Main What Kind Of Lame Power Is Heart Anyway Discussion

Collapse/Expand Topics

07:51:35 AM Sep 18th 2017
Regarding the The Silmarillion entry, am I the only one who interpreted Vairė's role as "the Weaver" as her being essentially the equivalent of the Fates in our world's mythology? Doesn't sound very lame to me.
10:15:28 AM Dec 2nd 2011
edited by Paireon
◦For that matter, Reed's stretching powers can seem a tad useless in a lot of situations (he's never displayed the kind of limitless shapeshifting abilities of, say, Plastic Man). But Reed's real super-power is being the most brilliant scientist on Earth.

I (and several other people) disagree. Reed's real, bona fide, Game-Breaker superpower is his downright supernatural ability to still be considered a good guy when it's glaringly obvious he's one of the biggest jerkasses in the whole Marvel U.

Search your feelings. You know it to be true.
02:53:33 PM Nov 13th 2011
Is there a more mundane/non-superhero version of this? Like, say you've got a group of geniuses, and the one girl on the team excels in art. Of course, she thinks it's pathetic, especially compared to the "cool computer geek". Does it count?
10:22:02 AM Dec 2nd 2011
Well, if it's actually shown as pathetically useless, then yes, it is this trope (as well as about half a dozen Unfortunate Implications, but you already knew that, I believe).
04:42:40 PM Sep 5th 2011
It's fun to just twist a trope into a couple anothers:


Wheeler: "It's useless, that's what it is! Ma-Ti is the weakest one of all! Haw haw haw!"

  • >BLAM!<* WHEELER falls over.

MA-TI blows off the smoke from the barrel of her pearl-handled Colt revolver, twirls it and flawlessly slides back into her gun belt.

Ma-Ti: "I Heart pearl-handled Colts."

WHEELER writes in agony while clutching his thigh-wound resulting from the gunshot:

Wheeler: "You didn't have to SHOOT me! I was only kidding! I thought you had HEART!"

Ma-Ti: "I Heart irony."


It's not a totally bad Trope. Satire works great when performing such out-of-character changeovers while keeping it somewhat true to the original Trope. In a literal sense, anyway...

...but I hated that "Planeteers" nonsense. So why not mix in a couple Western-genre tropes to make Ma-Ti a badass? ;-)

10:51:56 AM Dec 2nd 2011
Meh, as far as I'm concerned that's just Ma-Ti (who's a he BTW) -and by extension the show's writers- being possessed of a dismally deficient imagination. If it allows him to control ALL animals, that means he can control arthropods (arachnids, crustaceans, insects...) which should give him nigh-inexhaustible firepower... But Wait, There's More!! Lots of microorganisms could be considered animals under standard classifications, so he could be an extremely effective Plague Master... But Wait, There's More!! Humans are animals according to classification, so why couldn't he control them as well (although maybe there was some sort of explanation in-show for that last one, can't remember)?
12:46:35 AM May 26th 2012
Double-meh: They're all a bunch of treehugging androgynites. That includes Ma-Ti (I didn't even bother looking up its piccy, and I won't either for I spent decades bleaching that crap out of my head instilled within me as a kid who didn't know any better).

Anyway, with your stuff in mind then it's all Ma-Ti and its crew's fault for AIDS. That's if these perversions of fiction were real, of course.

10:28:46 PM Jul 15th 2011
The Lost Room has a bunch of items with various effects. Some are useful, others are not. The comb stops time, the flask suffocates people, and the glass eye can heal. On the other hand, the wristwatch cooks eggs, the pencil creates pennies, and the radio makes you three inches taller.
10:14:39 AM Aug 2nd 2010
edited by

  • For the record, Marluxia's power being "Flower" or "Plant" is a common misconception - his actual power is Death. Which is why his weapon is a scythe, and why he's constantly surrounded by flower petals - those are a Japanese symbol of death. It also explains his Desperation Move, Death Sentence, which puts a countdown over your head that will kill you instantly unless you reshuffle your deck before it hits zero. This knowledge combined with his disturbingly evil plan and his downright alarmingly manly voice makes him actually one of more intimidating members to this troper.

Can someone confirm this as his power rather than just (admittedly, dark when you think about it) symbolism? The 358/2 Days manual specifically refers to Marluxia's ability as the control of flowers...
11:49:40 AM Feb 4th 2011
edited by Biffbiffley
smart-ass question.

does the 10 eyed man only have eyes in his head? If not he'd be the 12 eyed man, no?
01:13:02 AM Jun 9th 2010
Title should read "What Kind Of Lame Power Is Heart Anyway", and not "[...] Lame Poweris Heart Anyway" (notice capitalization/space).
04:22:58 PM Apr 12th 2010
edited by Old_Ropes
Where, exactly, is the trope namer? i.e. Captain Planet and the Planeteers ? Also, I wanted to point out that maybe 'Heart' isn't so lame after all:
05:42:49 PM May 3rd 2010
edited by fhqwhgads
fhqwhgads: I'm pretty sure the Trope Namer is a subliminal message from the Animutation The French Erotic Film. Near the end they do a parody of Captain Planet with "Earth! Fire! Wind! Water! Heart Spleen!". If you look in front of the spleen, you can see the text "What kind of lame-ass power is heart anyway?"
Collapse/Expand Topics