Follow TV Tropes

Following

Discussion Main / TwoSiblingsInOne

Go To

You will be notified by PM when someone responds to your discussion
Type the word in the image. This goes away if you get known.
If you can't read this one, hit reload for the page.
The next one might be easier to see.
tryer Since: May, 2011
Jun 20th 2011 at 9:33:11 AM •••

reply: Invoked by Hansel and Gretel in Black Lagoon. They're siblings, but who's the boy and who's the girl? Good question. They change around at will - and when one of 'em winds up dead, the survivor happily declares that they're still together, even as she changed into a he... (Note that all we see is a change of wig and voice - but it is implied that whatever physiological difference there may have been between them, is no longer visible without an autopsy.)

  • Well Rock certainly knew which is whch
    • Either that, or he just saw something that was neither one nor the other, which could explain his expression equally well...

reply: In Heroes, Niki Sanders manifests the consciousness of her dead, older sister, Jessica Sanders, and gains super strength when she does so. Jessica died protecting her sister from their abusive father and continues to protect her, even if she uses violent and sociopathic means to do so. It was never made clear weather this was actually two minds in the same body (Though 'Jessica' seems to think so) or just regular old Multiple Personality Disorder.

reply:

  • This was the origin of Golden Age DC Comics superhero Captain Triumph. When Lance Gallant swore revenge for his brother Michael's death, Michael's ghost appeared to him, and by merging they gained superpowers.

reply: Bronze Age Marvel Comics character 3-D Man was the soul(?) of a dead brother, brought back to life by the live brother when concentrating through his glasses.

reply: Marvel Comics' Brother Voodoo with Jericho (living) and Daniel (spirit) Drumm. Daniel could leave Jericho's body to possess other beings.

reply:

  • The plot of Haunted Sister by Lael Littke. Janine's twin Lenore died when they were young. After a near-death experience where Janine goes to heaven but is told it's not her time, Lenore's soul comes back with her. The two don't get along very well, and Lenore increasingly tries to take over more.

reply: Sakon from Naruto. (kind of complicated, need authority on what the hell they are)

reply: Does absorbing a twin in utero count? If so we could include Thad Beaumont/George Stark from Stephen King's The Dark Half

reply: This may be too literal to count, but in My Brother's Keeper by Charles Sheffield, two brothers (one a concert pianist, the other a state department spy) are in an arranged accident. Surgeons save the pianist by grafting in pieces of his brother's brain. Occasionally he will get an idea, clue or warning (usually in the form of music) from his dead brother's brain. Um, yeah.

reply: Yes kentdyson88, I intended it to count even before the siblings are born because that seems to happen quite often with twins even before they are born, one dies before/right after birth and this happens.

reply: Add to Shuffle example:

  • Nerine has a similar thing with Lycoris, although in this case it's "clone" rather than "sibling".
And to Naruto one: it's Sakon and Ukon.

reply: Psychic Academy (a manga) had a pair like this, where the sister has her brother's heart. Comes as a surprise, because in the early part of the story it is the brother that is dominant (and The Antagonist).

reply: Version of this in The Dark Half by Stephen King. Thad Beaumont absorbs his twin sibling in the womb but only partially, leading to the sibling needing to be surgically removed from Thad's brain and killed. The spirit of the dead sibling causes him to write dark novels and leads him to fame and success. Later in life, when Thad decides to stop writing the sibling (twin) manifests as a real person with identical fingerprints to Thad and naturally begins killing people. They also share a telepathic link that seems to allow each to experience the pain and thoughts of the other, like Occlumency.

reply: Hanako And The Terror Of Allegory: Dead sibling Nozomi takes over Kaede's body as part of a revenge scheme.

reply:

  • Haunt is a comic about a Badass Priest haunted by his brother, a deceased secret agent, becoming a superhero.
  • Firestorm from DC Comics was this, before Doing In the Wizard and becoming a fire elemental.

reply: If absorbing the twin in utero counts, there is an article in cracked.com that tells of this.

reply: Not to mention the anime Basilisk, where the Big Bad of the group apparently absorbed his twin brother. His brother is still alive, so to speak, as a monstrous symbiote who gives his brother immense regeneration in return for surviving freakishly. This also counts as squick, since said symbiote is only able to speak through his brother's ripped throat.

reply: What indexes should I put this in? Sibling Tropes and even Twin Tropes? Tropes of the Soul, Split Personality Tropes, Internal Conflict Tropes, Identity Index? Any more?

reply: End of markup

Top