TV Tropes Org
site search
The Phantom Menace back to reviews
Comments
Layman perspective
I have never been a Star Wars fan. Actually, it was kind of a turn-off growing up to see my friends collecting every comic book, novelization and special edition release. Even to a twelve-year-old, the plot of the EU was clearly running on fumes, recycling old plots and images (decades after the events of Jedi) rather than rolling the dice on new stuff. The video games don't help, reusing the same old Cloud City textures. Basically, the EU does a disservice to the variety and color of the original trilogy.

Which is why everyone looks so fondly on Episode One. For all the script's faults, at least we get to see something different. Some places are familiar, like the Trade Federation warship (intentionally patterned on a future Star Destroyer) and Tattooine, but overall this is the riskiest of the prequels. The later movies were an endless parade of caverns for some reason.

Unfortunately, if Episode One has a leg up on scenery, Episodes 2 & 3 had better characterization. I'm a plot guy, and I can tell you that The Phantom Menace is constant foreshadowing. Sure, a lot of stuff happens, but if we have no connection to the characters, who cares? Chancellor Velorum ends up being the most sympathetic character in the movie, and he's just a pencil-pusher! You might say Shmee and Anakin are tragic figures, but Lucas is queasy about inserting miserable-looking slaves into a family film, so the mother-son act like they're on siesta at Disneyland. I had always envisioned Obi-Wan and Anakin as contemporaries. While I'm sure a lot of kids loved putting themselves in Anakin's shoes, I'm sure the same could be done with an adult character. This movie got off to a bad start with making Anakin and Obi-Wan into naive adolescents for the whole trilogy —and THUD goes the drama.

As a film in its own right, Episode One is fun but unmemorable. As a Star Wars movie, the whole story could probably be consolidated into Episode Two and not lose much.
What are you talking about? Very few look fondly on episode one using your arguments or they're too damn into the Nostalgia Filter to judge it fairly.

TPM is either remembered as mediocre or detestable for the most part. Although I like more than the original,I safely place both into mediocrity

Obi-Wan was not an adolescent,he was older than Anakin was at the end of the prequel trilogy. And I frankly liked having him being trained,that was a good call.

And I thought Anakin was actually very well written,unlike in the second episode where they focus far too much on him having to become evil. Jake Lloyd was unfairly blamed,and although the performance was understandably dull since most kid actors are,you could still feel that something was off.

And Qui-Gon is single-handedly the greatest character in the whole damn saga. He represents everything the Jedi should've been and what Anakin would've been under better conditions.

The problem rests on Jar-Jar,the execution of the plot,and the pacing which plods (the political scenes),and then suddenly surges(the climax).

And it would've been better if kid Anakin saw Qui-Gon get killed.

Yeah it does do,too much foreshadowing,but Qui-Gon,Padme (when she's in handmaiden mode that is),and Shmi stand up very nicely on there own which cannot be said for any of the characters next episode.

You're right that Episodes Two and One could be consolidated,but only because it is Episode Two,and not Episode One that is lacking.

comment #17016 terlwyth 29th Nov 12
And Qui-Gon is single-handedly the greatest character in the whole damn saga.

I just... Just... What?
comment #17029 Scardoll 30th Nov 12
Why isn't Qui-Gon the greatest character in the prequel. I realize that this is a matter of opinion but I said basically the same thing in my review and no one disagreed. Granted no one has commented yet but still. Qui-Gon is wise, compassionate, and is willing to go against the rules to do what's right, which is one flaw the Old Jedi Order had: they were too rule focused.
comment #17030 FantasyLiver 30th Nov 12
I had good memories of him but I thought in the end he's got a fairly static role, he's fantastic as a jedi ideal, but I enjoyed seeing Obi-Wan going from a know nothing temperamental apprentice Jedi to his willing controlled death at the end
comment #17037 TomWithNoNumbers 1st Dec 12
@Scardoll for suggesting otherwise,....WHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHAAAAAAAAAAAAATTTTTTTT???!?!?

@Tom Arguably the same could be said for Obi-Wan and Yoda in the original trilogy,because that's what The Mentor entails. But usually the mentor entails a Blue Oni type of persona,and they are somewhat crusty. Qui-Gon was a very optimistic and a Red Oni and willing to do what's right rather than what make immediate sense.

Maybe he was static,but static does not equal bad,and he was a twist.
comment #17040 terlwyth 1st Dec 12
He's definitely good I just felt that Obi-Wan's arc let him have that at some points and also let him do other things. But Qui-Gon was definitely absolutely fundamental for everything that did work and without him Obi-Wan wouldn't have made sense and we'd have lost an important perspective on the Jedi it's true
comment #17041 TomWithNoNumbers 2nd Dec 12
Much as I love Qui-Gon, I felt that, for many reasons, he had to die. He's a character whose influence is felt far more powerfully due to his absence, rather than his presence. He's basically there to suggest that there might have been alternative fates for a lot of the characters had he survived. Anakin would have gotten the father-figure he needed and not been so susceptible to Palpatine, Obi-Wan would have had the time to find his footing as a Knight instead of taking on a padawan of his own immediately, Shmi might very well have been freed, and Dooku likely wouldn't have left the Order had his former padawan not died. Qui-Gon's death thus represents a real turning point in the Saga and builds the tragedy very effectively, in my opinion. I have always been left wondering: if only Qui-Gon had survived, how might things have been different?
comment #17042 RedHudsonicus 2nd Dec 12
I wish more people would note the performance of the woman who played Shmi,that was a really good performance all about.
comment #17043 terlwyth 2nd Dec 12
While everything you say about Qui-Gon is true (everyone here's in agreement that he's a breath of fresh air), it put Anakin and Obi-Wan in a weird position dramatically. Basically, Qui-Gon goes around sticking plugs in leaky boats, so he had to die. The Idiot Plot demands it.

In TPM, Obi-Wan is essentially aligned the dogmatic wing of the Jedi. An anti-Anakin, if you will. He supposedly rebels by insisting on training Ani like Qui-Gon wanted him too. That's nice, but he's still a colorless character, and only develops in the aftermath of ROTS. Then he resembles Qui-Gon in spirit.

But now I'm drifting into the other prequels.
comment #17070 johnnyfog 4th Dec 12
In order to post comments, you need to Get Known
TV Tropes by TV Tropes Foundation, LLC is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.
Permissions beyond the scope of this license may be available from thestaff@tvtropes.org.
Privacy Policy