Same pic as Sick And Wrong!: Fille Fatale

On a related note, I would prefer for the picture to be taken off Sick and Wrong. The page is supposed to be in-universe examples only, not a place for us to stick everything that upsets us, and the picture is an example of the latter. I don't support sexualising children, but having that picture on the page invites Trope Decay.

This duplicate image still needs to be resolved.

My vote is still to take it off Fille Fatale.

Well... I've got an idea for a new Fille Fatale image, but I'm rather concerned that the picture I have in mind is just a bit over the line. It involves Rin from Kodomo No Jikan. It's not explicit, but it's still HEAVILY suggestive:

If this really is too much, I won't argue.◊

Rin's a great example, but that'll never fly around here.

Oh! What about...oh whats her name...the little western gothloli in Ore Tachi Ni Tsubasa Wa Nai? There might be a good scene with subs that express this. I'll try to check tomorrow if I get a chance.

(ugh, just realized how much work the work page for that needs...)

edited 4th May '11 11:49:04 PM by SakurazakiSetsuna

Very well. Just thought I'd get that one off my chest. Thanks!

The search continues...

edited 4th May '11 11:53:53 PM by LanceOmikron

Something like this setsuna?[1]◊

Or there is this from Negima (Resized to 350)

edited 5th May '11 12:03:03 AM by Raso

Yeah, though that image in particular will never fly around here.

Evangeline isn't really a Fille Fatale though, no matter what she looks like.

I think it needs to stay on Sick and Wrong, the one here needs to be changed.

What's wrong with that pic? I don't see any serious SFW issues...or are you talking about the quality?

That wasn't referring to the Evangeline pic. Raso linked a different picture in his first sentence.

Gotcha, I didn't notice that.

I think this is the safest image that can be used for this trope, something else would either be not representative of the trope or considered pedobait.

The Sick and Wrong image can perfectly be changed to something else, while this would be harder, plus the image fits here way better than in the other trope.

edited 5th May '11 2:27:34 PM by shark33

No, I think it would be better for sick and wrong, I don't think just because it's not some in universe example-doesn't mean it would lead to trope decay...

Besides, in-universe example right here on TV Tropes...it sure is something we would all consider...Sick and Wrong!

If we're gonna keep going back and forth on which trope the image fits more, we should just scrap the image entirely and focus our energy on finding new images for both tropes. Really, it seems that the image only fits either trope due to justifications and concessions, and that shouldn't be needed.

In short, we can do better.

edited 5th May '11 7:34:22 PM by LanceOmikron

Alice, from Ore Tachi Ni Tsubasa Wa Nai:

[1]◊, [2]◊, [3]◊, [4]◊, [5]◊, [6]◊

Crowner time?

Agreed; maybe we should start out with a single-issue crowner on which page the image should stay on, with a third option to scrap it entirely and find new pics for both pages.

Supporting.

Sounds like a plan.

I'm ok with that idea.

But I agree that the image should stay on Sick and Wrong.

Here's the crowner, with the three options as listed. I thought about adding pros and cons but I don't think I could be objective for all the options.

edited 22nd May '11 9:38:46 PM by Willbyr

How about this one for Fille Fatale, cropped out of the Skip Beat that rd85jejfcd3qujtw3940ri suggested on the first page. She's freakin' 7 and it sure looks like she knows exactly what she's doing to him.

edited 22nd May '11 9:47:46 PM by Madrugada

It's got potential, but I like the Evangeline pic a bit more.

Which one is the Evangeline one?

The one in post 31, right?

I didn't get the trope from the Evangeline picture, because I didn't get an immediate sense of the character's age. It also looks like we're past the seductive behavior bit. The Skip Beat pic is kinda long and text heavy but it seems more on the money.