Ambiguous Name: Most Annoying Sound

With that in mind, does Critical Annoyance seem more like this trope but more specific?

I know I'm not who was being replied to, but I'm against cutting Critical Annoyance on The Same, but More Specific grounds. Unlike Most Annoying Sound, that trope is objectively present, and its purpose (indicating low health) isn't subject to interpretation.

Edited by GastonRabbit on Jul 26th 2019 at 9:38:49 AM

Fair enough.

Maybe In-Universe examples can be moved to one of the other Annoyance Tropes, such as Torment by Annoyance?

That could work.

Works for me as well.

Calling crowner in favor of Darth Wiki.

What should be done with the redirect The Most Annoying Sound?

Edited by costanton11 on Jul 29th 2019 at 7:11:43 AM

I was thinking DarthWiki.The Most Annoying Sound should be made to catch Main.The Most Annoying Sound's inbounds. I tried cutlisting that redirect, but the request was declined, hence my suggestion to move that redirect to Darth Wiki.

I had actually created a Trope Finder ask for misophonic distress just a couple of hours ago before I knew about this thread. Maybe that could be created to help with funneling out some of the examples that don't fit the original meaning?

EDIT: Looking at those non-gaming examples, I'm thinking there may actually be a separate trope there for toys whose sounds become annoying with repetition, since there are a few media examples mixed into the Toys section. The wrestling example seems like a better fit for Torment by Annoyance since it's done deliberately to get on the nerves of the opponents of his wrestlers.

Edited by Willbyr on Jul 30th 2019 at 2:22:00 PM

Do changes need to be made to the description when moving to Darth Wiki?

Gone ahead and moved the page. Added it to Wick Namespace Migration.

Shouldn't the page be filed under Flame Bait, since it's on Darth Wiki now? I mentioned Flame Bait earlier in the thread, but I don't think anyone else discussed it.

Edit: Either way, I made the redirect DarthWiki.The Most Annoying Sound so redirect currently located at Main.The Most Annoying Sound is on Darth Wiki as well.

Edit: Indexed DarthWiki.Most Annoying Sound under the main Darth Wiki index.

Edited by GastonRabbit on Aug 2nd 2019 at 9:19:57 AM

I'm not sure if Darth Wiki pages are automatically Flame Bait.

I wasn't completely sure either. That's why I asked.

Edited by GastonRabbit on Aug 3rd 2019 at 8:17:26 AM

So, if the page is moved to Darth Wiki but isn't Flame Bait, can we still have examples on YMMV pages?

From what I understand, Darth Wiki items aren't allowed on the main wiki.

Let's get clarification before we start removing examples from YMMV pages, though.

I'm a little unsure, since a lot of YMMV pages have small Nightmare Fuel sections, but besides that I've never seen a Darth Wiki trope on a normal YMMV page...

Nightmare Fuel just uses the Darth Wiki background in its subpages.

I found this on the main Darth Wiki page:

Please note: Darth Wiki and Sugar Wiki do not go on main or YMMV pages. For more information, please read What Goes Where on the Wiki.

Edited by costanton11 on Aug 4th 2019 at 4:43:06 AM

Wicks now below 2400.

Wicks at 2300.

Took it down to 2222, and interestingly, some examples are valid because they're In-Universe to a reviewer's experience.

Should Sensory Index index the trope?

Edited by Malady on Sep 24th 2019 at 5:11:44 AM

Yes. And you don't have to remove wicks from Just for Fun pages either.

BTW, it's at 1956 now, and the namespaces left are Characters and beyond.