What's Happening

Troperville

Tools

collapse/expand topics back to Main/CurbStompBattle

1810072342
topic
12:12:35 PM Mar 19th 2014
Is adding an extract from the Lonely Island song Rocky appropriate for the Quotes page? It might be fairly long, but it's a pretty effective example.
raptyr
topic
12:04:00 PM Feb 23rd 2014
Requesting a possible rename, as the current name is offensive and can be too easily misused or taken out of context.

Suggested renamings: Overwhelming Victory or Unfair Victory, or One-sided Win
SeptimusHeap
12:38:01 PM Feb 23rd 2014
Huh? I don't see how it's offensive in the slightest. Also, I don't see any evidence of the latter two.
AidanMclaren
08:52:11 PM Mar 17th 2014
It's not "offensive" per se, but it is a pretty unnecessarily disgusting and wretchedly macho way of naming a one-sided battle.
SeptimusHeap
12:12:08 AM Mar 18th 2014
This trope is about one-sided battles, so the name is appropriate. Sorry, but I am not seeing why "pretty unnecessarily disgusting and wretchedly macho way" is a problem.
MrFable
topic
06:31:35 PM Nov 3rd 2013
edited by 68.4.127.102
Am I the only one that thinks the Real Life section shouldn't exist? Looks like total flame bait.
pittsburghmuggle
topic
08:17:02 PM Feb 3rd 2013
I don't really like the name. "Curb stomping" bring to my mind to groups taunting each other, not a beatdown. Just my two bits.
Thecommander236
09:25:29 PM Feb 3rd 2013
Fair enough, but the actual name curb stumping is literally stumping someone's face into the curb.
pittsburghmuggle
01:02:34 AM Feb 4th 2013
Ah.
brianify
topic
11:33:43 AM Jun 20th 2012
IMO, this article's examples need to be thoroughly scrubbed. From my reading of it, this trope is about when the audience is led to believe that either A) the fight will be drawn-out/evenly matched, but then it decidedly isn't, or B) one side is heavily favored but then loses badly. However, like half of the examples in every branch ends up being "Alice is massively more powerful than Bob. Alice then beats the crap out of Bob. This is a curb-stomp battle." We need to either change the meaning of this article to basically encapsulate One Sided Battle, or do some pruning.
ading
12:49:59 PM May 16th 2013
The article itself just says that it's when the fight is extremely one-sided.
ArmandoPayne
topic
01:32:17 PM Mar 7th 2012
Where should I put a sport equivalent, because I want to add Barcelona's curb-stomp battle of Bayer Leverkusen, so where could I add it?
ACW
topic
11:04:45 AM Jan 19th 2012
edited by ACW
What's the difference between this and No-Holds-Barred Beatdown?
CrypticMirror
01:19:28 PM Jan 19th 2012
No-Holds-Barred Beatdown is for the villain is pasting the hero to the floor, and the hero seems helpless to fightback.

Curb-Stomp Battle is for when the hero is given a magic plot pass to defeat the villain without the villain being able to touch him.

It's a tone thing. The NHBB is usually filled with tragedy and angst while this is when you go up to grab a coffee and some chips and know you can get back in time for the heroes congratulating each other on a victory well earned.
Yuoaman
topic
07:56:05 PM Dec 26th 2011
Shouldn't the page for Tabletop Games actually read "Tabletop Games" and not "Tabletops Games"?
MichaelKatsuro
05:47:14 AM Jun 12th 2012
Yes. Yes, it should.
TheAntiTed
topic
03:36:17 PM Feb 20th 2011
I think the picture currently in place comes close to Just a Face and a Caption. Yes, the two (identical!) characters are 99 levels apart in skill, but I shouldn't have to read the caption and then squint at the picture to figure out what its trying to demonstrate. Anyone agree? I'll remove it tomorrow if no one objects.
InvertTheWorld
04:38:30 PM Mar 2nd 2011
How about this? [1]
InvertTheWorld
04:41:07 PM Mar 2nd 2011
edited by FEASTY0UREYESASSILOGIN
Sorry, new here and I don't yet know how to put pics up...

The Aron in this picture massacred an entire Lv100 team by itself (though a Tyranitar from earlier's Sand Stream finished the job) using Sturdy and Endeavor, winning 6-1 for the trainer.
CaptainCrawdad
topic
09:52:27 PM Nov 5th 2010
Took out American History X. It only gets mentioned because it includes a literal curbstomp, but the scene in question is not a curbstomp battle. Daniel opens fire on some thieves, then forces one to bite the curb at gunpoint. It's not a fight scene.
Night
topic
06:00:32 PM Oct 12th 2010
Prop 8 curbstomp mention: I think someone has linked to the wrong trial decision, or possibly altered it to present the wrong trail completely. I am correcting with a link to the correct decision and the not-Strauss v. Horton trial.
AmbarSonofDeshar
topic
10:25:52 AM Jul 16th 2010
The following was posted as a Curb-Stomp Battle. I don't think it is (and I'm not sure how anyone could) but my edit arguing that it isn't has been repeatedly removed, without any reason given, or any proof that my point is invalid. I've moved it here so that someone objective can please examine the following and tell me if it should even be on this page?

  • Another instance is during the duel between Shinn and Kira, where after the initial exchange of beam rifle fire, the fight becomes a three and a half-minute long scene of Shinn shutting down all of Kira's attacks, constantly putting Kira on the defensive, countering at exactly the correct moments, and finally ramming the Freedom with an Anti-Ship Sword. Unlike most other examples on this page, however, it is widely considered to be really awesome instead of lame, possibly because 'I have studied your fighting style and figured out how to counter it' comes across better than 'I can hit harder and faster than you, so HA'.
  • Not a Curb Stomp though. Kira was holding back, and trying to avoid killing Shinn, so that automatically means it shouldn't count. And on top of that, he still destroyed two of the Impulse's three forms, with the last one being totalled when the Freedom exploded. Shinn has the advantage for most of the fight, but it's hardly easy (in fact were he in a different suit he would have lost twice) and Kira still inflicts some serious damage, all without once aiming for Shinn's cockpit. People who complain about Kira' easy victory once he returns and proceeds to discard his Technical Pacifist status and try to kill Shinn (who no longer has a suit that can be repaired mid-air) should remember that.

Correct me if I'm wrong now, but the requirement for a Curb Stomp battle is that one side completely destroys the other with total ease and doesn't so much as get scratched. Now does the above sound like that? Shinn's suit is disable twice and has to be repaired in mid-air (and if it was any other suit he would have lost the first time it was disabled). It's all right to say he won the fight. It's even okay for the Kira-haters (and there's certainly a lot of them on this site) to list it as a CMOA. But a Curb Stomp, it is not. Or am I missing something here?
Night
05:58:13 PM Oct 12th 2010
edited by Night
Blah, wrong spot
Pureauthor
10:09:23 PM Dec 14th 2010
First off, I don't think stating the requirements for a Curb Stomp is for the losing side to never get a hit in. For example, in the Pokemon example Ash loses 6-2 to Paul. Meaning 2 of Paul's Pokemon were knocked out. In the One Piece example Luffy vs. Blueno is listed as an example, even though at one point Blueno was able to trap and disorient Luffy. The requirement is for the fight to be extremely one sided.

With that in mind, let's look at Kira's supposed disabling of Shinn's Impulse. You cannot claim that Shinn's ability to replace Impulse parts somehow invalidates the fact that Shinn can win precisely because he has that ability on hand. Crocodile vs. Luffy Round 1 is considered a Curb Stomp Battle precisely because Crocodile has a power that completely nullifies any of Luffy's attempts at an offence. If the ability was removed or disabled, then Crocodile would be a lot harder pressed, but it wasn't, and so it's a Curb Stomp Battle. (In any case, Kira should know that Shinn has a modular Gundam because he's seen it in action before, so it's his loss for not formulating a better strategy than 'aim for the limbs and wing it'.)

That said, the first time Kira scored a hit on Shinn's mech, Shinn was able to turn the situation around immediately and leave Kira in a worse position than he was before via ramming him with the Force Silhouette. The second time was after Kira was functionally defeated and running away. At neither point was Kira able to regain any momentum in the battle, so what was the point of scoring those blows?

Lastly, and nowhere near as importantly, I don't think there was any indication of Kira holding back during the fight, and if he were, it'd make for some screwy motivations: His friends on the Archangel are, as far as he knows, depending on him to be their bodyguard. Why would he be screwing around instead of fighting to the best of his ability?
AmbarSonofDeshar
06:37:21 PM Jan 14th 2011
edited by AmbarSonofDeshar
Because Kira doesn't want to kill Shinn. He never aims for the cockpit and tries repeatedly to disable his mech by taking apart the arms and head. Rey and Shinn discuss that before the fight even. When they rematch, with Shinn in the Destiny and Kira in the Strike Freedom, Kira repeatedly aims for the cockpit. It's one of the reasons Shinn is so surprised that he can't beat him the second time; Kira's really trying to kill him now.

He also doesn't necessarily know the Impulse is modular; he's seen it in battle, but I don't recall Shinn ever having to switch out before while battling Kira.

As for Kira running away, I'd argue that takes away from it's status as a Curb Stomp. Kira isn't trying to fight. He's trying to get the Archangel out of ZAFT territory and then bail himself. He's got no interest in defeating Shinn and just wants to leave. He repeatedly gives up opportunities to go on the offensive in order to try and exit without having to kill anyone. Kira's objective from the start is not "beat Shinn" which should also count against it's status as a potential Curb Stomp.

Finally yes Shinn planned for Kira destroying his mech. But that doesn't mean that Kira's outmanouvering and destroying the Impulse twice is any less impressive. Heck, when the Freedom blows at the end, it takes the Impulse's third form with it. Even in show it's not treated like a Curb Stomp. Shinn looks stunned that he won, and no one acts as though it weren't an incredibly difficult battle for him. That's why everyone is so impressed. Calling it a Curb Stomp arguably takes away from the level of Shinn's accomplishment.

Anyway, removed this one again, and rewrote the rest of the Gundam Seed Destiny one's to be less venemous. And before someone asks, I didn't turn it into "rah rah Destiny" either. It now reads neutral.
SomeGuy
topic
03:50:41 PM Apr 25th 2010
I just deleted the page picture and page quote, on the grounds that neither demonstrate the trope. All they did was show one character attacking another with some effectiveness. They didn't show a Curb-Stomp Battle by any means.
211.208.241.11
08:37:51 AM May 9th 2010
Is it even demonstratable?
94.5.121.102
topic
01:16:40 PM Apr 25th 2010
This. Not a history buff, so, what the hell is going on here?

  • In the Texas War for Independence from Mexico, the Mexican army attacked the fort of San Jacinto, led by Santa Anna, and the much smaller Texan force led by General Sam Houston. Roughly 700 Mexican soldiers were killed, roughly 730 captured. 8 Texan soldiers were killed, none captured, and the battle lasted eighteen minutes. Eighteen minutes!
    • That...isn't the Battle at San Jac. It wasn't a fort, it was a Mexican Army camp. The Mexicans were taking a siesta, the Texans charged out shouting "Remember the Alamo!" and curb stomped the Mexicans.
Egon
topic
03:20:49 AM Mar 23rd 2010
During the tank fight in Sora no Woto ep 12, I was at the edge of my seat thinking: "****, if the 'opponents' get a blow in it might all be over." It's still this trope, isn't it?
AddythePawnSlayer
10:40:02 AM Mar 23rd 2010
I haven't seen the show but I don't think so - it's only this trope if one side is actually clearly stomping all over the other. If there's any doubt whatsoever as to the outcome, or if the other side manage to get a few significant blows, it's not this trope.
CharredKnight
topic
11:45:49 PM Mar 15th 2010
I just deleted a bunch of ones from One Piece. While the Akainu and Whitebeard fight was short, Akainu melted off a good portion of Whitebeard's face, and Whitebeard did not take Akainu out of the fight. That would be like calling the first time Akainu fought Whitebeard a curbstomp battle for Akainu.

As for the battle between Whitebeard and Blackbeard, it ended when Blackbeard and his entire crew killed Whitebeard. While Whitebeard did a ton of damage Blackbeard still won that fight.
AddythePawnSlayer
topic
12:04:37 PM Mar 5th 2010
One Sided Battle now redirects here as per this forum thread. The trope formerly known as One Sided Battle is now Pendulum War.
back to Main/CurbStompBattle

TV Tropes by TV Tropes Foundation, LLC is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.
Permissions beyond the scope of this license may be available from thestaff@tvtropes.org.
Privacy Policy