Main Black And White Morality Discussion

Collapse/Expand Topics

08:47:29 PM Dec 16th 2015
02:18:10 AM Dec 17th 2015
Not really. Seems like a Trope Talk topic, though.
11:03:42 AM Aug 30th 2015
The C&C Tiberium Series example is directly contradicted by this page. What should be done?
01:31:18 PM Aug 30th 2015
edited by MagBas
How the series itself portrays this?
02:59:59 AM Nov 9th 2014
  • Dragon Ball Z. While debatable in Vegeta, most of the Z fighters are really good and nice guys. Moreover, enemies are evil, crazy and monstrous sociopaths willing to destroy worlds.

Why this example was removed?
01:22:41 PM Nov 19th 2014
I cannot see a reason why. DBZ is one of the most clear-cut shows out there, other than Vegeta and Fat Buu. Even formerly evil characters wind up pretty much "white" when they become good.
11:13:43 AM Dec 2nd 2014
edited by
From ATT, here's why it's Black and White Morality: There's always two sides, one straight up good, one straight up bad. Piccolo is a bit of a Bad Butt by DBZ but he's still unquestionably on the side of good for the entire series. That there might be evil "in him" doesn't change the fact that he's purely on the side of good in the larger conflict. Characters don't have to be all-loving heroes for it to be Black and White Morality. The issue is the larger conflicts. In every conflict, there's generally two sides: The Z Fighters (clearly good) and whoever they're fighting, who's clearly bad. "If there are any morally ambiguous or grey characters around (such as an Anti-Hero or Worthy Opponent), they will eventually shift firmly to one side or the other" which is precisely what happens to every ambiguous character.

There's nothing ever indicating that the heroes are doing anything morally ambiguous, or that maybe Freiza has it right. There's the good guys, there's the bad guys. The good guys aren't entirely caricatures of a Shining Knight, and the villains aren't ALL cartoonishly evil Complete Monsters, but they're still clearly one the sides of good or bad respectively. I think that part of the issue is that people equate Black and White Morality with characters being one-dimensional, which isn't necessarily the case.
01:12:03 PM Dec 2nd 2014
I must confess to jumping the gun and removing it after reading the discussion on Ask The Tropers - but before the discussion had reached a consensus. I'm sorry for this. Please feel free to put it back.
01:56:25 PM Dec 2nd 2014
No worries. And any way you cut it, the example that you did pull was really quite wrong. I'm going to wait for more discussion before I add a writeup of my own.
12:47:31 PM Dec 5th 2014
Bump. Any other thoughts?
10:49:21 AM Dec 8th 2014
edited by
Readding a reworded entry, if no one objects.

  • Dragon Ball Z:In every conflict, there's generally two sides: The Z Fighters (clearly good) and whoever they're fighting, who's clearly bad. Even though many characters may start out somewhat ambiguous, being an Anti-Hero or even an outright villain, they firmly cement themselves on the side of good before too long. Even Vegeta who spends the series in a Heel–Face Revolving Door settles into the side of good eventually. At no point is there ever a question as to whether the Arc Villain du jour is justified or anything but a villain.
03:23:49 PM Oct 10th 2012
The image being used so far from Fire Emblem Tellius is really screwed up. That's showing Elincia from FE 10 in a completely different situation. Plus the camera focus is on Leanne. Isn't there something we can use from FE 9?
02:23:49 PM Feb 7th 2012
I wish real life was black and white, too.
04:58:56 PM Feb 7th 2012
It already is. =/
Collapse/Expand Topics