a whodunit and GhostStory. The last chapter shifts the story ''again'' into [[spoiler:Stale Beer SpyFiction, albeit with much older agencies.]]

to:

* GenreShift: ''Downton Abbey'' was primarily a historical drama, but moves into a whodunit and GhostStory. The last chapter shifts the story ''again'' into [[spoiler:Stale Beer SpyFiction, albeit with in a much older agencies.setting.]]



* TookALevelInJerkass: Thomas is noted to have become even more unpleasant after the Duke of Crowborough's visit.

to:

* TookALevelInJerkass: Thomas is noted to have become even more unpleasant after the Duke of Crowborough's visit.visit.
* UnderestimatingBadassery: Robert dismisses [[spoiler:William Melville as a jumped-up police detective who'd question the guests at dinner about some crime or other, not realizing Melville had a man murdered in his home.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HistoricalVillainUpgrade: Discussed when Isobel talks about Jane Boleyn over dinner and suggests she's been misunderstood, demonized for betraying Anne Boleyn when she only wanted to keep her family home.

Added: 187

Changed: 49

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AssholeVictim: [[spoiler:Both Bates and Napier believe that poison was too good for someone like Pamuk.]]



** Violet alludes to her past as part of the court of the Duke of Edinburgh, where she met Prince Kuragin in canon.

to:

** Violet alludes to her past as part of the court of the Duke of Edinburgh, where Edinburgh when he married Grand Duchess Marie, which is how she met Prince Kuragin in canon.


Added DiffLines:

* NamedByTheAdaptation: Viscount Branksome's wife is named Callandra Grace here.

Added: 163

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ItRunsInTheFamily: Kemal Pamuk suffered from heart problems inherited from his grandfather and was taking aconite as a tonic

to:

* ItRunsInTheFamily: Kemal Pamuk suffered from heart problems inherited from his grandfather and was taking aconite as a tonictonic.


Added DiffLines:

* PerspectiveFlip: The first couple chapters take place from Anna's point of view when she's awoken in the middle of the night by Lady Mary to move Pamuk's corpse.

Added: 246

Changed: 257

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MakeItLookLikeAnAccident: [[spoiler:Evelyn Napier told Bates to give Pamuk some laudanum to make him fall asleep, but actually gave him an overdose of his heart medication, letting Bates believe he'd mixed the vials up.]]

to:

* ItRunsInTheFamily: Kemal Pamuk suffered from heart problems inherited from his grandfather and was taking aconite as a tonic
* MakeItLookLikeAnAccident: [[spoiler:Evelyn Napier told Bates to give Pamuk some laudanum to make him fall asleep, but actually gave him an overdose of his heart medication, letting Bates believe he'd Napier mixed the vials up.up in a fit of jealousy.]]

Added: 393

Changed: 259

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheManBehindTheMan: [[spoiler:William Melville to Evelyn Napier. And behind ''him'' is an unknown political figure who ordered Pamuk's murder.]]

to:

* MakeItLookLikeAnAccident: [[spoiler:Evelyn Napier told Bates to give Pamuk some laudanum to make him fall asleep, but actually gave him an overdose of his heart medication, letting Bates believe he'd mixed the vials up.]]
* TheManBehindTheMan: [[spoiler:William Melville to Evelyn Napier. And behind ''him'' is an unknown political figure who ordered Pamuk's murder.]]murder and handed the job to Melville, who contracted Napier.]]
* NeverMessWithGranny: Anna's grandmother Kerensa always protected her from her lecherous stepfather. Unfortunately she died and his behavior became worse now that there was nobody to stop him.

Added: 252

Changed: 9

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Violet alludes to her past as part of the court of the Duke of Edinburgh, where she met Prince Kuragin.

to:

** Violet alludes to her past as part of the court of the Duke of Edinburgh, where she met Prince Kuragin.Kuragin in canon.
* CollidingCriminalConspiracies: [[spoiler:Napier had intended for Pamuk to die in his bed of a heart attack, but Pamuk's visit to Mary's room drastically complicated things because he died ''there''. He still manages to cover it up with Bates' help.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheManBehindTheMan: [[spoiler:William Melville to Evelyn Napier. And behind ''him'' is an unknown political figure who ordered Pamuk's murder.]]

Added: 211

Changed: 117

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GenreShift: ''Downton Abbey'' was primarily a historical drama, but moves into a whodunit and GhostStory.

to:

* GenreShift: ''Downton Abbey'' was primarily a historical drama, but moves into a whodunit and GhostStory. The last chapter shifts the story ''again'' into [[spoiler:Stale Beer SpyFiction, albeit with much older agencies.]]


Added DiffLines:

* HistoricalDomainCharacter: [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_Melville William Melville]], head of Scotland Yard's Special Branch. The Napiers are [[HistoricalCharactersFictionalRelative cousins]] of his.

Added: 148

Changed: 55

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AgeGapRomance: Implied with Viscount Branksome and his offscreen wife, considering that Branksome is mentioned to have been close to the Dowager Countess' age.

to:

* AgeGapRomance: Implied with Viscount Branksome and his offscreen wife, considering that Branksome is mentioned to have been close to the Dowager Countess' age.age and his son Evelyn is only a few years older than Mary.


Added DiffLines:

* OriginalCharacter: Paul Smithson, an assistant to Dr. Clarkson who's attracted to Anna. Anna uses him to get some information about Pamuk's death.

Added: 149

Changed: 74

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''[[https://archiveofourown.org/works/24316333/chapters/58621849 The Curious Case of Mr. Pamuk]]'' is a ''Series/DowntonAbbey'' fanfic where Anna Smith, head housemaid at Downton Abbey, starts her own investigation into the death of Kemal Pamuk after he dies in Lady Mary's bed.

to:

''[[https://archiveofourown.org/works/24316333/chapters/58621849 The Curious Case of Mr. Pamuk]]'' is a ''Series/DowntonAbbey'' fanfic written by [[https://archiveofourown.org/users/Anise/pseuds/Anise Anise]] where Anna Smith, head housemaid at Downton Abbey, starts her own investigation into the death of Kemal Pamuk after he dies in Lady Mary's bed.


Added DiffLines:

* HauntedHouse: Downton's north tower is said to be haunted by Jane Boleyn, while Mary is personally haunted by [[spoiler:the ghost of Kemal Pamuk.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CallForward:
** Sybil suggests she might like working in a hospital.
** Violet alludes to her past as part of the court of the Duke of Edinburgh, where she met Prince Kuragin.



* PlotTriggeringDeath: Kemal Pamuk's sudden death kicks off the plot.

to:

* PlotTriggeringDeath: Kemal Pamuk's sudden death kicks off the plot.plot.
* TookALevelInJerkass: Thomas is noted to have become even more unpleasant after the Duke of Crowborough's visit.

Added: 161

Changed: 25

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AgeGapRomance: Implied with Viscount Branksome and his offscreen wife, considering that Branksome is mentioned to have been close to the Dowager Countess' age.



* ObfuscatingStupidity: [[spoiler:Viscount Branksome pretended to be an oaf only interested in hunting and horse-racing. In reality, he was an agent in the British foreign office who's heavily implied to have killed for the British government.]]

to:

* ObfuscatingStupidity: [[spoiler:Viscount Branksome (Evelyn Napier's father) pretended to be an oaf only interested in hunting and horse-racing. In reality, he was an agent in the British foreign office who's heavily implied to have killed for the British government.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

''[[https://archiveofourown.org/works/24316333/chapters/58621849 The Curious Case of Mr. Pamuk]]'' is a ''Series/DowntonAbbey'' fanfic where Anna Smith, head housemaid at Downton Abbey, starts her own investigation into the death of Kemal Pamuk after he dies in Lady Mary's bed.

Completed, can also be read [[https://www.fanfiction.net/s/13525548/1/The-Curious-Case-of-Mr-Pamuk here]].

!!Tropes that appear in this fanfic:
* AmateurSleuth: Anna, taking things further than in the original series.
* DramaticIrony: When Mary appears at Anna's bedside for help moving Pamuk's corpse, Anna originally thinks it's thieves after the silver helped by Thomas. Funnily enough Thomas is indirectly responsible for this particular escapade after he was forced to help Pamuk find Mary's room.
* GenreShift: ''Downton Abbey'' was primarily a historical drama, but moves into a whodunit and GhostStory.
* ObfuscatingStupidity: [[spoiler:Viscount Branksome pretended to be an oaf only interested in hunting and horse-racing. In reality, he was an agent in the British foreign office who's heavily implied to have killed for the British government.]]
* PlotTriggeringDeath: Kemal Pamuk's sudden death kicks off the plot.

Top